00:00:00
from the undeniable hits of the
00:00:01
Backstreet Boys in in sync to the
00:00:03
breakout success of One Direction and
00:00:05
the Jonas Brothers every generation has
00:00:07
their teenage heart throb and for teens
00:00:09
and pre-teens in 2009 that position was
00:00:12
unmistakenly occupied by Justin Bieber
00:00:15
known as bers Justin fans were known to
00:00:17
pack Arenas flood social media with
00:00:20
endless posts and even cause near riots
00:00:22
at his appearances this Behavior was so
00:00:25
common that it was even given a name
00:00:27
Bieber Fever was taking over the world
00:00:29
with one famous case in Australia where
00:00:32
they had to cancel the show after only a
00:00:34
few minutes as eight girls in the crowd
00:00:36
fainted after catching a glimpse of the
00:00:38
artist while teens and pre-teens around
00:00:40
the world dreamed of being Justin's baby
00:00:43
Believers would never get the chance and
00:00:45
eventually grow out of the fandom but
00:00:47
what if I told you one believer never
00:00:49
gave up in fact she was there the whole
00:00:51
time lurking in the shadows using her
00:00:54
famous friends and Dad's Hollywood
00:00:56
Connections to turn her 13-year-old
00:00:58
dream into reality this this is the
00:01:00
story of how Relentless ambition and a
00:01:02
hidden agenda turned Haley Baldwin into
00:01:05
one less lonely
00:01:07
girl following the 2009 release of
00:01:09
Justin Bieber's debut singles one time
00:01:12
and one less lonely girl he was invited
00:01:15
on to the Today Show to perform them
00:01:17
unbeknownst to Justin this appearance
00:01:19
would completely change his life as
00:01:21
Haley Baldwin's father Steven Baldwin
00:01:24
would take her backstage to meet
00:01:26
15-year-old Justin Bieber when she was
00:01:28
just 13 years old my daughter
00:01:32
haly we've been we've been enjoying
00:01:34
music like many 13-year-old girls of the
00:01:37
time Haley likely had a crush on Justin
00:01:39
and her father Steven was using his
00:01:41
connections to do something sweet for
00:01:43
his daughter however this wouldn't be
00:01:45
the only time Haley was around Justin
00:01:48
before he really knew who she was for
00:01:50
example Haley would also appear at
00:01:53
Justin's Toyota concert series
00:01:55
performance in Rockefeller Plaza before
00:01:57
following him to Los Angeles to attend
00:02:00
the premiere of his movie Never Say
00:02:02
Never where she can be seen watching him
00:02:04
from the sidelines as he walks the
00:02:05
purple carpet Steven Baldwin would
00:02:08
actually pull some strings that allowed
00:02:10
Haley to meet Justin again and this
00:02:12
would give us their first photo together
00:02:14
4 months later Haley would even be
00:02:16
photographed posing with a photo of
00:02:18
Justin Bieber on the cover of M magazine
00:02:21
while attending the premiere of the 2011
00:02:23
movie Monty Carlo something ironic about
00:02:26
this is that Justin's photograph is next
00:02:28
to his new at the time girl friend
00:02:30
Selena Gomez who also starred in the
00:02:32
Monte Carlo movie and would soon become
00:02:35
Haley's Arch Enemy it's clear by this
00:02:37
point that Haley baldman wanted Justin
00:02:39
Bieber for herself and even though
00:02:41
Selena Gomez took him off the market
00:02:43
Haley wasn't going to give up so easily
00:02:45
for example in 2012 Justin Bieber and
00:02:48
Selena Gomez would enjoy a date night
00:02:51
together where they would eat sushi and
00:02:53
go to the movie theater however
00:02:55
paparazzi photos and videos would reveal
00:02:58
that none other than Haley Baldwin was
00:03:00
following them around on their date
00:03:02
keeping an eye on Justin now it's
00:03:05
possible all of this has been a
00:03:06
coincidence Haley does have a famous
00:03:08
father and the Hollywood circle is
00:03:10
smaller than it appears except that in
00:03:13
2019 a self-proclaimed former Justin
00:03:16
Bieber Super Fan posted a video on
00:03:18
YouTube where she claims to have helped
00:03:20
set up Haley with Justin and has the
00:03:22
receipts to show for it I feel like this
00:03:24
is an opening to a documentary I used to
00:03:27
be a Bieber fan and I'm not talking a
00:03:28
Bieber fan I'm walking a New York City
00:03:31
Bieber fan and we've all been there but
00:03:33
I lived in New York City and I had the
00:03:34
resources to go see him according to
00:03:36
this video Dana the former Super Fan
00:03:39
used to run a Justin Bieber fan account
00:03:41
with over 200,000 followers and had
00:03:43
become somewhat of a niche internet
00:03:45
celebrity amongst the Justin Bieber
00:03:47
