THE COLOR OF COVID-19 | Disparate Impact, Inequitable Response | A Town Hall Meeting
Ringkasan
TLDRThe Skoll Foundation hosted a discussion on the impact of COVID-19 on marginalized communities, focusing on structural racism and inequities exacerbated by the pandemic. CEO Don Gips opened the session by highlighting disparities such as black adults aged 35-44 being nine times more likely to die from COVID-19 than white adults, and Native Americans being eight times more likely to die. The event featured researchers, activists, and social innovators who discussed the dire state of disparities within healthcare and other systems, all rooted in structural racism and historic injustices. Cheryl Dorsey, President of Echoing Green, emphasized investing in social entrepreneurs through the Racial Equity Fund to dismantle structural racism. Dr. Mary Bassett and Dr. Eric Broat discussed the need for structural solutions and the resilience of indigenous populations, respectively. The session also included discussions on the challenges within the criminal justice system exacerbated by the pandemic, with recommendations for improving safety and transparency. The importance of collective action, systemic change, and the critical role of love in activism and philanthropy were recurring themes.
Takeaways
- π The pandemic exposed global inequities, emphasizing structural injustices.
- π Black adults are significantly more likely to die from COVID-19 than white adults in the US.
- π₯ Collaborative efforts are critical to addressing racial disparities and systemic racism.
- π Dr. Mary Bassett calls for structural changes like paid sick leave and affordable housing.
- π Indigenous resilience shows historical survival amidst repeated pandemics and challenges.
- π Criminal justice reform is needed to address COVID-19 impacts in correctional facilities.
- π‘ Echoing Green's Racial Equity Fund supports social innovation to dismantle racism.
- π£οΈ Cultural messaging is essential for effective public health communication.
- πͺ Love and solidarity are powerful tools for change within communities.
- π οΈ Systemic change requires investment in marginalized communities' leaders.
Garis waktu
- 00:00:00 - 00:05:00
Don Gips introduces a convening to address global challenges, emphasizing the inequities revealed by COVID-19, especially in racial disparities. He acknowledges partners and highlights the importance of collective action. A poet, Darius Simpson, sets the tone with a piece on systemic inequities exacerbated by the pandemic.
- 00:05:00 - 00:10:00
Cheryl Dorsey of Echoing Green outlines the Racial Equity Fund's mission to dismantle structural racism and highlights partnerships for inclusive economies. She emphasizes indigenous land acknowledgment and collaboration with New Profit and Indian Collective to promote equity and justice.
- 00:10:00 - 00:15:00
Tulane Montgomery from New Profit stresses the importance of love and action in philanthropy to tackle serious challenges. Nick Tilson from Indian Collective discusses systemic issues unveiled by the pandemic and the need to build indigenous power and collective liberation. They both emphasize the present crisis and the need for transformative action.
- 00:15:00 - 00:20:00
Cheryl Dorsey reflects on the rising COVID-19 cases and mortality. Historical references frame the discussion on systemic racism and its impact on pandemic disparities. Dr. Mary Bassett delves into racial disparities in health, emphasizing the structural origins of these inequities and advocating for structural solutions.
- 00:20:00 - 00:25:00
Dr. Mary Bassett highlights the early emergence of racial disparities in COVID deaths, criticizing the lack of federal data. She stresses the need for policy changes addressing structural racism and calls for systemic solutions involving the private sector. Collaboration with Reverend Dr. William Barber underscores the moral urgency of addressing these inequities.
- 00:25:00 - 00:30:00
Dr. Eric Broat shares insights from indigenous communities, noting how systemic policies have historically marginalized tribal health. He emphasizes indigenous wisdom's power to address challenges, advocating for increased indigenous healthcare workforce and addressing data and staffing shortages in tribal health systems.
- 00:30:00 - 00:35:00
Dr. Broat highlights pandemics as part of indigenous history, underscoring resilience and continuity in traditional practices. He emphasizes the need for realistic workforce assessments to address shortages. The importance of intersecting historical trauma with current health crises is stressed.
- 00:35:00 - 00:40:00
Sonia Perez of UnidosUS discusses COVID-19's disproportionate impact on Latinos, highlighting children and youth as critical demographics for the nation's future. Community-based networks play vital roles in public health messaging, emergency relief, and economic support, facilitating advocacy rooted in lived local experiences.
- 00:40:00 - 00:45:00
UnidosUS adapts its approaches based on community-identified needs during the pandemic, exemplifying innovative local partnerships to address digital divides and health access issues. There's an emphasis on structural inequities across various domains like health, housing, education, and employment, with organized advocacy crucial for systemic change.
- 00:45:00 - 00:50:00
Cynthia Choi talks about anti-Asian racism and community response efforts through Stop API Hate, acknowledging the multifaceted pressures of the pandemic. These efforts emphasize community-based solutions prioritizing safety without criminalization, representing a broader anti-racist, solidarity-driven framework among diverse groups.
- 00:50:00 - 00:55:00
Commission on COVID-19 and Criminal Justice response recommendations focus on safety, transparency, and data in corrections systems. It highlights gaps in federal and local implementations, exploring reform opportunities to reduce COVID's impact within the justice system.
- 00:55:00 - 01:00:00
Efforts in the criminal justice system spotlight de-incarceration trends prompted by grassroots advocacy. The focus is on solutions to systemic issues revealed by the pandemic, promoting alignment of criminal justice with public health goals. The importance of data transparency is reiterated.
- 01:00:00 - 01:05:00
Nathaniel Smith discusses systemic flaws in current economic and justice systems, urging alternative community-centered solutions. Emphasis is placed on acknowledging foundational racial injustices and creating equitable economic models. Includes focus on an emergent Southern narrative for equity-led development.
- 01:05:00 - 01:10:00
Ernest Boykin shares personal insights as a formerly incarcerated individual adapting to systemic failures exacerbated by COVID. He exposes systemic inadequacies in societal reintegration processes heightened by the pandemic, emphasizing the need for holistic reform centered on inclusivity and opportunity.
- 01:10:00 - 01:15:00
Dr. Olajide Williams of Hip Hop Public Health stresses culturally relevant behavior change strategies addressing cognitive and emotional barriers to health in Black communities. He identifies a rising trauma epidemic linked to long-standing social disparities and emphasizes culturally tailored health messaging.
- 01:15:00 - 01:20:00
Monique Tula highlights the harm reduction movement's challenges amid COVID-19, focusing on systemic erasure within public health emergency strategies. She stresses the ongoing harms of the war on drugs and the persistent need for harm reduction services, pointing to structural racism and social advocacy as focal points.
- 01:20:00 - 01:29:09
Dr. Kim Gallon discusses the role of data and the personal stories behind statistics, particularly regarding virus impact assessments. She highlights βliving dataβ as a method of ensuring cultural and community relevance in understanding COVID-19 effects, emphasizing the need for nuanced narrative approaches beyond raw data.
Peta Pikiran
Pertanyaan yang Sering Diajukan
What was the main focus of Don Gips' opening remarks?
Don Gips highlighted the inequities exposed by the COVID-19 pandemic, especially in the US, and the urgent need for action and collaboration to address structural racism and injustices.
What statistical disparities were highlighted in the presentation?
The event highlighted disparities such as black adults aged 35-44 being nine times more likely to die from COVID-19 compared to white adults, and Native Americans being eight times more likely to die.
Who participated in the discussion?
The discussion featured leading researchers, activists, social innovators, and partners like NDN Collective and New Profit.
What is the Racial Equity Fund by Echoing Green?
Echoing Green's Racial Equity Fund focuses on dismantling structural racism and building inclusive economies by launching and scaling social enterprises focused on racial equity.
What is the significance of the poem by Darius Simpson?
The poem aimed to set the tone for the discussion by highlighting systemic inequities exposed by COVID-19, asking critical questions about health care access, treatment of essential workers, and systemic racism.
How did the COVID-19 pandemic differ in its impact on various racial groups according to the speakers?
The pandemic had a disproportionate impact on people of color, with higher mortality rates among black, Indigenous, Latinx, and Asian and Pacific Islander communities compared to white communities.
What solution did Dr. Mary Bassett discuss for addressing racial disparities?
Dr. Mary Bassett discussed the need for structural solutions such as paid sick leave, health insurance, affordable housing, and better access to living wages and the labor market for communities of color.
What is the perspective of Dr. Eric Broat regarding pandemics and indigenous communities?
Dr. Eric Broat contextualized the pandemic by highlighting the historical challenges indigenous communities have faced, showing resilience and continued cultural practices as a means of survival.
What recommendations did the Council on Criminal Justice provide for handling COVID-19 in the criminal justice system?
Recommendations included going beyond CDC guidelines, transparent communication, universal masking, frequent testing, limiting contact, and involving impacted communities in decision-making.
Lihat lebih banyak ringkasan video
The 3 Surprising Dairy Products You Should Consume For Longevity | Dr. William Li
One TBSP Of This Everyday Burns Visceral Fat For Weight Loss | Dr. William Li
5 Drinks That Remove Fat From Your Liver & Speed Up Fat Loss | Dr. William Li
AB DIS 10/10/2024 : Mucocutaneous disorder & Vesiculobullous disease
A Beautiful Mind Escena de la Rubia Adam Smith se equivoco
Design Thinking - Paper Prototypes
- 00:00:04Welcome everyone
- 00:00:07I'm Don Gips,
- 00:00:07the CEO of the Skoll Foundation
- 00:00:09and one of my greatest privileges
- 00:00:11is to participate in convenings like this
- 00:00:15that provoke us to think critically and act urgently
- 00:00:19to address the biggest challenges of our day.
- 00:00:22The COVID-19 pandemic
- 00:00:24has exposed the inequities and weakness
- 00:00:27of unjust and unsustainable systems globally.
- 00:00:32This has been especially true in the US.
- 00:00:36There are a few statistics that really bring this to life.
- 00:00:41In the US, black adults between the ages of 35 and 44
- 00:00:47are nine times more likely to die from COVID-19
- 00:00:50than white adults.
- 00:00:52Native Americans are eight times more likely to die
- 00:00:55than white adults.
- 00:00:57The pandemic has made it glaringly clear
- 00:01:00that we may all be in the same storm,
- 00:01:03but we're not in the same boat.
- 00:01:06These disparate health outcomes
- 00:01:08are deeply rooted in structural racism
- 00:01:11and historic injustices.
- 00:01:14Today, we'll hear from some of the leading researchers,
- 00:01:17activists, social innovators,
- 00:01:20working at the intersection of racial justice
- 00:01:23and the COVID-19 pandemic.
- 00:01:27I'd like to give special thanks
- 00:01:28to our convening partners,
- 00:01:30NDN Collective and New Profit
- 00:01:33for their engagement and collaboration on this event.
- 00:01:37We're blessed to have them as partners
- 00:01:39and it will take all of us,
- 00:01:40shoulder to shoulder working together
- 00:01:43to address the challenges we're discussing today.
- 00:01:48We'd like to share a short video
- 00:01:50featuring poet Darius Simpson
- 00:01:53to help set the tone
- 00:01:55and offer some context for the discussion that comes ahead.
- 00:02:00COVID-19 shook the world to its core
- 00:02:05or kicked up a familiar dust
- 00:02:09or coughed up what's been resting
- 00:02:11in the diaphragm of the United States for centuries.
- 00:02:16Coronavirus broke headlines as a global pandemic
- 00:02:19while 2020 was still getting its bearings.
- 00:02:23You might think in a time of social distancing
- 00:02:27while many of us face an issue
- 00:02:29that is incapable of discriminating,
- 00:02:32that we are finally in this together.
- 00:02:35Yet there are communities
- 00:02:38who are more drastically impacted,
- 00:02:40even by a virus that promises nothing,
- 00:02:43except that it is equally contagious
- 00:02:45regardless of skin color.
- 00:02:50Perhaps a virus need not discriminate
- 00:02:53if the humans it is infecting
- 00:02:55have created systems that do the discriminating for it.
- 00:03:00If we are advised that are safest place is inside,
- 00:03:03then what of the people without an inside?
- 00:03:07If we must distance from even family,
- 00:03:10then what of the families who live in no bedroom apartments
- 00:03:13stacked on top of each other?
- 00:03:16If school has moved from classrooms to the kitchen table,
- 00:03:20then what of the students without kitchen tables?
- 00:03:25I had one shift where I saw about 84 patients.
- 00:03:28The first 21 days-
- 00:03:29Maybe this virus
- 00:03:30has illuminated an age old inequity in this country
- 00:03:33with mortality rates 6.7 times higher for black people,
- 00:03:37four times higher for indigenous folks,
- 00:03:402.5 times higher for Latin X humans,
- 00:03:42and 2.6 times higher for Asian and Pacific Islanders.
- 00:03:46Perhaps now is not the time for answers
- 00:03:49but for questions
- 00:03:51like how might we even the playing field?
- 00:03:54Where are the gaps and needs?
- 00:03:57Which humans have access to which health care?
- 00:04:00Who can afford to work from home?
- 00:04:03Why are essential workers being called heroes
- 00:04:05but not being paid like heroes?
