00:00:00
g'day space cadets
00:00:02
in this video i want to talk about a
00:00:04
topic which really confused me for a
00:00:06
long time it's something that often gets
00:00:08
dismissed as a counter-intuitive topic
00:00:11
where you just have to trust the maths
00:00:13
i'm talking of course about converging
00:00:15
diverging nozzles and the opposite
00:00:17
behavior of subsonic and supersonic
00:00:19
compressible flows
00:00:21
there are already some really good
00:00:23
videos out there which cover the
00:00:24
mathematical description of what's going
00:00:26
on
00:00:27
i've linked a good video from josh the
00:00:29
engineer in the description which will
00:00:31
help you get an engineering level of
00:00:32
understanding
00:00:34
i don't want to repeat too much of that
00:00:36
content here instead i want to try and
00:00:38
convince you that there's nothing
00:00:39
counter-intuitive about supersonic flow
00:00:42
i'm not saying that it's simple to
00:00:44
understand
00:00:45
but if we take some time to think about
00:00:47
the situation in the right way and focus
00:00:49
on the fundamental physics i think we
00:00:52
can build an intuitive picture
00:00:54
i'm going to start with a couple of
00:00:56
points that may not make total sense to
00:00:58
you right now but keep them in mind as
00:01:00
we build up our understanding of the
00:01:02
problem
00:01:03
fluid flows speed up or slow down
00:01:06
depending on pressure differences
00:01:08
if a fluid flowing in a pipe has lower
00:01:10
pressure downstream than upstream this
00:01:13
pressure difference will cause the fluid
00:01:15
to accelerate
00:01:16
if the downstream pressure is higher the
00:01:19
fluid will decelerate
00:01:21
this is also true at the throat of a
00:01:23
nozzle
00:01:24
when the nozzle is operating in the
00:01:26
supersonic regime there is a pressure
00:01:28
gradient at the throat which speeds up
00:01:30
the flow above mach 1.
00:01:32
when the nozzle is operating in the
00:01:34
subsonic regime there is a pressure
00:01:36
gradient at the throat which slows the
00:01:38
flow back down from mach 1.
00:01:40
understanding these gradients and how
00:01:42
they form is what we will talk about for
00:01:44
most of this video
00:01:46
secondly the fluid pressure at the
00:01:48
nozzle exit must match the environment
00:01:51
pressure
00:01:52
this is a fundamental truth like
00:01:54
conservation of mass and conservation of
00:01:56
energy
00:01:57
the pressure in the nozzle can be lower
00:01:59
or higher than the atmospheric pressure
00:02:01
at the exit but then there will be shock
00:02:03
waves or expansion fans to enforce
00:02:06
pressure or quality
00:02:08
here we have a typical venturi with a
00:02:11
gas flowing through it the flow comes in
00:02:13
from the left and moves to the right
00:02:15
as the cross-section area gets smaller
00:02:18
the fluid must move faster to conserve
00:02:20
energy and momentum in the system
00:02:22
i'm guessing most of you will be
00:02:24
familiar with bernoulli's principle for
00:02:26
incompressible flows where the total
00:02:28
energy of the fluid must be conserved
00:02:30
this means that as the flow speeds up
00:02:33
its pressure drops and vice versa the
00:02:36
same general idea applies here but when
00:02:38
we talk about compressible flows instead
00:02:41
of total energy we use properties called
00:02:43
the total pressure and total temperature
00:02:46
these values are the pressure and
00:02:47
temperature the flow would have if we
00:02:49
slowed it to a speed of zero with no
00:02:52
losses
00:02:53
if we plot the total pressure through
00:02:55
the venturi we can see that it is
00:02:57
constant everywhere as we have perfect
00:02:59
subsonic flow with no friction and no
00:03:01
other losses
00:03:03
if we also plot the static pressure
00:03:06
which is what we would measure with a
00:03:07
pressure sensor
00:03:08
we can see that it is close to the total
00:03:10
pressure everywhere
00:03:12
this is telling us that the fluid is
00:03:14
moving slowly and that we can quite
00:03:16
accurately treat this flow as