Community 15-year-old Haley Baldwin
00:03:50
followed Dana in 2011 and over time she
00:03:53
would become friendly with her online
00:03:55
regularly tweeting back and forth and
00:03:57
dming her for Intel on just Bieber's
00:04:00
location here you're going to see where
00:04:02
I wrote saai fifth app the DM that was
00:04:04
right above that that she sent to me is
00:04:06
gone because she unsent it right away
00:04:08
and if I went back to my MacBook from
00:04:10
2013 maybe I could find that because
00:04:12
above that and you're going to have to
00:04:14
take my word for this one cuz I don't
00:04:16
have it but she said what hotel is
00:04:18
Justin staying at Kylie and I want to
00:04:20
know according to Dana when she would
00:04:22
give Haley information on what hotel
00:04:25
Justin Bieber was staying at Haley would
00:04:27
either book a room there or eat at the
00:04:29
hotel room restaurant Haley's goal was
00:04:31
to cross paths with Justin Bieber as
00:04:34
much as possible in hopes that he one
00:04:36
day considered her a potential partner
00:04:38
we would give her that info because she
00:04:40
would either stay at that hotel or she
00:04:41
would eat at that hotel or do whatever
00:04:44
at that hotel so she could bump into him
00:04:46
KY Baldwin went from trying to bump into
00:04:50
Justin Bieber at the saai the London to
00:04:53
marriage is so iconic like everyone's
00:04:55
making a joke that it was her 10year
00:04:56
plan like Dana even shows tweet S A now
00:05:00
16-year-old Haley Baldwin sent to her
00:05:02
where Haley discusses Justin Bieber's
00:05:04
height and speculates how much more he
00:05:06
will grow something you would expect a
00:05:08
Super Fan to tweet even back in 2013
00:05:12
Haley was serious about protecting her
00:05:14
man and would ask if the DMS Dana
00:05:16
tweeted from Justin Bieber were real or
00:05:19
not with Dana confirming to her that she
00:05:21
was just making a joke although it's
00:05:23
difficult to believe everything you hear
00:05:24
on the Internet it's worth mentioning
00:05:26
that Haley Baldwin actually participated
00:05:29
in a Justin Bieber fan video
00:05:31
orchestrated By Dana after Justin Bieber
00:05:34
and Selena Gomez released a lipsync
00:05:36
video to Karly Ray jepson's Call Me
00:05:38
Maybe Dana and several other Justin
00:05:41
Bieber super fans recreated it with none
00:05:44
other than Haley Baldwin sending Dana a
00:05:46
clip of herself to include in the fan
00:05:49
Recreation at this point in time Justin
00:05:51
Bieber and Selena Gomez had broken up
00:05:53
and gotten back together multiple times
00:05:56
but 2014 would Mark the beginning of
00:05:58
their longest break yet and luckily for
00:06:00
Haley she had become close with Kylie
00:06:03
and Kendall Jenner this is important
00:06:05
because Justin was also friends with the
00:06:07
Jenner Sisters and because they now
00:06:09
shared mutual friends Haley's access to
00:06:12
Justin had never been easier she would
00:06:14
no longer have to rely on believer fan
00:06:16
accounts to give her Intel on his
00:06:18
location now she could simply ask her
00:06:20
friends this new found connection with
00:06:23
the Jenner Sisters proved valuable and
00:06:25
things were looking up for Haley after
00:06:27
she was spotted getting dinner with
00:06:29
Justin going to a movie and then going
00:06:31
back to his house where she wouldn't be
00:06:33
seen leaving until the following morning
00:06:36
however with Justin's heart healing from
00:06:38
the recent breakup with Selena and New
00:06:40
Year's Eve quickly approaching haly had
00:06:42
her eyes on the prize and didn't want to
00:06:44
risk Selena ruining that for her it's a
00:06:47
little loose but fans speculate that
00:06:49
Selena Gomez last minute New Year's Eve
00:06:51
trip to Dubai with Kendall Jenner and
00:06:53
Gigi Hadid was actually a setup to put
00:06:56
Haley and Justin together with Selena
00:06:59
out of the country the chances of Justin
00:07:01
and Selena rekindling their relationship
00:07:04
at midnight were now zero unfortunately
00:07:06
for Haley Justin would make it clear
00:07:08
that he wasn't looking for a new partner
00:07:10
and instead was more focused on having
00:07:13
fun and just like old times Haley would
00:07:15
defend her territory after Hy was
00:07:18
photographed leaving a building with
00:07:19
Justin Haley would post a video of
00:07:21
herself to social media telling her
00:07:23
driver to change the radio station after
00:07:25
a Hy song started playing can you change
00:07:28
the station
00:07:30
please this is when Haley really started
00:07:33
to lose the plot and get progressively
00:07:35
