By One Vote: Woman Suffrage in the South | The Citizenship Project | NPT
摘要
TLDRThe video chronicles the struggle for women's suffrage in the South, focusing on Tennessee's critical role in ratifying the 19th Amendment. It details the intense political atmosphere in the Tennessee State Capitol during the final vote, highlighting the efforts of various suffragists, including Sue Shelton White and Alice Dudley, as well as the challenges posed by anti-suffragists. The narrative emphasizes the intersection of race and gender, noting how African American women faced additional barriers. Ultimately, the video illustrates the persistence of suffragists and the significance of Tennessee's ratification in the broader context of women's rights in America.
心得
- 🗳️ Women's legal position was akin to that of felons before suffrage.
- 🌍 Race played a significant role in the suffrage movement.
- 🏛️ Tennessee was crucial for ratifying the 19th Amendment.
- 👩⚖️ Key figures included Sue Shelton White and Alice Dudley.
- ⚖️ African American women faced unique challenges in the movement.
- 📚 Local organizations and church groups helped mobilize women.
- 🗳️ The Tennessee House's vote was pivotal for women's voting rights.
- 📜 The 19th Amendment's ratification did not eliminate barriers for African American women.
- 🔄 Progress in women's rights requires ongoing effort and vigilance.
- 🌹 The 'War of the Roses' symbolized the conflict between suffragists and anti-suffragists.
时间轴
- 00:00:00 - 00:05:00
The legal status of women was akin to that of felons, lacking freedom and rights, which made their fight for suffrage inevitable, especially as race played a significant role in the movement. The struggle for women's rights was set against the backdrop of the Tennessee State Capitol, where the future of American women was at stake.
- 00:05:00 - 00:10:00
In August 1920, Tennessee's House of Representatives convened to vote on the ratification of the 19th Amendment, which would grant women the right to vote. The atmosphere was tense, with suffragists and anti-suffragists present, each anxious about the outcome of the vote that would determine the fate of women's suffrage in the nation.
- 00:10:00 - 00:15:00
The suffrage movement had deep roots in the South, where women faced unique challenges due to the region's history and social fabric. The Civil War and Reconstruction had already disrupted societal norms, and the fight for women's rights was seen as another potential upheaval, particularly in a region resistant to change.
- 00:15:00 - 00:20:00
The suffrage movement in the South was influenced by earlier abolitionist efforts, with women like the Grimke sisters advocating for both women's rights and the end of slavery. The legal and social constraints on women were severe, with married women lacking basic rights, and African American women facing even greater oppression.
- 00:20:00 - 00:25:00
The Seneca Falls Convention in 1848 marked a pivotal moment in the women's rights movement, declaring that all men and women are created equal. However, the call for suffrage was seen as radical, and while it sparked a movement, many Southern women were hesitant to join due to differing social experiences and opportunities compared to their Northern counterparts.
- 00:25:00 - 00:30:00
The Civil War shifted gender roles, with women taking on new responsibilities as men went to war. This change laid the groundwork for the suffrage movement, as women began to organize and advocate for their rights, particularly in the wake of the social upheaval that followed the war.
- 00:30:00 - 00:35:00
By the late 19th century, Southern women began to advocate for suffrage, often aligning their efforts with the political strategies of white Southern Democrats who sought to maintain power. This led to a complex relationship between race and suffrage, as leaders sought to appeal to white voters while navigating the racial dynamics of the time.
- 00:35:00 - 00:40:00
As the suffrage movement gained momentum, national leaders recognized the need to include Southern states in their strategy. However, this often meant compromising on issues of race, as they sought to attract white Southern support while sidelining the contributions of black women in the movement.
- 00:40:00 - 00:45:00
The Women's Christian Temperance Union emerged as a significant force in the South, allowing women to engage in various social issues beyond prohibition. This organization helped women develop skills in leadership and advocacy, furthering their push for suffrage and reform in their communities.
- 00:45:00 - 00:50:00
By the early 20th century, organized suffrage groups had formed in Tennessee, with women from various backgrounds joining the movement. The fight for suffrage became intertwined with broader social changes, as women sought not only the right to vote but also greater equality and representation in society.
- 00:50:00 - 00:57:46
The ratification of the 19th Amendment in Tennessee was a culmination of years of struggle, with suffragists facing intense opposition from anti-suffragists. The final vote hinged on the actions of a few key legislators, illustrating the high stakes and political maneuvering involved in the suffrage battle.
思维导图
视频问答
What was the legal position of women before suffrage?
Women's legal position was similar to that of felons, lacking rights to own property, serve on juries, or have custody of their children.
What role did race play in the suffrage movement?
Race played a major role, as national leaders needed support from Southern states, which often resisted suffrage due to racial politics.
What was the significance of Tennessee in the suffrage movement?
Tennessee was the 36th state needed to ratify the 19th Amendment, making it a crucial battleground for women's voting rights.
Who were some key figures in the suffrage movement in Tennessee?
Key figures included Sue Shelton White, Alice Dudley, and Josephine Pearson, each representing different perspectives within the movement.
What challenges did African American women face in the suffrage movement?
African American women faced both sexism and racism, often being excluded from mainstream suffrage efforts and facing intimidation.
How did the suffrage movement evolve in the South?
The movement evolved through local organizations, church groups, and the Women's Christian Temperance Union, which helped women gain political skills.
What was the outcome of the vote in Tennessee?
The Tennessee House voted to ratify the 19th Amendment, largely due to a last-minute change by a young legislator, Harry Burn.
What were the long-term effects of the 19th Amendment?
While the amendment granted women the right to vote, many African American women still faced barriers to voting due to discriminatory laws.
What does the video suggest about the nature of progress in women's rights?
The video suggests that progress in women's rights is often slow and requires ongoing effort to protect and defend those rights.
What was the 'War of the Roses' in Tennessee?
The 'War of the Roses' referred to the symbolic battle between suffragists, who wore yellow roses, and anti-suffragists, who wore red roses during the legislative session.
