00:00:04
in 1963 detectives investigated the
00:00:08
murder of a woman in California but it
00:00:11
would take technology almost 30 years to
00:00:14
catch up with the killer
00:00:16
[Music]
00:00:20
a trash bag is the only clue detectives
00:00:23
have to the identity of a serial killer
00:00:26
so far their search has met only with
00:00:28
failure but a new fingerprint technology
00:00:32
will give them one last chance to put
00:00:34
the killer away in a murder
00:00:38
investigation in Vermont police have
00:00:40
their suspect now all they need is solid
00:00:43
evidence to convict him the case hinges
00:00:46
on a bloody but distorted palm print on
00:00:49
the murder weapon in cases that look all
00:00:54
but hopeless science finds a solution in
00:00:58
the telltale marks of the killer's death
00:01:01
grip
00:01:02
[Music]
00:01:26
in 1985 a serial killer was on the loose
00:01:31
in San Diego California
00:01:33
the killer targeted prostitutes and
00:01:36
other women he'd rape and murder them
00:01:38
then discard their bodies in trash
00:01:40
dumpsters to catch him police needed to
00:01:44
identify his fingerprints which proved
00:01:47
to be elusive on the morning of May 9th
00:01:55
1986 police responded to a call from a
00:01:58
woman who came upon a ghastly sight as
00:02:01
she was taking out her garbage the
00:02:03
killers latest victim when they arrived
00:02:07
they saw a sight that had become all too
00:02:10
familiar a body in a dumpster
00:02:13
this time the murderer had wrapped it in
00:02:16
two garbage bags joined with masking
00:02:18
tape after disposing of the body in the
00:02:21
dumpster he covered it with a blanket
00:02:23
police questioned neighbors to find out
00:02:26
if they'd seen anyone suspicious no one
00:02:29
had seen anything out of the ordinary
00:02:32
homicide detectives came to the scene to
00:02:35
investigate
00:02:37
an emergency unit arrived to retrieve
00:02:41
the body
00:02:50
the victim was identified as Joanne
00:02:53
sweets a prostitute she had been raped
00:02:56
and strangled to death and several of
00:02:58
her ribs were broken
00:02:59
that was the serial killers calling card
00:03:03
[Music]
00:03:06
would the killer elude police again it
00:03:10
was going to be a tough case to crack
00:03:12
since most of the victims were
00:03:14
prostitutes the murders weren't always
00:03:16
reported or the few eyewitnesses were
00:03:19
unreliable
00:03:25
but this time the detectives were able
00:03:27
to lift the fingerprint from the
00:03:29
dumpster
00:03:35
detective Dan Hatfield was part of a
00:03:38
task force formed to stop the horrid
00:03:40
wave of killings before it went any
00:03:42
further
00:03:43
primarily the whole focus of the the
00:03:46
task force was to look into women
00:03:49
primarily prostitutes that had been
00:03:53
found murdered here in the city of San
00:03:54
Diego and also in the county there is
00:03:56
approximately 35 to 40 unsolved cases
00:04:01
the Joanne sweets case was the latest
00:04:04
with any luck it would be the last
00:04:08
detectives believe the killer lived or
00:04:10
worked in the neighborhood two other
00:04:13
prostitutes bodies had also been
00:04:15
discovered in dumpsters nearby we had
00:04:20
Tara Simpson that was found in the and
00:04:24
another dumpster that's adjacent to to
00:04:26
the Joanne sweets case the dumpster was
00:04:29
located the T of the the alley the early
00:04:34
morning hours police were called here
00:04:37
they found the garbage container fully
00:04:39
engulfed fire department finds that
00:04:42
there's a female in there and she is
00:04:44
badly burned a lot of the evidence was
00:04:46
lost because of the the fact that she
00:04:48
was badly burned several months after
00:04:50
Tara Simpson's body was found here we go
00:04:54
up several blocks up the same alleyway
00:04:57
at another dumpster was found the body
00:05:00
of Trina carpenter
00:05:02
Trina carpenter had also been manually
00:05:05
strangled she was wrapped in a green
00:05:08
duffel bag at that time Hatfield was
00:05:12
sure the same man was behind the deaths
00:05:15
of all the women but the investigation
00:05:18
turned up no suspects a manual search of
00:05:22
fingerprints in police files failed to
00:05:24
match the print found on the dumpster
00:05:26
where sweets body was found whoever left
00:05:30
the print didn't have a criminal record
00:05:32
the case went unsolved
00:05:37
three years later fingerprint expert
00:05:40
Diane Donnelly joined the task force to
00:05:43
work on the jo-ann sweets case I was
00:05:46
brought in on this case in 1989 at the
00:05:49
request of homicide and this is one of
00:05:52
the cases that they had asked to go back
00:05:54
and re-examine some of the evidence to
00:05:57
see if there was anything else we could
00:05:58
do at this point she learned that
00:06:01
fingerprint experts had already tried
00:06:03
using a chemical called gentian violet
00:06:05
to lift prints from the masking tape
00:06:07
that held the garbage bags around the
00:06:09
body the process can expose fingerprints
00:06:14
left on sticky surfaces when a finger
00:06:18
touches the adhesive side of tape and is
00:06:20
removed skin cells remain behind the
00:06:25
gentian violet stains those cells
00:06:27
revealing the print experts repeated the
00:06:32
process over and over but couldn't raise
00:06:35
a single print
00:06:43
then shortly after Donnelly joined the
00:06:46
task force
00:06:47
she and San Diego detectives received a
00:06:50
break they decided to make another
00:06:52
attempt to identify the print from the
00:06:55
dumpster using a new computerized
00:06:57
