Phantom Forces RESPONDED TO THE ALLEGATIONS and uh
概要
TLDRIn the video, Strider criticizes Stylist Studios for their poor handling of serious allegations involving conduct with minors by certain staff members and contractors. He airs concerns about the studio's perceived negligence and inadequate responses to these allegations, asserting that they often act only when issues become public, rather than proactively addressing misconduct within their community. Strider highlights cases involving individuals like Juke and Willow, citing evidence of inappropriate behavior that was allegedly ignored or poorly managed by Stylist Studios. He faults the studio for initially dismissing evidence presented against these individuals and for failing to implement effective preventive measures. Strider expresses a sense of frustration with repeated patterns of misconduct and cover-ups, indicating that these behaviors reflect badly on the studio and call for a serious reevaluation of their policies and community management practices. The video further accuses the studio of covering up issues rather than addressing them transparently, urging the community to be aware and push for greater accountability. Despite acknowledging some minor errors in his presentation, Strider stands by his findings, emphasizing the need for a safer environment for the community, particularly for younger members.
収穫
- ⚠️ Strider criticizes Stylist Studios for mishandling allegations of misconduct.
- 🎥 He encourages others to make videos and raise awareness.
- 🕵️♂️ Strider investigated and found numerous issues within the studio's community.
- 🚫 Highlights inappropriate behavior and insufficient action by staff.
- 🔍 Calls for transparency and accountability from Stylist Studios.
- 🛡️ Urges protection of minors and better policy implementation.
- 🤔 Points out patterns of neglect and cover-ups within the studio.
- 🔄 Studios promised to review and improve their procedures.
- 📢 Community upset, demanding better handling of allegations.
- 👥 Discussed community involvement and communication issues.
タイムライン
- 00:00:00 - 00:05:00
The speaker discusses receiving a response from Stylist Studios to a video they made, which they describe as disappointing. They invite others to create content or report on the matter and express dissatisfaction with Stylist's handling of specific situations involving inappropriate messages shared by minors and adults within the community. The speaker expresses the vastness of the issue and the need for a more comprehensive following due to additional information received.
- 00:05:00 - 00:10:00
Stylist Studios issued a response perceived as inadequate, failing to acknowledge serious allegations adequately. They seemingly ignored accusations of negligence concerning their community of children and inappropriate conduct tolerated within the Discord server. The responses from Stylist Studios are seen as dismissive, and the speaker questions their awareness of the environment fostered by their developers, highlighting potential oversight or indifference.
- 00:10:00 - 00:15:00
Further allegations against Stylist Studios involve inappropriate handling of offensive material linked to the game and its community. An individual known for predatory behavior was allowed within the community, causing concern about the developers' responsibility to prevent such actions. The speaker suspects a troubling pattern of overlooking serious offenses involving minors, questioning the studio's priorities and concern for community safety.
- 00:15:00 - 00:20:00
The speaker criticizes responses from Stylist Studios, pointing out the lack of accountability for past incidents involving inappropriate behavior. They detail incidents where known offenders were inadequately addressed and express frustration over the perceived negligence and lack of proactive measures to prevent harm. The speaker questions the sincerity of Stylist Studios’ claims of action and the adequacy of their responses to serious allegations.
- 00:20:00 - 00:25:00
There is skepticism regarding Stylist Studios' actions and intentions, speculating about the rehiring practices and secrecy surrounding dismissals of problematic individuals. They illustrate inconsistencies in the studio’s handling of allegations and communicate unease about the transparency and integrity of their operational practices. The issue of minors’ safety in the community and questionable developer conduct persists.
- 00:25:00 - 00:31:50
The speaker reflects on the apparent dissonance between public acknowledgment and internal handling of serious issues within Stylist Studios. There's emphasis on the community's reaction to this perceived indifference and the necessity for a change in approach, underlining the importance of addressing and rectifying systemic issues of negligence and misconduct to restore community trust and safety.
マインドマップ
ビデオQ&A
What did Stylist Studios do in response to the YouTube video?
Stylist Studios quickly responded but was criticized for an inadequate response, leading to further discussion of internal issues.
Who is the YouTuber criticizing Stylist Studios?
The YouTuber is Strider, who previously investigated and exposed allegations against Stylist Studios.
What are the main allegations against Stylist Studios?
The allegations include misconduct by staff members involving minors, inadequate responses from the studio, and covering up these issues instead of addressing them publicly.
What specific case is brought up against the studio's staff?
Cases involving inappropriate interactions with minors by staff and moderators, including Juke and Willow, are highlighted.
How did Stylist Studios handle the allegations initially?
They were perceived to ignore early reports and acted only after significant public pressure and exposure.
What historical issues exist within the community as discussed in the video?
The video highlights previous incidents involving inappropriate conduct by staff and inadequate actions taken to prevent it.
How did the community respond to the allegations?
The community was largely upset, demanding accountability and transparency from Stylist Studios.
What changes did Stylist Studios promise to implement?
The studio promised to review their policies and ensure better handling of misconduct, particularly around protecting minors.
What was Strider's intention in creating the video?
Strider aimed to expose negligence and misconduct, urging transparency and more robust protections for young community members.
What stance does the YouTuber take towards Stylist Studios' actions?
The YouTuber is critical of Stylist Studios, highlighting repeated patterns of neglect and cover-ups in response to serious allegations.
ビデオをもっと見る
Pipe Stress Analysis using ANSYS
READING & WRITING/ Lesson 4 Exemplification & Classification 3rd Quarter Senior High School
Grade 11/12 Reading and Writing Ep3 Classification and Exemplification Essay Comparison and Contra
Other Geological Hazards | Disaster Readiness and Risk Reduction
Economist Paull Krugman on Trump Tariffs, Immigration and Jobs Report
Is Onsemi (ON) Stock Cheap? It Is, If This Is True.
