00:00:00
today we will be looking at two
00:00:01
horrifying caving stories that went
00:00:04
horribly wrong the second incident is
00:00:06
especially tragic marking the first such
00:00:09
unprecedented event in the caving
00:00:10
Community which raised concerns about
00:00:12
their safety protocols as always viewer
00:00:16
discretion is advised it was May 11th
00:00:19
1996 when an experienced caving team of
00:00:21
11 members and government safety experts
00:00:24
ventured into midnight Creek cave
00:00:26
California this cave had been off limits
00:00:28
since 1994
00:00:30
closed due to dangerous levels of
00:00:32
hydrogen sulfide in the water the team
00:00:34
was there to test for gases and evaluate
00:00:37
conditions but what started as a
00:00:38
controlled exploration turned into a
00:00:41
nightmarish ordeal for one of them the
00:00:43
group had split into smaller teams to
00:00:45
navigate the treacherous cave Richard BR
00:00:48
Colin O'Neal Kurt wexel and Renee Van
00:00:51
rewick were part of the trailing group
00:00:54
the team set up gas detectors to check
00:00:56
the hydrogen sulfide levels in the air
00:00:58
they tested the water for d dangerous
00:01:00
chemicals focusing on sulfur content
00:01:03
each team member took turns monitoring
00:01:05
different areas of the Cave the safety
00:01:08
experts looked for any signs of
00:01:09
instability in the cave structure
00:01:11
everything seemed under control at first
00:01:14
but that would soon change the Upstream
00:01:16
section had been uneventful but as they
00:01:18
began their return tragedy struck
00:01:21
Richard leading the group stepped on to
00:01:23
what appeared to be Solid Ground a slick
00:01:26
moss covered rock and suddenly lost his
00:01:28
footing in an an instant he disappeared
00:01:31
into a narrow vertical Chute in the
00:01:33
streamed his carbide lamp flickering out
00:01:35
as he fell the Chute was just 3 ft in
00:01:38
diameter barely wide enough for
00:01:40
Richard's body he landed in a standing
00:01:42
position but his torso was twisted
00:01:44
awkwardly and his head dipped below the
00:01:47
water's surface the force of the Fall
00:01:49
wedged him in tightly with his legs
00:01:51
pinned upward and his chest compressed
00:01:53
the icy streams surged around him
00:01:56
filling his nose and mouth with freezing
00:01:58
water panicked he craned his neck upward
00:02:01
desperately trying to create an air
00:02:03
pocket to breathe the everpresent danger
00:02:05
of hydrogen sulfide added another layer
00:02:08
of dread to the situation as the gas
00:02:10
could quickly overwhelm him if he didn't
00:02:12
find relief soon for a few agonizing
00:02:15
seconds he wasn't sure if anyone had
00:02:17
seen him fall the thought of being alone
00:02:20
in this suffocating position sent a
00:02:22
surge of adrenaline through his body his
00:02:25
head felt like it was being pressed
00:02:26
underwater by an invisible hand each
00:02:29
attempt to hold his head up required an
00:02:31
excruciating effort his muscles
00:02:33
trembling with the strain the frigid
00:02:35
water was unrelenting and each drop that
00:02:38
streamed into his nose made him gag and
00:02:40
cough the position began to take its
00:02:42
toll nausea welling up as his stomach
00:02:45
Twisted painfully above him Colin O'Neal
00:02:48
had seen the fall and reacted
00:02:50
instinctively moving toward the Chute to
00:02:52
help in his haste Colin misjudged the
00:02:55
slickness of The Rock and slipped
00:02:57
plummeting into the Chute himself the
00:02:59
impact drove Richard deeper into the
00:03:01
narrow passage worsening his predicament
00:03:04
Richard's body compressed further his
00:03:07
ribs now pressing painfully against the
00:03:09
unyielding rock walls he couldn't tell
00:03:11
if he was at the bottom of the shoot or
00:03:13
if there was another drop waiting
00:03:15
beneath him fear and claustrophobia
00:03:17
gripped him as the thought of hydrogen
00:03:19
sulfide poisoning lurked in his mind