fingerprint matching system several
00:07:01
suspects were considered and dismissed
00:07:03
before a match was made the prints
00:07:07
belonged to a man named Brian Maurice
00:07:09
Jones at the time of the San Diego
00:07:12
murders he'd never been arrested since
00:07:16
then Jones had been convicted for rape
00:07:18
robbery and kidnapping a prostitute he
00:07:22
became the prime suspect in the murder
00:07:24
of Joanne sweets but detectives knew the
00:07:31
print from the dumpster wasn't enough to
00:07:33
make a case
00:07:34
Jones would have an alibi his mother
00:07:38
lived in a building adjacent to the
00:07:40
alley where sweets body had been found
00:07:42
and of course you could logically assume
00:07:46
that his defense would be that he had
00:07:47
taken out his mother's trash so we
00:07:50
needed something more concrete that
00:07:51
proverbial nail in the coffin to link
00:07:56
him to this murder and maybe some of the
00:07:58
other murders of the of the women in San
00:08:00
Diego even without a print Dan Hatfield
00:08:04
had a strong hunch that Jones had
00:08:07
murdered Joanne sweets and the others
00:08:09
according to Hatfield scenario Jones
00:08:13
most likely cruised the boulevard
00:08:14
looking for victims
00:08:16
he'd pick a prostitute and take her to
00:08:19
his mother's apartment while she was at
00:08:21
work
00:08:23
he'd act like a typical client but the
00:08:26
evening would culminate in murder
00:08:28
[Music]
00:08:43
afterward he'd wrapped the body up and
00:08:46
take it up to the dumpster like he was
00:08:48
taking out the trash
00:08:50
Jones was still in prison for lesser
00:08:53
crimes but he'd be eligible for parole
00:08:56
in ten years if Hatfield could link him
00:08:59
to the jo-ann sweets murder he'd makes
00:09:02
sure Jones would never get out
00:09:04
I believe when mr. Jones dumped Joanna
00:09:10
sweets body in the dumpster he probably
00:09:13
felt he could get away with it since he
00:09:15
got away with the other two murders in
00:09:19
their effort to prove Jones's guilt the
00:09:22
detectives would pin their hopes on the
00:09:24
latest method of fingerprint technology
00:09:32
stalled for three years the murder
00:09:35
investigation of Joanne sweets got a
00:09:37
jump start in 1992 detectives once again
00:09:42
focused on the garbage bags the killer
00:09:44
used to rap his victim six years earlier
00:09:48
no prints were found on the bags but Dan
00:09:52
Hatfield and Diane Donnelly were sure
00:09:55
the prints were there at the time that I
00:09:59
was investigating these cases it was my
00:10:02
feeling that there were in fact latent
00:10:04
prints on the garbage bags we were just
00:10:06
not using the right technique I checked
00:10:09
around I talked with the FBI what they
00:10:13
told me is that there was a technique
00:10:15
that was being used in England and also
00:10:17
in Canada with the Royal Canadian
00:10:19
Mounted Police a technique called vacuum
00:10:22
metal deposition at which point I called
00:10:25
Canada I found out that they were in
00:10:27
fact using this technique to lift latent
00:10:30
prints from plastics and that they were
00:10:34
more than happy to do our case Donnelly
00:10:38
took the evidence to the laboratories of
00:10:40
the Royal Canadian Mounted Police in
00:10:42
Ottawa
00:10:43
she was hopeful but the prints were six
00:10:46
years old
00:10:47
would they have degraded too much for
00:10:50
the process to work they were more than
00:10:53
willing and happy to assist me in this
00:10:55
matter but they were not too optimistic
00:10:57
about obtaining any identifiable
00:11:00
imprints the process known as vacuum
00:11:05
metal deposition was developed in the US
00:11:07
but most jurisdictions don't have the
00:11:10
money to utilize it it's used more
00:11:13
widely in Europe and Canada its main
00:11:16
application is on plastics but for
00:11:21
fingerprint expert pat alert Ernests of
00:11:23
the Royal Canadian Mounted Police it's a
00:11:25
versatile process that works when all
00:11:27
other techniques have failed it's
00:11:31
possible to get fingerprints on things
00:11:33
like magazine paper paper towel
00:11:37
tissue very fine exhibits it has a
00:11:42
limited application in some of those
00:11:43
things but really when there's no other
00:11:45
way to do it and it works if we take the
00:11:51
best exhibit the solid plastic type of
00:11:54
exhibits it's a matter of keeping that
00:11:55
clean and then placing it inside the
00:11:58
work holders of the chamber handling the
00:12:01
evidence carefully litter displaces it
00:12:04
in the chamber a few milligrams of gold
00:12:08
are deposited on a heating element once
00:12:18
the chamber is sealed pumps create a
00:12:20
vacuum
00:12:22
once it's within a vacuum the gold
00:12:24
source is heated and that heat is
00:12:27
melting the metal the metal would almost
00:12:30
liquefy boil and then you can compare it
00:12:33
to steam where we go straight up and
00:12:35
condense on the surface that it hits a
00:12:39
thin invisible layer coats the plastic
00:12:42
surface of the garbage bag if the bag
00:12:45
contains no fingerprints the layer of
00:12:47
gold will be uniform
00:12:49
but if fingerprints are present the gold
00:12:52
will sink into them leaving the oily
00:12:55
ridges of the print uncoated
00:12:58
[Music]
00:13:04
the process is then repeated with a few
00:13:06
milligrams of zinc like the gold the
00:13:13
zinc vaporizes within the evidence
00:13:15
chamber it will rican dents only on two
00:13:18
other metals so it will only cling to
00:13:21
the previous layer of gold but the zinc
00:13:26