查看更多视频摘要
- 00:00:06women's legal position was pretty much
- 00:00:09the same as the legal position of felons
- 00:00:14it's the need for freedom and rights and
- 00:00:18civic respect and place in society women
- 00:00:22had to have that it was inevitable that
- 00:00:27race was going to play a major role in
- 00:00:29the suffrage movement when national
- 00:00:31leaders in order to achieve a national
- 00:00:33victory had to have some southern states
- 00:00:36it is not ladylike politics at all this
- 00:00:40fight that is going to take place in the
- 00:00:43halls of the Tennessee State Capitol
- 00:00:46it's this incredibly dramatic moment and
- 00:00:50the future of American women is being
- 00:00:53decided right there
- 00:00:55[Music]
- 00:01:01[Music]
- 00:01:08major funding for by one vote woman's
- 00:01:12suffrage in the South is provided by the
- 00:01:15Bethany fund Tennessee Civil War
- 00:01:19National Heritage Area the Josey Davis
- 00:01:23foundation in memory of Frances bond
- 00:01:26Davis the Shane Foundation Cathy and
- 00:01:30Martin Brown and the MSB Cockaigne fund
- 00:01:33and by Carlene Libas and Harris hastin
- 00:01:38additional support provided by First
- 00:01:41Tennessee foundation an and Charles Roos
- 00:01:44Hanna Paramore Breen Andrea Conti Lori
- 00:01:49gold Eskin and the following
- 00:01:55[Music]
- 00:02:02and by members of NPT thank you on a
- 00:02:14blistering hot August day in 1920
- 00:02:17Seth Walker Speaker of the Tennessee
- 00:02:20State House convened what he hoped would
- 00:02:22be the final day of a special session
- 00:02:25for three weeks the house had debated
- 00:02:28whether to ratify the 19th amendment to
- 00:02:30the US Constitution granting women the
- 00:02:33right to vote a vote in the House
- 00:02:37chamber was all that stood in the way of
- 00:02:39Tennessee becoming the 36th and final
- 00:02:42state needed to make the 19th amendment
- 00:02:44the law of the land when the legislature
- 00:02:48was called into session by Governor
- 00:02:50Roberts
- 00:02:51most of us expected it to be a routine
- 00:02:53affair
- 00:02:54actually we reach Nashville we learned
- 00:02:57that what we thought was practically a
- 00:02:59state issue was a national issue because
- 00:03:02as when Tennessee so went the nation the
- 00:03:05tension in the chamber is intense the
- 00:03:10heat is intense you have women in their
- 00:03:14long dresses drenched in perspiration
- 00:03:17and in anxiety you have the visitors
- 00:03:22galleries half of which are occupied by
- 00:03:26the suffrage supporters half by the
- 00:03:28anti-suffrage supporters each fearful
- 00:03:31and anxious about what this roll call is
- 00:03:35going to bring
- 00:03:37tucked behind the brass bar in the back
- 00:03:40of the chamber sue Shelton white of
- 00:03:43Jackson Tennessee stood ready with
- 00:03:46pencil and paper ready to keep a tally
- 00:03:48of the votes sue white is part of that
- 00:03:51third generation of suffragists who are
- 00:03:55no longer willing to be so patient they
- 00:03:59see their future in having a voice in
- 00:04:02their government in having more equality
- 00:04:05in other social and political aspects of
- 00:04:09their lives and they want it now
- 00:04:12in the balcony amongst the press of
- 00:04:16suffragists and Dallas Dudley of
- 00:04:19Nashville leaned into the rail ready to
- 00:04:22defy her social upbringing and shout her
- 00:04:24approval or disapproval and Alice Dudley
- 00:04:27comes out of some Nashville nobility
- 00:04:31she's a mother
- 00:04:32she is beautiful and she counteracts all
- 00:04:36the stereotypes that the anti
- 00:04:38suffragists have used for decades across
- 00:04:43the chamber in the opposite balcony
- 00:04:45Josephine Pearson of Monteagle Tennessee
- 00:04:48led the aunt eyes as president of the
- 00:04:50Tennessee Association opposed to woman
- 00:04:53suffrage and she seemed ideal she seemed
- 00:04:58to be opposed to any rights for women
- 00:05:01even though she herself was a single
- 00:05:04woman who had been an independent
- 00:05:06schoolteacher at one time as morning
- 00:05:10turned into afternoon the heat rose in
- 00:05:13the chamber the Speaker of the House
- 00:05:15pushed for the vote that he believed
- 00:05:17would be the defeat of the 19th
- 00:05:20amendment the men are exhausted are
- 00:05:24frightened for their political future
- 00:05:26it's this incredibly dramatic moment and
- 00:05:30the future of American women is being
- 00:05:33decided right there after three weeks of
- 00:05:37open and sometimes furtive lobbying
- 00:05:39political betrayals illicit payoffs and
- 00:05:43masterful legislative stalling tactics
- 00:05:46the clerk began the roll call on the
- 00:05:48vote for or against the ratification of
- 00:05:51the 19th amendment Anderson well
- 00:06:01the civic fate of millions of women
- 00:06:04across the u.s. rested in the hands of
- 00:06:06the all-male Tennessee House of
- 00:06:08Representatives to reach this point
- 00:06:12American women had spent decades
- 00:06:14fighting through complex layers of
- 00:06:16social political and racial constraints
- 00:06:19but nowhere were there greater
- 00:06:22challenges than in the south and the
- 00:06:24roots of this battle went back even
- 00:06:27before the Civil War
- 00:06:31the social fabric had been torn asunder
- 00:06:34by the Civil War and reconstruction and
- 00:06:37now here's another movement that
- 00:06:39promises to tear the fabric again and
- 00:06:49the soul of women particularly and the
- 00:06:54southern states did not support for
- 00:06:58Selfridge a minimum can you see what's
- 00:07:02in the doubtful power what was really
- 00:07:05ironic that the final battle over a
- 00:07:08woman's suffrage was going to happen in
- 00:07:10a southern state after all this was the
- 00:07:12region that was the most resistant the
- 00:07:14suffragists had fought hard but with
- 00:07:17little success when people today you're
- 00:07:19looking back on this and they assumed
- 00:07:22that there was going to be a victory at
- 00:07:24the end of this fight they were assuming
- 00:07:27a lot
- 00:07:28[Music]
- 00:07:31the woman suffrage movement began in the
- 00:07:35Northeast and it was a direct offshoot
- 00:07:38of the anti-slavery movement nearly
- 00:07:41every woman who was involved in the
- 00:07:44early women's rights movement was
- 00:07:46involved in the anti-slavery movement
- 00:07:48some of the first abolitionists to speak
- 00:07:51publicly about the rights of women were
- 00:07:53two sisters from Charleston South
- 00:07:55Carolina
- 00:07:56Sarah and Angelina Grimke in the early
- 00:08:001800s men and women were created equal
- 00:08:03all I ask of our brethren is that they
- 00:08:07will take their feet from off our necks
- 00:08:10and permit us to stand upright on that
- 00:08:12ground which God designed us to occupy
- 00:08:14they begin to bring that sensibility of
- 00:08:18southern women into the suffrage
- 00:08:22movement decades earlier than it really
- 00:08:24begins to coalesce as a movement in the
- 00:08:27southern states fighting slavery led the
- 00:08:31grim keys and other female abolitionists
- 00:08:33to question the accepted cultural and