- 00:00:00as many of you guys know and let me know
- 00:00:01on Discord stylist Studios actually
- 00:00:03responded to my video which is pretty
- 00:00:05admirable that they did respond this
- 00:00:07quickly however the response is uh not
- 00:00:09the best before I respond to this
- 00:00:11response let me just get a few things
- 00:00:13out of the way first number one a lot of
- 00:00:14people have been asking me if they can
- 00:00:16make a video about this yes please make
- 00:00:18a video about this if you have more to
- 00:00:20add to this or if you just want to
- 00:00:21report on it I I don't care both of
- 00:00:23those are great you can use Clips are in
- 00:00:24the video I'm not going to take down the
- 00:00:26video as you guys could probably tell
- 00:00:27from the video I I'm not too happy with
- 00:00:29um what found when I investigated
- 00:00:31stylist number two I've gotten probably
- 00:00:33250 different DMS with even more stuff
- 00:00:36so I probably will have to make a part
- 00:00:38two I really hope somebody like Ruben
- 00:00:39Sim makes a video about this because I'm
- 00:00:41just one person that did an
- 00:00:43investigation and this is so much stuff
- 00:00:45to go through it's ridiculous number
- 00:00:47three the cry person which was the first
- 00:00:49stylus mod I actually looked at the
- 00:00:51messages from I found a bunch of really
- 00:00:53bad messages from him he actually dm'd
- 00:00:55me on Discord he was 13 years old when
- 00:00:58he sent those messages he was talking
- 00:01:00with an 18-year-old about those topics
- 00:01:02and yes that just makes stylist look
- 00:01:04even worse the last thing before I start
- 00:01:06going into this the C person who was
- 00:01:08banned alongside Willow was actually one
- 00:01:10of the people who was by Willow and they
- 00:01:12banned this individual for quote being a
- 00:01:16victim they banned both of them and they
- 00:01:17put them together they put theer and the
- 00:01:20victim in the same announcement and said
- 00:01:22we're Banning these people for their
- 00:01:24behavior of course a lot of people
- 00:01:25thought that the Cali person was also a
- 00:01:27groer when actually they were the one
- 00:01:29being groom this Al led to probably one
- 00:01:30of the worst mod messages I've seen on
- 00:01:33PF and I've seen a lot in this Discord
- 00:01:35there are a lot of bad ones people made
- 00:01:36it a speech bubble gift on Discord uh
- 00:01:39you can see it right now that's what he
- 00:01:40said oh yeah let's just get into this
- 00:01:42response and uh go through what they
- 00:01:44said it says greetings everyone it has
- 00:01:46been a colorful Journey this evening for
- 00:01:48us as you all know Strider has posted a
- 00:01:50video with some serious allegations
- 00:01:52against our studio with a very
- 00:01:53compelling narrative I honestly thought
- 00:01:55the video turned out pretty bad but a
- 00:01:56bunch of access messages got leaked they
- 00:01:58started deleting everything and going
- 00:02:00into damage control before I even posted
- 00:02:02the video so I had to rush the video
- 00:02:04completely out before you know they
- 00:02:05started shutting down everything given
- 00:02:07his status is a former Cc or content
- 00:02:09creator and his past contributions to
- 00:02:11our game we are happy to provide a
- 00:02:13response for the community and address
- 00:02:15his concerns on behalf of stylist I do
- 00:02:17like how they said I had contributions
- 00:02:18to the game if you guys didn't know I
- 00:02:20basically used to look at all the
- 00:02:21updates and then give them feedback and
- 00:02:23stuff like that I also had DMS with
- 00:02:25every contractor except for M I never
- 00:02:28had any DMS with M which is is lucky and
- 00:02:30we'll get into more Mar stuff in a bit
- 00:02:31don't worry about that this part where
- 00:02:33they say from a glance I don't what do
- 00:02:35they mean bro did they watch the video
- 00:02:36or did they glance at the video in the
- 00:02:38content creator chat Leo who is one of
- 00:02:40the main pfds was asking people for like
- 00:02:42a summary of the video instead of just
- 00:02:44watching the video which is great if you
- 00:02:46make a game and people are calling out
- 00:02:48your game to not even watch the video
- 00:02:50calling them out anyway there are
- 00:02:51multiple allegations pertaining to
- 00:02:52members within our community to our
- 00:02:54staff members and contractors and
- 00:02:56leading up lastly to one of our lead
- 00:02:58developers the video begins with a
- 00:02:59twitch streamer named Bella the bat Pony
- 00:03:01blah blah blah basically for this one
- 00:03:03they say the admin failed to act and ban
- 00:03:05that individual for a year and then they
- 00:03:06said we are not involved with the
- 00:03:08content creator team they are not
- 00:03:10involved with Banning people so for this
- 00:03:12one they are claiming negligence they
- 00:03:14had no idea guys they made this Discord
- 00:03:16for their Community for their kids game
- 00:03:18but you know they don't really have to
- 00:03:19look at it at all personally I've never
- 00:03:21even heard of the individual until after
- 00:03:23watching this video I think this was
- 00:03:24made by Leo and if this is true that's
- 00:03:27that's pretty bad that was a 19-year-old
- 00:03:29talking to a 13-year-old the claim that
- 00:03:30this oversight is indicative of
- 00:03:32questionable behavior on the developers
- 00:03:34is frankly unfounded I think the fact
- 00:03:36that they don't know would also be
- 00:03:38pretty questionable but this one in
- 00:03:39particular wasn't supposed to indict the
- 00:03:42Developers for anything this one was
- 00:03:43just to make a timeline I actually had
- 00:03:45one before this that I cut from the
- 00:03:46video because it had even less to do
- 00:03:49with the developers because this video
- 00:03:50actually just started as a just scandals
- 00:03:53of PF thing that was basically just to
- 00:03:55talk about the scandals that have
- 00:03:56happened with this game and the content
- 00:03:58creators because basically nobody had
- 00:03:59has made a video like that before I just
- 00:04:01wanted to post that video Just to let
- 00:04:03people know what had happened and just
- 00:04:05give people information on why certain
- 00:04:07people had left because of course the
- 00:04:09devs hadn't given information to anybody
- 00:04:11about what had happened to all those
- 00:04:12content creators so it didn't start out
- 00:04:14as a PF devs exposed video but then I
- 00:04:17looked into it and I uh yeah I turned