00:03:22
Colin struggled to free himself and
00:03:23
called out for help Renee and Kurt
00:03:26
alarmed by the commotion rushed to the
00:03:28
scene with assistance Renee managed to
00:03:31
pull Colin out of the Shute but Richard
00:03:33
remained trapped his friends could see
00:03:35
the water level rising around him his
00:03:37
face pale and his eyes wide with Terror
00:03:40
every second was critical and the
00:03:42
thought of toxic gases accumulating in
00:03:44
the cave added to their urgency
00:03:47
Richard's attempts to breathe became a
00:03:49
tormenting cycle he would summon all his
00:03:51
strength to lift his head gasping for
00:03:54
precious air only to have his muscles
00:03:56
give out and his head fall back into the
00:03:58
icy stream each time water filled his
00:04:01
nose and mouth triggering violent coughs
00:04:03
and wretches his vision blurred and
00:04:06
waves of nausea surged through him the
00:04:08
effort of holding his head up was
00:04:10
draining him faster than the cold water
00:04:12
could the group quickly debated their
00:04:14
options falling on to Richard to push
00:04:16
him downward was a desperate and risky
00:04:18
move but it seemed like the only
00:04:20
immediate solution with careful
00:04:22
coordination one of them positioned
00:04:24
himself to use the weight strategically
00:04:27
as he tried to push the force caused
00:04:29
Richard's body to shift but instead of
00:04:31
freeing him it drove his right shoulder
00:04:33
against the jagged Rock leaving him
00:04:35
gasping in pain his legs Twisted further
00:04:38
sending searing pain through his hips
00:04:41
time was slipping away the air in the
00:04:43
cave was Heavy with tension Renee and
00:04:45
Kurt checked their Maps frantically
00:04:47
searching for an alternate passage that
00:04:49
might lead to a position below Richard
00:04:51
if they could access the shoot from
00:04:53
another angle they might be able to push
00:04:55
him upward instead of driving him deeper
00:04:57
into the narrow trap the Clock Was
00:04:59
ticking and Richard's groans of pain
00:05:01
spurred them into action the possibility
00:05:04
of rising gas levels added to their
00:05:06
desperation while Renee and Kurt
00:05:07
searched for the alternate route Colin
00:05:10
stayed with Richard trying to keep him
00:05:12
calm but Richard's condition was
00:05:14
deteriorating his lips turned blue and
00:05:16
his breaths came in Shallow labored
00:05:18
gasps the strain of holding his head
00:05:20
above the water had taken its toll his
00:05:23
body convulsed and he gagged each wretch
00:05:26
making it harder to breathe the
00:05:28
sensation of drowning was was ever
00:05:30
present a cruel reminder of how
00:05:32
precarious his position was after what
00:05:34
felt like an eternity Renee and Kurt
00:05:37
found a potential route it involved
00:05:39
traversing a tight water-filled passage
00:05:42
that would bring them below the Chute
00:05:44
the route was cramped but there was no
00:05:46
other choice the two squeezed through
00:05:48
the narrow tunnel the passage was barely
00:05:51
wide enough to allow movement meanwhile
00:05:53
Richard's strength was fading his head
00:05:56
dipped below the water again and this
00:05:58
time he struggled longer to lift it back
00:06:00
up the effort sent a fresh wave of pain
00:06:03
through his neck and shoulders his mind
00:06:05
raced with dark thoughts what if this
00:06:08
was it what if his friends couldn't
00:06:10
reach him in time he thought of his
00:06:12
family of the things he'd left
00:06:14
unfinished each thought was interrupted
00:06:16
by the cold choking grip of the water
00:06:19
and the stinging realization that the
00:06:21
air he was gasping for might itself be
00:06:24
tainted finally Renee and Kurt emerged
00:06:26
at the base of the Chute From Below they
00:06:29
could see Richard's ordeal meanwhile van
00:06:31
reached the scene without even asking
00:06:33
what had happened he quickly sprang
00:06:35