- 00:08:36legal norms controlling a woman's life
- 00:08:38her life was supposed to be centered on
- 00:08:41the domestic sphere that's what it was
- 00:08:43called
- 00:08:44that meant home and hearth and family
- 00:08:47and nothing else
- 00:08:48women's legal position was pretty much
- 00:08:51the same as the legal position of felons
- 00:08:54married women had no rights to own
- 00:08:57property to serve in juries they did not
- 00:09:00have rights to their own children if
- 00:09:02they got divorced any income from any
- 00:09:06work that she did would be his the
- 00:09:09clothing on her back would be his prior
- 00:09:12to the Civil War most African American
- 00:09:16women were enslaved in the American
- 00:09:18South they therefore had no control
- 00:09:21whatsoever over their own bodies over
- 00:09:24their lives their families and children
- 00:09:27could be taken away from them at any
- 00:09:29time women in jail were basically
- 00:09:33relegated to a position of second-class
- 00:09:35citizenship but for black women they
- 00:09:38wore a double burden not only did they
- 00:09:41have to face
- 00:09:43sexism but they also had to face racism
- 00:09:46most women knew that they couldn't
- 00:09:48support themselves long term so they had
- 00:09:51to get married
- 00:09:52and sometimes the pool was a little thin
- 00:09:54and so she happened to marry someone who
- 00:09:57became a brutal drunk she was stuck in
- 00:10:02rising frustration at the lack of power
- 00:10:04over their own lives a small group
- 00:10:08organized a convention on the status of
- 00:10:10women in 1848 the Seneca Falls
- 00:10:13convention concluded with the
- 00:10:16declaration of sentiments it was modeled
- 00:10:19after the Declaration of Independence
- 00:10:22which declared all men are created equal
- 00:10:25despite the pleas of Abigail Adams to
- 00:10:28remember the ladies these truths to be
- 00:10:31self-evident that all men and women are
- 00:10:35created equal that they are endowed
- 00:10:37iived her of this first right of a
- 00:10:39citizen the elective franchise thereby
- 00:10:42leaving her without representation in
- 00:10:44the halls of legislation he has so they
- 00:10:46had a long list of things that they
- 00:10:48wanted to address and the vote was just
- 00:10:51really only one of them at that time
- 00:10:53asking for the vote was considered to be
- 00:10:55astonishingly radical the Seneca Falls
- 00:10:58convention sparked what grew into the
- 00:11:01main movement advocating for women's
- 00:11:04rights and woman suffrage but most
- 00:11:07southern women were not eager to join
- 00:11:10the experiences that tended to create
- 00:11:12suffrage ISM happened in the Northeast
- 00:11:15earlier than they happened in the south
- 00:11:17things like industrial development the
- 00:11:21rise of women's voluntary associations
- 00:11:24college education those things happened
- 00:11:27earlier in the northeast and so Southern
- 00:11:29women had a generation difference in the
- 00:11:32opportunity to experience some of those
- 00:11:34things
- 00:11:34[Music]
- 00:11:44the Civil War was in some ways a crisis
- 00:11:47of gender in that when the Civil War
- 00:11:50came and the male's of a household left
- 00:11:53the women were left particularly in
- 00:11:56rural areas as much of Tennessee was
- 00:11:59women in Tennessee were left on their
- 00:12:01own to fend for themselves many white
- 00:12:04women entered the public sphere by
- 00:12:07necessity managing farms alone or
- 00:12:10becoming teachers nurses factory workers
- 00:12:13at the end of the war the south also had
- 00:12:16to contend with the social and economic
- 00:12:19upheaval of emancipation reconstruction
- 00:12:23was this critical point in American
- 00:12:25history and which Americans were
- 00:12:27reconsidering and redefining what it
- 00:12:30meant to be a citizen and the debate
- 00:12:32centered on the 14th and 15th amendment
- 00:12:36black men were given citizenship and the
- 00:12:40right to vote but women were left out
- 00:12:43and that ended up causing a big rift
- 00:12:46among suffragists and the women who had
- 00:12:49fought really hard to bring slavery to
- 00:12:52an end really felt betrayed
- 00:12:55white Republicans very much wanted black
- 00:12:58men who would have allegiance to the
- 00:13:01Republican Party to have the vote
- 00:13:03including women women of any race in the
- 00:13:08Fifteenth Amendment was definitely too
- 00:13:11controversial and was quite clear that
- 00:13:14including women would have guaranteed
- 00:13:16its failure when you ask for woman's
- 00:13:21suffrage as opposed to manhood suffrage
- 00:13:25you're asking for two major developments
- 00:13:28to happen at the same time you're asking
- 00:13:31on the one hand for a different way that
- 00:13:35Americans view african-american men they
- 00:13:39are no longer property they are now your
- 00:13:43fellow citizens with all the same rights
- 00:13:45that you have so that's a big thing
- 00:13:48Americans can't really focus on two big
- 00:13:52changes or very simply they don't want
- 00:13:56to focus on these two big changes to
- 00:13:59American society by the 1870s and 80s a
- 00:14:03growing number of unusually bold white
- 00:14:05Southern women began advocating for
- 00:14:08women's rights within 20 years their
- 00:14:11impassioned pleas convinced national
- 00:14:13leaders to look south in the 1890s white
- 00:14:17Southern Democrats were trying to regain
- 00:14:19political power they were trying to keep
- 00:14:22black men from voting or to counter its
- 00:14:25effect and southern and northern
- 00:14:27suffragists saw an opportunity in this
- 00:14:30and they develop sort of a Southern
- 00:14:33Strategy ironically they borrowed some
- 00:14:37of their ideas from Henry blackwell a
- 00:14:39northern abolitionists who said you can
- 00:14:42accomplish your goal not by
- 00:14:44disfranchising black men but giving the
- 00:14:47votes to women you're for millions of
- 00:14:51southern white women will counterbalance
- 00:14:53your for millions of Negro men and women
- 00:14:56and thus the political supremacy of your
- 00:14:59white race will remain unchanged
- 00:15:03they sent professional recruiters into
- 00:15:06the area Susan De'Anthony and Carrie
- 00:15:08Chapman can't win on major speaking
- 00:15:11tours throughout the region and
- 00:15:13everywhere spreading this message when
- 00:15:17those two suffers leaders came to
- 00:15:19Memphis they of course spoken very
- 00:15:22racialized settings there's no record of
- 00:15:25exactly what they said to the black
- 00:15:27women but you can just understand it's
- 00:15:30going to be a little different from what
- 00:15:31they're saying to the white woman but
- 00:15:33the thing is there's an understanding
- 00:15:35that maybe we need to address suffrage
- 00:15:39as an issue that can be pushed by both
- 00:15:42by women in both communities it was
- 00:15:45inevitable that race was going to play a
- 00:15:47major role in the suffrage movement and
- 00:15:50national leaders in order to achieve a
- 00:15:52national victory had to have some
- 00:15:54southern states and southern suffragists