- 00:04:19into that because that's what I found
- 00:04:21next the claim is that there were skins
- 00:04:22pertaining to the content creator case
- 00:04:24that were not removed for years despite
- 00:04:25containing skins of known Predators this
- 00:04:28is true similarly this issue did not
- 00:04:30surface the developer attention right
- 00:04:32away and there was a lack of internal
- 00:04:33systems in place to rapidly replace
- 00:04:35skins without any existing data
- 00:04:37modification tooling that we have today
- 00:04:38as such we have likely assigned a lower
- 00:04:40priority to this issue while bugs and
- 00:04:42exploits drew our constant
- 00:04:45Focus that okay I think removing a skin
- 00:04:48from a 19-year-old that talk to a
- 00:04:5013-year-old is probably a good idea
- 00:04:52especially if you're not going to tell
- 00:04:54people why those individuals got banned
- 00:04:56and they still have social media up so
- 00:04:58people could go and find them especially
- 00:05:00if they are under the age of 18 again
- 00:05:02this claimed that our negligence to
- 00:05:03remove these skins in a timely manner
- 00:05:05constitutes developer support for
- 00:05:07predatory behavior is baseless and Akin
- 00:05:09to outright defamation I don't think I
- 00:05:11said this in the video I'm pretty sure I
- 00:05:13just said they didn't remove the skins
- 00:05:15and if that looks bad for the developers
- 00:05:17that's not my problem I just said what
- 00:05:19they did which they just acknowledged
- 00:05:21what they did and yeah it looks bad
- 00:05:23because it's it's a bad look basically
- 00:05:25they said bugs are more important than
- 00:05:27removing the skins and yeah I thought it
- 00:05:29was weird that they didn't remove the
- 00:05:30Skins which is why I brought it up in
- 00:05:31the video it's a thing they did a
- 00:05:33similar situation happened today we
- 00:05:34would be much better equipped to process
- 00:05:36the removal due to framework
- 00:05:37improvements we have made in the last
- 00:05:39couple years next the topic of Juke is
- 00:05:40brought up later known to be one of the
- 00:05:42most serious offenders in both bad
- 00:05:44business and Phantom Forces says
- 00:05:46Community I don't know if he was one of
- 00:05:47the most serious offenders in bad
- 00:05:49business because they banned him from
- 00:05:51Bad Business after the first thing he
- 00:05:52did so I would probably just give it
- 00:05:54over to Phantom Forces for this one
- 00:05:55video primarily summarizes juke's
- 00:05:57offenses in a roundabout manner however
- 00:05:59it makes a false claim that after juk
- 00:06:01was exposed and removed by Bad Business
- 00:06:04Developers for sending inappropriate
- 00:06:05messages to miners he quote quickly
- 00:06:08became a phantom Force's content creator
- 00:06:10afterwards because he was friends with
- 00:06:11axis angle this entire response kind of
- 00:06:13feels like it's chat GPT and this also
- 00:06:16would be if they just read the
- 00:06:17transcript of the video I had to rush
- 00:06:19out this video and I did put something
- 00:06:20on screen that said he was actually one
- 00:06:22before I didn't know that he was already
- 00:06:24a PF content creator but then during
- 00:06:26editing I realized oh wait he already
- 00:06:28was so I did put something on screen
- 00:06:30I'll give him the benefit of the doubt
- 00:06:31and say they just missed that but to
- 00:06:33clarify juke's infractions were made
- 00:06:35known to us by bad business's developers
- 00:06:38while he was already an existing PF
- 00:06:40content creator this is true but neither
- 00:06:41team realized the extent of juke's
- 00:06:43predatory behaviors right away yes but
- 00:06:45Bad Business took the things he had
- 00:06:48already done and realized that it was
- 00:06:50already enough to ban if you go back to
- 00:06:52the first Jack's video that was plenty
- 00:06:54of stuff to get him removed from any
- 00:06:56community in general much less a
- 00:06:58children's game our initial
- 00:07:00interpretation was that he was removed
- 00:07:01for sending inappropriate messages ding
- 00:07:04ding ding that is true and we assumed
- 00:07:05that his disciplinary action had already
- 00:07:08been handled within the bad business
- 00:07:10Community he sent inappropriate messages
- 00:07:12to kids on Roblox I think you can ban
- 00:07:16him from every Community after that Juke
- 00:07:17later confided to us of his disciplinary
- 00:07:20action from Bad Business and wish to
- 00:07:22start a new in Phantom Forces this part
- 00:07:24was really interesting cuz I thought he
- 00:07:25was already a content creator for
- 00:07:27Phantom Forces which is true he was but
- 00:07:29but then he basically became a full Bad
- 00:07:31Business one and then he essentially
- 00:07:33moved back to Phantom Forces after he
- 00:07:35was kicked for talking to kids then they
- 00:07:37say presumably Having learned his lesson
- 00:07:40presumably Having learned his lesson he
- 00:07:42essentially talked axis into keeping him
- 00:07:44in the content creator program and
- 00:07:46letting him play PF which turned out to
- 00:07:48be pretty bad idea not going to lie
- 00:07:50remember guys if you talk to kids only a
- 00:07:51couple of times you probably will never
- 00:07:53do it again as we were unaware of any
- 00:07:55infractions he had committed in the
- 00:07:56Phantom Forces Discord itself if you do
- 00:08:00it in DMS if you do it in a different
- 00:08:02Discord you're fine to talk to kids but
- 00:08:04just don't do it in ours just kidding
- 00:08:06you can do it in RS cuz I talked about
- 00:08:08that in the video dude we were to keep
- 00:08:10an eye on his behavior to see if his
- 00:08:11removal from Bad Business was sufficient
- 00:08:13or if we needed to take action on our
- 00:08:16end therefore delaying actions to remove
- 00:08:18him until further notice we now know
- 00:08:20that it turned out to be well beyond the
- 00:08:22scope after Jax's video revealed more
- 00:08:24information than we were initially
- 00:08:25provided once we realized the extent of
- 00:08:27his actions axis angle made the decision
- 00:08:29to remove him immediately with that I
- 00:08:30firmly believe we have acted in best
- 00:08:32faith to the knowledge provided to us at
- 00:08:34the time Striders claimed that we were
- 00:08:35harboring Juke knowingly while he was a
- 00:08:38is therefore unwarranted axis angles in
- 00:08:40his apology is going to be talking about
- 00:08:42Juke a little bit but yeah the fact that
- 00:08:44Juke confided the messages told the
- 00:08:46Phantom Forces developers what Juke had
- 00:08:49done yes they didn't know the full