right into action van coordinating with
00:06:38
Colin grabbed Richard by his legs they
00:06:40
began the delicate process of pulling
00:06:42
him upward while Colin and Renee pushed
00:06:45
from below the angle was awkward and the
00:06:47
walls of the shoot made every movement a
00:06:49
struggle Richard felt the pressure from
00:06:52
below and tried to assist pushing with
00:06:54
what little strength he had left the
00:06:56
pain in his shoulder flared as he
00:06:58
twisted his torso and his ribs screamed
00:07:01
in protest but inch by inch he began to
00:07:04
rise the water level receded slightly
00:07:07
giving him just enough space to catch
00:07:09
his breath encouraged by this progress
00:07:11
his friends redoubled their efforts
00:07:13
spurred on by the knowledge that failure
00:07:16
was not an option in such a hostile
00:07:18
environment with one final coordinated
00:07:20
push and pull Richard's torso Broke Free
00:07:23
from the shoot Colin grabbed him under
00:07:25
the arms and hauled him onto the ledge
00:07:27
his body collapsing like a rag dog all
00:07:30
he lay there shivering violently his
00:07:32
chest heaving as he gulped in The Damp
00:07:34
cave air his friends gathered around him
00:07:37
checking for injuries though he was
00:07:39
battered and bruised with a likely
00:07:41
dislocated shoulder he was alive the
00:07:44
exit from Midnight Creek cave was
00:07:46
fraught with difficulty made all the
00:07:48
more challenging by Richard's impaired
00:07:50
Vision as the only one familiar with the
00:07:52
Cave's complex layout the responsibility
00:07:55
of guiding the group out fell entirely
00:07:57
on his shoulders without his glasses the
00:08:00
dim light from their carbide lamps did
00:08:02
little to clarify the path ahead every
00:08:05
shadow seemed to shift turning familiar
00:08:07
terrain into a confusing Labyrinth
00:08:10
Richard relied on his memory of the
00:08:12
Cave's passages but the Blurred shapes
00:08:14
and uneven surfaces slowed their
00:08:16
progress his companions stayed close
00:08:19
assisting where they could but much of
00:08:21
the navigation fell to him each turn and
00:08:24
crawl through narrow passages felt like
00:08:25
a test of endurance as they cautiously
00:08:28
move forward step by step the group made
00:08:30
their way toward the surface their Pace
00:08:33
deliberate but determined when they
00:08:35
finally emerged into the open night the
00:08:37
sight of the stars above felt like a
00:08:39
hard one triumph over the endless
00:08:41
Shadows they had left behind the
00:08:43
nightmare was over looking back on that
00:08:45
night it was clear that Richard's
00:08:47
survival was due to the quick thinking
00:08:49
and unwavering determination of his
00:08:51
friends without their efforts the
00:08:53
outcome could have been tragically
00:08:55
different midnight Creek cave with its
00:08:58
hidden dangers and unforgiving terrain
00:09:00
had tested them all in ways they never
00:09:02
anticipated this next story unfolds an
00:09:05
event that had never happened before in
00:09:07
late November 1992 banshe hole in
00:09:09
Tennessee became the site of a tragic
00:09:12
caving accident the cave known for its
00:09:14
imposing 95t vertical entrance
00:09:17
challenged even seasoned cavers on this
00:09:19
particular Expedition four cavers
00:09:21
descended the sheer drop into the cavern
00:09:24
below among them was a relatively
00:09:26
inexperienced participant unaware of how
00:09:28
critical technical precision and
00:09:30
physical endurance would be during their
00:09:32
exploration The Descent was executed
00:09:34
with a single rope system anchored
00:09:36
securely at the surface each caver
00:09:39
relied on their gear to descend into the
00:09:41
darkness the first few minutes inside
00:09:43
Banshee hole were uneventful the team
00:09:46
explored a section of the cavern using
00:09:48
the steady glow of their lights to
00:09:49
navigate the rugged terrain the cave
00:09:51
stretched out before them consisting of