- 00:15:57were working for the vote in the midst
- 00:15:59of a regional movement to restore white
- 00:16:01political supremacy twenty-five years
- 00:16:06after losing the battle to include women
- 00:16:08in the Fifteenth Amendment national
- 00:16:11suffrage leaders discouraged that
- 00:16:13arguments based on justice were falling
- 00:16:16on deaf ears were willing to resort to
- 00:16:18political expediency this moral
- 00:16:22compromise came into stark relief at
- 00:16:24their conventions held in the south in
- 00:16:27an attempt to woo white Southerners to
- 00:16:30their cause because they needed to have
- 00:16:32a national constituency leaders of the
- 00:16:36National American Woman Suffrage
- 00:16:38Association decided to hold conventions
- 00:16:41in the south they did however accept the
- 00:16:45idea of segregation they also at the
- 00:16:48same time were a sort of circus Lee
- 00:16:51wooing black women so they were playing
- 00:16:54both sides of the game at this point
- 00:16:57trying to attract black women but to do
- 00:17:00it surreptitiously so that they would
- 00:17:02not offend white people it's about the
- 00:17:04turn of the century state legislators
- 00:17:07throughout the South found other means
- 00:17:10of preventing african-american men from
- 00:17:13voting
- 00:17:14such as
- 00:17:15poll taxes and understanding clauses all
- 00:17:19assisted by rulings from the Supreme
- 00:17:22Court when the laws did not work well
- 00:17:25enough they turn to physical
- 00:17:28intimidation and those impacted black
- 00:17:30women as well and the more active and
- 00:17:34high-profile a black woman was the more
- 00:17:36likely she was to be subject to such
- 00:17:39intimidation after that that whole
- 00:17:43Southern Strategy was exposed as
- 00:17:46ineffective and the movement more or
- 00:17:50less went dormant in the South until the
- 00:17:54last decade of the suffrage movement
- 00:17:57[Music]
- 00:17:59the social and economic upheaval of the
- 00:18:02Civil War had provided the impetus for
- 00:18:04building a southern suffrage movement as
- 00:18:06it thrust women into the public sphere
- 00:18:09in the face of great need they defied
- 00:18:13convention and threw themselves into
- 00:18:15rebuilding their families their lives
- 00:18:17and their communities in the aftermath
- 00:18:20of the civil war you see women joining
- 00:18:23together and creating organizations on a
- 00:18:27local level that are capable of working
- 00:18:30together to build institutions like
- 00:18:34churches like schools when you look at
- 00:18:39organizations within the black church
- 00:18:41with any church women are the doers the
- 00:18:44other organizes so they took those
- 00:18:47skills that they had in the church they
- 00:18:50honed it in the community they knew how
- 00:18:53to galvanize people church groups are
- 00:18:56providing a mechanism for women to start
- 00:18:58gathering and that becomes more
- 00:19:00politicized and moves more into civic
- 00:19:02work and public work as women to find
- 00:19:04their roles in society as taking on
- 00:19:07problems in the community that need
- 00:19:09attention and it is cumulative from
- 00:19:12their own in 1885 a young widow Lizzie
- 00:19:17Crozier French chafed at the limited
- 00:19:19life women led in her conservative
- 00:19:22hometown of Knoxville Tennessee suffrage
- 00:19:25would have been too radical an issue for
- 00:19:27most women in her community to start
- 00:19:29broadening their minds French founded
- 00:19:32the AUSA Li circle as a women's book
- 00:19:34club the club was very successful but
- 00:19:37after a certain period of time she got
- 00:19:39sort of bored with him discussing things
- 00:19:42that were sort of ancient questions and
- 00:19:44so she is reported to have stood up in
- 00:19:46the middle of one of the meetings and
- 00:19:48said ladies Dante is dead now let's move
- 00:19:52on with things that can help the people
- 00:19:53now and so she tried to change it more
- 00:19:56into a social action group the Asli
- 00:20:00circle grew to be a powerful force for
- 00:20:02women's reform efforts in Knoxville
- 00:20:05throughout the segregated south african
- 00:20:08american women's clubs
- 00:20:10also thrived there were hundreds of
- 00:20:13african-american women's clubs that had
- 00:20:15thousands of members throughout the
- 00:20:17south they did differ slightly from the
- 00:20:21white women's clubs in that they were
- 00:20:23all very serious they didn't seem to
- 00:20:26engage very much in trivial pursuits
- 00:20:30rather they stuck to issues of education
- 00:20:33reform and political empowerment by the
- 00:20:36late 1800s the women's Christian
- 00:20:39Temperance Union had become one of the
- 00:20:41most popular organizations in the South
- 00:20:43moving well beyond its initial mandate
- 00:20:46of prohibition the WCTU allowed women to
- 00:20:50organize and act upon a variety of
- 00:20:54subjects whether its schools or public
- 00:20:57life politics all the time creating
- 00:21:00activities that allowed women to learn
- 00:21:03how to run a meeting learn how to raise
- 00:21:05money learn how to talk to politicians
- 00:21:08the women's Christian Temperance Union
- 00:21:11was the golden key that unlocked the
- 00:21:14prison doors of pent-up possibilities it
- 00:21:17was the generous Liberator the joyous
- 00:21:20iconoclast the discoverer the developer
- 00:21:23of southern women
- 00:21:26as they moved into the public sphere
- 00:21:28these women were interested in reforming
- 00:21:31things like working conditions and child
- 00:21:33labor and incredibly to raise the age of
- 00:21:38consent which in some southern states
- 00:21:40was as low as ten years old they began
- 00:21:45to see that the power they lacked in
- 00:21:48making these suggestions was the ballot
- 00:21:52box they could come to the state capitol
- 00:21:54and talk to the lawmakers here but until
- 00:21:58they could vote for those lawmakers they
- 00:22:01had no power from post-civil war church
- 00:22:16groups to temperance action to community
- 00:22:19civic groups women are claiming their
- 00:22:21space in society and there was no
- 00:22:23repressing that or holding it back it's
- 00:22:26the need for freedom and rights and
- 00:22:28civic respect and place in society women
- 00:22:33had to have that the vote for women was
- 00:22:36the logical outcome
- 00:22:40[Music]
- 00:22:42by 1900 and even more by 1910 the army
- 00:22:48of women was there they had had another
- 00:22:50generations worth of experiences in
- 00:22:52women's clubs another generation had
- 00:22:55been to college the moment seemed to
- 00:22:57have arrived by 1911 there were
- 00:23:00organized suffrage groups in all the
- 00:23:02major Tennessee cities by 1910 you've
- 00:23:18suddenly got some younger women coming
- 00:23:20along that add a little more energy to a
- 00:23:25group of women that have become rather
- 00:23:27set in their ways
- 00:23:28take for example and Alice Dudley
- 00:23:31she was from what would be regarded as a
- 00:23:34good family and yet she went to a
- 00:23:38suffrage meeting there's a direct