won't stick on the oily residue of the
00:13:28
fingerprint where there's no gold the
00:13:31
result is a high contrast fingerprint
00:13:35
[Music]
00:13:41
the bags were removed from the chamber
00:13:44
and inspected this moment would make or
00:13:48
break the case against Jones after six
00:13:52
years in hiding the prints on the bags
00:13:54
finally became visible and with them a
00:13:58
dead end case cleared a major roadblock
00:14:03
we knew this exhibit was six years old
00:14:05
we knew was involved in a homicide which
00:14:08
made it a high-profile case and it was
00:14:11
quite exciting to see the latent when we
00:14:13
pulled it out a chamber the latent
00:14:16
prints found on the garbage bags matched
00:14:18
the prints of Brian Maurice Jones the
00:14:22
vacuum metal deposition process enabled
00:14:25
Hatfield and Donnelly to connect him to
00:14:27
the murder the nail in the casket were
00:14:30
in fact the latent prints that were
00:14:33
taken from the garbage bags and that
00:14:36
came back matching Brian Jones without a
00:14:38
doubt there was no way for him to
00:14:41
disprove the fact that these were
00:14:43
somebody else's prints that was a nail
00:14:46
in the coffin as far as I'm concerned in
00:14:50
1996
00:14:51
the state of California tried Brian
00:14:54
Maurice Jones for the murder of Joanne
00:14:56
sweets and several related crimes he was
00:14:59
convicted and sentenced to death
00:15:02
advances in the science of fingerprint
00:15:05
detection had solved a case that seemed
00:15:07
all but hopeless I feel very good about
00:15:12
it the fact that even though these
00:15:15
victims were prostitutes they were
00:15:17
people also and I think with his
00:15:21
conviction I believe that they had their
00:15:23
day in court and justice was served
00:15:28
the vacuum deposition process raised
00:15:31
Brian Jones's fingerprints and secured
00:15:33
his conviction but it was a computer
00:15:36
that first singled him out in another
00:15:41
California case detectives used computer
00:15:44
technology to pursue a killer across
00:15:46
three decades on October 2nd 1963 thora
00:15:58
Rose was spending a quiet evening alone
00:16:00
in her apartment in Hollywood California
00:16:04
she had rented the apartment just a
00:16:06
month earlier after separating from her
00:16:08
husband and was slowly adjusting to life
00:16:11
on her own Rose worked as a waitress and
00:16:16
kept mainly to herself in her free time
00:16:21
the ground-floor apartment
00:16:23
was considered to be in a safe
00:16:25
neighborhood even for a woman who lived
00:16:27
alone
00:16:29
[Music]
00:16:32
but that night someone invaded that
00:16:35
safety and Thor arose became his target
00:16:43
he waited in the darkness as she settled
00:16:46
in for the evening
00:16:52
when her lights went out he made his
00:16:55
move
00:16:56
[Music]
00:17:02
as rows drifted off to sleep he pried
00:17:06
open a window over the kitchen sink and
00:17:09
crawled into her apartment
00:17:20
[Music]
00:17:28
once inside he slipped through the
00:17:31
kitchen and crept toward the bedroom
00:17:40
when he got there he attacked
00:17:45
after a violent struggle Thor arose age
00:17:49
43 was dead when Rose failed to come to
00:17:56
work the next day her employer
00:17:58
telephoned her but got no response
00:18:01
concerned he called the police when they
00:18:05
arrived they found thora roses body in
00:18:08
the bedroom
00:18:10
[Music]
00:18:20
police questioned neighbors but no one
00:18:23
had seen anyone enter or leave Rosa's
00:18:26
apartment nobody heard a thing
00:18:35
it was one of the worst crimes the quiet
00:18:38
Hollywood neighborhood had ever
00:18:40
experienced almost 35 years later Los
00:18:46
Angeles Police Detective Mike McDonough
00:18:48
visits the scene of the crime Hollywood
00:18:52
back then was a completely different
00:18:55
place that is this today I mean when you
00:18:57
think Hollywood back in 63 it was still
00:18:59
in the movie industry still a lot of
00:19:02
single-family residences here a couple
00:19:05
of apartment buildings completely
00:19:07
different world the crime rate was
00:19:12
practically nothing to compare what it
00:19:13
is to today Hollywood now we're
00:19:16
averaging anywhere from 50 to 60
00:19:18
homicides a year back in 1963 they had
00:19:21
for the murder caused a major stir the
00:19:27
Homicide Division of the Los Angeles
00:19:29
Police Department gave the case top
00:19:31
priority at first just two detectives
00:19:36
were assigned to the case but the number
00:19:38
quickly rose to 6 eventually 32
00:19:42
uniformed officers and two sergeants
00:19:45
joined the investigation they canvassed
00:19:48
the neighborhood for a suspect inside
00:19:51
the apartment
00:19:52
experts dusted for fingerprints there
00:19:56
was farmed palm prints and finger prints
00:19:58
inside the kitchen and throughout the
00:19:59
house there's a property 27 fingerprints
00:20:03
that were lifted inside the residence
00:20:04
leading from the front window here into
00:20:06
the bedroom
00:20:09
the police officers working the
00:20:11
neighborhood found nothing it was up to
00:20:14
the fingerprint experts alone to solve
00:20:16
the case with the long trail of
00:20:19
fingerprints left behind the detectives
00:20:22
were certain they would catch the
00:20:23
murderer their confidence was
00:20:26
well-founded for more than 100 years
00:20:29
fingerprinting has proven to be one of
00:20:32
the most effective ways to pin criminals
00:20:34
to crimes the science goes back to 1880
00:20:38
when Scottish physician Henry Falls
00:20:41
suggested that ridge patterns on the