- 00:04:08What will happen
- 00:04:09when they are no longer considered essential?
- 00:04:12What if we acted in solidarity with our most vulnerable?
- 00:04:15What if black and Latin X people
- 00:04:17didn't comprise 56% of the prison population?
- 00:04:21What if there was no prison to populate?
- 00:04:24What if no one was disposable
- 00:04:26and the virus couldn't recycle itself
- 00:04:28in the imaginations of the rich?
- 00:04:30And what if we just stopped for a second
- 00:04:34to consider all the sickness that existed before,
- 00:04:38to consider how we might start healing those systems,
- 00:04:42to consider the color of COVID?
- 00:04:58Let me now have the great pleasure
- 00:05:01of introducing Cheryl Dorsey,
- 00:05:03president of Echoing Green.
- 00:05:06We're so proud to have invested
- 00:05:08in Echoing Green's Racial Equity Fund
- 00:05:11that leverages social innovation
- 00:05:13to dismantle structural racism
- 00:05:16and build inclusive economies.
- 00:05:19The fund will launch and scale 500 social enterprises
- 00:05:23focused on racial equity
- 00:05:26and break down barriers to capital
- 00:05:27that social entrepreneurs
- 00:05:29and innovators of color face globally.
- 00:05:33We see it as a critical investment
- 00:05:35in the next generation of leaders
- 00:05:37who will help dismantle
- 00:05:38the root causes of racial, inequity, and injustice.
- 00:05:42I'm also happy to say
- 00:05:43that Cheryl is the new member of the Skoll Foundation Board.
- 00:05:47She's been a teacher of mine for a long time
- 00:05:49and brings a wealth of wisdom
- 00:05:52to how to drive true transformational change
- 00:05:55through social innovation.
- 00:05:57As Skoll continues its journey
- 00:06:00working with proximate social innovators
- 00:06:02across sectors to help advance racial justice and equity,
- 00:06:07I can't think of a better leader from us to hear from.
- 00:06:10Cheryl, over to you.
- 00:06:13Thank you so much, Don.
- 00:06:14Really appreciate those kind words.
- 00:06:17Also want to send a big thanks
- 00:06:19to the entire Skoll family,
- 00:06:21Jeff, the staff, the entire board.
- 00:06:24It's been an honor
- 00:06:26to begin to work more closely with you all,
- 00:06:28a true honor, especially in this moment.
- 00:06:31Also want to thank our convening partners
- 00:06:32New Profit and Indian Collective,
- 00:06:35and to all of those who've joined us today
- 00:06:37for this important conversation.
- 00:06:39And I must say greetings from Washington, DC,
- 00:06:42a rainy Washington, DC.
- 00:06:43But to open,
- 00:06:45I would like to humbly make a land acknowledgement.
- 00:06:49I would like to start
- 00:06:50by recognizing and acknowledging
- 00:06:52the indigenous people of the land where I now sit,
- 00:06:56the Nacotchtank.
- 00:06:57The name is derived
- 00:06:58from the word
- 00:07:01meaning a town of traders.
- 00:07:03And I know that while a land acknowledgement is not enough
- 00:07:06it is an important social justice and decolonial practice
- 00:07:10that promotes indigenous visibility
- 00:07:12and a reminder that we were all settled on indigenous land.
- 00:07:16Let this land acknowledgement be an opening for all of us
- 00:07:19to contemplate a way to join
- 00:07:21in decolonial and indigenous movements
- 00:07:23for sovereignty and self-determination.
- 00:07:26And as we turn to our discussion now,
- 00:07:29if you'll indulge me a few housekeeping notes.
- 00:07:32I'm gonna ask that everyone remain on mute
- 00:07:33to minimize background noise.
- 00:07:36Please feel free to enter your questions
- 00:07:38for all of our wonderful speakers
- 00:07:40using the Q and A box on the bottom of your screen.
- 00:07:43Please note that our speakers may refer to references
- 00:07:47during their talk.
- 00:07:48Someone is going to link them in the chat feature.
- 00:07:50So please be on the lookout for those materials.
- 00:07:52And of course, feel free to chat in real time
- 00:07:55with other audience members in the chat box on the right.
- 00:07:58We may be virtual, but we're here together
- 00:08:00and we're in conversation.
- 00:08:03Representatives of each of our convening partners,
- 00:08:05as Don mentioned
- 00:08:06are here with us today and will now say a few words.
- 00:08:10First, we'd love to hear from Tulane Montgomery
- 00:08:12and then Nick Tilson.
- 00:08:15Thank you so much, Cheryl,
- 00:08:16and so good to be here with all of you
- 00:08:18tuning in from all over the planet
- 00:08:20to have this important and timely conversation.
- 00:08:22My name is Tulane Montgomery.
- 00:08:23I'm managing partner of New Profit.
- 00:08:26We are so proud and honored
- 00:08:28to be convening partners
- 00:08:29with Skoll Foundation and Indian Collective.
- 00:08:31And I just want to offer a quick note.
- 00:08:34So New Profit is a philanthropy,
- 00:08:36Skoll is a philanthropy, Echoing Green,
- 00:08:38and I want to offer a little reminder
- 00:08:40of the roots of philanthropy.
- 00:08:41If you look into the etymology
- 00:08:43of the word philanthropy,
- 00:08:45it means to love humankind.
- 00:08:47And I want to offer that as a reminder
- 00:08:49and a frame for this conversation
- 00:08:50because when the stakes are as high as they are today,
- 00:08:53when the fight is as serious as it is right now,
- 00:08:55sometimes talking about love
- 00:08:57can feel like a cop out, right?
- 00:08:58But I would offer that love is not for the weak willed
- 00:09:01or the simple minded.
- 00:09:02Love requires bravery, courage,
- 00:09:04clarity, honesty, and genius.
- 00:09:06And so we're gonna have this conversation
- 00:09:08with the intent that we will gather enough information
- 00:09:11and unearth the questions that enable us in philanthropy
- 00:09:15to really lead with love as the impact that we have.
- 00:09:19And so I'm so excited to be here with all of you today
- 00:09:20and look forward to this conversation.
- 00:09:22It couldn't come at a more important time.
- 00:09:30My name's Nick Tilson,
- 00:09:31in my Lakota language.
- 00:09:33I'm the president and CEO of the Indian Collective.
- 00:09:36Indian Collective is honored and excited
- 00:09:38to be partnering with New Profit, with the Skoll Foundation.
- 00:09:44Some of these relationships are really new
- 00:09:46over this past year.
- 00:09:48And so we're honored to be here
- 00:09:50having this very important conversation
- 00:09:52that we're gonna be having.
- 00:09:53And I think that the part of the poem
- 00:09:57that you got to hear at the beginning
- 00:10:00was this crisis that we're in
- 00:10:03and this pandemic that we're in
- 00:10:05has uncovered and unearthed systemic issues
- 00:10:09throughout our communities and throughout this country,
- 00:10:13and really hitting at the core
- 00:10:15of the challenges that we're faced with.
- 00:10:17And so Indian Collective is a national organization
- 00:10:20dedicated to building indigenous power
- 00:10:22and changing the conditions
- 00:10:24in which the way indigenous self-determination is supported
- 00:10:27is honored to be partnered in having this conversation
- 00:10:30You're gonna be able to hear from Eric
- 00:10:32and other indigenous leaders in having
- 00:10:36this fruitful conversation
- 00:10:38about not only the struggles that we're in today
- 00:10:42but where we could be going
- 00:10:43and how we can actually collect the building power
- 00:10:46solving problems and leaning in
- 00:10:49towards collective liberation in the future.
- 00:10:51So we're honored to be partnered on this event
- 00:10:56and honored to be pivoting at this time in history.
- 00:11:03Because I think that many years from now,
- 00:11:04we will look back at this time in the history
- 00:11:07and we'll be asking what did we do?
- 00:11:09What did we contribute to that time?
- 00:11:11And so here we are.
- 00:11:13So honored to be here and have a good session, everybody.
- 00:11:19Tulane, Nick, thank you both so much
- 00:11:22and raising up contents of both love and crisis, right?
- 00:11:27Because Nick, you're right,
- 00:11:29we are in a moment of crisis in this country.
- 00:11:32You know, today we are going to surpass
- 00:11:34nine million cases of COVID-19
- 00:11:37and we will have lost almost 229,000 of our fellow citizens
- 00:11:42by this evening.
- 00:11:44The epidemic is getting worse in 47 of 50 states
- 00:11:48and we lost more than 1,000 souls yesterday alone.
- 00:11:51The death rates are rising again.
- 00:11:53You know, professor of history and history of medicine,
- 00:11:56Frank Snowden said,
- 00:11:57"to study pandemics is to understand a society structure,
- 00:12:01its standard of living, its political priorities.
- 00:12:04The disproportionate impact of COVID-19 on people of color,
- 00:12:08the higher burdens of cases and deaths,
- 00:12:11is an indictment and one that elucidates
- 00:12:13the impacts of structural racism on communities of color."
- 00:12:16That's what we're here to talk about today.
- 00:12:18Let me start by welcoming our first speaker,
- 00:12:21Dr. Mary Bassett,
- 00:12:22to talk more about these racial inequities and their drivers
- 00:12:26after she introduces herself.
- 00:12:28Dr. Bassett?
- 00:12:29Thanks very much, Cheryl.
- 00:12:31It's such an honor to be here.
- 00:12:33I want to thank the Skoll Foundation
- 00:12:34and I'm so pleased to be here with all the other panelists.
- 00:12:38So I'm Dr. Mary Bassett.
- 00:12:39I direct a center called the François-Xavier Bagnoud or FXB
- 00:12:46Center for Health and Human Rights at Harvard University.
- 00:12:49And I have a longstanding interest
- 00:12:51in racial disparities in health.
- 00:12:54We've heard the numbers
- 00:12:56and I feel that I should begin, as others have.
- 00:12:59And Helen you're from Massachusetts.
- 00:13:01We're on land which was previously occupied
- 00:13:05by the Wampanoag people and others.
- 00:13:08It's hard for us to remember in our daily lives
- 00:13:13because this population has been so reduced
- 00:13:16that there are 600 federally recognized
- 00:13:19and other indigenous groups who have survived
- 00:13:23and are among us still.
- 00:13:25So we have been looking at the early emergence
- 00:13:31of racial disparities in COVID mortality and case rates.
- 00:13:35And it's shown what everyone's already heard,
- 00:13:39that it's abundantly clear that this country,
- 00:13:41the wealthiest and one of the most
- 00:13:43medically advanced countries in the world
- 00:13:45has utterly failed to control this pandemic
- 00:13:49and the vulnerabilities preexisted COVID-19,
- 00:13:54preexisted the current administration.
- 00:13:56And we're seeing huge gaps.
- 00:13:59So among black people between the ages of 35 and 44
- 00:14:04our research shows a nine fold increased risk of death.
- 00:14:09This increased risk in young people
- 00:14:11is related to everyday life,
- 00:14:14not to inadequate bodies.
- 00:14:17It's related to people who are still working,
- 00:14:20people who are still traveling on crowded transport,
- 00:14:24people who are going home
- 00:14:25to crowded multi-generational households.
- 00:14:28And we need to talk about that before we start talking
- 00:14:32about the problems of diabetes and heart disease.
- 00:14:36Dr. Bassett, can you talk about
- 00:14:40some of the data that your organization had collected?
- 00:14:47And then can you sort of unpack what that means?
- 00:14:49And then we only have a few minutes with you,
- 00:14:52some of the policy solutions that will help us
- 00:14:56sort of cross over to the other side of this.
- 00:14:59So as you know, the best sort of data during this pandemic
- 00:15:03has been coming from journalists,
- 00:15:05particularly the print media.
- 00:15:06And this is an indictment
- 00:15:08of what's happened to our public health authorities.
- 00:15:11The CDC has been effectively muzzled,
- 00:15:13and we learned in March
- 00:15:15of the excess African-American mortality.
- 00:15:17The data weren't available by race
- 00:15:19from the federal government.
- 00:15:21But when they became available, we analyzed them
- 00:15:24and they show what you've already heard.
- 00:15:27Three, four fold times higher risk of death,
- 00:15:30and much extremely high risk of death among younger adults
- 00:15:36who are black, Latin X, and indigenous.
- 00:15:40Now it's important to interpret these data correctly.
- 00:15:45The fact that they are so large,
- 00:15:47that they emerged so quickly,
- 00:15:49suggests that they're structural in origin
- 00:15:51and they need structural solutions.
- 00:15:54People often say, we can't do these,
- 00:15:56they're too complicated.
- 00:15:56They mean things like having paid sick leave,
- 00:15:59health insurance, affordable housing,
- 00:16:01addressing the longstanding inadequate access
- 00:16:06to the labor market
- 00:16:08and the access to living wage for people of color.
- 00:16:13And these are things actually that the private sector
- 00:16:17may be more agile at addressing
- 00:16:21and should figure out
- 00:16:22that this is worth their while to address
- 00:16:25because the cost of not addressing it
- 00:16:27is paid in human lives.