- 00:23:40correlation between how tough it was to
- 00:23:43argue for suffrage in this region and
- 00:23:46the fact that it that these elite women
- 00:23:48were the ones doing it because only they
- 00:23:50could get away with it a new breed the
- 00:23:53career woman also joined the ranks of
- 00:23:56the suffrage movement sue Shelton white
- 00:23:59was the first female court stenographer
- 00:24:02in Jackson Tennessee so she's that
- 00:24:05third-generation of suffragists who sees
- 00:24:09the future sees what the vote might
- 00:24:13benefit her in many many ways even more
- 00:24:16than just the vote it's the sense of
- 00:24:18equality of opportunity opening up and
- 00:24:21she wants it
- 00:24:25this movement really was grabbing the
- 00:24:28imagination of the every woman in
- 00:24:31America because it promised a kind of
- 00:24:36opening not just for the vote but for a
- 00:24:39new kind of role for women in society
- 00:24:44African American women also saw the
- 00:24:46promise of a new role but their fight
- 00:24:49proved more complex a Delahunt Logan
- 00:24:53from Tuskegee Alabama was one of the few
- 00:24:56who openly advocated for suffrage while
- 00:24:59still living in the south I've come
- 00:25:02across no evidence that african-american
- 00:25:05women moved outside of their own
- 00:25:07communities to promote suffrage for
- 00:25:10women what they did do for example at
- 00:25:14Tuskegee Institute in that protected
- 00:25:17African American environment those women
- 00:25:20sometimes did indeed hold rallies for
- 00:25:23women voting but they wouldn't have done
- 00:25:25so in the town of Tuskegee or have done
- 00:25:28so in the city of Atlanta as the
- 00:25:31movement gained strength in the south
- 00:25:34national leaders continued to try to
- 00:25:37appease white Southerners on the race
- 00:25:39issue and they were very very wary of
- 00:25:42how anything they said about race was
- 00:25:44going to be used against them by the
- 00:25:47anti suffragists and so they continued
- 00:25:51to tolerate discrimination and they
- 00:25:54played down the role of black women in
- 00:25:56the movement
- 00:25:58former Tennesseans Mary Church Terrell
- 00:26:01and Ida B wells actively worked for
- 00:26:04women's suffrage but in their adopted
- 00:26:07hometowns of Washington DC and Chicago
- 00:26:09Illinois in 1913 they were confronted
- 00:26:14with the racial politics of the movement
- 00:26:16when they were asked to march at the
- 00:26:18back of a massive suffrage parade on the
- 00:26:20nation's capitol Mary Church Terrell she
- 00:26:25led a group in that March while they
- 00:26:29marched they marched in the back on the
- 00:26:31other hand you have how to be Wells but
- 00:26:35what she does is that she steps out when
- 00:26:39the Chicago delegation is walking and
- 00:26:41she walks with that Chicago delegation
- 00:26:45with white women I think what that
- 00:26:47parade incident tells us is that first
- 00:26:51of all there is no one way of responding
- 00:26:53ah to be well says well no I'm not going
- 00:26:57to do it she was very uncompromising
- 00:27:00mary church terrell would have looked
- 00:27:04for the compromise for the good of the
- 00:27:06whole but they're all working for the
- 00:27:09same thing
- 00:27:12by then the woman suffrage movement had
- 00:27:16made major gains in other regions
- 00:27:18especially in the West but southern
- 00:27:21legislators were still resistant
- 00:27:23Tennessee suffragists did have enough
- 00:27:26support in the major cities to organize
- 00:27:28May Day parades with hundreds of cars
- 00:27:31and women be decked and suffrage yellow
- 00:27:33at the first parade in Nashville in 1914
- 00:27:38according to the local paper and Alice
- 00:27:41Dudley gave the first open-air speech by
- 00:27:44any woman in Tennessee a southern woman
- 00:27:47should be happy and content in her home
- 00:27:51on her pedestal and here they're coming
- 00:27:54down to the pedestal into the mud of the
- 00:27:56streets and saying uh-uh
- 00:27:58things are not alright and that was
- 00:28:01really pretty radical if the most
- 00:28:04privileged person in the society
- 00:28:07rejected its fundamental hierarchical
- 00:28:09structure and demanded to have equal
- 00:28:13representation and power than that kind
- 00:28:16of suggested the corruption of the
- 00:28:18entire system
- 00:28:21Antti suffragists had an arsenal of
- 00:28:24ideology and arguments against women's
- 00:28:27suffrage that fell into basically five
- 00:28:29categories biological biblical or
- 00:28:33religious sociological arguments racial
- 00:28:36arguments and states rights arguments
- 00:28:39remember that woman's suffrage means a
- 00:28:42reopening of the entire Negro suffrage
- 00:28:44question loss of state rights and
- 00:28:47another period of reconstruction horrors
- 00:28:50southerners had worked so hard since the
- 00:28:54civil war to take away all the rights of
- 00:28:57African American men regarding politics
- 00:29:01and now this would open this whole can
- 00:29:04of worms of who should be voting and is
- 00:29:08it the federal government's
- 00:29:09responsibility to determine who can vote
- 00:29:12inside a state and who cannot by the
- 00:29:16mid-nineteen tends the woman's suffrage
- 00:29:18movement gained enough momentum to
- 00:29:21require an organized opposition
- 00:29:24manufacturers did not want women to have
- 00:29:26the right to vote
- 00:29:28because they would probably start
- 00:29:30pushing for regulations over these
- 00:29:34factories the liquor industry opposed
- 00:29:38women having the right to vote because
- 00:29:40they blamed women for prohibition and
- 00:29:45finally there were the railroads they
- 00:29:48had a very significant voice in the
- 00:29:52hallways and back rooms where the deals
- 00:29:55were cut here at the General Assembly
- 00:29:59while these business interests worked
- 00:30:01the halls of state legislatures
- 00:30:03throughout the south women provided the
- 00:30:06public face of organized anti-suffrage
- 00:30:09groups in tennessee josephine pearson of
- 00:30:14monaco emerged as the leader this is
- 00:30:18what was so unbelievable about josephine
- 00:30:21pearson she had never married she was a
- 00:30:23totally independent woman and yet she
- 00:30:26was a very effective spokesman telling
- 00:30:30people why women shouldn't have the
- 00:30:32right to vote
- 00:30:34posing Woman Suffrage in their view
- 00:30:36isn't opposing their own self-interest
- 00:30:39it's protecting those other areas of
- 00:30:42their self-interest their economic
- 00:30:45self-interest their class
- 00:30:47self-interest their region's political
- 00:30:50structure all of those things that they
- 00:30:53benefit from they're choosing to protect
- 00:30:58by 1917 women had won either full or
- 00:31:02partial suffrage in seventeen states but
- 00:31:06the southeastern states remained
- 00:31:08steadfastly resistant as national
- 00:31:12leaders turned their organizational
- 00:31:14strength towards a federal
- 00:31:16constitutional amendment Southern women
- 00:31:19had to face political reality it's
- 00:31:22probably safe to say southern