00:20:43
fingers and hands
00:20:44
could be useful in identifying criminals
00:20:47
in 1901
00:20:49
Scotland Yard adopted the idea and the
00:20:52
rest of the world soon followed
00:20:56
fingerprinting works for two reasons
00:20:58
first no two people share print patterns
00:21:02
and second a person's fingerprints
00:21:05
remain unchanged throughout life the
00:21:10
skin of human fingers and hands have
00:21:13
raised patterns called friction ridges
00:21:15
which help us grip objects more firmly
00:21:19
they're constantly coated with a film of
00:21:22
perspiration from tiny pores the curves
00:21:26
loops and other characteristics of the
00:21:28
ridges can occur in billions of
00:21:30
combinations at a crime scene the
00:21:34
perpetrator may leave noticeable prints
00:21:37
if he touched blood grease or another
00:21:39
dark substance if he touched something
00:21:42
soft like putty the fingerprints may be
00:21:45
impressed on its surface but the
00:21:49
majority of fingerprints are invisible
00:21:51
known as latent fingerprints they're
00:21:55
made of about 98% perspiration and 2%
00:21:59
body oil we leave them on virtually
00:22:02
everything we touch like film in a
00:22:06
camera they must be developed to be seen
00:22:10
the fingerprint experts at Los Angeles
00:22:13
Police Department's fingerprint lab have
00:22:15
long relied on powders to make latent
00:22:18
prints visible it's been one of the most
00:22:21
common and effective methods since
00:22:23
fingerprinting began when lightly
00:22:27
applied with a camel hairbrush
00:22:29
powder adheres to the moisture in the
00:22:31
fingerprint providing a finely detailed
00:22:34
image the detective then lifts the print
00:22:38
using a strip of clear tape and places
00:22:41
it on a card with his initials the time
00:22:43
date and location of the print this
00:22:47
detailed information is vital if the
00:22:49
print will be used as evidence in court
00:22:53
after the fingerprint experts working on
00:22:56
the thorah Rose case lifted
00:22:58
finger and palm prints from her
00:23:00
Hollywood apartment they had to prove
00:23:02
they belong to the perpetrator there's
00:23:06
always a possibility they could belong
00:23:08
to someone else
00:23:11
detectives obtained what are called
00:23:13
elimination prints from everyone who had
00:23:16
contact with Thoreau Rose they were able
00:23:19
to contact those people the restaurants
00:23:22
places she worked they fingerprinted
00:23:24
Evelyn it was there they also went as
00:23:26
far as local delivery boys as far as
00:23:29
serving delivering chicken mail people
00:23:32
newspaper people anyone that had any
00:23:35
contact with this place they checked out
00:23:38
after all other persons were eliminated
00:23:41
detectives drew the only possible
00:23:43
conclusion the prints belonged to the
00:23:46
killer now they could be sent to the lab
00:23:49
to be compared by fingerprint examiner's
00:23:52
to prints of criminals in their files
00:23:55
whenever police make an arrest for even
00:23:58
the smallest infraction they require the
00:24:01
arrested person to be fingerprinted the
00:24:04
prints are kept on file and in some
00:24:06
cases sent to other police jurisdictions
00:24:09
if the suspect is ever involved in
00:24:12
another crime his prints will be
00:24:14
available for comparison the traditional
00:24:18
way of recording fingerprints is the ink
00:24:20
and roll method each finger is rolled on
00:24:24
an ink pad then impressed on a card with
00:24:27
the arrested person's name and personal
00:24:29
data the document is then added to the
00:24:32
fingerprint files recently some
00:24:36
jurisdictions have begun scanning
00:24:38
fingerprints into a computer the scanner
00:24:41
creates a digital image of the prints so
00:24:44
they can be added to the database a beam
00:24:47
of light replaces the ink pad either way
00:24:52
the matching process begins when the
00:24:54
examiner compares prints from the crime
00:24:56
scene with prints from police files
00:25:02
comparing fingerprints is much the same
00:25:05
today as in 1963 the examiner must look
00:25:10
for matching points of identification
00:25:12
the friction ridges arrange themselves
00:25:15
into arches loops and whorls sometimes
00:25:19
they end abruptly sometimes they split
00:25:22
in two the examiner considers all these
00:25:26
patterns when making an identification
00:25:29
if enough of them match then he can be
00:25:32
certain he's looking at the prints of
00:25:34
the same person in the thorah Rose case
00:25:39
Los Angeles detectives reviewed all the
00:25:41
fingerprints in their files when none
00:25:45
matched they sent a detective to the
00:25:47
State Capitol in Sacramento to expand
00:25:49
the search statewide he scoured every
00:25:53
file looking at a staggering thirty
00:25:56
thousand fingerprints the labor took
00:25:59
months but still nothing matched
00:26:03
I mean it's apparent point that they
00:26:05
they put in an unbelievable man-hours of
00:26:09
time on this case and even with all that
00:26:13
they have done which is probably
00:26:15
thousands of thousands of percent more
00:26:17
than what we could do today with our
00:26:18
crimes they still weren't able to come
00:26:20
up with anything even though the killer
00:26:23
had left behind many fingerprints the
00:26:26
detectives couldn't match them to anyone
00:26:28
with a police record the case was
00:26:31
unsolved the files were shelved and the
00:26:35
murderer of thora Rose went free thirty
00:26:39
years would pass before time and
00:26:42
technology would flush him out three
00:26:49