- 00:16:29No, I appreciate that, Dr. Bassett,
- 00:16:31and I've heard you say that we've got to move
- 00:16:34beyond the individual to the structural
- 00:16:35and sort of laying out some of these policy prescriptions
- 00:16:38is quite important.
- 00:16:39But I appreciate you as a researcher, as a clinician,
- 00:16:44but also as a moral agent
- 00:16:46that's bringing a sense of urgency.
- 00:16:48I know that you've done some work
- 00:16:49with Reverend Dr. William Barber,
- 00:16:51who's co-chair of the Poor People's Campaign.
- 00:16:53And I was rereading a piece you all coauthored in June
- 00:16:56for the nation called, "Systemic Racism is Social Dynamite".
- 00:17:00Tell us more about your work together
- 00:17:01and what you mean by this.
- 00:17:03Well, we just had a convening
- 00:17:05with Reverend Barber and his co-chair
- 00:17:07of the Poor People's Campaign.
- 00:17:10And as you know,
- 00:17:10they focus on the problem of systemic racism, poverty,
- 00:17:14our ecological destruction and more.
- 00:17:18And before we wrap up,
- 00:17:19I got to ask you to back up so we can see your tee shirt.
- 00:17:24Reverend Barber would ask me to do that.
- 00:17:26Can you see it?
- 00:17:28No, we can't.
- 00:17:29I can stand up a little bit.
- 00:17:30Thank you.
- 00:17:31That's right, thank you, Dr. Bassett.
- 00:17:34These are issues where we each have an individual role
- 00:17:40but for too long academics,
- 00:17:42people in public health authorities,
- 00:17:45have been reluctant to talk
- 00:17:47about the true underlying facts
- 00:17:50that drive this vulnerability.
- 00:17:52And mean that this wealthy country is accounting
- 00:17:55for less than five percent of the world's population
- 00:17:58as over 20% of the world's cases and rising.
- 00:18:02So Reverend Barber talks about this,
- 00:18:05talks about the cost in the deaths,
- 00:18:12how we interpret death numbers,
- 00:18:14and understand what lies behind them,
- 00:18:18these are the policies
- 00:18:20which have enabled a tiny fraction of our society
- 00:18:23to become incredibly wealthy,
- 00:18:25three people controlling the wealth,
- 00:18:27and we know their names,
- 00:18:29of half of the population is incredible
- 00:18:34and those have a cost in death rates.
- 00:18:38So he asks us to go back and he challenges us.
- 00:18:43And I'm proud to have been able to to join him
- 00:18:47in making those challenges.
- 00:18:49So everybody should go to their website and take a look.
- 00:18:53We need data.
- 00:18:54We can't see what's going on without data.
- 00:18:58But we also need to have movements.
- 00:19:01And these are movements
- 00:19:02that should involve not only people of color.
- 00:19:05These are movements that we need to protect all of us.
- 00:19:09And so that's my view on all this.
- 00:19:15It seems out of my lane as a public health expert,
- 00:19:19but we all got to get out of our land
- 00:19:22because COVID-19 is on the open highway.
- 00:19:26No, I appreciate that Dr. Basset,
- 00:19:28and I appreciate sort of
- 00:19:30the intersectional intergenerational interracial nature
- 00:19:33of this conversation.
- 00:19:35And as Reverend Barber talks about
- 00:19:37sort of the need for the moral revival
- 00:19:39that is called for in this moment.
- 00:19:40And I appreciate you.
- 00:19:41I'm sorry we don't have more time.
- 00:19:43But you have teed up our next speaker
- 00:19:45perfectly, Dr. Bassett.
- 00:19:46So thank you so much
- 00:19:49and let me now, thank you so much, really appreciate you.
- 00:19:53And I will turn to your fellow clinician now,
- 00:19:56Dr. Eric Broat,
- 00:19:58a tribal health and inpatient COVID provider.
- 00:20:01Dr. Broat, after you introduce yourself,
- 00:20:03can you talk about how the COVID crisis is playing out
- 00:20:06in your community?
- 00:20:08Oh, good morning.
- 00:20:09Thanks for the opportunity to be here.
- 00:20:12I just want to start
- 00:20:13first by acknowledging the original inhabitants
- 00:20:15of the land that Oregon Health and Science University
- 00:20:18is built upon and occupying.
- 00:20:20I acknowledged the .
- 00:20:27I acknowledge the systemic policies
- 00:20:29of genocide, removal, relocation, and assimilation
- 00:20:33that have and continue to impact
- 00:20:35native communities to this day.
- 00:20:37And I also want to acknowledge that we are all here
- 00:20:40because of the sacrifices forced upon them.
- 00:20:43I work at Oregon Health and Science University.
- 00:20:45I'm a family medicine provider.
- 00:20:47I practice inpatient medicine
- 00:20:49at a large academic health institution as a COVID provider
- 00:20:53but then also work in a tribal health clinic
- 00:20:55in rural frontier central Oregon.
- 00:20:58And then I also lead and direct
- 00:21:00the Northwest Native American Center of Excellence,
- 00:21:02which is an educational initiative
- 00:21:04that believes in the power of indigenous youth
- 00:21:08and believes in the wisdom that we have in our communities
- 00:21:12to solve some of the most pressing challenges
- 00:21:14that are facing the world today.
- 00:21:17And what we aim to do specifically
- 00:21:19is to increase the number of us, indigenous people,
- 00:21:22who are working in the health work force
- 00:21:24and can become the future health leaders of tomorrow.
- 00:21:28You ask an excellent question.
- 00:21:30And I think that it's been alluded to
- 00:21:33in the introductory remarks,
- 00:21:34it was alluded to in the short clip of the video,
- 00:21:40it was also alluded to by the other partners
- 00:21:44who have spoken to this morning
- 00:21:46about how this is a crisis within a crisis.
- 00:21:50And it shows that there are systemic issues that are being,
- 00:21:55they're just laying bare
- 00:21:58how this is gonna disproportionately
- 00:22:00affect certain communities.
- 00:22:01And what's been the hardest thing for me to see is that,
- 00:22:07and to realize, is that it didn't have to be this way.
- 00:22:10You know like we could have had
- 00:22:13clean, safe water for everybody.
- 00:22:16We could have had affordable housing for everybody.
- 00:22:19We could have had access to testing and treatment options
- 00:22:22for more people.
- 00:22:24And I think it's those policies and those decisions
- 00:22:27that have been generations in the making
- 00:22:29that are driving the current circumstances
- 00:22:31that we face today.
- 00:22:33No, Dr. Broat, thank you for that.
- 00:22:35I mean it's sort of what I studied in medical school
- 00:22:38and graduate school as well, right?
- 00:22:39The social determinants of health,
- 00:22:41sort of taking on this not only holistic,
- 00:22:43but historical, what you talk about,
- 00:22:46it's like the nesting doll phenomenon,
- 00:22:47right a crisis within a crisis within a crisis.
- 00:22:50You spend a lot of your time
- 00:22:51thinking about health workforce shortage,
- 00:22:54data collection issues as well
- 00:22:56and how lack of data can lead to invisibility.
- 00:22:58Can you dig in for us a little bit on that, Dr. Broat?
- 00:23:02Well, as far as the health workforce issue
- 00:23:05you know, in the tribal health system,
- 00:23:08which is gonna be urban Indian health,
- 00:23:11sovereign tribal health clinics,
- 00:23:14but then also the Indian health service,
- 00:23:16we have a real challenge
- 00:23:18identifying the health workforce shortages
- 00:23:20that are out there.
- 00:23:21In our region,
- 00:23:22we actually just launched
- 00:23:26the first known tribal health workforce survey
- 00:23:28that's inclusive of all of the constituencies
- 00:23:33within the tribal health system
- 00:23:34and not siloed out.
- 00:23:35And when you look at these issues
- 00:23:38like access to care, right,
- 00:23:41places in the great plains
- 00:23:43or out here in the Pacific northwest,
- 00:23:45we may have some of the most beautiful, expensive facilities
- 00:23:52from the outside, right,
- 00:23:54where you have spent a lot of money and created jobs
- 00:23:57to build this facility,
- 00:23:59yet if you can't staff it,
- 00:24:01and if you don't have any doctors
- 00:24:02for instance, if you've built a large hospital
- 00:24:05that's supposed to serve tribal people,
- 00:24:08yet your ICU isn't staffed
- 00:24:11and it becomes a storage facility,
- 00:24:13how's that gonna help the people?
- 00:24:15Or if you have a large,
- 00:24:17or a really well-built primary care clinic
- 00:24:21but you don't have any doctors that work there,
- 00:24:24how are you gonna provide the care
- 00:24:26to people that are there?
- 00:24:28And I think those are the elements that can be tough
- 00:24:31when you're looking at lack or piosity of data around,
- 00:24:36whether it's the invisibility of indigenous people
- 00:24:39when it comes to having COVID,
- 00:24:41being admitted to the hospital,
- 00:24:43death rates, et cetera,
- 00:24:44the tribes have actually been doing tremendous work
- 00:24:47and the tribal epidemiology centers
- 00:24:48to correct the data
- 00:24:50and make sure that we are seen in the data.
- 00:24:53But then as well, from a workforce standpoint,
- 00:24:56if people don't even know the challenges that exist,
- 00:24:59how can we address them at a policy level?
- 00:25:01And so that's what we're really trying to do out here
- 00:25:04is have an accurate realistic picture
- 00:25:07of what the shortages are so we can do something about it.
- 00:25:10Appreciate that and appreciate you,
- 00:25:13sort of this notion of data justice that is so critical
- 00:25:17to getting beyond this.
- 00:25:19You know, it was interesting when we talked
- 00:25:21and I got to meet you, Dr. Broat,
- 00:25:22I was struck by something you said
- 00:25:24where you said you know, pandemics aren't new to us.
- 00:25:28Can you talk about how you contextualize this moment,
- 00:25:32this storm that we're all navigating through?
- 00:25:36And I think, you know, as COVID has gone on,
- 00:25:40you know, my wife and I, we live here in Portland, Oregon,
- 00:25:44we're both from tribal communities
- 00:25:46and we we plant a traditional garden in our yard
- 00:25:50and we grow those medicines and we grow those foods
- 00:25:53that we eat and we still practice those ways.
- 00:25:56And it hasn't been lost on me
- 00:25:59that our communities have faced tremendous challenges
- 00:26:02in the past,
- 00:26:04whether it's been colonization,
- 00:26:06whether it's been acts of genocide
- 00:26:09or whether it's been epidemics and pandemics.
- 00:26:11And people kept leaning in and thinking of us then
- 00:26:16so that we could be surviving now.
- 00:26:18They continued to plant those foods and those medicine
- 00:26:22and those are things that I draw strength from
- 00:26:25knowing that somebody kept doing that work
- 00:26:28and kept believing in those ways
- 00:26:31and thinking of us in a positive way for the future.
- 00:26:34And as I look at my own family story,
- 00:26:39in the 19 teens like my family,
- 00:26:44there are five people of Spent
- 00:26:47that died during an epidemic in Northern Minnesota.
- 00:26:50And these are stories that have been carried forward
- 00:26:53and we have not forgotten them.
- 00:26:55And so COVID in that sense has also been a painful reminder
- 00:26:59of the things that our ancestors went through.
- 00:27:03And it really wasn't that long ago.
- 00:27:06So those are the ways I think of that
- 00:27:10and that's how I contextualize it personally.
- 00:27:12I appreciate that so much, Dr. Broat,
- 00:27:13and I'm sorry, again, this rich conversation
- 00:27:17that we simply don't have enough time for
- 00:27:19but I will ask our audience.
- 00:27:20I thoroughly enjoyed getting to spend some time
- 00:27:24on the We Are the Healers website
- 00:27:26that shares your story and your leadership example
- 00:27:29as a clinician, as a tribal health leader.
- 00:27:31So appreciate that and appreciate you
- 00:27:33and looking forward to continuing in the Q and A session.
- 00:27:37So thank you, Dr. Broat.
- 00:27:38Now I'm gonna turn to Kaleal Cumberbatch.
- 00:27:41Kaleal, while mistakes are inevitable
- 00:27:46in the face of such a massive and rapidly evolving
- 00:27:48domestic and global challenge,
- 00:27:50I think it is clear that our federal government's
- 00:27:55and some state government's responses to the pandemic
- 00:27:58are marked by massive failures in judgment and inaction.
- 00:28:02And these failures obviously land most heavily
- 00:28:04on vulnerable and marginalized populations,
- 00:28:07including incarcerated citizens.
- 00:28:09And for example,
- 00:28:10we know that the five largest outbreaks in the country
- 00:28:12are linked to correctional facilities.
- 00:28:14You're a senior fellow at the council on criminal justice,
- 00:28:17which launched the national commission
- 00:28:19on COVID-19 and criminal justice.
- 00:28:22Can you first walk us through the genesis of the commission?
- 00:28:25Why was it set up?
- 00:28:26Who's on the commission?
- 00:28:28And some of your key findings on the impact of COVID-19
- 00:28:31on incarcerated citizens and the criminal justice system?