- 00:31:24suffragists were very practical at this
- 00:31:27point there were just so many states
- 00:31:29that we're never going to enact woman
- 00:31:31suffrage if they really wanted it to be
- 00:31:33nationwide it was going to have to come
- 00:31:35by federal amendment with the outbreak
- 00:31:40of war a rift between the two national
- 00:31:43suffrage groups grew wider Carrie
- 00:31:47Chapman Catt president of the National
- 00:31:50American Woman Suffrage Association or
- 00:31:53the National encouraged all her members
- 00:31:56to turn their energy toward the war
- 00:31:58effort she hoped their actions would
- 00:32:01convince president woodrow wilson that
- 00:32:03women deserve the full right of
- 00:32:05citizenship however Alice Paul leader of
- 00:32:10the National Woman's Party refused to
- 00:32:13stop her aggressive tactics designed to
- 00:32:15embarrass the president the whole idea
- 00:32:19of women standing up and being this
- 00:32:24aggressive on top of just being
- 00:32:26suffragists which was considered
- 00:32:27aggressive enough kind of puts it over
- 00:32:30the pale and so both southern men find
- 00:32:34it very offensive and southern women
- 00:32:37even southern suffrages
- 00:32:42sue Shelton white however found the bold
- 00:32:45tactics appealing she changed
- 00:32:48affiliations eventually moving to
- 00:32:50Washington DC to work for Alice Paul she
- 00:32:54served her time in the mainstream
- 00:32:56suffrage organization she's gotten
- 00:32:59frustrated and so she joins the women's
- 00:33:01Party because she thinks they are going
- 00:33:04to be more aggressive and more
- 00:33:06confrontational in demanding the vote
- 00:33:08and she's willing to do that now the
- 00:33:10majority of Tennessee suffragists
- 00:33:12however followed Carrie Chapman Catt
- 00:33:14SCID vice to join the war effort Carrie
- 00:33:18Chapman Catt who is a political
- 00:33:20pragmatist and she gambled having her
- 00:33:23legions of activists enter the war
- 00:33:26effort and for her that was a real
- 00:33:29sacrifice because she was a committed
- 00:33:32pacifist but the gamble paid off Woodrow
- 00:33:35Wilson eventually came out and supported
- 00:33:38the federal amendment
- 00:33:41only five months after the Armistice
- 00:33:44Tennessee suffragists introduced a bill
- 00:33:47to the state legislature allowing women
- 00:33:49to vote in presidential and municipal
- 00:33:52elections and their appeal to Tennessee
- 00:33:56men the suffragists emphasized women's
- 00:33:59contributions to winning the war as well
- 00:34:02as how many women could already vote in
- 00:34:05other states all the women of the West
- 00:34:08some millions of the north and many
- 00:34:10thousands of the south are already
- 00:34:13voters what made the women of Tennessee
- 00:34:15expect of you that is what finally
- 00:34:19tipped a scale when there were so many
- 00:34:22states that had supported it that the
- 00:34:27politicians in both political parties
- 00:34:29begin to sense that women were going to
- 00:34:33get the vote you were going to double
- 00:34:35the electorate and which side of that
- 00:34:37did you want to be on
- 00:34:40on April 14 1919 Tennessee women won the
- 00:34:45right to vote in presidential and
- 00:34:47municipal elections adding even more
- 00:34:50momentum to the building tidal wave of
- 00:34:52Pro suffrage sentiment less than two
- 00:34:56months later with President Wilson
- 00:34:58support both houses of the US Congress
- 00:35:01passed the 19th amendment to become law
- 00:35:05the amendment now had to be ratified by
- 00:35:0836 states as the fight for the federal
- 00:35:13amendment went to the states for
- 00:35:14ratification Tennessee suffragists
- 00:35:17immediately put their new state voting
- 00:35:20rights into action creating a list of
- 00:35:22reforms they wanted and organizing a
- 00:35:25voter registration drive Catherine
- 00:35:28Kenney spearheaded the efforts in
- 00:35:30Nashville and an extraordinary alliance
- 00:35:52rarely seen in the south Kenny teamed
- 00:35:55with dr. Mattie Coleman and J Frankie
- 00:35:58Pierce influential leaders in the black
- 00:36:00community to register approximately
- 00:36:042,000 african-american women in
- 00:36:06Nashville I have found very little
- 00:36:09evidence that indicates that black women
- 00:36:12and white women worked together in the
- 00:36:15south adela Logan tried to encourage the
- 00:36:18National Association of colored women to
- 00:36:20join in efforts with white groups of all
- 00:36:23sorts but for the most part those
- 00:36:25efforts were not very successful the
- 00:36:28white women weren't open to it for the
- 00:36:29most part by September 1919 every major
- 00:36:33city in the state reported remarkable
- 00:36:36numbers of women black and white
- 00:36:39registry
- 00:36:40[Music]
- 00:36:42by late March 1920 only one more state
- 00:36:46was needed to ratify the federal
- 00:36:47amendment but few viable options
- 00:36:50remained a spring warmed into summer
- 00:36:54suffragists hopes of being able to vote
- 00:36:56in the 1920 presidential election were
- 00:36:59repeatedly dashed as state legislators
- 00:37:02rejected the amendment our governor's
- 00:37:05refused to call special sessions in all
- 00:37:08but one state Tennessee
- 00:37:11so the suffragists are very nervous when
- 00:37:15they realize that the last battle may
- 00:37:17have to be fought in a southern state
- 00:37:20because again most of the southern
- 00:37:24states have already rejected the 19th
- 00:37:26amendment so there's this sense of
- 00:37:30anxiety and well placed by the
- 00:37:32suffragists they don't get it now they
- 00:37:34may not get it after the 1920 election
- 00:37:38it'll be too hard to regain momentum
- 00:37:41Tennessee Governor Albert Roberts
- 00:37:43resisted enormous pressure even from
- 00:37:47President Wilson to call a special
- 00:37:49session vote against his election was
- 00:38:01coming up right away and he didn't want
- 00:38:04them to have ago and I said why you know
- 00:38:08if you give them the book they'll have
- 00:38:10to talk to you
- 00:38:13so he weighed the political liability of
- 00:38:16this decision before he announced that
- 00:38:21he would call the special session the
- 00:38:24caveat being that the special session
- 00:38:26would convene after the August primary
- 00:38:31so the message was very clear women if I
- 00:38:36don't win the Democratic nomination for
- 00:38:38governor
- 00:38:40you can probably write off having the
- 00:38:43special session it will not take place
- 00:38:48as Tennessee suffragists threw
- 00:38:51themselves into organizing support
- 00:38:53battle-hardened Carrie Chapman Catt
- 00:38:56offered her sober assessment no matter
- 00:38:59how well the women may work ratification
- 00:39:03in Tennessee will go through the work
- 00:39:05and action of men and the great motive
- 00:39:08that will finally put it through will be
- 00:39:11political and nothing else we have long
- 00:39:15since recovered from our previous faith
- 00:39:18in the action of men based upon the love
- 00:39:20of Justice and they began a physically
- 00:39:28demanding and tireless crusade going