decades after the murder of thora Rose a
00:26:52
new computerized system of fingerprint
00:26:54
comparison went online
00:26:57
the automated fingerprint identification
00:26:59
system or a ffice promised to
00:27:02
revolutionize the field of fingerprint
00:27:04
identification
00:27:05
[Music]
00:27:09
it matches prints in a fraction of the
00:27:12
time it took using the old method
00:27:18
[Music]
00:27:19
fingerprint examiner Donald Kier was one
00:27:22
of the first at the Los Angeles Police
00:27:24
Department to put APIs to use this
00:27:28
fingerprint system takes the time to get
00:27:32
used to as new it takes time to utilize
00:27:34
and how law crimes assault Kier and his
00:27:37
colleagues first used a ffice to match
00:27:39
prints collected from current crimes
00:27:41
against those in Ephesus files then they
00:27:45
tried an experiment to see if the system
00:27:48
could solve old cases by matching
00:27:50
previously unmatched prints they chose
00:27:55
50 old homicide cases to test could Avis
00:28:00
breathe new life into dead cases to find
00:28:04
out Kier went to the archives in the
00:28:06
basement of the police department there
00:28:14
under the dust of 30 years or more stood
00:28:17
shelves brimming with old fingerprint
00:28:20
files they were gathered from all manner
00:28:23
of crimes some solved some not one of
00:28:27
the files he pulled contained prints
00:28:30
from the thorah Rose murder it was the
00:28:33
oldest case selected the chance of
00:28:36
finding a suspect after almost 30 years
00:28:38
seemed remote but with millions of
00:28:42
prints added to police files since 1963
00:28:45
and the ability of the APHIS system to
00:28:48
compare them at lightning speed
00:28:50
detectives had a glimmer of hope
00:28:54
but first the prints from the Rose case
00:28:57
had to be prepared before a facin
00:29:01
recognize any fingerprint an examiner
00:29:03
must photograph it at five times its
00:29:05
normal size in contrast to prints taken
00:29:11
from a suspect at the police station the
00:29:13
ridges and patterns of most prints from
00:29:16
a crime scene are faint and indistinct
00:29:18
the examiner must carefully enhance the
00:29:21
pattern on tracing paper otherwise the
00:29:25
computer scanner will be unable to read
00:29:27
it any place where I'm looping it off is
00:29:31
where a Ridge in the fingerprint pattern
00:29:33
ends and we want to make sure those are
00:29:37
really clear because that's what the
00:29:38
computer uses for a search
00:29:40
they're called minutiae or
00:29:42
characteristics I check it frequently to
00:29:45
see if I'm missing anything go back over
00:29:49
what I've been doing here where the
00:29:52
latent print is unreadable the examiner
00:29:54
must hazard a guess as to line and
00:29:57
detail the tracing is scanned into the
00:30:00
computer the examiner cleans up any
00:30:03
indistinct lines on the screen and
00:30:06
identifies notable characteristics of
00:30:08
the latent print the computer will use
00:30:11
these as a frame of reference a fost
00:30:18
then begins the matching process the
00:30:23
computer looks at several areas of the
00:30:25
unknown print it then compares these
00:30:28
points against prints in its database it
00:30:32
ranks each print according to how
00:30:34
closely it matches the unknown print in
00:30:37
another room
00:30:38
the massive efis mainframe searches
00:30:41
through millions of digitized
00:30:42
fingerprints looking for a match in less
00:30:46
than an hour it completes a job that
00:30:48
would ordinarily take months then the
00:30:53
system delivers the closest matches
00:30:58
but it's up to the examiner to make the
00:31:00
final match by eye the prince identified
00:31:04
by APHIS are compared side-by-side with
00:31:08
the suspects print
00:31:09
[Music]
00:31:12
a real minutia point like this one was a
00:31:15
pretty
00:31:16
pretty big one right here a little short
00:31:20
and it looks like that might be it there
00:31:21
but over next to it was a
00:31:29
disregard the APHIS system has had
00:31:33
remarkable results during its first year
00:31:36
of operation San Francisco police were
00:31:39
able to clear 816 unsolved cases
00:31:42
including 52 homicides
00:31:47
Los Angeles police hope for similar
00:31:50
success with their unsolved cases they
00:31:53
weren't disappointed soon after they
00:31:56
entered the fingerprints from the thorah
00:31:58
Rose case a ffice made a hit the
00:32:02
computer produced three suspects among
00:32:05
them a man named Vernon Robinson in 1963
00:32:10
Robinson hadn't been arrested so his
00:32:12
fingerprints weren't on file but he'd
00:32:15
been arrested a number of times since
00:32:17
then so his prints were part of police
00:32:19
records
00:32:23
detectives using APIs fingered him as a
00:32:26
suspect Detective Mike McDonough headed
00:32:30
the new investigation my main concern
00:32:33
was to see if mr. Robinson should have
00:32:37
been there or not I want to make sure
00:32:39
that he wasn't one of the detectives or
00:32:42
a police officer at the scene he wasn't
00:32:44
a paramedic or that he wasn't for some
00:32:46
reason a friend of Miss Robinsons that
00:32:50
fingerprints has happened to be there
00:32:52
when all other possibilities were
00:32:55
eliminated McDonough concluded that
00:32:57
Robinson was the likely killer of Thor
00:33:00
arose with that our fingerprint people
00:33:05
obtained the additional fingerprints
00:33:07
started hand searching them physically
00:33:10
checking the fingerprints from the crime
00:33:11
scene
00:33:12
against mr. Robinson's prints and
00:33:14
everyone is going right back to mr.