- 00:28:35Thank you, Cheryl
- 00:28:36and thank you to the staff at Skoll,
- 00:28:38Jimmy Briggs in particular for organizing this amazing event
- 00:28:42and his team for making it extremely easy to be here.
- 00:28:45The national commission on COVID-19
- 00:28:47and the criminal justice system
- 00:28:50was established by the Council on Criminal Justice.
- 00:28:53The Council on Criminal Justice is a think tank
- 00:28:56and a membership organization
- 00:28:57that was founded last year by Adam Gell.
- 00:29:00Much like the Council on Foreign Relations,
- 00:29:03the council aims to create a new center of gravity
- 00:29:07for fact-based, evidence-informed
- 00:29:10criminal justice conversations.
- 00:29:12The council launched the commission
- 00:29:14because frankly no one else had.
- 00:29:17There needed to be a serious,
- 00:29:19nonpartisan national conversation
- 00:29:21on how the criminal justice system
- 00:29:24was going to respond to COVID-19.
- 00:29:26And so the council stepped in
- 00:29:28and stepped up to fill the void.
- 00:29:30The commission is led and co-chaired
- 00:29:33by two former attorney generals,
- 00:29:35Loretta Lynch and Alberto Gonzalez,
- 00:29:37along with 11 other leaders
- 00:29:39from the criminal justice area
- 00:29:42who bring various perspectives,
- 00:29:44including public health and public safety.
- 00:29:47In addition, my colleague Thomas Apt
- 00:29:48serves as the director of the commission
- 00:29:51and last month the commission released its recommendations
- 00:29:54for response and future readiness
- 00:29:56offering a series of broad and overlapping recommendations,
- 00:30:00as well as a series of sector-specific recommendations
- 00:30:04covering the sectors of courts, corrections,
- 00:30:07community-based organizations and policing.
- 00:30:10To that end, here are a few of the major recommendations
- 00:30:14the commission has already made.
- 00:30:17One is to go beyond the CDC guidance
- 00:30:21to stop exponential growth of COVID-19
- 00:30:23within the criminal justice system,
- 00:30:25essentially making the CDC guidance the floor
- 00:30:28as opposed to the ceiling.
- 00:30:30Communicate transparently about COVID-19 response plans,
- 00:30:33policies, and more importantly,
- 00:30:36and to some extent of the utmost importance, data.
- 00:30:39As Dr. Bassett mentioned,
- 00:30:41data is something that is very little
- 00:30:43and it's hard to come by,
- 00:30:45especially from major corrections
- 00:30:48agencies all across the country.
- 00:30:51Third, adopt universal masking requirements for all staff
- 00:30:55and impacted population
- 00:30:57when indoors and in close contact with others.
- 00:31:00Four, widely and frequently test staff
- 00:31:03in justice involved populations for COVID-19
- 00:31:07using the most reliable methods available.
- 00:31:10Fifth, limit contact and maximize distance
- 00:31:13and reduce density.
- 00:31:15As we all know, density is one of the major factors
- 00:31:17that COVID-19 plays on to accelerate its spread.
- 00:31:22And last, but certainly not least,
- 00:31:24to actively engage and consider impacted communities
- 00:31:28in all decision-making processes.
- 00:31:32There's a link in the chat
- 00:31:34for folks to check out the full report
- 00:31:36and we hope that that you'll read it
- 00:31:38to learn a little bit more.
- 00:31:39Moving forward, the commission will be releasing
- 00:31:42more recommendations in December
- 00:31:44and these recommendations will be focusing
- 00:31:47more on systemic issues,
- 00:31:49looking to capitalize on the lessons learned
- 00:31:52and to really try to envision
- 00:31:55post-pandemic criminal justice system
- 00:31:57that is way more better aligned
- 00:32:00with public health and public safety
- 00:32:02than the current one that we have.
- 00:32:03Thank you, Kaleal.
- 00:32:04Can I ask, has the current administration
- 00:32:06and even agencies at the state and local level,
- 00:32:09have they been receptive
- 00:32:11and have any of the recommendations you just laid out for us
- 00:32:14been adopted and implemented?
- 00:32:17Yeah, we would,
- 00:32:19we've been sharing our report and its findings
- 00:32:22and its recommendations widely
- 00:32:24with quite literally any and everyone.
- 00:32:27That's a key role of myself
- 00:32:28and one of my colleagues, Andrew Page
- 00:32:30To our knowledge,
- 00:32:32so far we don't know of any entities
- 00:32:37that have implemented any of the recommendations
- 00:32:40that we laid forth in the report.
- 00:32:44However, you know, it's extremely difficult
- 00:32:47to get states and localities all on the same page,
- 00:32:50and especially with the absence
- 00:32:52of strong federal leadership.
- 00:32:53And so more importantly, what we would hope,
- 00:32:56is that those entities are focusing
- 00:32:59on producing and reporting data
- 00:33:03that would help to give us a better idea
- 00:33:05of what the best practices are.
- 00:33:07And unfortunately, we don't see that right now.
- 00:33:11Right.
- 00:33:12So I was talking a couple of weeks ago.
- 00:33:16I'm looking, in this moment, Kaleal,
- 00:33:17for bright spots, right?
- 00:33:19So I was talking a couple of weeks ago
- 00:33:21with an Echoing Green fellow,
- 00:33:23fellow Echoing Green fellow, Van Jones
- 00:33:25and he's with Reform Alliance
- 00:33:26and he was sort of giving me an update
- 00:33:28on the alliance's safer plans acronym,
- 00:33:31which sort of talks about many of the recommendations
- 00:33:34that your organization laid out.
- 00:33:36But in particularly he was talking
- 00:33:37about the push and success
- 00:33:39around releasing elderly and the vulnerable
- 00:33:42to home confinement, right,
- 00:33:44just to get them out of those dense spaces, as you said.
- 00:33:46Can you talk about any other bright spots
- 00:33:48that you're seeing?
- 00:33:50Right the grassroots energy
- 00:33:51around protecting our fellow incarcerated citizens?
- 00:33:55Yeah, sure.
- 00:33:56I mean I think one of the silver linings,
- 00:33:59if we can call it that,
- 00:34:00that came out of the way that COVID-19
- 00:34:02just completely ravaged the criminal justice system
- 00:34:05is that we are seeing municipalities, states,
- 00:34:08and to some extent the federal government,
- 00:34:10do exactly what many advocates were calling for
- 00:34:13in some cases for decades,
- 00:34:15which is essentially to rapidly decarcerate
- 00:34:17or to deconcentrate the criminal justice system.
- 00:34:20And so one of the ways of doing that
- 00:34:23is the one that you mentioned,
- 00:34:24that Van and the Reform Alliance had laid out.
- 00:34:26But there are many more,
- 00:34:27particularly in the pretrial phase
- 00:34:29of a person's involvement in the criminal justice system.
- 00:34:31And for those who may not be aware,
- 00:34:33pre-trial is essentially the phase
- 00:34:35where a person is legally innocent,
- 00:34:36as we all have the legal and constitutional right
- 00:34:39to be viewed as innocent before guilty.
- 00:34:42And we've seen some municipalities
- 00:34:45drop their jail population by 50% in a matter of months.
- 00:34:50And this is a notion
- 00:34:52that those same municipalities and many across the country
- 00:34:56said were almost impossible.
- 00:34:57And it was due largely
- 00:35:00because of the grassroots efforts
- 00:35:02that were largely putting those options
- 00:35:04in front of those municipalities in those states,
- 00:35:07again, for sometimes decades
- 00:35:09before we actually saw it done
- 00:35:11over the course of the months from March
- 00:35:13until, to some extent, August.
- 00:35:16That's extraordinarily important,
- 00:35:18really appreciate you raising that Kaleal.
- 00:35:20I wish we had more time.
- 00:35:21This is such an important topic,
- 00:35:23but appreciate you dropping in the study
- 00:35:25with recommendations
- 00:35:26and we'll look forward to hearing more
- 00:35:28about what the council is up to.
- 00:35:31So thank you so much for that.
- 00:35:33Now I'm gonna turn to our next speaker, Sonia Perez,
- 00:35:36who is COO of UnidosUS,
- 00:35:38formerly National Council of La Raza.
- 00:35:41UnidosUS is the nation's largest
- 00:35:43Latino civil rights and advocacy organization.
- 00:35:46Sonia, you sit on top of an extraordinary network
- 00:35:50and you are seeing and hearing a lot as well as doing a lot.
- 00:35:52Can you talk to us about the disparate impact of COVID-19
- 00:35:55on Latinos in the US?
- 00:35:57Yes, absolutely.
- 00:35:58And thank you again, Cheryl, for this conversation,
- 00:36:01to Skoll, to all the panelists.
- 00:36:03It's really powerful for all of us to come together
- 00:36:06and I know we feel a tremendous responsibility
- 00:36:08for the communities that we serve
- 00:36:10and for creating the kind of world we want to live in
- 00:36:13and ensuring equity among these communities.
- 00:36:16So this is work UnidosUS
- 00:36:18has been doing for more than five decades
- 00:36:20and really seeing firsthand right
- 00:36:23the structural inequalities across issues, right?
- 00:36:27It isn't just about health,
- 00:36:28it's housing, it's economic and employment opportunities,
- 00:36:31it's education.
- 00:36:32So we are not surprised, frankly,
- 00:36:36having seen the impact of COVID on the Latino community.
- 00:36:39We're about 19% of the US population
- 00:36:42and yet about 37% of COVID cases nationwide
- 00:36:47are among Latinos, among children in particular.
- 00:36:50It's a huge concern because we're seeing deaths
- 00:36:54among children age five to 17,
- 00:36:57among Latino children, again, facing COVID
- 00:37:01it's about 37% of deaths among children are Latino.
- 00:37:04So we're seeing the implications on this population,
- 00:37:08which is a critical,
- 00:37:09it's not just for the Latino population,
- 00:37:11it's for the country, right,
- 00:37:13we're a young population,
- 00:37:14we're about one in five Americans.
- 00:37:16So the future of the country
- 00:37:18really rests on the economic and wellbeing of Latinos.
- 00:37:21And I would say
- 00:37:22that the community-based network in particular
- 00:37:25that we work with,
- 00:37:26affiliates across the country and in Puerto Rico,
- 00:37:29and we should talk about Puerto Rico
- 00:37:31and the experience of COVID there as well.
- 00:37:34But these are organizations
- 00:37:36that are serving on the front lines,
- 00:37:38really have the experience
- 00:37:40of seeing how COVID is affecting our community
- 00:37:43and also have pivoted to be able to provide services
- 00:37:46and do what is needed
- 00:37:48in the absence of a federal coordinated response.
- 00:37:52I'd love to dig into that if you don't mind.
- 00:37:55So now I know
- 00:37:56that you, you have such a broad network, you know
- 00:37:59hundreds and hundreds of organizations
- 00:38:00that are part of your national network.
- 00:38:02And as you look across the country,
- 00:38:04can you share some place-based examples
- 00:38:06of how civic organizations are standing in the breach,
- 00:38:09whether at the border, middle of the country,
- 00:38:11big urban areas?
- 00:38:12Would love to hear some again some bright spots, Sonia.
- 00:38:16Sure, well, I do think
- 00:38:17that one of the lessons we've learned
- 00:38:18is from listening to these organizations,
- 00:38:21listening to our affiliate network
- 00:38:22and understanding what they're seeing,
- 00:38:25but also using that information to shape our responses.
- 00:38:28So for example, they talked very early on
- 00:38:31about the need for money, more resources for the community.
- 00:38:34So we did set up an Esperanza Hope Fund, as we called it,
- 00:38:38to do a focus on public health messaging,
- 00:38:41for example, in dual language,
- 00:38:43and I would refer folks to our website, unidosus.org.
- 00:38:46We do have a toolkit and a bunch of materials,
- 00:38:50again, developed in coordination with these organizations,
- 00:38:53specifically around messaging
- 00:38:55that works for the Latino community.
- 00:38:57So using the resources of the Hope Fund
- 00:39:01to do public health messaging
- 00:39:02and to target the community,
- 00:39:04to support these organizations with resources for them,
- 00:39:07to provide cash assistance
- 00:39:10to do emergency relief, to pivot
- 00:39:12from what they were doing
- 00:39:13to then now provide food banks
- 00:39:16and to provide health services and testing, et cetera,
- 00:39:19and also to do national advocacy.
- 00:39:21So using the information that we learned
- 00:39:23and listening to them, learning from them,
- 00:39:26being able to elevate their stories and what they've done.
- 00:39:28So, for example, in Chicago,
- 00:39:31on the South side of Chicago,
- 00:39:32Esperanza Health Centers very early on
- 00:39:35used a data-based and driven approach,
- 00:39:38which we all hear
- 00:39:40is critical to solving this problem
- 00:39:42and understanding taking a particular community
- 00:39:45where they were working tracking the positivity rate
- 00:39:48and doing testing in order to reduce the positivity rate
- 00:39:51and communicating that to the community, right?
- 00:39:54The science and the knowledge and the facts that we have
- 00:39:58can be translated
- 00:39:59so that everybody can understand what it means
- 00:40:01and how they can protect themselves.