- 00:08:51extent but the full extent is is really
- 00:08:54bad what they already had was plenty of
- 00:08:56course what happened after is even wor
- 00:08:59worse so yeah the fact that stylist kept
- 00:09:01Juke on their content creator program
- 00:09:04after the bad business developers
- 00:09:06contacted them about it is very bad on
- 00:09:08its own but the problem is literally
- 00:09:09everything else stacked on top of it
- 00:09:11right this one event on its own wasn't
- 00:09:13enough for me to you know condemn the
- 00:09:16developers when this happened I thought
- 00:09:17it was really bad what they had done but
- 00:09:19I didn't go out and make a video about
- 00:09:21all of stylus because I didn't realize
- 00:09:24how much of an issue this had been but
- 00:09:25anyway next attention is brought to how
- 00:09:28one of our former moderators for having
- 00:09:29sent unsavory messages to miners dating
- 00:09:32back in 2018 this user has left on his
- 00:09:34own accord after these messages have
- 00:09:36been exposed in a Google do as such we
- 00:09:38are unable to pursue any further
- 00:09:40disciplinary action against the
- 00:09:42individual oh my gosh they did not they
- 00:09:46did not read they did not watch the
- 00:09:47video they did not watch the video
- 00:09:48spirals had a very long conversation
- 00:09:51with Leo about this guy in which Leo
- 00:09:53essentially just did nothing the whole
- 00:09:55time and now that this guy was getting a
- 00:09:57lot of different uh me messages about
- 00:10:00the whole situation because he was
- 00:10:02talking to a minor in 2018 he left of
- 00:10:04his own accord but Leto had plenty of
- 00:10:06time to do something about it basically
- 00:10:08spirals exposed Hal to Leo Leto said eh
- 00:10:11I'm not doing anything about this and
- 00:10:13then Hal left and now he's saying well
- 00:10:15he left so I couldn't do anything about
- 00:10:17it yes you could you could this is
- 00:10:18probably my favorite part of this whole
- 00:10:20thing the summary is rather brief but
- 00:10:22the concern raised in the video is that
- 00:10:24these messages still exist in the
- 00:10:25records of the public channels the
- 00:10:27resulting conclusion appears to be that
- 00:10:28we need to clean up these channels so
- 00:10:30that younger members cannot search for
- 00:10:32or stumble onto these inappropriate
- 00:10:34messages we agree with this and
- 00:10:36therefore we instructed our staff to
- 00:10:37purge the history of our eight plus
- 00:10:40year-old public channels to ensure our
- 00:10:42young members would not encounter these
- 00:10:43messages which however contradicts with
- 00:10:45strider's later talking points of cover
- 00:10:47up basically they put words in my mouth
- 00:10:49here this is not what I said and they
- 00:10:50said that we totally agree with what you
- 00:10:52didn't say we're actually not covering
- 00:10:54up anything which I'll talk a lot more
- 00:10:56about a cover up in my next video no I
- 00:10:58did not say that the public channels
- 00:11:00should be deleted in fact they were
- 00:11:03deleted before I even made the video
- 00:11:05because if you guys remember in my last
- 00:11:07video I talked about the fact that
- 00:11:08somebody leaked some of uh access angle
- 00:11:11old messages that didn't look too good
- 00:11:13for him so they deleted every single
- 00:11:15Channel now they're saying we actually
- 00:11:16instructed our staff to delete these
- 00:11:18channels because of this video because
- 00:11:20of this argument in this video that I
- 00:11:21didn't make as an aside there was a
- 00:11:23passing claim that our Discord lacked
- 00:11:25age verification and failed to ban users
- 00:11:27under 13 I love how they say this is a
- 00:11:28passing claim like this is just
- 00:11:30something that I mentioned for one
- 00:11:31second well I guess it kind of was I
- 00:11:33didn't mention it for that long but I
- 00:11:34think it's more than a passing claim I
- 00:11:36think it's a pretty big thing they say
- 00:11:37they fail to ban users under 13 what I
- 00:11:40got from the mod that I dm'd was not
- 00:11:42that they fail to ban users under 13 is
- 00:11:44that they don't even try thus leading to
- 00:11:47opportunities for miners to be taken
- 00:11:48advantage of we acknowledge that this is
- 00:11:50an issue that deserves more attention
- 00:11:52and we will review with the staff team
- 00:11:53on what can be done to better protect
- 00:11:55our community members they are now
- 00:11:57acknowledging this is a problem but then
- 00:11:59they completely pretend that this was my
- 00:12:01claim this was not my passing claim this
- 00:12:04was not my claim I DMD one of the admins
- 00:12:07hey what do you guys do about people
- 00:12:08under 13 and he said they don't even try
- 00:12:10to ban them this part is also very funny
- 00:12:12the video moves to former mmaker wolf
- 00:12:15dogs summarizing the inappropriate
- 00:12:17messages and photos he has sent to
- 00:12:19miners early on we received numerous
- 00:12:21reports with screenshots regarding these
- 00:12:23inappropriate messages however we were
- 00:12:25unable to immediately verify through
- 00:12:27Discord whether the submitted
- 00:12:28screenshots were legitimate or
- 00:12:29fabricated we have also been informed
- 00:12:31that there were many users who seek to
- 00:12:33Witch Hunt this user so we had
- 00:12:35conflicting information we decided we
- 00:12:36needed more time before making any
- 00:12:38conclusions regarding the reports later
- 00:12:40on our admin team discovered further
- 00:12:42evidence that these reports including
- 00:12:44evidence of the elicit photos were
- 00:12:46verified to be true we immediately
- 00:12:47ceased ties with wolf dogs and reported
- 00:12:49the issue directly to Discord let me
- 00:12:51guess uh Discord didn't do anything we
- 00:12:52decided that if legal action was
- 00:12:54required with authorities Discord
- 00:12:56themselves would be able to escalate the
- 00:12:58case as necessary this is a community of
- 00:13:01people they need to actually be informed
- 00:13:03on what is going on with this we
- 00:13:05consider the issue to be resolved and
- 00:13:07did not make any public announcements to
- 00:13:09avoid drawing attention from intrigued
- 00:13:11community members who may seek out these
- 00:13:13illicit photos themselves to spread
- 00:13:14around for amusement so remember guys
- 00:13:17this is the Predator we are talking
- 00:13:19about we need to make sure that he
- 00:13:21doesn't get embarrassed from people
- 00:13:23spreading photos of him they didn't tell