00:03:18
incompressible
00:03:20
for this video
00:03:21
we're not concerned with the total
00:03:23
temperature so we'll just skip straight
00:03:24
to the mach number
00:03:26
the mach number is the ratio of the
00:03:28
fluid speed at a particular location to
00:03:31
its speed of sound at that same location
00:03:34
let's plot the mach number now
00:03:36
as we expected from the pressure plot we
00:03:39
can see that the mach number is close to
00:03:40
zero everywhere and gets just a little
00:03:42
bit higher at the throat
00:03:44
below mach numbers of about 0.3 we can
00:03:48
treat fluids as incompressible without
00:03:50
sacrificing much accuracy
00:03:52
we can't really see anything interesting
00:03:54
with this slow flow so let's speed it up
00:03:58
as we increase the speed we see changes
00:04:00
in both the mach number curve and the
00:04:02
static pressure curve
00:04:03
the static pressure drops a little bit
00:04:05
everywhere as the increased velocity
00:04:07
converts energy which had previously
00:04:09
been stored as pressure into kinetic
00:04:11
energy
00:04:12
the pressure drop is particularly
00:04:14
noticeable at the throat as this is the
00:04:16
point of highest velocity
00:04:20
eventually we reach mach 1 at the throat
00:04:24
now let's pause and recall the points we
00:04:26
introduced earlier the fluid speeds up
00:04:29
or slows down due to pressure gradients
00:04:32
if we consider two points in the
00:04:34
converging section of the nozzle we can
00:04:36
see that the pressure is higher at point
00:04:38
one than it is at point two
00:04:40
now remember that pressure is really
00:04:42
just molecules whizzing around and
00:04:44
colliding with each other the speed of
00:04:46
the particles and also the speed of
00:04:48
sound in the gas are determined
00:04:50
primarily by the gas temperature
00:04:53
a higher pressure means more particles
00:04:55
in a given volume and therefore more
00:04:57
collisions
00:04:59
the slice of gas between points one and
00:05:01
two will be experiencing more collisions
00:05:04
on the left hand side than on the right
00:05:06
hand side
00:05:07
these extra collisions from the left
00:05:09
hand side create a force which
00:05:10
accelerate the slice of gas to the right
00:05:14
now if we look at the downstream side we
00:05:17
can see the reverse effect happening
00:05:19
the pressure at point 4 is higher than
00:05:22
at 0.3 creating a net force which is
00:05:24
slowing down the slice of gas
00:05:27
this pressure gradient is why subsonic
00:05:30
nozzles are subsonic
00:05:32
you might be thinking wait
00:05:34
we have sonic flow in the throat and an
00:05:36
expanding nozzle doesn't that mean the
00:05:38
flow should be supersonic
00:05:40
let's recall point two
00:05:43
the nozzle exit pressure must match the
00:05:45
atmospheric pressure
00:05:47
the short story here is that the exit
00:05:49
pressure is too high to achieve
00:05:51
supersonic flow
00:05:53
in other words with a high atmospheric
00:05:55
pressure we don't have a large enough
00:05:57
pressure difference to achieve
00:05:59
supersonic flow
00:06:00
we've primarily used an area contraction
00:06:03
to achieve sonic flow
00:06:05
but we also reduce the atmospheric
00:06:08
pressure slightly to encourage higher
00:06:10
flow velocities in the subsonic regions
00:06:13
using our knowledge of pressure and
00:06:15
pressure gradients
00:06:16
we know that if we lowered the
00:06:18
environment pressure even further we
00:06:20
would expect to see higher velocities
00:06:23
let's do that now
00:06:25
we're going to see some interesting
00:06:26
stuff in this animation so i'll just
00:06:28
shut up and let you watch and we'll chat
00:06:30
about what we saw later
00:07:17
as we reduce the atmospheric pressure
00:07:19
further the exit gas velocity increased
00:07:21
to compensate for the reduced static
00:07:23
pressure
00:07:24
this pressure reduction propagated up
00:07:26
the subsonic flow region until the
00:07:28
choked flow of the throat
00:07:30
we know that in sonic and supersonic
00:07:32
flows pressure information can't travel
