What is the traditional definition of a revolution?

A fundamental change in the political order in a short period of time, often originally signifying a restoration of a previous order rather than a complete break.

How did the term 'revolution' originate?

The term was borrowed from astronomy, referring to the movement of celestial bodies and their complete return to a previous position.

What event is considered the first to be called a revolution?

The expulsion of the Stuart dynasty from England in 1688, known as the Glorious Revolution.

How did the French Revolution alter the term's meaning?

Despite seeking a completely new political system, the French Revolution shifted the term's meaning, yet ironically restored absolutist governments multiple times.

Why do movements often adopt the term 'revolution'?

Movements are labeled as revolutions to portray them as inherently positive or progressive, aligning with the desire to appear as the 'good guys.'

How has Karl Marx influenced modern perceptions of revolution?

Karl Marx's writings, emphasizing class struggle and economic inequality, have contributed to viewing revolutions as a natural reaction to capitalism.

What is Revolution? | Casual Historian

00:04:50

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nrAdIB_MbY

Résumé

TLDRThe video delves into the concept of 'revolution,' examining its shift from a term describing the astronomical movement of celestial bodies to its political application, denoting significant political changes often thought of positively. Historically, revolutions like the Glorious Revolution aimed to restore previous orders rather than entirely break from the past. However, events like the French Revolution redefined it to some extent, aligning it with complete political overhauls. The video's analysis highlights Karl Marx's influence in modern times, where revolutions are often associated with class struggle and economic shifts, prompting frequent usage of the term across socio-political movements. This pervasive adoption signifies rapid change, making revolutions appealing as they promise swift resolutions to societal issues.

A retenir

🌀 The word 'revolution' originates from astronomy, denoting a circular path of celestial bodies.
⚡ The classic political definition involves a rapid change or restoration of political order.
🇬🇧 The first notable political revolution was the Glorious Revolution in England, 1688.
🇫🇷 The French Revolution redefined 'revolution' while ironically restoring old regimes.
📚 Karl Marx's ideas prevail, promoting revolutions as responses to economic inequality.
👍 Modern movements use 'revolution' to imply positive change and moral righteousness.
🔄 Many political changes termed revolutions today would not fit classical definitions.
🏃‍♂️ Revolution is appealing due to the promise of swift change.
🔑 Movements labeled as revolutions are often perceived as inherently good.
⏳ Rapid change is equated with revolutions, offering a quick fix to societal issues.

Chronologie

00:00:00 - 00:04:50
The word 'revolution' is often considered in its political context, implying fundamental changes in political orders. However, its roots come from astronomy, referring to celestial shifts that eventually revert back to their original positions. Historically, 'revolution' signified a restoration rather than a complete break from the past. For instance, the Glorious Revolution in England was about restoring a previous political order. Over time, especially with events like the French Revolution, the term began to signify creating entirely new systems, diverging from its original meaning. Consequently, the modern understanding of 'revolution' expanded, encompassing various movements not originally qualifying under the classical definition.

Carte mentale

Questions fréquemment posées

What is the traditional definition of a revolution?
A fundamental change in the political order in a short period of time, often originally signifying a restoration of a previous order rather than a complete break.
How did the term 'revolution' originate?
The term was borrowed from astronomy, referring to the movement of celestial bodies and their complete return to a previous position.
What event is considered the first to be called a revolution?
The expulsion of the Stuart dynasty from England in 1688, known as the Glorious Revolution.
How did the French Revolution alter the term's meaning?
Despite seeking a completely new political system, the French Revolution shifted the term's meaning, yet ironically restored absolutist governments multiple times.
Why do movements often adopt the term 'revolution'?
Movements are labeled as revolutions to portray them as inherently positive or progressive, aligning with the desire to appear as the 'good guys.'
How has Karl Marx influenced modern perceptions of revolution?
Karl Marx's writings, emphasizing class struggle and economic inequality, have contributed to viewing revolutions as a natural reaction to capitalism.

Voir plus de résumés vidéo

Accédez instantanément à des résumés vidéo gratuits sur YouTube grâce à l'IA !

Sous-titres

Défilement automatique:

00:00:00
what comes to mind when you hear the
00:00:01
word revolution you might think of this
00:00:03
or this or maybe even this but what
00:00:06
exactly is a revolution it's a word
00:00:09
that's thrown around so much that the
00:00:10
meaning is blurred if you want to make
00:00:12
an event or a movement sound more
00:00:14
important just add revolution to it did
00:00:16
people start growing food differently
00:00:17
agricultural revolution did people start
00:00:20
making stuff differently industrial
00:00:22
revolution did a politician just come to
00:00:23
power just add revolution to the end of
00:00:25
their name but are the things we refer
00:00:27
to as revolutions actually revolutions
00:00:30
and why are we so obsessed with this
00:00:32
idea those are the questions i'm going
00:00:34
to answer first off what is a revolution
00:00:36
when we hear the word revolution we
00:00:38
mostly think about it in a political
00:00:39
context the common definition is a
00:00:42
fundamental change in the political
00:00:43
order in a short period of time this is
00:00:46
a very convenient definition for people
00:00:47
who like to call everything a revolution
00:00:49
but its missing historical context the
00:00:52
word revolution was borrowed from
00:00:53
astronomy in that context revolution
00:00:56
referred to the movement of celestial
00:00:57
bodies in math this path is defined as a
00:01:00
360 degree turn in other words celestial
00:01:03
bodies always return to where they were
00:01:05
before the earliest political usage of
00:01:07
the term revolution described a
00:01:08
restoration of some form or political
00:01:10
order rather than a complete break with
00:01:12
the past and we can see this definition
00:01:14
applied to earlier revolutions the first
00:01:16
event to be commonly referred to as a
00:01:18
revolution was the expulsion of the
00:01:20
steward dynasty from england in 1688
00:01:22
referred to as the glorious revolution
00:01:25
by getting rid of james ii they were
00:01:26
restoring their protestant english
00:01:28
constitution a similar reasoning was
00:01:30
applied by many to the american war of
00:01:32
independence by separating themselves
00:01:34
from great britain the americans would
00:01:36
be restoring their english constitution
00:01:37
in north america the french revolution
00:01:40
however is another beast entirely the
00:01:42
idea of restoring any former political
00:01:44
system was not on anyone's minds despite
00:01:47
the desire for a completely new
00:01:48
political system they still refer to
00:01:50
their movement as a revolution which is
00:01:52
itself a break from the historical use
00:01:54
of the term up to that point ironically
00:01:56
enough just as the french were busy
00:01:58
redefining the term their actual
00:02:00
revolution was following the classical
00:02:01
definition by restoring absolutist
00:02:03
governments several times given this am
00:02:06
i anglophilic sensibilities i think it's
00:02:08
appropriate for us to blame the french
00:02:10
for our modern misuse of the term so if
00:02:12
we apply the classical definition of
00:02:14
revolution to the ones mentioned earlier
00:02:16
the agricultural and industrial
00:02:17
revolutions do not qualify however if
00:02:20
you apply the definition that the french
00:02:21
were simultaneously redefining and
00:02:23
violating then they do but if the word
00:02:25
revolution doesn't accurately apply to
00:02:28
most of the terms it's attached to why
00:02:29
do we use it so often the short answer
00:02:32
is karl marx karl marx is one of the
00:02:34
most influential political philosophers
00:02:36
of the modern age the writings of karl
00:02:38
marx and other socialists look at the
00:02:40
world and everything in it through an
00:02:42
economic lens and interpret all events
00:02:44
in history as conflicts between classes
00:02:46
and that mindset is pervasive to this
00:02:49
day even those who don't subscribe to a
00:02:51
marxist agenda are still thinking in
00:02:52
terms of his vocabulary every politician
00:02:55
goes out of their way to make appeals to
00:02:56
the workers filipino tilt-a-whirl
00:03:00
operators are this nation's backbone
00:03:04
and when they are in office they are
00:03:06
praised or chastised for how their votes
00:03:08
or policies impact the lower classes in
00:03:10
his writings karl marx wrote that the
00:03:12
concentration of wealth under capitalism
00:03:13
would eventually lead to revolution
00:03:15
because of him we see economic
00:03:17
inequality as the greatest sin of the
00:03:19
modern world and so the pervasiveness of
00:03:21
marx's thought in the modern world
00:03:22
combined with our natural inclination to
00:03:24
support the underdog in any conflict
00:03:26
leads to us perceiving revolution as
00:03:28
being inherently good everybody wants to
00:03:30
be the good guys this is why so many
00:03:32
movements are referred to as revolutions
00:03:34
if you're fighting for a revolution then
00:03:36
you must be the good guy and to support
00:03:38
anyone else in said conflict would mean
00:03:40
that you are supporting the bad guys and
00:03:42
therefore are yourself a bad guy if you
00:03:44
want to be on the right side of history
00:03:46
then you must be seen as a revolutionary
00:03:48
because of this every politician
00:03:50
including those on the right portray
00:03:52
their campaigns as a revolution this
00:03:54
line of thought is so pervasive even
00:03:56
adolf hitler referred to himself as a
00:03:58
revolutionary there's one more reason
00:04:00
why we like the idea of revolution the
00:04:02
possibility of rapid change the world is
00:04:05
never as we want it to be and the
00:04:06
changes we want never happen fast enough
00:04:09
the great appeal of revolution is the
00:04:10
speed at which things change think of a
00:04:13
cause you're passionate about now
00:04:14
picture that cause being resolved
00:04:16
overnight just like that you get what
00:04:18
you want without having to raise a
00:04:20
finger making revolution the political
00:04:21
equivalent of a get rich quick scheme so
00:04:24
there you have it a word whose meaning
00:04:25
has changed adopted as a means of change
00:04:28
because we want someone else to change
00:04:32
[Music]
00:04:40
[Music]
00:04:43
you tell me that it's evolution
00:04:47
well you know