- 00:40:02You provide the information,
- 00:40:04communities will protect themselves.
- 00:40:06This same organization is now engaged
- 00:40:08in educating and informing the community
- 00:40:11about the importance of vaccine trials.
- 00:40:13So, you know, that's just one example
- 00:40:15of one small community.
- 00:40:16I would also point to Reading, Pennsylvania
- 00:40:18as another place where some innovative leadership
- 00:40:22was taking place
- 00:40:23with one of our affiliate executive directors
- 00:40:25who reached out to us
- 00:40:27to share the concern
- 00:40:28about the fact that kids are being remote,
- 00:40:31you know, remote learning is happening
- 00:40:32and yet in Reading, Pennsylvania,
- 00:40:3490% of the kids in that school district are Latino
- 00:40:38and yet did not have all,
- 00:40:39they did not have access to the internet,
- 00:40:41did not have the digital devices.
- 00:40:45This organization, the Hispanic Center of Reading
- 00:40:48knows that we work with Comcast.
- 00:40:49So we coordinated a conversation
- 00:40:51between Comcast Reading, the Reading School District
- 00:40:55and this affiliate.
- 00:40:57And as a result, they were able to do an agreement
- 00:41:00to ensure that 10,000 students
- 00:41:02have now access to the internet
- 00:41:03and to these devices.
- 00:41:05So there are ways that you can address the local issues
- 00:41:08by listening to what's happening at the community,
- 00:41:11but also looking for opportunities for partnership, right?
- 00:41:14It isn't just about one organization
- 00:41:16or one entity or one sector addressing this.
- 00:41:20It's really all of us coming together.
- 00:41:21And I think we're seeing that clearly
- 00:41:23from the examples in these communities.
- 00:41:25No, I so appreciate you raising that up,
- 00:41:27sort of the sine qua non of social innovation
- 00:41:30is sort of this alliance-based model for change, right,
- 00:41:33bringing together partnerships and collaborations
- 00:41:35that drive change.
- 00:41:36So appreciate that.
- 00:41:38Don't have a lot of time left, Sonia,
- 00:41:40but given just the import of the work
- 00:41:42and leadership of UnidosUS,
- 00:41:44can you talk about how this crisis, the pandemic,
- 00:41:47has sort of shaped the organization's thinking
- 00:41:50around equity considerations?
- 00:41:51Has it changed their policy, agenda you're organizing?
- 00:41:54I'm just curious how you all are navigating this moment.
- 00:41:57Yeah, I think this is the moment.
- 00:41:59I mean, this year, we're all experiencing this,
- 00:42:01the refocus and importance of elevating conversations
- 00:42:04around racism, around racial injustice,
- 00:42:09around structural racism and inequities that we've,
- 00:42:12again, we've been working on these issues
- 00:42:13for more than five decades
- 00:42:15and it isn't just happening in one place,
- 00:42:17it's happening across different issues.
- 00:42:19And we can, I think, take this moment and this opportunity
- 00:42:23to expand the conversation
- 00:42:25about what does it mean that we're a nation that's changing,
- 00:42:28demographics are changing,
- 00:42:30that we need to think about how racism
- 00:42:32affects different communities of color.
- 00:42:35And also in the case of Latinos,
- 00:42:37again, because of the size of the population,
- 00:42:40you know, 20% of the US population is Latino,
- 00:42:45young population, the future of our country
- 00:42:46in terms of workers and taxpayers.
- 00:42:48So we need to broaden the conversation
- 00:42:50to think about what does it mean for this community.
- 00:42:53And really once we're looking at issues of equity,
- 00:42:56it isn't just affecting our communities of color.
- 00:42:58It's about creating the country that we want
- 00:43:00and how we all benefit from that.
- 00:43:03No, so appreciate that Sonia.
- 00:43:05Never has that felt more important
- 00:43:07than in this moment on this day
- 00:43:10when we're looking to election day
- 00:43:11just a few short days from now.
- 00:43:13So appreciate you, appreciate those remarks.
- 00:43:15Thank you so much.
- 00:43:16I'm gonna turn to the last speaker in this segment,
- 00:43:19Cynthia Troy.
- 00:43:20Hi Cynthia.
- 00:43:22You know, I have to say I've known of
- 00:43:24and followed your work at Chinese for Affirmative Action
- 00:43:27because your co-executive director, Vincent Pan,
- 00:43:29is an Echoing Green alum.
- 00:43:31So LA have long appreciated your work.
- 00:43:34And I also know that long before the pandemic,
- 00:43:36you all were organizing the Chinese American community
- 00:43:40to participate in mass rallies and vigils
- 00:43:42in response to rising xenophobia
- 00:43:44and white nationalism in San Francisco's Chinatown.
- 00:43:48Can you talk about this moment,
- 00:43:50which is not at all new for your constituents,
- 00:43:53but magnified and complicated
- 00:43:55by the impacts of this disease?
- 00:43:58Thank you, Cheryl and thanks for this opportunity
- 00:44:02to talk about the disparate impact
- 00:44:05on the Asian-American community.
- 00:44:07So as the panelists have articulated well,
- 00:44:11I think COVID has really exposed
- 00:44:14the pre-existing condition of structural racism
- 00:44:17and how that's played out in our community
- 00:44:20is the fact that there has been a surge
- 00:44:23in anti-Asian racism and xenophobic
- 00:44:26that's manifested in attacks against our community.
- 00:44:30So in the same ways
- 00:44:32that our community has had health impacts,
- 00:44:36disparate economic impacts.
- 00:44:38Here in San Francisco, over 50% of the deaths are Asian.
- 00:44:44We also see that with Asian American workers
- 00:44:48and in the labor force,
- 00:44:50because that they are working in the hospitality industry,
- 00:44:55retail and so forth,
- 00:44:57that they're not only losing their jobs,
- 00:44:59but they are also facing discrimination
- 00:45:03and being attacked while being essential workers.
- 00:45:07But with regard to our work with our partners,
- 00:45:11we started Stop API Hate with APCON based in Los Angeles
- 00:45:17and SF State University.
- 00:45:19We came together
- 00:45:20because we knew that the backlash would be severe.
- 00:45:24This isn't anything new, as you pointed out.
- 00:45:27It actually defines our experience
- 00:45:30as Asians, as immigrants here,
- 00:45:33where we have been blamed for economic crisis,
- 00:45:37public health crisis,
- 00:45:39and of course,
- 00:45:40whenever there's any kind of US foreign relations issue.
- 00:45:46And just imagine all three of these things coming together.
- 00:45:49So it's the trifecta.
- 00:45:51And what's that resulted in
- 00:45:53is we have 2,700 incidents
- 00:45:57that have come onto our reporting site
- 00:45:59where individuals while living out their daily lives
- 00:46:03have been verbally attacked, physically attacked
- 00:46:05and encountered discrimination in the workplace
- 00:46:09and in private businesses.
- 00:46:10And we did this because we wanted to
- 00:46:15number one, have it be taken seriously.
- 00:46:17So we have been able to do that, to make a case.
- 00:46:21We also wanted to make sure
- 00:46:23that the response to it was appropriate.
- 00:46:26So there's been a huge focus on policing and hate crimes.
- 00:46:31We think that that's the wrong direction.
- 00:46:34We actually want to promote practices
- 00:46:36that will not cause further harm,
- 00:46:38will not further criminalize.
- 00:46:41And in fact, we want to focus on community-based efforts
- 00:46:45that really address safety and justice
- 00:46:48and the root causes of violence in our community.
- 00:46:52And I'm very inspired by the fact that this is happening
- 00:46:56not just here in California, but throughout the country.
- 00:47:02So appreciate that.
- 00:47:04And can you talk a little bit,
- 00:47:06in regards to the Stop API Hate campaign,
- 00:47:09how that intersects, works in alliance,
- 00:47:12with groups like Black Lives Matter,
- 00:47:14to advance the cause of racial equity more generally?
- 00:47:18Where are the overlaps there, Cynthia?
- 00:47:21We think it's inextricably tied.
- 00:47:24Our work is rooted in the recognition
- 00:47:28that black, indigenous, people of color and immigrants,
- 00:47:31we need to work together and in solidarity,
- 00:47:35which is why, I think, we've worked very hard
- 00:47:38to actually point to the racist rhetoric,
- 00:47:42white supremacy,
- 00:47:44and the fact that we have over 400 anti-immigrant policies
- 00:47:50that have been enacted under the Trump administration.
- 00:47:54Many of you know about the more familiar ones,
- 00:47:57like the trying to end DACA, the Muslim ban.
- 00:48:01What we're trying to do is educate our own community
- 00:48:05about the history of white supremacy,
- 00:48:08the history of policing in the United States.
- 00:48:12And this is the work that many organizations,
- 00:48:15as I said, including ours,
- 00:48:17are working to educate our community
- 00:48:19who may not be familiar with those civil rights history
- 00:48:22and the fact that there is a racial hierarchy, colorism,
- 00:48:27and this is all work that we need to dismantle together.
- 00:48:31No, so appreciate that,
- 00:48:32sort of the reference to, you know, game-changing works
- 00:48:37like Isabel Wilkerson's cast,
- 00:48:39you know, sort of the history of racial violence is broad.
- 00:48:43I'm thinking back to the anti-Chinese riots,
- 00:48:45the Rock Springs Massacre,
- 00:48:47forced evacuations in the specific Northwest
- 00:48:49in the 19th century.
- 00:48:51This is as old as our country, Cynthia.
- 00:48:54And how do you align sort of the energy
- 00:48:58of things like Stop API Hate campaign
- 00:49:02along with this political moment?
- 00:49:04How do you continue to have that sort of energy
- 00:49:07and focus and attention on this work
- 00:49:10that might be heightened during a election season
- 00:49:13to ensure that it continues after?
- 00:49:17Well, we obviously have done a lot
- 00:49:19to try to engage our community.
- 00:49:22We have 11 million potential voters
- 00:49:26from the Asian-American community,
- 00:49:28one of the fastest growing electorates,
- 00:49:32but we have had a problem with turnout.
- 00:49:35And so that has been the huge push.
- 00:49:37And now we have what is,
- 00:49:40I think we've seen some statistics
- 00:49:42about young people, young voters
- 00:49:45who are more animated now
- 00:49:46because of the fact that we are having a racial reckoning,
- 00:49:50we are connecting the dots to what's happening to us,
- 00:49:53to other communities of color.
- 00:49:56And the fact that it's important
- 00:49:58that we recognize that this is structural racism,
- 00:50:01it's not new,
- 00:50:02and that we can actually do something about that.
- 00:50:04And so regardless of the outcome of the election,
- 00:50:08our work needs to continue.
- 00:50:11I just want to remind the fact
- 00:50:13that in prior democratic administrations
- 00:50:16we were deporting people,
- 00:50:18there was an effort to criminalize parts of our community.
- 00:50:21And so I think we have to recognize
- 00:50:24that whatever the election outcomes,
- 00:50:27we actually need to build more movements
- 00:50:30that are doing work within our community,
- 00:50:32as well as across our communities.
- 00:50:34And that's the energy and what inspires me today.
- 00:50:37No, that's beautifully said.
- 00:50:39So thank you, Cynthia.
- 00:50:40Perfect moment for me to pause here
- 00:50:43and to thank you and all of our speakers
- 00:50:45in this first segment.
- 00:50:46Thank you for educating us and taking us on this journey.
- 00:50:48And I'll just say, I'll end where I began.
- 00:50:50You know, we're in a crisis,
- 00:50:52we have to name it,
- 00:50:54we have to own it.
- 00:50:55You know, I was reminded the official magazine of the NAACP,
- 00:50:57which has been in continuous publication since 1910
- 00:51:00is named The Crisis.
- 00:51:01And the first editor of that magazine,
- 00:51:04the great W.E.B. Dubois wanted,
- 00:51:06through the name and the narratives,
- 00:51:08to convey what a critical moment it was
- 00:51:11for black folks in this country,
- 00:51:13what a dangerous moment it was for them.
- 00:51:16But the magazine was also
- 00:51:18an extraordinarily important vehicle
- 00:51:20for many of the key voices of the Harlem Renaissance.
- 00:51:23And I will say I've always been really heartened
- 00:51:25by that trajectory toward inspiration and transformation
- 00:51:29out of pain and trauma.
- 00:51:32And I think it really sets up perfectly
- 00:51:34our next moderator Jimmy Briggs,
- 00:51:36a Skoll Foundation principle and journalist
- 00:51:39whose prose is truly poetry.
- 00:51:41He's now convened a group of creatives,
- 00:51:43innovators who are responding to the pandemic
- 00:51:46who are drawing from community need and culture
- 00:51:49working every day to prevent the pandemic spread
- 00:51:51and help those impacted by this disease.
- 00:51:54So I'm really honored to turn it over to you, Jimmy.
- 00:51:59Thank you so much for that gracious introduction
- 00:52:02and also for your masterful questioning and dialogue
- 00:52:07with our speakers.