00:07:34
upstream
00:07:36
the effect of a downstream pressure
00:07:38
reduction when the throat is already
00:07:39
choked is to remove the particle
00:07:42
collisions from the right hand side
00:07:44
no particle collisions means no
00:07:46
communication method
00:07:48
the mach 1 flow essentially fills a
00:07:50
vacuum to its right
00:07:52
however
00:07:53
the gas particles can still easily
00:07:55
interact with those particles above and
00:07:57
below them as they're all traveling at
00:07:59
roughly the same speed
00:08:01
we can exploit these vertical particle
00:08:03
interactions in order to tell the flow
00:08:05
what to do
00:08:06
instead of communicating via pressure
00:08:08
gradients and particle collisions we
00:08:11
instead communicate with the flow via
00:08:13
the nozzle shape
00:08:14
as the supersonic flow moves down the
00:08:17
nozzle the area gets larger and the
00:08:19
particles communicate this to each other
00:08:21
vertically
00:08:22
due to conservation of mass the
00:08:24
particles expand to fill the larger
00:08:26
cross-section and the pressure drops
00:08:29
from conservation of momentum a
00:08:31
reduction in pressure means an increase
00:08:33
in velocity
00:08:34
the flow will keep accelerating as we
00:08:36
keep increasing the area
00:08:39
the flow can communicate vertically at
00:08:40
roughly the speed of sound but it's
00:08:43
traveling through the nozzle at multiple
00:08:44
times the speed of sound so this
00:08:46
vertical communication is really
00:08:48
diagonal
00:08:50
this idea is the basis of the method of
00:08:52
characteristics which we may discuss in
00:08:54
a later video
00:08:56
this image here was produced via the
00:08:57
method of characteristics and
00:08:59
illustrates these diagonal communication
00:09:02
lines in a typical rocket nozzle
00:09:04
let's briefly return to the subsonic
00:09:07
supersonic transition animation
00:09:09
initially a small region of supersonic
00:09:12
flow develops but then something strange
00:09:14
happens there's a large increase in
00:09:16
pressure and a large drop in mach number
00:09:18
and this happens almost instantaneously
00:09:21
at a certain point in the nozzle
00:09:23
as the pressure gets lower this point
00:09:25
gets closer towards the end of the
00:09:27
nozzle
00:09:28
this strange effect is a normal shock
00:09:31
neither the supersonic or the subsonic
00:09:34
expansion alone can match the nozzle
00:09:36
exit pressure with the atmospheric
00:09:37
pressure and so a small amount of both
00:09:40
is needed
00:09:41
a normal shock is nature's way of
00:09:43
transitioning between the two flow
00:09:45
regimes
00:09:47
let's detour for a minute and have a
00:09:48
quick chat about normal shocks
00:09:51
i think everyone watching this video is
00:09:53
probably already familiar with the idea
00:09:55
of shock waves forming around a
00:09:56
supersonic aircraft
00:09:58
the airplane is moving faster than the
00:10:00
speed of sound so the air can't get out
00:10:03
of the way and piles up creating a shock
00:10:06
wave and a region of high pressure
00:10:08
behind the shock wave
00:10:10
we're interested in the part of the
00:10:11
shock wave that forms at the very tip of
00:10:14
an aircraft's nose or wing leading edge
00:10:17
here the shock wave is perpendicular to
00:10:19
the direction of motion of the aircraft
00:10:21
this kind of shock wave can also occur
00:10:23
in tubes and nozzles as we saw before
00:10:26
the flow behind a normal shock wave is
00:10:28
always subsonic
00:10:30
the faster the plane goes the more air
00:10:33
piles up and the higher the pressure
00:10:35
behind the shock becomes
00:10:37
a higher mach number means a bigger
00:10:39
pressure difference
00:10:41
this is easy to understand from the
00:10:42
point of view of the aircraft where the
00:10:44
shock wave appears stationary
00:10:46
but
00:10:47
consider what this situation would look
00:10:49
like to someone standing on the ground
00:10:51
to them the airplane and its shock wave
00:10:54
are moving
00:10:55
to the observer a higher pressure