- 00:39:32across the state whether it be on the
- 00:39:35train in the wagon meeting with every
- 00:39:38member of the Tennessee General Assembly
- 00:39:41attempting to persuade them of the
- 00:39:45justice the righteousness of this cause
- 00:39:49I remember going in while counting their
- 00:39:54pasta there's three of them
- 00:39:58this is Camry rose in it and just way
- 00:40:03before the time of bus says Norway are
- 00:40:07negated I and get to the courthouse
- 00:40:10worse arrive in the counted with the
- 00:40:15mailman he's at me - they will nature
- 00:40:20today the auntie suffragists are also
- 00:40:24organizing they go from Memphis to
- 00:40:27Nashville to Chattanooga trying to get
- 00:40:29support for halting preventing the
- 00:40:33governor from calling a special session
- 00:40:35and if that fails at least to promising
- 00:40:40to vote against ratification as the
- 00:40:45summer heat and sticky humidity
- 00:40:47descended on Nashville
- 00:40:48national leaders of all factions arrived
- 00:40:51to rally their troops sue white returned
- 00:40:55to her home state eager but anxious with
- 00:40:58only limited resources from the National
- 00:41:01Woman's Party both Carrie Chapman Catt
- 00:41:03president of the National and Josephine
- 00:41:06Pearson president of the Tennessee State
- 00:41:09Association opposed to woman suffrage
- 00:41:11took rooms at the elegant hermitage
- 00:41:14hotel
- 00:41:16so you've got these two women on
- 00:41:18different floors of the Hermitage hotel
- 00:41:20where the scene of the fight is going to
- 00:41:25take place it becomes known as the War
- 00:41:28of the Roses because the ant eyes wore
- 00:41:30red roses red flowers and the
- 00:41:33suffragists wore yellow roses or yellow
- 00:41:36flowers was a table they want different
- 00:41:45floors punch each other as July gave way
- 00:41:57to August legislators arrived for the
- 00:42:00special session and were met by legions
- 00:42:02of women hoping to pen a yellow or red
- 00:42:05rose on their lapels the suffragists had
- 00:42:08done their homework they were indeed
- 00:42:10much more organized than the ant eyes
- 00:42:13were so when the session convened they
- 00:42:16really thought they had a very
- 00:42:19comfortable margin and yet this is at
- 00:42:23the point when the ant eyes really began
- 00:42:26to work so everyone converges on the
- 00:42:31hermitage and the lobby is just a swarm
- 00:42:34of people debating and arguing and
- 00:42:37lobbying and perhaps bribing on the 8th
- 00:42:54floor of the hotel
- 00:42:55despite prohibition laws liquor
- 00:42:58lobbyists set up what came to be known
- 00:43:00as the Jack Daniels suite luring
- 00:43:03legislators they're hoping to turn
- 00:43:05yellow roses into red
- 00:43:16[Music]
- 00:43:23within the first few days of the special
- 00:43:26session suffragists saw the effects of
- 00:43:29the anti x' lobbying efforts powerful
- 00:43:32political allies who had pledged to lead
- 00:43:34the efforts for ratification turned anti
- 00:43:38including Speaker of the House
- 00:43:43[Music]
- 00:43:54[Music]
- 00:44:02it is not ladylike politics at all this
- 00:44:06fight that is going to take place in the
- 00:44:09halls of the Tennessee State Capitol the
- 00:44:12arguments are fierce the ridicule and
- 00:44:17humiliation of the suffragists were on
- 00:44:50the fifth day of the special session
- 00:44:53Friday the 13th the Tennessee Senate
- 00:44:56overwhelmingly voted to ratify the
- 00:44:58amendment suffragists now had to contend
- 00:45:02with the ever-shifting House of
- 00:45:04Representatives led by their unexpected
- 00:45:06adversary Seth Walker a master of
- 00:45:10legislative stalling tactics in
- 00:45:22Nashville at the time with each delay in
- 00:45:28the Tennessee House the suffragists
- 00:45:32became more and more anxious
- 00:45:34the
- 00:45:34because on a daily basis as the men
- 00:45:37convened they saw men who had supported
- 00:45:41ratification men who had worn yellow
- 00:45:44roses now appearing in the House chamber
- 00:45:47wearing red roses when the Sun rose on
- 00:45:53the tenth day of the special session all
- 00:45:55the leaders of the many suffrage
- 00:45:58factions counted who remained on their
- 00:46:01list of supporters and all came up short
- 00:46:05even most of Nashville's representatives
- 00:46:08personally pledged buy and Alice Dudley
- 00:46:11had defected to the auntie's the vote
- 00:46:15would finally happen in this one moment
- 00:46:18and this unlikely place rested the civic
- 00:46:22fate of millions of women the House
- 00:46:29clerk continued the roll call for the
- 00:46:31final vote on the ratification of the
- 00:46:3419th amendment
- 00:46:41Harry Berne was the first time
- 00:46:43legislature from Nyota Tennessee and the
- 00:46:46youngest member of the house at only 24
- 00:46:48years old it so happens that after I had
- 00:46:51gotten to Nashville people from all over
- 00:46:54the country had gone into my County that
- 00:46:56had indignation meetings they caused the
- 00:46:58courts to adjourn so that they might
- 00:47:00pass resolutions and they were my
- 00:47:02constituency where was in a great state
- 00:47:04of turmoil I don't know yet exactly what
- 00:47:08the majority favored but anyway there's
- 00:47:11lots of feeling existed so much so that
- 00:47:13when I would go home on a weekend I
- 00:47:15would generally keep a body guard around
- 00:47:17so that no one would attack me with the
- 00:47:20intense pressure from Republican leaders
- 00:47:22and constituents back home Bern had
- 00:47:25voted with an ties all along despite his
- 00:47:28personal support for suffrage he had
- 00:47:31hoped his vote would not matter in the
- 00:47:34final outcome
- 00:47:35but a last-minute change by West
- 00:47:38Tennessee legislature banks Turner meant
- 00:47:41the final vote would likely end in a tie
- 00:47:45he is so torn
- 00:47:48he is so conflicted here he is does he
- 00:47:52do what personally what his conscience
- 00:47:54feels is right or does he do what would
- 00:47:59be better for him for his re-election
- 00:48:01campaign and he's done the math and
- 00:48:03realized that with banks Turner flipping
- 00:48:07towards the amendment he may be the
- 00:48:11deciding vote it's just what he didn't
- 00:48:13want to happen in a fortuitous bit of
- 00:48:17timing Bern received a letter from his
- 00:48:19mother Feb Ensminger Bern right before
- 00:48:23he walked into the house chamber my
- 00:48:27mother was the college woman she was a
- 00:48:30student of national and international
- 00:48:31affairs she took an interest in all
- 00:48:34public issues she could not vote and yet
- 00:48:38the tenant farmers on our farm some of
- 00:48:41whom were illiterate good vote fat-burn
- 00:48:45had been closely following the reports
- 00:48:47of the Tennessee legislature in her
- 00:48:49local newspaper nestled amongst folksy
- 00:48:52news of his hometown Byrnes mother gave
- 00:48:55her son some advice Hirai vote for
- 00:48:59suffrage and don't keep him in doubt
- 00:49:02I've been waiting to see how you stood
- 00:49:04but have not seen anything yet don't
- 00:49:06forget to be a good boy and help mrs.