00:33:16
Robinson I'm at this point there was no
00:33:18
doubt about it
00:33:20
Los Angeles police tracked Robinson to
00:33:23
Minneapolis Minnesota where he was now a
00:33:26
family man with a management job in a
00:33:28
maintenance company
00:33:33
he denied committing the crime insisting
00:33:36
that at the time of the murder he was in
00:33:37
San Diego at the Naval Base where he was
00:33:40
stationed
00:33:41
but naval records indicated Robinson had
00:33:44
completed his training by the date of
00:33:46
the murder his alibi was without support
00:33:49
[Music]
00:33:52
what would sway the jury was I mean the
00:33:54
fingerprints are there you cannot deny
00:33:56
that I mean we're not talking one or two
00:33:57
fingerprints we're talking 20 some
00:34:00
fingerprints were talking about the
00:34:02
point of entry through the entire house
00:34:03
and right up to where the victim was
00:34:06
discovered after killing Thoro rose
00:34:09
vernon robinson managed to evade capture
00:34:12
for almost 30 years his life had changed
00:34:16
but his fingerprints remained the same
00:34:20
after they were matched with those from
00:34:22
the crime scene Robinson was convicted
00:34:24
of murder and sentenced to life
00:34:26
imprisonment
00:34:29
avis a phenomenal breakthrough in
00:34:31
Criminal identification had finally
00:34:34
obtained justice for Thor arose
00:34:38
though a facade romantically improved
00:34:40
the chances of matching fingerprints to
00:34:43
criminals it's useless without clear
00:34:45
prints to work from but crime scenes are
00:34:49
often messy and criminals don't always
00:34:51
leave their prints in convenient spots
00:34:54
in a case in Vermont a murder
00:34:57
investigation hinged on too fragile and
00:35:00
ill placed prints and one investigators
00:35:03
attempt to read them on Memorial Day
00:35:09
1990 - Glenn Michelson had a party he
00:35:14
and his friends were putting the cold
00:35:15
Vermont winter behind them and kicking
00:35:18
off the beginning of summer but the
00:35:21
celebration was nearly ruined by an
00:35:23
uninvited guest as the party was winding
00:35:27
down he tried to make off in mikaelsons
00:35:30
car with one of the kegs of beer but
00:35:33
three of mikaelsons buddies caught him
00:35:36
in the act they chased him off the
00:35:38
property
00:35:39
and retrieved the keg with the commotion
00:35:46
over and the keg emptied the three men
00:35:49
decided to continue celebrating at a
00:35:51
nearby tavern Michaelson stayed home
00:35:59
the group returned to the house 45
00:36:02
minutes later still in high spirits at
00:36:06
first they didn't notice their host was
00:36:08
nowhere in sight when they called out to
00:36:11
him he didn't answer they assumed he
00:36:14
went to bed it wasn't until one of the
00:36:17
men noticed something peculiar in
00:36:19
another room that the horrible truth
00:36:21
revealed itself a ski pole that appeared
00:36:25
to be sticking out of the floor was
00:36:27
actually embedded in mikaelsons skull
00:36:32
they called the Vermont State Police who
00:36:35
rushed to the scene
00:36:43
mikaelsons friends couldn't believe the
00:36:45
friend they'd left with a few hours ago
00:36:48
now lay dead
00:36:51
[Music]
00:36:56
while the police made their report
00:36:58
detectives scoured the house for clues
00:37:05
their inspection of the brutal crime
00:37:07
scene revealed a bloody knife in the
00:37:09
kitchen sink it looked like the victim
00:37:12
had been stabbed several times before
00:37:15
the ski pole was repeatedly jabbed into
00:37:17
his skull according to sergeant miles
00:37:23
Heffernan the victim didn't die easily
00:37:28
he was obviously involved in a struggle
00:37:33
had a lot of blood on his clothes there
00:37:36
was a lot of blood on the walls in the
00:37:38
hallway when questioned the three men
00:37:41
who found the body told the detectives
00:37:43
about the person who tried to steal
00:37:44
mikaelsons car and the beer keg his name
00:37:48
was Robert Plant he tagged along with
00:37:51
one of the invited guests and grew surly
00:37:54
as the evening progressed the men
00:37:57
recalled he wore white shoes with pink
00:38:00
laces the same shoes that were found
00:38:02
near the barefoot corpse the cowboy
00:38:05
boots that Michelson had worn were
00:38:07
missing as police continued to
00:38:10
investigate a call came through about a
00:38:13
car that had run off the road less than
00:38:15
a mile away a neighbor named Robert
00:38:18
salzman made the report mr. Salzmann was
00:38:23
in the living room with his wife and
00:38:24
child and heard the car go off the road
00:38:26
he came out and observed Robert Plant
00:38:31
walking from the vehicle to the front
00:38:33
porch of mr. Solomon's residence he had
00:38:37
a discussion with Robert Plant initially
00:38:40
Plante seemed Pleasant he asked if he
00:38:43
could get a wrecker and mr. Salzmann was
00:38:47
agreeable but then plant became
00:38:51
aggressive and broke a window Salzmann
00:38:55
threw him off his property and called
00:38:57
the police
00:38:59
they arrived within minutes and found
00:39:02
the car on the side of the road it
00:39:04
matched the description of blend
00:39:06