00:10:57
difference across the shock means a
00:10:59
louder boom and a shock that travels
00:11:02
past them faster
00:11:04
higher pressure differences create
00:11:06
shocks that travel faster
00:11:08
this is an important point for our
00:11:10
nozzle example
00:11:12
one final note on shocks they are an
00:11:14
inefficient compression process and we
00:11:16
lose a lot of energy across a normal
00:11:18
shock if you were paying close attention
00:11:21
to our transition example before you
00:11:23
would have noticed that the total
00:11:24
pressure in the nozzle dropped sharply
00:11:27
when there was a normal shock present
00:11:29
and the higher the mach number the
00:11:31
greater this total pressure loss
00:11:36
in this intermediate expansion situation
00:11:38
we only have a small region of
00:11:40
supersonic flow if we continued the
00:11:43
supersonic expansion all the way to the
00:11:45
nozzle end we would have about a mach 4
00:11:47
flow
00:11:48
but the nozzle pressure would be much
00:11:51
lower than the atmospheric pressure
00:11:52
which is still quite high
00:11:54
in fact this large pressure difference
00:11:57
would correspond to something like a
00:11:59
mach 6 shock
00:12:00
a mach 6 shock in a mach 4 flow would
00:12:03
travel up the nozzle at about mach 2.
00:12:07
while pressure information can't
00:12:08
transmit upper supersonic flow via
00:12:11
traditional particle collisions
00:12:13
normal shocks can propagate up
00:12:15
supersonic flows
00:12:17
this mach 6 shock would move up the
00:12:19
nozzle and the pressure immediately
00:12:21
before the shock would increase as the
00:12:24
amount of supersonic expansion prior to
00:12:26
the shock has decreased
00:12:28
the pressure difference across the shock
00:12:30
is now smaller
00:12:31
making it a weaker shock which would
00:12:34
travel slower
00:12:36
as it continued propagating up the
00:12:38
nozzle
00:12:38
it would travel slower and slower until
00:12:41
it reached an equilibrium point where it
00:12:43
stops moving
00:12:45
at this equilibrium point the supersonic
00:12:48
pressure drop
00:12:50
shock pressure increase
00:12:52
and subsonic pressure increase combined
00:12:55
would match the nozzle end pressure with
00:12:57
the atmospheric pressure
00:12:59
it's important to note that the shock
00:13:01
doesn't affect the flow properties in
00:13:03
the supersonic flow region
00:13:05
only the shape of the nozzle can do this
00:13:08
the shock position simply determines
00:13:10
where the supersonic flow region ends
00:13:14
as the exit pressure is reduced
00:13:17
this lower pressure information can
00:13:19
propagate up the subsonic flow section
00:13:21
until it reaches the shock
00:13:24
with a lower downstream pressure the
00:13:26
pressure differential across the shock
00:13:28
has been decreased
00:13:29
making it a weaker and slower shock and
00:13:32
so it will move down the nozzle until it
00:13:34
finds a new equilibrium point
00:13:37
eventually the shock will reach the
00:13:39
nozzle exit
00:13:40
if we reduce the pressure further the
00:13:42
pressure difference becomes too small
00:13:44
for a normal shock to exist and we will
00:13:46
transition into two-dimensional oblique
00:13:48
shocks and fancy shock structures like
00:13:50
muck diamonds
00:13:52
i haven't animated these here for
00:13:54
simplicity but the end result is that
00:13:56
the flow doesn't slow down as much as it
00:13:58
would have for a normal shock
00:14:01
eventually we reach a perfectly expanded
00:14:03
nozzle with no shocks anywhere
00:14:07
finally i want to address one last
00:14:10
confusing point
00:14:11
why can't we increase the mach number
00:14:13
above 1 by contracting the throat area
00:14:16
further
00:14:17
we'll work through a couple of examples
00:14:19
to understand this
00:14:20
first let's consider a choked converging
00:14:23
nozzle
00:14:24
if we suddenly removed part of the
00:14:26
converging section
00:14:27
we would create a large pressure
00:14:29
difference between the subsonic flow at
00:14:31
the new throat location and the
00:14:33
atmospheric pressure