- 00:52:09For myself, I just want to acknowledge a few people,
- 00:52:12I guess in-house business, if you will.
- 00:52:14You know, I think it was brother Kaleal
- 00:52:16who called me out in his remarks
- 00:52:19for putting this together,
- 00:52:20but I have to acknowledge and honor my colleagues
- 00:52:23within the Skoll Foundation,
- 00:52:24who've been working so tirelessly alongside me,
- 00:52:26to bring this vision to fruition,
- 00:52:28namely Jessica Flooty, Phil Collis, Claire Wathan,
- 00:52:31Jule Alton, Robin Belinsky,
- 00:52:34Sierra Gonzalez and Norma Rodriguez,
- 00:52:36along with Theresa Chen.
- 00:52:37And also thank you, Don Gibbs, our CEO
- 00:52:40for giving the green light to do this pilot town hall
- 00:52:43and your affirmation of the vision and learning agenda
- 00:52:48we want to build from it.
- 00:52:49I also, I have to, as Cheryl notes,
- 00:52:53we are on the crisis,
- 00:52:54I feel compelled to,
- 00:52:57in love, as Tulane pointed out the need for love,
- 00:53:00hold up the families
- 00:53:02of Walter Wallace and Qoran Holton Brown,
- 00:53:04who are suffering in Philadelphia and DC as we speak,
- 00:53:09and also really want to send prayers and affirmation
- 00:53:14to Washington DC and Philadelphia
- 00:53:16in the midst of uprisings
- 00:53:18in response to the murders of those gentlemen,
- 00:53:22as well as our fallen sister Breonna Tayler,
- 00:53:25who herself was a frontline activist
- 00:53:28in the midst of COVID-19 whose life was taken.
- 00:53:31I want to introduce our discussants
- 00:53:33and remain mindful of time.
- 00:53:36I want to introduce them,
- 00:53:37allow them the opportunity to speak
- 00:53:39about their respective work
- 00:53:41and impact they're seeing
- 00:53:43and the impact of COVID-19,
- 00:53:44but also the impact that their words and actions are having
- 00:53:46in response to COVID-19
- 00:53:48and then bring both groups together as a whole
- 00:53:52so we can percolate the responses
- 00:53:56and questions that are popcorning in the chat now.
- 00:53:58First, I want to introduce Ernest Boykin,
- 00:54:01who is a criminal justice reform advocate
- 00:54:03and works in partnership
- 00:54:05with Families Against Mandatory Minimums.
- 00:54:06We also have Kim Gallon,
- 00:54:08associate professor of history at Purdue University
- 00:54:10and the founder of COVID Black,
- 00:54:12as well as the Nathaniel Smith,
- 00:54:14founder and chief equity officer
- 00:54:16of the Partnership for Southern Equity in Atlanta, Georgia.
- 00:54:18Then we have Monique Tula,
- 00:54:20who's executive director
- 00:54:21for the National Harm Reduction Coalition.
- 00:54:23And finally Dr. Olajide Williams,
- 00:54:25who's professor of neurology at Columbia University
- 00:54:27and the father of Hip Hop Public Health.
- 00:54:30My first question will be directed towards Ernest Boykin.
- 00:54:34Brother Ernest, you heard Kaleal Cumberbatch
- 00:54:37from the Council on Criminal Justice
- 00:54:38speak about the impact of COVID-19
- 00:54:41on incarceration and the criminal justice system.
- 00:54:43I was hoping, Ernest,
- 00:54:44you could briefly share your perspective
- 00:54:48of what those who are currently incarcerated
- 00:54:52in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic are experiencing
- 00:54:54and what the journey home is like
- 00:54:56coming back to one's home community
- 00:55:00that is debilitated sometimes even more deeply,
- 00:55:03not only by systemic racism, but now by the pandemic?
- 00:55:06Hey, hello.
- 00:55:08I'd like to say thank you at the Jimmy and Skoll Foundation
- 00:55:10and thank you to the panel.
- 00:55:12And you know, my heart goes out to the young man, Qoran.
- 00:55:16I actually live in the same neighborhood as he does.
- 00:55:20That's right down the street.
- 00:55:21He was killed on Seventh and Kennedy Street Northwest.
- 00:55:24I live on 14th and Kennedy, so that really hits home.
- 00:55:28I've seen the protest and it's terrible.
- 00:55:33But back to what you said, Jimmy,
- 00:55:36basically I didn't understand at first
- 00:55:39why I was selected for this panel.
- 00:55:42However, once I listened to everybody
- 00:55:45and Jimmy brought me up to speed,
- 00:55:48I feel like I can really add a great perspective
- 00:55:51because I was a recipient of compassionate release
- 00:55:55on July the 17th,
- 00:55:57and most people who were were incarcerated
- 00:56:00or in that situation,
- 00:56:01a lot of people don't have the ability
- 00:56:03to articulate themselves
- 00:56:05and speak about what they went through
- 00:56:09or what they're going through.
- 00:56:10So I want to be that voice
- 00:56:11for the people who can't speak for themselves,
- 00:56:15the voiceless.
- 00:56:18Coming home from prison is like,
- 00:56:23just to put you in perspective,
- 00:56:25imagine being in a coma, and then you sleep for two years,
- 00:56:33a year, however long you're in that coma
- 00:56:35and then you wake up, you come home,
- 00:56:38and there's new buildings,
- 00:56:41there's new people that live in your neighborhood,
- 00:56:43kids have grown up,
- 00:56:46it's like a shock.
- 00:56:47And that's the same thing
- 00:56:49that a person coming home from prison
- 00:56:51experiences on a normal day.
- 00:56:55They understand that they come home from prison,
- 00:56:56nothing's gonna be the same,
- 00:56:58especially if they've been in there
- 00:56:59for a year, five years, 10 years, 20 years, 30 years.
- 00:57:03However, during the midst of this COVID,
- 00:57:07for everybody to understand what a person is going through,
- 00:57:09just put yourself in the position like you were in a coma
- 00:57:12and you come out
- 00:57:12and now you see everybody with masks on,
- 00:57:15you're basically thinking you're free from prison
- 00:57:17but you're going back in the house to be locked down.
- 00:57:20So you can't move around like you want,
- 00:57:22the processes are slowed down,
- 00:57:24he DMV is slowed down so you can't get an ID.
- 00:57:28So without an ID, you can't really have healthcare,
- 00:57:31you can't drive, you can't do anything without an ID.
- 00:57:35So things like that have been impeded by this COVID process,
- 00:57:39not only the systems,
- 00:57:44but now you can't see your family members
- 00:57:46or your loved ones
- 00:57:48that you've missed over this period of time
- 00:57:50that you've been absent.
- 00:57:51And you know, I look at it
- 00:57:55as a good and a bad thing,
- 00:57:57you know, because that's the type of person I am,
- 00:57:58I always can find the good in a situation.
- 00:58:01Being that COVID has struck,
- 00:58:04there are a lot of opportunities for returning citizens
- 00:58:07to gain employment now.
- 00:58:09There's a lot of jobs that people don't want to take
- 00:58:12because of COVID.
- 00:58:13So now there are opportunities
- 00:58:16for people who want to better themselves to go back to work.
- 00:58:19There's also opportunity for a person
- 00:58:22to do online education and things like that.
- 00:58:26So I can look at the upside,
- 00:58:28but a lot of people, they don't look at the upside
- 00:58:31because COVID is affecting minorities,
- 00:58:34it's affecting the black and brown community,
- 00:58:36even the Asian community,
- 00:58:38a lot differently than it is affecting the white community
- 00:58:42or the affluent community.
- 00:58:45I live in a community, like I said,
- 00:58:47I live on 14th and Kennedy street
- 00:58:49and all the houses around me are pretty big houses within
- 00:58:54and we're right across from Rock Creek Park,
- 00:58:56the famous Rock Creek Park.
- 00:58:58But if you go down the street three blocks, three blocks,
- 00:59:02this is where the gentleman was killed by the cops.
- 00:59:05They chased him on a moped,
- 00:59:07which is supposed to be against policy,
- 00:59:10and he was murdered.
- 00:59:11So there's all kinds of poverty.
- 00:59:14The line is really thin but it's a big gap,
- 00:59:18it's a huge gap.
- 00:59:20And this is the difference.
- 00:59:23The white community is experiencing one COVID
- 00:59:25and the poor people,
- 00:59:27the blacks, the browns and even the Asians
- 00:59:31who are being discriminated against
- 00:59:32because they calling it the China virus,
- 00:59:35they're experiencing a whole other COVID.
- 00:59:38My neighbors, who are most of them are white,
- 00:59:41they're in their gardens,
- 00:59:42they're with their kids,
- 00:59:43they're with their dogs
- 00:59:45they're buying new things because they have money,
- 00:59:49some of them are executives
- 00:59:50and they're taking out huge salaries from home
- 00:59:53and they're enjoying themselves,
- 00:59:55they're enjoying this pandemic,
- 00:59:56even though they can't go out,
- 00:59:57but they still have the opportunity
- 00:59:59to order to the house,
- 01:00:03they can go to the grocery store and buy crab legs
- 01:00:05and see food and have a good old time.
- 01:00:08But then the people in the poor communities,
- 01:00:11the people who have just returned from prison,
- 01:00:15they are actually having a really tough time.
- 01:00:18They are really trying to struggle how to make ends meet
- 01:00:22and trying to figure out,
- 01:00:24goodness gracious Lysol is five dollars a can
- 01:00:27and then now I have to do this
- 01:00:30and I got to get on the bus
- 01:00:31with people sneezing and coughing.
- 01:00:34You got to get on the back of the bus at DC.
- 01:00:36It's free now, yes, it's free.
- 01:00:38However, you got to get on the back of the bus
- 01:00:40and the symbolism in just getting on the back of the bus
- 01:00:44for a black person is terrible.
- 01:00:47This is what black people had to do,
- 01:00:49get on the back of the bus,
- 01:00:51and now they have to do it again because of COVID.
- 01:00:53Thank you so much, Ernest.
- 01:00:54Thank you for that perspective,
- 01:00:56that barely needed perspective.
- 01:00:58I want to go to Dr. Williams,
- 01:01:02Hip Hop Public Health.
- 01:01:03Dr. Williams, we've heard previously from several speakers
- 01:01:07about the need for communications and narrative.
- 01:01:10And from your perspective, I'm curious,
- 01:01:12I mean through Hip Hop Public Health,
- 01:01:14you are working to create culturally resonant messaging,
- 01:01:19behavioral health messaging,
- 01:01:20particularly for black and Latin X populations.
- 01:01:23And I'm wondering,
- 01:01:24as a physician public health specialist,
- 01:01:27can you speak to the work of Hip Hop Public Health
- 01:01:29but also the critical need for messaging
- 01:01:33that reaches the communities
- 01:01:36that need to be served the most?
- 01:01:39Sure.
- 01:01:40First of all, I just want to thank,
- 01:01:41thank you, Jimmy,
- 01:01:42for putting this together and the entire Skoll team.
- 01:01:47So, you know, Hip Hop Public Health,
- 01:01:49we recognize the challenge of behavior change
- 01:01:54and the myriad structural barriers that are often tied
- 01:01:59to social determinants of health
- 01:02:02and require more complex solutions.
- 01:02:05But we believe that we need to get to a place
- 01:02:10where healthy behavior needs to become the easiest behavior
- 01:02:15or the default behavior,
- 01:02:17from an environmental, cognitive and emotional perspective.
- 01:02:22The environmental structural challenges,
- 01:02:25some of whom Dr. Bassett has discussed
- 01:02:28and other panelists have spoken about so eloquently
- 01:02:31are outside of Hip Hop Public Health's mission.
- 01:02:34And what we try to do
- 01:02:35is address the powerful cognitive
- 01:02:38and emotional components of behavior change
- 01:02:42within black communities
- 01:02:43where we've been building trust over more than a decade.
- 01:02:49So we do this by addressing behavior change
- 01:02:52through a model we developed
- 01:02:55that kind of operationalizes
- 01:02:57a culturally tailored health education approach
- 01:03:01that uses hip hop
- 01:03:03across the socioecological levels of behavioral influence.
- 01:03:08And we focus almost exclusively on youth of color.
- 01:03:14You know, we recognize that many of our constituents
- 01:03:17are in what we call the pre-contemplation stage
- 01:03:20of behavior change,
- 01:03:23given the hardships that they endure
- 01:03:25and the social deprivation that surrounds them.
- 01:03:30We try to practically
- 01:03:32target specific components of actionable knowledge,
- 01:03:37as well as behavioral skills and self-efficacy
- 01:03:42in a way that emotionally connects with them.
- 01:03:45It's culturally adapted to their lifestyles
- 01:03:50and is cool and relevant.
- 01:03:53We've done this with our COVID prevention media.
- 01:03:57We've done this with things like mindfulness resources.
- 01:04:01You know, I personally believe one of the next waves,
- 01:04:04one of the next epidemics that we're gonna see
- 01:04:07in communities of color
- 01:04:08is one that's been brewing for a long time
- 01:04:11and it's about to explode.