- 00:13:25people that this guy was talking to kids
- 00:13:27because they wanted to protect his
- 00:13:29photos are you kid dude do I even need
- 00:13:31to explain why that's just Mar
- 00:13:34inaccurately described as a fourth
- 00:13:36developer I think I said he's number
- 00:13:38four like the fourth most important
- 00:13:40developer on the game and yes
- 00:13:41technically he isn't a developer he was
- 00:13:43a contractor but in terms of the
- 00:13:45hierarchy and the people working at
- 00:13:47stylist he was number four I don't think
- 00:13:48you guys can argue that he wasn't number
- 00:13:50four so they're saying I inaccurately
- 00:13:52described him as a fourth developer I
- 00:13:53think I said he was the fourth most
- 00:13:55important and they're saying oh this is
- 00:13:57not the definition of a developer I
- 00:13:58meant is the fourth most important
- 00:14:00person working on the game if he's not
- 00:14:01technically a developer he's technically
- 00:14:03a contractor I guess you can use that to
- 00:14:05say this claim is completely false was
- 00:14:07one of our former contractors hired to
- 00:14:09manage content updates during a time
- 00:14:10when the lead developers myself were
- 00:14:12busy with college so he was doing a lot
- 00:14:15of this stuff during that time the video
- 00:14:16summarizes the strings of his
- 00:14:17inappropriate messaging conduct uh
- 00:14:20conduct sorry with Miners and the timing
- 00:14:22of his announcements to quit suddenly
- 00:14:24when we perceived reports of these our
- 00:14:25initial perception was that it was the
- 00:14:27start of another attempted WI hunt it's
- 00:14:29funny that the two people that have been
- 00:14:31uh quote unquote witch hunted uh
- 00:14:33actually talked to miners due to Mar's
- 00:14:34wavering reputation among certain
- 00:14:36community members he was pretty hated
- 00:14:38though he was pretty hated though I
- 00:14:39remember a lot of people didn't like him
- 00:14:40nonetheless we took the allegation
- 00:14:42seriously and we asked him to step down
- 00:14:44out of respect while we reviewed the
- 00:14:46reports basically for Juke they left him
- 00:14:47as a content creator and presumed he
- 00:14:50learned his lesson the guy who actually
- 00:14:52was confirmed to talk to kids he's
- 00:14:54allowed to stay on but Mah who was very
- 00:14:56hated and people could have
- 00:14:57realistically faked these screenshots he
- 00:14:59had to step down but Juke didn't which
- 00:15:01is bad because the M thing happened
- 00:15:03before Juke so for Mah they made him
- 00:15:05step down and then for Juke they kept
- 00:15:07him on it's like they got worse at it in
- 00:15:09what world would you have him step down
- 00:15:11if you didn't believe it was true but
- 00:15:13then for the guy where it actually
- 00:15:15happened you didn't it doesn't make any
- 00:15:17sense as the evidence turned out to be
- 00:15:19validated his voluntary resignation
- 00:15:21transformed into a permanent dismissal
- 00:15:23from our team are you sure about that
- 00:15:25actually are you sure about that
- 00:15:26actually however we determined his
- 00:15:28overall fractions were not on the same
- 00:15:30level as Juke and so this was deemed
- 00:15:32sufficiently handled an additional
- 00:15:34announcement for his further departure
- 00:15:35seemed unnecessary remember guys this is
- 00:15:38the number four guy goes Leo Axis
- 00:15:43shin7 or whatever his name is and then
- 00:15:45it went Mah Mah was number four you
- 00:15:46can't argue on that he was the number
- 00:15:48four guy in fact from their own
- 00:15:50statements in this he was essentially
- 00:15:51the number one guy on the game during
- 00:15:53this but when he talks to miners in the
- 00:15:56server where he is making a game which
- 00:15:58also happens to be a kids game you don't
- 00:16:00have to announce it you you guys don't
- 00:16:01actually have to announce it it's
- 00:16:02actually perfectly fine because yes his
- 00:16:04Discord is still around his Twitter is
- 00:16:06still around all of his stuff is still
- 00:16:08there especially the not safe for work
- 00:16:10accounts he has are still around and you
- 00:16:12didn't tell anybody that he likes kids
- 00:16:15in hindsight this was an unsatisfactory
- 00:16:17response for the community and we
- 00:16:18acknowledge that inadequacy in our
- 00:16:20thought process okay on their own each
- 00:16:22of these are very weird and I would be
- 00:16:24like what what are these guys doing but
- 00:16:26when you put together every single one
- 00:16:28yeah it's a consistent Behavior with
- 00:16:30these people Willow the next contractor
- 00:16:31to replace m is later found with similar
- 00:16:33reports of inappropriate messaging
- 00:16:35Behavior with miners summary of how the
- 00:16:37reports were handled is presented
- 00:16:39leading up to a public firing of Willow
- 00:16:41based on additional evidence that was
- 00:16:42later discovered to unveil the true
- 00:16:45severity of their infractions they were
- 00:16:47pretty bad I saw some of the things
- 00:16:50shrider concludes here that stylist has
- 00:16:51learned their lesson in making a public
- 00:16:53announcement this time compared to the
- 00:16:55previous cases however Strider
- 00:16:56immediately follows up to make a highly
- 00:16:58accused and fabricated claim that sid9
- 00:17:01is secretly Willow using an ALT account
- 00:17:03for sid9 who I have spent countless
- 00:17:04hours training to onboard into the PF
- 00:17:06content pipeline systems on such short
- 00:17:09notice this is outright insulting to the
- 00:17:11team we chose sid9 a close mutual friend
- 00:17:13among the leay developers with blah blah
- 00:17:15blah blah of ill intentions and we hope
- 00:17:16that the community would continue to
- 00:17:18respect his dedication and keeping
- 00:17:20Phantom Force's content ongoing I will
- 00:17:22say that the willow thing is the only
- 00:17:24thing I was like maybe it's not true
- 00:17:26which why I said allegedly the fact that
- 00:17:28between the days when axis said that
- 00:17:31Willow was stepping down with the
- 00:17:33ability to come back and permanently
- 00:17:35stepping down the sid9 account was
- 00:17:37created and said I'm going to be the
- 00:17:38next contractor is super weird remember
- 00:17:40they said that they were going to become
- 00:17:42a contractor before the extra things
- 00:17:43about Willow came out so this is sid9
- 00:17:45being created on a day where Willow
- 00:17:48could still come back to the game and
- 00:17:50then immediately saying oh I want to be
- 00:17:52a contractor someday is that not