- 00:49:09cat with her rats so when it came
- 00:49:12Harry's turn to vote Harry with his very
- 00:49:15quiet vote voted aye
- 00:49:18I vote for the suffrage cause Harry has
- 00:49:26changed his vote
- 00:49:28can you believe it the roll call
- 00:49:31continued through to the teas Travis
- 00:49:35Tucker Turner
- 00:49:39Turner the clerk mark Turner is not
- 00:49:44voting in the roll call continued to the
- 00:49:46end at that point it will be a tied vote
- 00:49:51which means suffrage will go down to
- 00:49:55defeat even with Harry burns affirmative
- 00:49:58vote what happens next is whatever's
- 00:50:03going through banks Turner's mind he
- 00:50:06says to the clerk there's a moment of
- 00:50:15complete utter stunned silence because
- 00:50:19everyone realizes this is it this is
- 00:50:23that one vote margin and ratification
- 00:50:27has passed then there's an explosion of
- 00:50:33emotion the ant eyes are furious they
- 00:50:39thought they had this deal sealed and
- 00:50:43now they are furious the suffragists our
- 00:50:46emotional beyond belief crying hugging
- 00:50:50each other
- 00:50:50[Applause]
- 00:51:00it was the next day before the press
- 00:51:04caught up with Harry T Byrne Harry
- 00:51:08why did you change your mind all the
- 00:51:11reporters wanted to know the answer to
- 00:51:13that question and so Harry told the
- 00:51:16reporters simply I always take my
- 00:51:21mother's advice on that roll call when I
- 00:51:24was confronted for the fact that I was
- 00:51:26going to go on record for time and
- 00:51:28eternity on the merits of the question I
- 00:51:30voted in favor of ratification
- 00:51:35there were all manner of shenanigans
- 00:51:38being pulled politically to try to get
- 00:51:41yet another vote but the vote held and
- 00:51:45so somewhat reluctantly I think governor
- 00:51:49Roberts finally said bring me the
- 00:51:53document I'm going to sign it and it was
- 00:51:55signed and immediately put on the train
- 00:51:58to go back to Washington to be presented
- 00:52:02to the secretary of state across the
- 00:52:04nation women who had worked for suffrage
- 00:52:07some their entire lives celebrated this
- 00:52:11hard-won civil right for some southern
- 00:52:14suffragists however the ratification by
- 00:52:17federal amendment was a bittersweet
- 00:52:19victory
- 00:52:21it only remains for the outward and
- 00:52:23visible sign of our freedom to be put in
- 00:52:25the hands of Southern women by the
- 00:52:27generous men of other states a situation
- 00:52:31that hurts our pride into which we
- 00:52:33submit with deep regret but not apology
- 00:52:37[Music]
- 00:52:39most southern suffer just really wanted
- 00:52:43to get the vote by state action because
- 00:52:46of what that symbolizes what it
- 00:52:49symbolized is that the your men the men
- 00:52:52in your life the men in your state see
- 00:52:54you as their political equal
- 00:52:58passage of the 19th amendment also did
- 00:53:01not mean african-american women would be
- 00:53:04treated as political equals
- 00:53:07african-american women in the south were
- 00:53:09faced with in many instances the failure
- 00:53:13to enforce the provisions of the
- 00:53:16Fifteenth Amendment many of them wanted
- 00:53:18to vote many of them tried to vote but
- 00:53:20they face the same barriers to voting
- 00:53:22that african-american men did in other
- 00:53:26words they were limited by provisions of
- 00:53:28poll taxes by physical intimidation they
- 00:53:33understood that they were going to be
- 00:53:34you know some restrictions and
- 00:53:36restraints placed upon them but they
- 00:53:38also understood that with fortitude with
- 00:53:42perseverance that they could get through
- 00:53:46it and be active participants in the
- 00:53:50political system the ratification of the
- 00:53:5519th amendment was only the first step
- 00:53:59in a long series of battles culminating
- 00:54:04in the 1960s with the Civil Rights Act
- 00:54:08and the Voting Rights Act but even those
- 00:54:12who are not the end who gets to vote in
- 00:54:15this country is still being debated a
- 00:54:19hundred years later looking back at
- 00:54:23history you can see that rights are
- 00:54:25given rights are taken away so the fact
- 00:54:27that we won this right to vote doesn't
- 00:54:30mean it's always there it needs to be
- 00:54:33defended it needs to be protected and
- 00:54:36that's an important lesson in democracy
- 00:54:38it doesn't take away from what was
- 00:54:41achieved but it shows that you can't
- 00:54:44just pass laws it's not that simple
- 00:54:48having the legal right particularly
- 00:54:51guaranteed in the Constitution is an
- 00:54:53enormous first step that doesn't mean
- 00:54:55that the world changed that's just
- 00:54:58that's just the tool with which we can
- 00:55:00change the world
- 00:55:01but we have to continue the processor
- 00:55:04Italy Road I think looking at the long
- 00:55:07history of women's suffrage what we can
- 00:55:10take away is that sometimes change
- 00:55:13happens over a very very long period of
- 00:55:17time but they do change and the wheel of
- 00:55:22progress just keeps right on turning
- 00:55:26with a few maybe backward rotations but
- 00:55:29it keeps turning the overall story of
- 00:55:33the southern suffrage movement is one of
- 00:55:36failure but the fact that southern
- 00:55:39suffragists managed to get four states
- 00:55:42to ratify and that Tennessee ratified
- 00:55:46despite all the pressure that was being
- 00:55:48applied to get it not to now that's a
- 00:55:52story in what sheer persistence can
- 00:55:55accomplish in the face of great
- 00:55:57obstacles
- 00:56:02you
- 00:56:07[Music]
- 00:56:20you
- 00:56:23you
- 00:56:24[Music]
- 00:56:38you
- 00:56:42major funding for by one vote woman's
- 00:56:45suffrage in the South is provided by the
- 00:56:48Bethany fund Tennessee's Civil War
- 00:56:52National Heritage Area the Josie Davis
- 00:56:56foundation in memory of Frances bond
- 00:56:59Davis the Shane Foundation Cathy and
- 00:57:04Martin Brown and the MSB Cockaigne fund
- 00:57:06and by Carlene Libas and Harris hastin
- 00:57:11additional support provided by First
- 00:57:14Tennessee foundation an and Charles Roos
- 00:57:17Hanna Paramore Breen Andrea Conti Laurie
- 00:57:22gold Eskin and the following
- 00:57:26[Music]
- 00:57:35and by members of NPT thank you
- 00:57:42[Music]
- women's suffrage
- Tennessee
- 19th Amendment
- suffragists
- race and gender
- political history
- Civil War
- women's rights
- anti-suffrage
- historical struggle