00:14:34
this pressure difference would quickly
00:14:36
accelerate throat flow
00:14:39
as the throat flow is initially subsonic
00:14:41
this low pressure would propagate back
00:14:43
up the flow as a low pressure pulse and
00:14:46
increase the flow speed everywhere
00:14:49
if the total pressure is high enough we
00:14:51
will still achieve choke flow at the
00:14:53
throat but now with a larger area and
00:14:55
higher mass flow
00:14:56
rate now let's consider what would
00:14:59
happen if instead of increasing the
00:15:01
throat diameter we decreased it
00:15:03
the accelerated flow would be supersonic
00:15:06
and have reduced pressure at the exit
00:15:08
the environment pressure would need to
00:15:10
be modified to prevent shocks from
00:15:12
forming at the exit
00:15:13
however the real problem here is that we
00:15:16
can't have converging supersonic flows
00:15:18
without shocks forming
00:15:20
whenever supersonic flow streamlines are
00:15:23
turned into themselves a shock will
00:15:25
occur
00:15:26
and these shocks are known as oblique
00:15:28
shocks
00:15:30
remember that in supersonic flows the
00:15:32
particles can't communicate back up the
00:15:34
stream and warn the incoming particles
00:15:36
that they will need to change direction
00:15:38
soon
00:15:39
instead the particles continue straight
00:15:41
until they collide with the deflected
00:15:43
downstream flow
00:15:45
the particles pile up this time creating
00:15:47
an oblique shock
00:15:49
oblique shocks are weaker than normal
00:15:51
shocks as the flow is simply being
00:15:53
deflected a little bit rather than
00:15:55
almost completely stopped
00:15:57
a supersonic contraction and the
00:15:59
resulting oblique shock waves are
00:16:01
exploited in supersonic wind tunnel
00:16:03
diffusers to gradually slow a supersonic
00:16:05
flow and increase its pressure back to
00:16:08
ambient without needing a strong normal
00:16:10
shock
00:16:11
we can clearly see in our image that the
00:16:13
streamlines are converging
00:16:15
if these flows were supersonic this
00:16:18
convergence would cause shock waves to
00:16:20
form
00:16:20
however our flow is only sonic and so an
00:16:24
infinitely weak shock wave would exist
00:16:26
temporarily
00:16:28
in reality it would not get to the point
00:16:30
where supersonic flow and shocks existed
00:16:33
as a high pressure pulse would propagate
00:16:35
up the nozzle to slow the flow
00:16:38
we would achieve choke flow again at the
00:16:40
throat but with a reduced mass flow due
00:16:42
to the smaller area
00:16:45
i would like to conclude this video by
00:16:47
reiterating a few key points
00:16:50
subsonic nozzles have a pressure
00:16:52
gradient of the throat which decelerates
00:16:54
the flow
00:16:55
while supersonic nozzles have a pressure
00:16:57
gradient at the throat which accelerates
00:16:59
the flow
00:17:01
a high total pressure and an area
00:17:03
contraction are required to generate
00:17:05
sonic mach 1 flow at the throat
00:17:09
we can't accelerate flows above mach 1
00:17:12
with an area contraction alone
00:17:14
a low atmospheric pressure and an area
00:17:17
expansion after the throat are required
00:17:19
to generate supersonic flow
00:17:22
we can communicate down a supersonic
00:17:24
flow with particle interactions but not
00:17:27
up the flow
00:17:29
instead we can communicate the desired
00:17:31
behavior of a supersonic flow
00:17:33
via the nozzle geometry
00:17:36
normal shocks can travel up a supersonic
00:17:38
flow but they can't influence the
00:17:41
properties in a supersonic flow region a
00:17:44
normal shock can only terminate a
00:17:46
supersonic flow region
00:17:48
the subsonic nozzle can be thought of as
00:17:51
a special case of supersonic flow where
00:17:53
the normal shock has progressed all the
00:17:55
way to the throat and then disappeared
00:17:57
leaving subsonic flow everywhere
00:18:01
that's all for this video please leave
00:18:03
any comments or questions you have in
00:18:04
the comments section and like and
00:18:06
subscribe if you enjoyed this video