- 00:17:54suspicious also the person that told me
- 00:17:56this is somebody who I hope will come
- 00:17:58forward because I do trust that they
- 00:18:00would know things like this they were a
- 00:18:02person that had a lot of community
- 00:18:04connections but unfortunately that
- 00:18:05person has not come forward I really
- 00:18:07hope they will you can see this is the
- 00:18:09thing that proves that my video is bad
- 00:18:12the only problem is let's go back up to
- 00:18:14Mar okay we took the allegation
- 00:18:15seriously and we asked him to step down
- 00:18:17out of respect remember that was on
- 00:18:19April Fool's Day 2021 however apparently
- 00:18:22in October of 2021 had a conversation
- 00:18:25with Shayan 007 which is the third main
- 00:18:28develop as I said about the fact that
- 00:18:30Mah could maybe be working on the game
- 00:18:33still and after pushing Shay enough he
- 00:18:35said he's in the process of onboarding
- 00:18:38new developers so 6 months after they
- 00:18:40had him stepped down he was still
- 00:18:41working on the game this isn't Willow
- 00:18:43we're talking about this is mar however
- 00:18:45the willow thing happened after Mar so
- 00:18:47if they let Mar stay around for that
- 00:18:49long they're probably going to let
- 00:18:51Willow stay a little bit after as well
- 00:18:53and they both do not deserve to be
- 00:18:55getting paid to work on a children's
- 00:18:57game after they got fired after they
- 00:18:59were exposed it can happen with one and
- 00:19:01so it can probably happen with the other
- 00:19:03and before I was about to start
- 00:19:04recording this video I actually got
- 00:19:06another Smoking Gun about this which is
- 00:19:08that oh my gosh I cannot believe this
- 00:19:10happened in 2022 I think February corny
- 00:19:13uploaded a video about the shotguns
- 00:19:14getting nerfed in Phantom Forces Corney
- 00:19:16used to be a Phantom Forces YouTuber now
- 00:19:18he just a Roblox YouTuber the reason
- 00:19:20that he knew about this update was that
- 00:19:22guess who dm'd him about it it was mar
- 00:19:25mar sent me a nice little DM he said
- 00:19:28just want to let you know if something
- 00:19:29you might be interested in test place is
- 00:19:30finally out after much delay or whatever
- 00:19:32remember guys this is February 2022 10
- 00:19:37months later so yeah well I can't prove
- 00:19:39that Willow was still working on the
- 00:19:40game I think M was still working on the
- 00:19:42game because the devs actually said this
- 00:19:44further in the video srider chooses out
- 00:19:46of context clips of axis's stream to
- 00:19:48imply that axis must be feeling some
- 00:19:50sort of PR guilt with these unprompted
- 00:19:52statements on stream going as far as to
- 00:19:54make connections to juke's actions I
- 00:19:56just said is he a Juke type individual
- 00:19:59I don't know and then I put maybe on the
- 00:20:01screen because of what happened after
- 00:20:03this editing Choice comes across as
- 00:20:05highly disingenuous and malicious and
- 00:20:06openly threatening and I don't think
- 00:20:08this is highly disingenuous or malicious
- 00:20:10to say maybe we'll get into that we'll
- 00:20:11get into that I can't believe this dude
- 00:20:14I can't believe it yeah cuz we'll get
- 00:20:16into this and finally Strider makes the
- 00:20:17claim that stylist has chosen to cover
- 00:20:19up all of its behaviors and private
- 00:20:21chats particularly pretending to access
- 00:20:23angles chat records back in 2016 which
- 00:20:26they did as of a few days ago multiple
- 00:20:28users have coincidentally reported these
- 00:20:30messages to us and presented their
- 00:20:31concerns to us regarding the hazards of
- 00:20:33a top developer having made such
- 00:20:36messages the blah blah blah they further
- 00:20:38recommended that we take action
- 00:20:39immediately to purge these messages so
- 00:20:41that our younger community members would
- 00:20:43not be able to chance upon them upon
- 00:20:45review we agreed with this decision to
- 00:20:46replace all of our public channels as
- 00:20:49suggested by the user report Strider
- 00:20:51however claims this is an act of
- 00:20:52covering up evidence of wrongdoing which
- 00:20:54we firmly refute with our motivation
- 00:20:56stated here except that now you can't
- 00:20:58see any of the bad messages any of the
- 00:21:00mods and developers have made oh my gosh
- 00:21:03it's such a coincidence that you can't
- 00:21:04see any of them anymore what the freak
- 00:21:06oh no there's even more access messages
- 00:21:08like this one uh which was in 2018 which
- 00:21:11is he was 22 but man if there were more
- 00:21:14of them I mean dude it's so unlucky that
- 00:21:17you guys can't find it anymore oh no as
- 00:21:19for Access angle chat Behavior they were
- 00:21:21Unbecoming for a lead developer involved
- 00:21:23sensitive topics that do not abide by
- 00:21:25our Discord guidelines today we would
- 00:21:28however point out that the message it
- 00:21:29was sent is dark
- 00:21:31satire import during an age of
- 00:21:33immaturity immaturity at the age of 20
- 00:21:36years old once again these statements
- 00:21:37are super weird and happened on multiple
- 00:21:41different occasions same with the twitch
- 00:21:42thing I saw the twitch Clips months and
- 00:21:44months ago but I didn't immediately jump
- 00:21:45and make a video because none of it had
- 00:21:47clicked yet you know what I mean most of
- 00:21:49the things from this video I learned in
- 00:21:50the past couple of weeks just by
- 00:21:52investigating and I do believe that
- 00:21:53these messages could have been dark
- 00:21:55satire like really really bad jokes it
- 00:21:58was 16 you know he was 20 years old and
- 00:22:00joking about that stuff still pretty
- 00:22:02it's still really bad it's the fact that
- 00:22:04these guys are essentially just
- 00:22:05admitting to everything I talked about
- 00:22:07in the video they refute two things
- 00:22:09which is the willow thing and then they
- 00:22:10come up with like a couple random things
- 00:22:12that I said wrong in the video but
- 00:22:14everything else they've said my bad my
- 00:22:16bad we should have we should have maybe
- 00:22:18probably maybe announced this and like I
- 00:22:20said one of those things on its own is
- 00:22:22still weird but it's not enough for me
- 00:22:23to turn on this game make this video but
- 00:22:26it's everything that I found and I found
- 00:22:28so many things nonetheless our studio
- 00:22:29will continue to evaluate if action is
- 00:22:32needed against axis angle depending on
- 00:22:34whether further reports of victims