mikaelsons vehicle but Plante was
00:39:09
nowhere in sight
00:39:11
apparently he fled on foot
00:39:16
police searched the woods and found him
00:39:18
in a short time passed out under a tree
00:39:27
on his feet were mikaelsons cowboy boots
00:39:34
[Music]
00:39:36
he was taken to the station for
00:39:39
questioning and booked for murder on the
00:39:44
surface it seemed Heffernan had an
00:39:46
open-and-shut case against him but
00:39:50
Plante denied the crime and the police
00:39:52
had no eyewitnesses theoretically plant
00:39:56
could claim he had stolen mikaelsons
00:39:58
property after someone else committed
00:40:00
the murder the detectives would try to
00:40:03
bolster their circumstantial case with
00:40:05
forensic evidence plants fingerprints
00:40:09
they new prints lifted from walls sinks
00:40:12
and drawers had little value since plant
00:40:15
had been a guest at mikaelsons party but
00:40:18
they found bloody prints on the grip of
00:40:20
the ski pole and on a doorframe near the
00:40:23
body
00:40:24
if these prints could be identified as
00:40:27
Robert Plant's police would clinch their
00:40:30
case to help him make the identification
00:40:34
Heffernan called on fingerprint expert
00:40:37
John Creighton of the Vermont Department
00:40:39
of Public Safety's forensic lab because
00:40:43
the prints were etched in the victims
00:40:44
dried blood
00:40:45
they were extremely incriminating and
00:40:48
extremely fragile traditional methods of
00:40:52
dusting with powder would not be
00:40:54
effective fortunately Creighton has a
00:40:58
well-stocked arsenal with the means to
00:41:01
recover difficult prints how a print is
00:41:05
raised depends on the kind of surface
00:41:07
it's on basically there's two different
00:41:11
types of evidence that come into the lab
00:41:13
for fingerprinting there's porous and
00:41:15
non porous evidence the porous evidence
00:41:17
is papers and cardboards and things of
00:41:19
that nature and the non porous evidence
00:41:21
is wood plastics metal glass things of
00:41:26
that nature so depending on what type of
00:41:28
evidence it is will dictate what type of
00:41:30
examination you do
00:41:35
paper and other porous surfaces leave no
00:41:39
moisture for powders to cling to one
00:41:42
classic method for raising prints from
00:41:44
these surfaces is iodine fuming iodine
00:41:49
crystals are placed inside a glass tube
00:41:55
the tube is then packed with fiberglass
00:41:57
and copper sulfate
00:41:59
[Music]
00:42:07
breath passing through the crystals
00:42:09
heats them creating fumes when the fumes
00:42:13
reach the fingerprints the iodine reacts
00:42:16
with fatty oils making them visible a
00:42:19
drawback of this method is that the
00:42:22
prints will disappear in about 20
00:42:24
minutes when the iodine evaporates
00:42:26
they must be photographed after fuming
00:42:29
so police will have a record of them
00:42:33
another way to find fingerprints on
00:42:35
paper is to spray the surface with a
00:42:37
chemical called ninhydrin ninhydrin is a
00:42:44
spray or a compound that reacts to amino
00:42:48
acids that are present in Akron and
00:42:52
sebaceous sweat deposited latent prints
00:42:54
the ninhydrin is sprayed onto porous
00:42:58
material and is then catalyzed or the
00:43:02
reaction is catalyzed by applying heat
00:43:05
and moisture generally by means of an
00:43:08
iron this develops the prints much more
00:43:11
quickly otherwise you'd have to set them
00:43:14
in the dark and wait anywhere from 24 to
00:43:17
possibly 72 hours for any latent
00:43:20
impressions to develop that way because
00:43:23
the amino acids in fingerprints take a
00:43:25
long time to disappear ninhydrin has
00:43:28
been used to develop latent prints as
00:43:30
old as 15 years superglue has also
00:43:35
become a staple of fingerprint
00:43:37
examiner's technically called
00:43:39
cyanoacrylate ester it's used on
00:43:42
non-porous surfaces like plastic where
00:43:45
fragile prints could be easily brushed
00:43:47
away when powders are applied super glue
00:43:51
is often used for developing prints
00:43:53
inside a car the glue is poured into a
00:43:57
small container and heated the car is
00:44:00
closed up tightly as the glue is heated
00:44:04
its fumes adhere to the moisture and
00:44:06
latent fingerprints and fixes them in
00:44:09
place the examiner can then use
00:44:14
traditional powders without the danger
00:44:16
of destroying the print
00:44:20
the Glenn Michelson case posed a
00:44:22
different set of problems
00:44:24
the bloody thumbprint on the doorframe
00:44:27
near the victim's body was barely
00:44:29
visible and too delicate to lift
00:44:32
Creighton asked detectives to remove the
00:44:35
section of doorframe bearing the print
00:44:37
and send it to him so he could examine
00:44:39
it in a more controlled environment
00:44:41
Creighton's job was to make the print on
00:44:44
the doorframe distinct without ruining
00:44:46
it he could then compare it with Robert
00:44:49
Plant's first he took photographs so he
00:44:55
would have a record of the evidence
00:44:56
before the procedure items of evidence
00:44:59
are photographed before any physical or
00:45:03