00:09:53
narrow passages and open Chambers they
00:09:56
moved carefully marking their path with
00:09:58
chalk to sure they could find their way
00:10:00
back the entrance chamber while wide
00:10:03
quickly funneled into a narrow Corridor
00:10:05
that descended further into the Earth
00:10:07
the walls were slick with moisture and
00:10:10
Tiny rivulets of water trickled down in
00:10:12
places disappearing into unseen cracks
00:10:14
below the group Advanced deeper into the
00:10:17
cave the corridor eventually giving way
00:10:19
to a large open chamber the floor was
00:10:22
uneven a patchwork of smooth Stone and
00:10:25
Jagged edges that required careful
00:10:27
navigation at the far end of the the
00:10:29
chamber a narrow passage beckoned its
00:10:31
entrance partially obscured by a curtain
00:10:33
of flowstone the group paused here to
00:10:36
rest but their pause was brief the
00:10:39
leader of the group reminded them of the
00:10:40
time and urged them to head back the
00:10:43
route back to the surface was long and
00:10:45
they needed to conserve their energy
00:10:47
however the true challenge of the trip
00:10:49
came during the return Ascent the group
00:10:51
decided to ascend one at a time the
00:10:54
least experienced one identified here as
00:10:56
the victim went first he was equipped
00:10:59
with a rudimentary ascending rig that
00:11:01
had been assembled based on instructions
00:11:03
from a flyer accompanying a pair of
00:11:05
jumar ascenders his setup included two
00:11:07
ascenders each attached to a foot with
00:11:10
slings of differing lengths and a chest
00:11:12
harness improvised from webbing a
00:11:14
carabiner connected the chest harness to
00:11:16
the Rope ostensibly to keep the climber
00:11:18
upright however the system lacked a
00:11:21
proper seat harness a critical emission
00:11:23
that would have provided essential
00:11:25
support and stability during the climb
00:11:27
the victim started his ascent cautiously
00:11:30
his progress steady but slow his
00:11:33
companions watched from below their
00:11:35
lights following his movements as he
00:11:36
inched upwards the ascent rope passed
00:11:39
through the Carabiner at his chest
00:11:41
keeping him upright but offering little
00:11:43
Comfort The Climb was arduous and as he
00:11:45
approached the lip a protrusion 8 to 10
00:11:48
ft below the top the situation began to
00:11:50
unravel the lip presented a significant
00:11:53
obstacle its overhanging nature required
00:11:55
a climber to shift their weight and pull
00:11:58
themselves over the edge a maneuver that
00:12:00
demanded upper body strength and precise
00:12:02
technique the victim struggled to
00:12:04
navigate this section his lack of
00:12:06
experience became apparent as his
00:12:08
movements grew increasingly
00:12:10
uncoordinated he attempted to push
00:12:11
himself over the lip but without a seat
00:12:13
harness to distribute the load his body
00:12:16
bore the full brunt of the effort the
00:12:18
chest harness dug into his torso
00:12:20
restricting his breathing and
00:12:21
circulation after several attempts the
00:12:24
victim became visibly fatigued his arms
00:12:26
trembled with the strain and his
00:12:28
progress halted the other cavers quickly
00:12:30
realized the severity of the situation
00:12:33
two of them ascended to his position
00:12:35
hoping to assist they tried various
00:12:37
techniques to either pull him over the
00:12:39
lip or lower him back down but their
00:12:41
efforts proved feudal the makeshift
00:12:43
harness now reinforced with additional
00:12:45
webbing became a trap rather than a
00:12:48
support system after nearly 3 hours of
00:12:50
exhausting attempts one of the cavers
00:12:52
made the difficult decision to leave the
00:12:54
group and seek outside assistance the
00:12:57
remaining cavers stayed with the victim
00:12:59
offering encouragement and trying to
00:13:01
keep him calm the chill of the cave
00:13:03
seeped into their bodies As Time