- 00:22:35involved due to his behavior will
- 00:22:37surface to us oh my gosh I think these
- 00:22:40people live in the same house with each
- 00:22:42other by the way I think they do I I
- 00:22:44can't remember them but guys they
- 00:22:45wouldn't even know if axis angles has
- 00:22:47done anything before please nobody come
- 00:22:49up with anything or else we're going to
- 00:22:50have to fire him until then we currently
- 00:22:52stand by our conviction that none of
- 00:22:53these statements alone indicate the axis
- 00:22:55angle yeah none of these statements
- 00:22:57alone I agree with that none of these
- 00:22:58statements alone indicate that axis
- 00:23:00angle or any of the lead developers
- 00:23:02myself or Shay are in support a behavior
- 00:23:04against minors to continue baseless
- 00:23:06claims with these as evidence would be
- 00:23:08considered acts of defamation against
- 00:23:09their team is this supposed to be like A
- 00:23:11Veiled Threat of a defamation lawsuit
- 00:23:13there is no way you can say this is
- 00:23:15defamation you guys just admitted to
- 00:23:16everything in this video basically and
- 00:23:18for the one thing that I don't know
- 00:23:20which is the willow thing I got that
- 00:23:21information from a different person and
- 00:23:23also said allegedly because that was the
- 00:23:24one thing I didn't really know like I
- 00:23:26said none of these statements alone
- 00:23:27indicate any of these things however
- 00:23:30together I do think that they do
- 00:23:32indicate something but it does show that
- 00:23:34they do not care what happens to people
- 00:23:37as long as they're not really impacted
- 00:23:39they have continued to sweep this under
- 00:23:40the rug which is why this video
- 00:23:42completely blew up the community because
- 00:23:43pretty much everybody underneath the
- 00:23:45surface has been thinking about these
- 00:23:47things and it really just took somebody
- 00:23:49to connect the dots and realize that
- 00:23:51this is not something that should be
- 00:23:53happening on a Roblox game or any game
- 00:23:55in general to be honest ultimately my
- 00:23:57goal is to provide great games that our
- 00:23:59community can enjoy we have a lot to
- 00:24:01learn and improve with how we handle our
- 00:24:02community but we will continue to make
- 00:24:04our best effort with our staff and core
- 00:24:06development team dude this is sad it
- 00:24:09would be so easy it's like Roblox the
- 00:24:11same thing with Ruben Sim where you have
- 00:24:13people that are trying to help you get
- 00:24:15these people out of your community but
- 00:24:17you seem to essentially be doing not
- 00:24:19just nothing but you essentially seem to
- 00:24:21be pushing back against it it's so weird
- 00:24:24but before we get to all the other
- 00:24:25statements let's get into the first axis
- 00:24:27angles apolog okay cuz this is a really
- 00:24:30important apology to talk about as you
- 00:24:31guys probably know from the first video
- 00:24:33the day before I uploaded that video a
- 00:24:35bunch of axis angles old messages got
- 00:24:37leaked and this was axis angle's apology
- 00:24:39for that because he really does care
- 00:24:40about his apology guys and this one is
- 00:24:42sh lauff saying this morning we received
- 00:24:45multiple reports regarding edgy jokes
- 00:24:47made in the server back in 2016 we don't
- 00:24:49personally subscribe to the comment
- 00:24:50jokes made when reviewing the evidence
- 00:24:53we came to the conclusion that almost
- 00:24:54all the server messages at that time
- 00:24:56required some level of action on our
- 00:24:58part acknowledging this we decided to
- 00:24:59arcave all channels created before 2018
- 00:25:02the server started as a community that
- 00:25:04didn't take itself seriously and with
- 00:25:05that our server rules policies and
- 00:25:07channels reflected that when the server
- 00:25:09became partnered and linked to Phantom
- 00:25:10Forces all of that changed hopefully
- 00:25:13people understand why we arive chats
- 00:25:15going through two years of very active
- 00:25:17chat messages in multiple channels just
- 00:25:19didn't seem feasible wait I thought this
- 00:25:20was about axis angles messages why is it
- 00:25:23written by a different person and it
- 00:25:25doesn't mention him and he doesn't
- 00:25:26apologize that's because this was the
- 00:25:28day that the access messages got leaked
- 00:25:30but because I didn't upload my video
- 00:25:33these people weren't pressured to do
- 00:25:34anything which is why they were going to
- 00:25:35sweep it under the rug again dude it's
- 00:25:37so silly that it's been 3 days as of
- 00:25:39uploading this video since they wrote
- 00:25:41this message and in their response
- 00:25:42they're trying to pretend they don't
- 00:25:44sweep things under the rug even though
- 00:25:46when axis made these messages they shut
- 00:25:48down the Discord and then posted this
- 00:25:51instead of him apologizing it's
- 00:25:54ridiculous unless I uploaded this video
- 00:25:57nothing would happen happened this is
- 00:25:58why I uploaded the video now we have the
- 00:26:00axis angle apology and it has some good
- 00:26:02in it it says I have several major
- 00:26:04regrets I am embarrassed by my conduct
- 00:26:06in the early days of the Discord and how
- 00:26:08my actions normalized misbehavior and
- 00:26:10put adult topics in a place accessible
- 00:26:12to miners these unnuanced provocative
- 00:26:14takes and vulgar jokes were not right
- 00:26:15for me to make for that I am sorry which
- 00:26:18if this was the only thing that he did
- 00:26:20and there's even more stuff that people
- 00:26:22have found and dm'd me about but if this
- 00:26:23was the only thing he did I would be
- 00:26:25like that is so weird but I think if he
- 00:26:27made an apology it would have been fine
- 00:26:29but the problem is he had the
- 00:26:31opportunity to make an apology but when
- 00:26:33people found his messages instead he had
- 00:26:36a different person make a statement that
- 00:26:39didn't even mention him and it's really
- 00:26:41sad because a lot of people have been
- 00:26:42throwing so much stuff at axis angle and
- 00:26:45it's really sad because I I did not
- 00:26:47think that axis angle would would do
- 00:26:50that he said he failed to protect our
- 00:26:52community from Juke I failed to gain an
- 00:26:54understanding of what he really was
- 00:26:55allowing him to keep making content
- 00:26:57which is great that he responded to this
- 00:26:59and like I said this would have been a
- 00:27:01good response to this if this was the
- 00:27:04only thing that happened and this is not