chemical development takes place in
00:45:07
order to recover and preserve any
00:45:09
existing latent detail that is present
00:45:12
on the item afterwards
00:45:15
then we can do the various processes
00:45:18
that are applied to developing the
00:45:20
latent impression on that item Creighton
00:45:26
sprayed the door frame with a stain
00:45:27
called amido black the chemical reacts
00:45:31
with blood darkening the print and
00:45:33
making it easier to identify the immuno
00:45:40
black is a protein stain it stains the
00:45:43
protein that is within the blood itself
00:45:46
so when the ridges or the outline of the
00:45:49
impression on the finger is deposited in
00:45:51
the blood the amido black is going to
00:45:54
make that impression darker it allows it
00:45:58
to have more contrast with the
00:46:01
background bloody fingerprints are very
00:46:04
fragile in most cases so they can't be
00:46:06
lifted with tape without destroying them
00:46:09
even after they're developed with amido
00:46:12
instead Creighton photographed the
00:46:15
enhanced print
00:46:19
when he compared it to plants it matched
00:46:24
but plant could have touched the
00:46:26
blood-stained doorframe after someone
00:46:29
else committed the crime and the
00:46:32
evidence against plant must convince a
00:46:34
jury of his guilt beyond a reasonable
00:46:37
doubt the irrefutable evidence in the
00:46:41
murder of Glenn Michelson had yet to be
00:46:43
processed
00:46:46
Glenn Michelson had been the victim of a
00:46:49
callous murder a ski pole driven through
00:46:52
his skull Robert Plant was the prime
00:46:57
suspect but could detectives tie him to
00:47:00
the crime the answer rested on a bloody
00:47:06
palm print left on the grip of the
00:47:09
weapon to identify the print John
00:47:14
Creighton needed to photograph it first
00:47:17
he'd have to make it more visible that
00:47:19
was easier said than done the big
00:47:24
dilemma was it was a black ski pole grip
00:47:26
and it was a dark reddish brown blood
00:47:29
impression that was deposited on that
00:47:32
now what I had to do was I had to
00:47:35
improve the contrast either by
00:47:37
lightening the background of the black
00:47:38
ski pole grip or by lightening the blood
00:47:43
impression itself lit the print
00:47:47
with a poly light a lamp that can
00:47:49
project a wide spectrum of wavelengths
00:47:52
the light produced enough contrast to
00:47:55
photograph the print but Creighton faced
00:47:58
a second problem the curvature of the
00:48:01
grip prevented the camera lens from
00:48:03
keeping the entire print in focus I had
00:48:08
to keep rotating the ski pole grip in
00:48:12
order to come up with enough
00:48:14
characteristics within the pattern area
00:48:16
or within the latent impression that
00:48:19
would give me enough information to make
00:48:21
an identification by manipulating the
00:48:25
grip Creighton was able to get a clear
00:48:27
photograph of the
00:48:29
after it was processed he compared the
00:48:32
print to plants it matched Creighton had
00:48:36
placed the murder weapon firmly in
00:48:38
plants hand the events of Glen
00:48:44
mikaelsons final hours now made sense
00:48:47
detectives believed that after being
00:48:49
kicked off mikaelsons property plant hid
00:48:52
in the darkness and waited for an
00:48:54
opportunity to sneak back into the house
00:48:57
once the guests had left he saw his
00:49:00
chance and made his move
00:49:07
he slipped into the kitchen and rummaged
00:49:11
around until he found a knife
00:49:16
[Music]
00:49:21
as he stepped into the hallway Michelson
00:49:24
spotted him
00:49:26
the two men struggled but plant had the
00:49:30
fatal advantage he stabbed Michelson
00:49:33
repeatedly until he brought the victim
00:49:35
down he removed mikaelsons boots and put
00:49:43
them on his own feet then he realized
00:49:46
his victim wasn't dead so he found a ski
00:49:54
pole in another room and returned to
00:49:57
finish him off
00:50:00
as he thrust the pole he put his hand on
00:50:03
the doorframe for support after the
00:50:09
final blow he left the house stealing
00:50:12
mikaelsons car for his getaway but he
00:50:16
only made it about a mile before he ran
00:50:18
off the road
00:50:24
the bloody prints that Creighton
00:50:26
analyzed gave detective miles Heffernan
00:50:29
the evidence he needed to convict Robert
00:50:32
Plant was very compelling very
00:50:38
compelling for a jury when they hired to
00:50:40
explain or explain away
00:50:42
you've got the thumbprint up in the
00:50:45
victim's blood on the door molding and
00:50:47
you've got the handprint on the murder
00:50:49
weapon it tells a story right there for
00:50:53
the murder of Glen Michaelson Robert
00:50:56
Plant received a sentence of 50 years to
00:50:58
life for more than a century
00:51:03
fingerprints have proven themselves a
00:51:05
reliable and irrefutable way to link
00:51:07
criminals to their crimes
00:51:12
[Music]
00:51:14
in the next century their role will
00:51:17
increase as scientists improve ways to
00:51:20
recover them
00:51:22
[Music]
00:51:24
more and more killers will be delivered
00:51:28
into the arms of justice by their own
00:51:30
hands
00:51:32
[Music]