00:13:05
stretched on the victim's breathing grew
00:13:08
labored and his body sagged against the
00:13:10
webbing suspended in the harness his
00:13:12
circulation was increasingly compromised
00:13:15
the Cumberland County Rescue Squad
00:13:17
responded with precision and urgency
00:13:19
mobilizing their team and Equipment
00:13:21
within minutes of receiving the distress
00:13:23
call their arrival at the scene a mere
00:13:26
40 minutes later gave the caving team
00:13:29
some hope the squad members were well
00:13:31
acquainted with the challenges of cave
00:13:33
rescues tight spaces complex rigging and
00:13:37
the physical toll such operations take
00:13:39
however the situation at banshe hle
00:13:42
presented a particularly grim and
00:13:44
challenging scenario upon reaching the
00:13:46
victim they quickly assessed his
00:13:48
condition he was suspended in the
00:13:50
improvised Harness System his body
00:13:52
showing clear signs of distress his head
00:13:54
LED slightly forward and his skin
00:13:57
appeared pale and clammy his lab
00:13:59
breathing and intermittent groans
00:14:01
painted a picture of someone teetering
00:14:02
on the edge of collapse The Rescuers
00:14:05
knew time was of the essence not just to
00:14:07
free him but to manage the physical
00:14:09
trauma that came from hanging suspended
00:14:11
in such a position for hours the team
00:14:13
worked methodically to secure the victim
00:14:15
and stabilize his position while
00:14:17
preparing to lower him to the ground
00:14:19
they reinforced the harness ensuring it
00:14:21
wouldn't fail under the strain of their
00:14:23
maneuvering communication was steady and
00:14:26
precise every action coordinated to
00:14:28
minimize additional strain on the victim
00:14:31
finally after a painstaking effort they
00:14:33
succeeded in freeing him from the
00:14:35
webbing that had been his prison as the
00:14:37
tension of the situation momentarily
00:14:39
eased a new crisis unfolded no sooner
00:14:42
was the harness released than the victim
00:14:44
went into cardiac arrest the sudden and
00:14:46
violent collapse left no room for
00:14:48
hesitation rescue Personnel immediately
00:14:51
initiated CPR their voices Rising above
00:14:54
the oppressive quiet of the cave as they
00:14:56
counted compressions and delivered
00:14:58
rescue breath breaths despite their best
00:15:00
efforts they were unable to revive him
00:15:03
every member of the team fought to
00:15:04
maintain composure as the Grim reality
00:15:07
set in the cave which had echoed with
00:15:09
their coordinated movements and Urgent
00:15:11
commands moments before now fell into a
00:15:14
somber silence subsequent investigation
00:15:17
revealed the victim's death was the
00:15:19
result of compression syndrome also
00:15:21
known as Crush syndrome a dangerous and
00:15:23
little known condition at the time this
00:15:25
life-threatening complication occurs
00:15:27
when blood circulation is restricted for
00:15:29
a prolonged period the blood in the
00:15:32
compressed areas of the body becomes
00:15:34
toxic due to the accumulation of lactic
00:15:36
acid potassium and other byproducts of
00:15:39
cellular metabolism when circulation is
00:15:42
suddenly restored these toxins flood the
00:15:44
bloodstream overwhelming the body
00:15:47
systems the result can be catastrophic
00:15:50
shock organ failure or as in this case
00:15:54
death the phenomenon of compression
00:15:56
syndrome was relatively unfamiliar in
00:15:58
the US at the time with few cave rescue
00:16:01
teams adequately trained to recognize or
00:16:03
manage it experts would later speculate
00:16:06
that if medical interventions like
00:16:08
intravenous saline and specific
00:16:10
medications had been administered before
00:16:12
the release of pressure the outcome
00:16:14
might have been different however in the
00:16:16
confined and treacherous environment of
00:16:18
banshe hole the odds had been stacked
00:16:21
Against The Rescuers from the start