- 01:04:12And that's the epidemic
- 01:04:14of trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder.
- 01:04:18And I think that really developing structures
- 01:04:21around those issues,
- 01:04:23as well as the type of culturally tailored and adapted
- 01:04:27and emotionally connecting messages that they need
- 01:04:30is gonna be critical for moving forward.
- 01:04:32Thank you so much for that analysis, Dr. Williams.
- 01:04:35I want to go to Monique Tula
- 01:04:38at the National Harm Reduction Coalition.
- 01:04:40And Monique, her and I know each other,
- 01:04:43and Cynthia earlier spoke about the trifecta of this moment,
- 01:04:49but it's really, it's more than a trifecta
- 01:04:51because as you know, Monique,
- 01:04:54the country has before COVID been facing an overdose crisis
- 01:04:59around fentanyl and heroin usage,
- 01:05:03particularly in the white community.
- 01:05:06I'm curious from your point of view,
- 01:05:08and working nationally,
- 01:05:10if you could just provide us a glimpse
- 01:05:13into what you're seeing,
- 01:05:14how this pandemic has impacted the harm reduction community,
- 01:05:19its ability to deliver the resources and information needed
- 01:05:22to keep people alive,
- 01:05:24but also how it's impacted,
- 01:05:26I would say the view of people
- 01:05:28who were in the harm reduction community and using drugs.
- 01:05:31I ask that question because I live in New York city
- 01:05:33and I hear neighbors and colleagues
- 01:05:37complain about the increase of the homeless population
- 01:05:40or complain about individuals being moved into hotels
- 01:05:44rather than being on the streets.
- 01:05:46I'm just curious from your point of view,
- 01:05:47what are you seeing
- 01:05:48and how has organization combating the stigma,
- 01:05:51combating the challenge
- 01:05:54the increased challenge for resources?
- 01:05:58Thank you, Jimmy.
- 01:05:59It's really, it's an honor to be here
- 01:06:00with all of these social justice warriors for real.
- 01:06:04And I just want to thank you also,
- 01:06:05commend your leadership
- 01:06:06for bringing this important topic
- 01:06:09to the forefront of Skoll's work.
- 01:06:12Greetings from chilly Los Angeles,
- 01:06:14and there's some folks outside doing some work,
- 01:06:17so let's pray they don't get started before you cut my mic.
- 01:06:22Let me just tell you a little bit about harm reduction
- 01:06:24'cause maybe some of your audience aren't familiar with it.
- 01:06:28Emergence of harm reduction was in direct response
- 01:06:33to the lack of attention and political will
- 01:06:36to address the raging HIV/AIDS epidemic
- 01:06:38among people who used drugs in the '80s.
- 01:06:41So the founders of harm reduction in the US were,
- 01:06:44what I call a group of radical badasses.
- 01:06:48To be honest with you,
- 01:06:48they were activists and community organizers.
- 01:06:51There were some researchers, social workers
- 01:06:53and people who used drugs themselves.
- 01:06:56And they all made the bold decision
- 01:06:59to care about people who used drugs
- 01:07:01who were dying from AIDS.
- 01:07:03So there's six principles of harm reduction,
- 01:07:06there's health and dignity,
- 01:07:07so the right to be healthy and seen as a whole person,
- 01:07:11participant centered services,
- 01:07:12so meeting people where they are
- 01:07:14rather than where we want them to be,
- 01:07:16participant involvement
- 01:07:18in the design of services for them,
- 01:07:20participant autonomy,
- 01:07:22sociocultural competency
- 01:07:26and then just pragmatism and realism.
- 01:07:28So we do not ignore or minimize
- 01:07:31the very real potential tragic harms
- 01:07:33that are associated with substance use.
- 01:07:37So I can't talk,
- 01:07:39nobody here can talk about health disparities,
- 01:07:42and in my case, among people who use drugs,
- 01:07:45or the overdose crisis or racial equity
- 01:07:48without naming front and center white supremacy
- 01:07:51which is what sustains the conditions
- 01:07:54under which black and brown and poor folks of all colors
- 01:07:59struggle to survive much less thrive, right?
- 01:08:03So white colonizers stole land
- 01:08:05that was inhabited by indigenous folks,
- 01:08:07not just here, but all over the planet.
- 01:08:09There isn't a continent that hasn't been marred
- 01:08:12by the bloody footprint of colonialism.
- 01:08:16So those of us who are demanding
- 01:08:18racial and economic justice,
- 01:08:20we have a long road ahead of us
- 01:08:22to change the policies that keep the white foot
- 01:08:25quite literally on the necks of black and brown people
- 01:08:28and it's taken us centuries to get here.
- 01:08:31But the war on drugs rages on,
- 01:08:33and we know that it's not enough to change policy.
- 01:08:36Good policies are only as good
- 01:08:38as the people who practice them.
- 01:08:40So it's the quality of our interactions
- 01:08:42that needs to change.
- 01:08:44And that is what harm reduction is all about.
- 01:08:47Syringe service programs are an example
- 01:08:51of a harm reduction public health strategy
- 01:08:54and they're considered essential services,
- 01:08:57although that's not always recognized
- 01:09:00in some of the jurisdictions around the country.
- 01:09:02And in fact in a recent survey on the impact of COVID-19
- 01:09:05on syringe service programs in the US,
- 01:09:08nearly all of the respondents noted
- 01:09:10that policy makers and leaders
- 01:09:13didn't include syringe service programs
- 01:09:15in jurisdictional emergency planning and response.
- 01:09:19And that is essentially the erasure of people who use drugs.
- 01:09:23But despite that erasure,
- 01:09:25demand for services is still high.
- 01:09:28And in response, staff of syringe service programs
- 01:09:32have remained open,
- 01:09:35they've maximized safety
- 01:09:38by reinforcing social distancing,
- 01:09:40minimizing the number of visits,
- 01:09:43and our organization, we stepped into immediate action
- 01:09:49in response to COVID-19.
- 01:09:50We co-created resources,
- 01:09:53formed mutual aid support groups
- 01:09:56for folks who are doing harm reduction work
- 01:09:57all over the country.
- 01:10:01Some of the resources that we created
- 01:10:03includes using more safely during COVID.
- 01:10:08And in fact, COVID actually goes against
- 01:10:10overdose prevention, risk reduction strategy.
- 01:10:14So we say don't use alone,
- 01:10:16COVID says need to socially distance
- 01:10:18and in some cases you have to socially isolate.
- 01:10:23All of our materials,
- 01:10:25many of the materials that we've created
- 01:10:27have been translated into Spanish
- 01:10:29and now some into Portuguese and Arabic,
- 01:10:33because we recognize that it's not an exclusive group,
- 01:10:38racially limited heterogeneous group
- 01:10:41of people who use drugs,
- 01:10:42it cuts across all races.
- 01:10:44And I guess I would just also,
- 01:10:48like many of my co-panelists
- 01:10:52and the discussants have been saying,
- 01:10:54COVID has really exposed some of the structural violence
- 01:11:01that we've all been living under.
- 01:11:04I was on a call recently
- 01:11:05with a number of executive directors
- 01:11:08of harm reduction programs around the country
- 01:11:10and one of our colleagues on the call
- 01:11:12said something was particularly profound.
- 01:11:15She said, "Syringe service programs
- 01:11:17can help keep people alive
- 01:11:20just long enough for them to get COVID."
- 01:11:23And I felt like that was really profound.
- 01:11:27It was gruesome, but for many it's not untrue.
- 01:11:31Thank you so much, Monique,
- 01:11:32for giving us that overarching frame of white supremacy
- 01:11:37and the historical racism
- 01:11:40the country has lived under for centuries.
- 01:11:43I want to go to Nathaniel Smith
- 01:11:45from Partnership for Southern Equity
- 01:11:47based out of Atlanta, Georgia.
- 01:11:49Nathaniel, you, through Partnership for Southern Equity
- 01:11:54have created a COVID-19 fund
- 01:11:57to support individuals
- 01:11:58in the regional southeastern United States,
- 01:12:01grappling with the economic and health and housing impacts
- 01:12:05of the virus.
- 01:12:07I'm hoping you can give us a glimpse
- 01:12:09what you're seeing from a regional perspective
- 01:12:11and how, the tenor, if you will,
- 01:12:16in terms of both the official state response,
- 01:12:20local responses playing out
- 01:12:21as well as how successful your efforts have been
- 01:12:26at Partnership for Southern Equity
- 01:12:27to mitigate the harshest consequences of the pandemic.
- 01:12:32Jimmy, again, I can't say enough how appreciative I am
- 01:12:36of this opportunity
- 01:12:37and just thank you so much in the Skoll Foundation
- 01:12:40for giving someone from the American South
- 01:12:42an opportunity to participate in this conversation.
- 01:12:45A lot of times the South is forgotten
- 01:12:48in key conversations like this.
- 01:12:50And as an organization
- 01:12:51like the Partnership for Southern Equity
- 01:12:53that believes that the road to true liberation
- 01:12:56must go through the South.
- 01:12:58It is critical to always provide opportunities
- 01:13:02for our voices to be heard.
- 01:13:04PSE is just a nonprofit organization,
- 01:13:06a racial equity organization,
- 01:13:08that is working to advance a new Southern agenda
- 01:13:11for racial equity and shared prosperity
- 01:13:13in the American South.
- 01:13:15And I would say, Jimmy,
- 01:13:16that in order for us to move forward
- 01:13:17and talk about where we are,
- 01:13:19we also have to talk about where we've been.
- 01:13:21James Baldwin talked a great deal
- 01:13:22about how history is the present.
- 01:13:24And we have to understand that in many ways.
- 01:13:27I've heard a lot of people talk about on this panel,
- 01:13:30which I'm just honored to be a part of,
- 01:13:33about the social determinants of health.
- 01:13:35And one of the things that we know and understand
- 01:13:39now more than ever
- 01:13:40is that racism is a social determinant
- 01:13:43and that not only is racism a social determinant
- 01:13:46but it is the social determinant
- 01:13:48for communities of color and black folks.
- 01:13:50And in many ways we believe the number one killer,
- 01:13:53not COVID or other diseases or viruses,
- 01:13:56the number one killer for black people
- 01:13:58and communities of color in this nation.
- 01:14:00We also have to understand within the context of our economy
- 01:14:04and why the South is so important
- 01:14:05that you had a region that built its economy
- 01:14:08off of free labor,
- 01:14:09the backs of slaves,
- 01:14:11and in many ways that relationship
- 01:14:13between hard working people
- 01:14:15who have been exploited by the extractive economy
- 01:14:18continues to perpetuate itself today.
- 01:14:20And we saw that in real time through COVID-19
- 01:14:24where low skilled labor became essential workers
- 01:14:28within the context of the lexicon of our economy.
- 01:14:31And what happens when we create an economy
- 01:14:35that is built exclusively on extraction and exploitation,
- 01:14:38and how that moves us towards a bankruptcy of empathy
- 01:14:43is where we are.
- 01:14:44And I think in many ways,
- 01:14:45COVID-19 has shown us
- 01:14:46that for the Partnership for Southern Equity,
- 01:14:49we also understood,
- 01:14:50and this is really what I wanted to get to Jimmy
- 01:14:53to answer your question
- 01:14:54is that you cannot continue to put good money in bad systems
- 01:14:58and expect good results.
- 01:15:00And that was one of the reasons
- 01:15:02why we decided to create a COVID-19 emergency fund
- 01:15:06because although we had a philanthropic ecosystem
- 01:15:10we knew that it was influenced in many ways
- 01:15:13by structural racism and privilege and white supremacy.
- 01:15:16So we wanted to create an alternative way to get money
- 01:15:19to black led organizations
- 01:15:21on the ground with minimal budgets
- 01:15:23because they are the closest
- 01:15:26to the people who need the money the most.
- 01:15:28And from that experience,
- 01:15:30we've seen the resilience
- 01:15:32and the commitment of frontline organizations
- 01:15:34in being involved in shaping their own destiny.
- 01:15:38One of our partners, Gloria Walton,
- 01:15:41who's the CEO of Solution Project,
- 01:15:43talks a great deal about how we need leaders
- 01:15:45from communities right now.
- 01:15:46And we also believe
- 01:15:48that the people that are closest to the problem
- 01:15:51are actually closest to the solution.
- 01:15:53And that's why I really appreciated Ernests' comments
- 01:15:56about what he's seeing on the ground
- 01:15:58because that is where we believe the answers are.
- 01:16:01And so for us, we believe that this is not just about COVID,
- 01:16:05it's about systems of extraction and oppression,
- 01:16:08it's about creating alternative economies
- 01:16:11that are healing and not extractive.
- 01:16:13It's about understanding the history
- 01:16:15of the stripping of humanity
- 01:16:18and its role in creating an economy that is not healing.
- 01:16:22And we have to find a way to move forward
- 01:16:24to create an economy
- 01:16:25that looks at everyone as an asset
- 01:16:27and no one as a liability.
- 01:16:30Thank you so much, Nathaniel.
- 01:16:31Wow, thank you so much for your analysis and framing.