- 00:27:05the only thing that happen that's the
- 00:27:07problem I want to address some claims in
- 00:27:08the video there are accusations that
- 00:27:10sid9 is actually Willow sid9 is not
- 00:27:13Willow please do not harass him when I
- 00:27:14said that we may rehire Willow this was
- 00:27:17after we removed her but before real
- 00:27:19evidence came through the first claims
- 00:27:21to come out against Willow while not
- 00:27:22Savory were not illegal and seemed
- 00:27:24politically motivated there was a lot of
- 00:27:26nuance here the day after the fact more
- 00:27:27people came out this time with
- 00:27:29legitimate claims against Willow which
- 00:27:31we immediately acted on I was never
- 00:27:32juke's friends my first real
- 00:27:34interactions just after I learned of him
- 00:27:36occurred at Midwest furfest when he
- 00:27:39asked if we could meet up for dinner it
- 00:27:40was the most awkward set of interactions
- 00:27:42I've ever had he manipulated another
- 00:27:44person into giving him money so he could
- 00:27:45buy me something then tried to
- 00:27:47manipulate me into being his boyfriend
- 00:27:49after drinking a whole bottle of my wine
- 00:27:51but at least in 2021 you were like 26 at
- 00:27:54the time I didn't see this as
- 00:27:56manipulation but what he didn't Juke
- 00:27:59would tell a Sab story get you to feel
- 00:28:00sorry for him then turn around and
- 00:28:02whatever lenience you gave him it was
- 00:28:04like he could not stop himself from
- 00:28:05taking the worst possible action at
- 00:28:07every opportunity my takeaway is that I
- 00:28:09got a small taste of what it's like to
- 00:28:11be one of juke's victims unfortunately
- 00:28:13the reason why I was on stream talking
- 00:28:14about different levels of infraction and
- 00:28:16harm is because ironically cancel
- 00:28:19culture makes no room for nuance for me
- 00:28:21cancel culture just means you said
- 00:28:23something bad back in 2016 this is a
- 00:28:25little bit different than what I would
- 00:28:27normally think I would normally think of
- 00:28:29um just a off-color joke and yeah the
- 00:28:31things that he said in 2016 were pretty
- 00:28:33bad they were in a kids server but it's
- 00:28:35everything else that's the problem I
- 00:28:37wasn't even going to put those
- 00:28:38screenshots in the video until I
- 00:28:41realized that he was 20 when he said
- 00:28:42that because I understand that people
- 00:28:43make really weird jokes but to be 20
- 00:28:46years old in a kids game server that you
- 00:28:48own saying those things and then doing
- 00:28:50everything else dude come on man but
- 00:28:53maybe my position as a privileged male
- 00:28:55allows me the Comfort to consider more
- 00:28:57nuanced takes unfortunate what I don't
- 00:28:59know what that mean unfortunately I feel
- 00:29:01my presumption that people are not out
- 00:29:03to cause harm actually in turn makes
- 00:29:05room for those people to perpetuate it
- 00:29:07maybe Juke is not the exception but a
- 00:29:10norm okay is he talking about me saying
- 00:29:12I am out to cause har and cancel culture
- 00:29:15or whatever absolutely not the case
- 00:29:17because I actually liked this game I'll
- 00:29:20probably go into that in part two but I
- 00:29:23dude I did not I did not want to have to
- 00:29:26make the video that I did did we have
- 00:29:29always given second chances at stylist
- 00:29:31this is probably a mistake in many in
- 00:29:33many cases I've already taken major
- 00:29:35steps to prevent Juke and Willow like
- 00:29:36cases we will formally discuss policy
- 00:29:38changes with staff to better address the
- 00:29:40future the problem with this is that
- 00:29:42this did not happen after Juke this did
- 00:29:45not happen after Willow this did not
- 00:29:48happen even after axis was exposed this
- 00:29:51is after my video so the fact that these
- 00:29:53people are saying that my video is
- 00:29:55slanderous and is spreading a hateful
- 00:29:56narrative and all this stuff but they
- 00:29:58only only make changes when I made my
- 00:30:02video can I does that it's just
- 00:30:05ridiculous it's just ridiculous dude
- 00:30:08this is so stupid I cannot believe that
- 00:30:11they wait until my video and then
- 00:30:12they're like well actually this video is
- 00:30:14bad but actually going to maybe start
- 00:30:16actually doing something about this
- 00:30:17stuff they finally start to bring this
- 00:30:19stuff up when I bring it to light and
- 00:30:21then they say this video is actually
- 00:30:23very bad and harmful but you will
- 00:30:25continue to cover it up until I actually
- 00:30:28talk about it it's ridiculous now this
- 00:30:29is the most fun part of this okay
- 00:30:31finally if anyone has evidence of me
- 00:30:34victimizing or abusing them they can
- 00:30:36make it public or report it to staff and
- 00:30:38then we can deal with the
- 00:30:40consequences C can you guys read that
- 00:30:42again so he made an apology but there's
- 00:30:45definitely something else going on here
- 00:30:47how else are people supposed to take
- 00:30:49that message if anyone has evidence you
- 00:30:51should make a report and then we can
- 00:30:52deal with the consequences if you didn't
- 00:30:55do anything he wouldn't say this he
- 00:30:57wouldn't say if he didn't do anything I
- 00:30:59talked to Ruben Sim both of us could
- 00:31:00agree that axis was weird I think this
- 00:31:02game is harmful and um it's sad because
- 00:31:05I really liked the game but I can't
- 00:31:07really take this any other way I I think
- 00:31:09that that yeah I don't know dude and
- 00:31:11then AIS angle says we are working with
- 00:31:13staff to assess what we will do moving
- 00:31:15forward how much staff we will have left
- 00:31:17and how to make changes to our policy to
- 00:31:19provide a safe environment for the
- 00:31:21community we will announce this action
- 00:31:23plan in addition to some clarifying
- 00:31:25statements in a follow-up response this
- 00:31:26may take a while but probably doing here
- 00:31:29is preparing to throw axess angles under
- 00:31:31the bus and say that the other two
- 00:31:33developers are fine and that they
- 00:31:35weren't involved in anything and we can
- 00:31:38just keep moving on am I clean are you
- 00:31:40kidding me dude anyway this video has
- 00:31:41been very difficult to record um but
- 00:31:45yeah I hope I can explain why this
- 00:31:47response was not good uh yeah so you
- 00:31:49guys
- Stylist Studios
- Allegations
- Community
- Discord
- Inappropriate Conduct
- Transparency
- Accountability
- Minors
- Response
- Negligence