- 01:16:35It's been especially,
- 01:16:36the call out of the donor community
- 01:16:41and supporting what works.
- 01:16:45Finally I want to go to Kim,
- 01:16:47Kim Dollan at Purdue University,
- 01:16:49the founder of COVID Black,
- 01:16:51the cofounder with Esther Arma and Necroy Gana.
- 01:16:56Esther's with the Arma Institute for Emotional Justice.
- 01:16:59She's working with Kim on the Black Front Line,
- 01:17:02which is an oral history project
- 01:17:05to center and elevate the voices of black healthcare workers
- 01:17:11on the frontline line in the midst of COVID
- 01:17:14in Ghana, the UK and United States.
- 01:17:15Kim, there's been a lot of talk in this conversation
- 01:17:18from the beginning with Dr. Bassett about data
- 01:17:21and the necessity of data.
- 01:17:24As someone who, data share is your wheelhouse,
- 01:17:28that's your expertise at COVID Black.
- 01:17:30Can you explain to us,
- 01:17:34we've heard about the importance of data,
- 01:17:36but how the use of data and how the misuse of data
- 01:17:39can also be harmful?
- 01:17:40I know when we spoke previously
- 01:17:42several days ago in advance of this conversation,
- 01:17:44you also mentioned living data.
- 01:17:45I was hoping you could contextualize that
- 01:17:48in this conversation.
- 01:17:49Thank you, Jimmy.
- 01:17:50And again, I want to echo on my co-panelists here
- 01:17:54and thank the Skoll Foundation.
- 01:17:56Again Jimmy, particularly you for inviting COVID Black
- 01:17:59to be a part of this important conversation.
- 01:18:02COVID Black started in early April
- 01:18:04with a call and organizing people
- 01:18:07to call on their local health departments
- 01:18:10to release the data.
- 01:18:11Seems like a lifetime ago,
- 01:18:13but in the early stages of the pandemic,
- 01:18:15data was really hard to come by on race and ethnicity.
- 01:18:19And so COVID Black started off
- 01:18:21with trying to get people on the ground
- 01:18:23to call on their health departments.
- 01:18:25Since that time, COVID Black has evolved
- 01:18:28into a nonprofit and data analytics firm
- 01:18:31that looks at black health data.
- 01:18:34We work at the intersection
- 01:18:35of race, health data information, and social justice.
- 01:18:40We redefine quantitative data
- 01:18:42and we turn it into what we call living data
- 01:18:44and data stories about black health.
- 01:18:48And more importantly, and this really touches
- 01:18:50on what Nathaniel said, Dr. Williams said,
- 01:18:52what Ernest said and Tula said,
- 01:18:54we connect black communities to their data.
- 01:18:57So at the heart of what we do
- 01:18:58is we think about data in a living data sort of way.
- 01:19:02I'll talk a little bit more about that in a second.
- 01:19:05But according to the APM Research Lab,
- 01:19:07their Color of Coronavirus project,
- 01:19:10one in 920 black Americans have died from COVID-19.
- 01:19:13And that was as of October 30th.
- 01:19:16And what that means,
- 01:19:17I really want to put that into real full relief,
- 01:19:20that has meant that multiple people in one family have died.
- 01:19:24COVID Black has collected the largest data set
- 01:19:27on black stories
- 01:19:28of people that have passed away from COVID-19.
- 01:19:31And I can tell you that with the collection of the data,
- 01:19:33I'm seeing multiple family members,
- 01:19:36multiple community members that have passed away.
- 01:19:39So Dr. Williams mentioning of trauma
- 01:19:43and that being the next health crisis is absolutely apt.
- 01:19:48Now the Color of Coronavirus and Andy Edward,
- 01:19:52the senior research associate is in the audience
- 01:19:54and she'll put the link to the homepage into the chat,
- 01:19:58is incredibly important quantitative data.
- 01:20:01But what COVID Black does is we turn quantitative data
- 01:20:03into living data,
- 01:20:05data and information about the black lived experience.
- 01:20:10And Dr. Williams and I talked a couple of days ago
- 01:20:13and he and other practitioners in the field,
- 01:20:16want more contextual data, right?
- 01:20:19And so what COVID Black has done
- 01:20:21is created an interactive visualization
- 01:20:24that will go live on December 1st
- 01:20:26that will allow people to see
- 01:20:28the different patterns of black people's lives
- 01:20:32who have passed away from COVID-19,
- 01:20:34but more importantly, to give black communities a way
- 01:20:38to connect to the loved ones that they've lost
- 01:20:40by being able to engage in their stories.
- 01:20:43I'll say one more thing.
- 01:20:45The next thing that we have to really get on top of
- 01:20:47is vaccine hesitancy.
- 01:20:49And COVID Black is gearing up now
- 01:20:52to start working with communities on the ground,
- 01:20:54helping them understand their data,
- 01:20:56being empowered by their data,
- 01:20:58because we talk about data a lot
- 01:20:59but we don't talk about making sure black communities
- 01:21:02have that data,
- 01:21:03making sure people of color have that data,
- 01:21:05are empowered by it, not alienated by it.
- 01:21:09So essentially what we do
- 01:21:10is we recover the lives and the stories of people
- 01:21:12from the data.
- 01:21:14We can't do this work without projects
- 01:21:16like the APM Research Lab, Color of Coronavirus,
- 01:21:19but COVID Black takes those numbers
- 01:21:21and turns them into stories.
- 01:21:23I just want to mention- Oh sorry, okay.
- 01:21:25I was gonna say thank you so much.
- 01:21:27We are running so short on time, Kim,
- 01:21:29and I apologize to you and everyone
- 01:21:32from the first quarter and the second one,
- 01:21:35I think this speaks to the need
- 01:21:37for a longer conversation, obviously
- 01:21:39but also your responses are so rich
- 01:21:42and necessarily detailed.
- 01:21:43I do want, before I transition to Don Gips
- 01:21:47who will, we will actually watch the video
- 01:21:51that was meant to be watched earlier
- 01:21:53and Don will close us out,
- 01:21:54but I wanted to, I'm gonna pull an audible here
- 01:21:59if you don't mind.
- 01:22:00I want to focus a question,
- 01:22:00a closing question, if you will,
- 01:22:02for a small number of you.
- 01:22:04I'm hoping that Nick and Tulane and Cynthia
- 01:22:10and Dr. Broat could be a part of this.
- 01:22:13The question I have
- 01:22:14and a number of you in equity,
- 01:22:15especially Cynthia and Sonia,
- 01:22:18in your earlier comments and responses with Cheryl,
- 01:22:23all of you have elevated,
- 01:22:28I guess the racialization of COVID-19,
- 01:22:32it was racialized
- 01:22:34in terms of how the narrative, how it's discussed,
- 01:22:38how it's discussed depending on who,
- 01:22:40the population impacted is being elevated is,
- 01:22:44it's been racialized in terms of the response,
- 01:22:47but as non-white Americans in this context,
- 01:22:52how do we affirm and ensure the visibility
- 01:23:00of our sisters and brothers
- 01:23:03from other racial and ethnic groups in this conversation?
- 01:23:07A lot of the attention at large in general public
- 01:23:11is a very dichotomous one, it's either black or white,
- 01:23:15but as we've heard over the past hour plus,
- 01:23:18it's not just black and white,
- 01:23:20it's Latino, it's Asian, it's indigenous American.
- 01:23:25It's also black but even within the blackness,
- 01:23:27there's diversity in that.
- 01:23:29How do we hold up each other's struggles
- 01:23:32and ally around each other's respective struggles?
- 01:23:34In other words, I mean Cynthia mentioned this,
- 01:23:36alliance with Black Lives Matter, for example,
- 01:23:38around hate and extremism
- 01:23:40directed towards the API community.
- 01:23:42So that's the question I want to leave for us,
- 01:23:44how do we move forward from this conversation
- 01:23:47in allyship and unity?
- 01:23:48And I would love to hear from from Dr. Broat and Nick,
- 01:23:51especially I wondered if you two could answer that
- 01:23:54but also Sonia and Cynthia.
- 01:23:55I mean I can start and I'd love to hear from others.
- 01:23:59But one thing that I think we need to really talk about
- 01:24:05is the role of social media and disinformation campaigns.
- 01:24:10And that exists within the different Asian communities
- 01:24:15and the different platforms that they are on,
- 01:24:17in which they get most of their news and information.
- 01:24:20And no one is immune, I think, to racist ideology.
- 01:24:28And this is the work
- 01:24:29that I think we have to really focus on
- 01:24:31within our communities.
- 01:24:33I mentioned this before
- 01:24:35that we are part of a network across the country
- 01:24:38that is planning worst case scenarios of mass violence.
- 01:24:43We are looking to our allies in the AMEMSA community
- 01:24:48and learning about what they set up post 9/11.
- 01:24:52This is a time where Asian Americans have been activated
- 01:24:56and have been for decades,
- 01:24:59but it's a time to mobilize in solidarity
- 01:25:03with other communities
- 01:25:05that are also disproportionately affected.
- 01:25:07It's a movement moment.
- 01:25:09It's also a time to call for more investments
- 01:25:13in civic engagement organizations,
- 01:25:15more investments in solidarity work
- 01:25:18that's so essential to our liberation.
- 01:25:21Yeah, I would completely agree and say
- 01:25:23that I also think it's on each of us.
- 01:25:26I love this conversation
- 01:25:27because it is expanding the narrative.
- 01:25:30It's making a complete narrative
- 01:25:32of what is happening right now
- 01:25:34to our country, to all of our communities
- 01:25:36and how we can all take a role in harnessing our power
- 01:25:40to make a different vision for what we want, right?
- 01:25:44The country has changed, it is changing,
- 01:25:47but we have a lot of power in this group,
- 01:25:49a lot of power in our communities
- 01:25:51that I think comes from these kinds of honest conversations.
- 01:25:55And it is difficult.
- 01:25:56There are difficult conversations about expansion.
- 01:25:58It's not about competition.
- 01:25:59It's not about one or the other.
- 01:26:02It is about how we all benefit
- 01:26:04from equity conversations and from racial justice.
- 01:26:08I think one thing that's been really powerful
- 01:26:10here in Portland, Oregon,
- 01:26:12as the protests and the Black Lives Matter movement
- 01:26:17has really swelled up in a positive way here.
- 01:26:21I know a lot of the media
- 01:26:22shows us many of the negative elements
- 01:26:24of protests and everything,
- 01:26:26but my wife and I,
- 01:26:28we live in a predominantly and historically
- 01:26:31black and native community here in North Portland.
- 01:26:34And just the love and outpouring of inclusion
- 01:26:38that we've had from our community members
- 01:26:40has been really powerful,
- 01:26:41whether it's having a rally of 15,000 people
- 01:26:45walking down our street here,
- 01:26:46and then being just like,
- 01:26:47hey, you guys, we want you to open this up in your language
- 01:26:52with your songs, in your ways.
- 01:26:54And to have people start it like that,
- 01:26:56like that extension of like love
- 01:27:01that we're talking about a little bit here, that undertone,
- 01:27:04has been tremendously powerful for us
- 01:27:06because when I'm up at a large academic health center
- 01:27:12talking to colleagues who may or may not,
- 01:27:14who are predominantly not black or brown,
- 01:27:17they're not the ones who are facing
- 01:27:20the eight and nine times death rate
- 01:27:22that we are in our communities.
- 01:27:24I don't know anybody in my family
- 01:27:26who has been touched by this yet,
- 01:27:29and I can speak and agree and just kind of like hold close
- 01:27:36and empathize with our black and brown brothers and sisters,
- 01:27:40because this is impacting us
- 01:27:43way differently than other people.
- 01:27:44And I think that the love
- 01:27:46that has been shared and extended to us
- 01:27:48as indigenous people,
- 01:27:50knowing that we all rise up through this movement
- 01:27:54as we work together,
- 01:27:56that gives me a tremendous amount of hope.
- 01:27:58And I'm very grateful for this movement and moment
- 01:28:02that also recognizes many of us in this circumstance.
- 01:28:07Thank you so much.
- 01:28:08Thank you so much, Dr. Broat and Kim
- 01:28:10Cynthia and Sonia and all of our panelists and speakers.
- 01:28:14We are over time slightly.
- 01:28:16I do want to hand it off to Don Gips, our CEO,
- 01:28:19to close us out and share the video with you.
- 01:28:21Thank you all the audience members for joining us
- 01:28:24and look forward to future iterations
- 01:28:26of this town hall series.
- 01:28:27Don?
- 01:28:29I can't add much to what Eric just said.
- 01:28:32Just so inspired by all of you
- 01:28:36in the chat, in the audience,
- 01:28:38and our speakers and Jimmy and Cheryl
- 01:28:40for leading this conversation.
- 01:28:42I only wish we had five more hours.
- 01:28:44Thank you everyone and love that
- 01:28:49and let's go make sure everybody votes
- 01:28:53so that we can change some of these systems.
- 01:28:56Thank you everybody.
- COVID-19
- racial justice
- health disparities
- structural racism
- indigenous resilience
- criminal justice
- equity
- social innovation
- philanthropy
- community impact