more and more bold with her actions
00:07:37
while Justin and Selena were still
00:07:39
separated Justin would do a series of
00:07:41
interviews where he Praises Selena and
00:07:43
describes her as the love of his life
00:07:45
going on to say they were quote so in
00:07:48
love nothing else mattered we were all
00:07:51
about each other clearly feeling jealous
00:07:53
about how Justin was speaking of his ex
00:07:55
Haley began accidentally retweeting
00:07:58
tweets that shipped Justin Bieber and
00:08:01
herself as well as tweets from people
00:08:03
wishing that Haley would fight Selena
00:08:05
this is when Haley's Behavior stops
00:08:07
coming across as enthusiastic and starts
00:08:10
coming off as obsessive as over the next
00:08:13
couple of years she would seemingly try
00:08:15
and mold herself to be more like Selena
00:08:18
Gomez in hopes of receiving attention
00:08:20
from Justin for example Haley has a
00:08:23
tendency to copy Selena's outfits and
00:08:26
poses fans have dug up many examples of
00:08:29
haly posting photos shortly after Selena
00:08:32
where she's either wearing the same
00:08:33
exact outfit or something very similar
00:08:36
the copying allegations even extend to
00:08:38
the poses she makes in the photos as
00:08:41
well as her facial expressions now if
00:08:43
you're shopping at the same stores or
00:08:45
keeping up with the current fashion meta
00:08:48
the reality is your outfits are going to
00:08:50
overlap with what other people are
00:08:52
wearing but all of these outfits were
00:08:55
posted by Selena first with Haley
00:08:58
sometimes posting her in the same exact
00:09:00
outfit as soon as 24 hours later the
00:09:03
accessories the facial expressions The
00:09:06
Outfits they're all the same but it
00:09:08
doesn't just stop with clothes on June
00:09:11
4th 2015 Selena Gomez would be spotted
00:09:15
with a new tattoo behind her ear this
00:09:17
tattoo is just the letter G and is
00:09:19
supposedly a tribute to her baby sister
00:09:21
Gracie however on June 16th just 12 Days
00:09:25
Later Haley Baldwin would be spotted
00:09:28
sporting an almost identical G tattoo in
00:09:31
the same exact location as Selena's
00:09:34
Haley would claim that the tattoo is an
00:09:36
homage to her pastor's daughter Georgia
00:09:39
but Haley seemingly copying Selena while
00:09:42
simultaneously rooting on her downfall
00:09:44
will become harder and harder to ignore
00:09:47
in February of 2018 Selena Gomez would
00:09:50
check herself into the preva Swiss
00:09:52
psychiatric facility in Connecticut a
00:09:54
facility that offers therapy for
00:09:57
individuals needing a retreat from
00:09:59
profile always on Lifestyles and Haley
00:10:02
would allegedly drive past Selena's home
00:10:05
with her pastor's wife to make sure
00:10:07
Selena was still in therapy the rest of
00:10:10
2018 is kind of confusing as Justin
00:10:13
Bieber would get back together with
00:10:15
Selina Gomez for a couple of months
00:10:17
before she finally broke up with him for
00:10:19
good only for Justin to marry Haley 6
00:10:22
months later Haley would later claim in
00:10:24
interviews that she and Justin
00:10:26
officially started dating in 2016 but if
00:10:29
that's the case why was Justin dating
00:10:32
Selena just months before your wedding
00:10:34
either way Haley Baldwin was now Haley
00:10:37
Bieber and even though she got what she
00:10:39
seemingly always wanted it still wasn't
00:10:42
enough following the release of Selena
00:10:44
Gomez song lose you to love me Haley
00:10:47
would immediately post a screenshot of
00:10:49
her playing summer Walker's song I'll
00:10:51
kill you while Haley would claim the
00:10:53
timing was merely a coincidence many
00:10:56
fans interpreted this post as another
00:10:58
attack on Selena to make matters more
00:11:01
confusing in 2019 Haley Bieber would
00:11:04
debut another tattoo this time on her
00:11:06
ring finger and featured the letter J
00:11:09
this tattoo is clearly a Justin Bieber
00:11:11
tribute however fans were quick to
00:11:13
notice that it shares a striking
00:11:15
resemblance to a ring Justin Bieber
00:11:17
bought Selena Gomez all the way back in
00:11:20
2012 a couple months later Haley even
00:11:23
made sure to crash Selena's album
00:11:25
release party being held at the
00:11:27
restaurant Craigs in West Hollywood
00:11:29
despite not being invited by making sure
00:11:31
to arrive there before it started and
00:11:33
staying long enough to overlap with the
00:11:35
event only leaving through a back door
00:11:37
when Selena left her party according to
00:11:40
tweets from the evening of the party
00:11:42
once Selena arrived the restaurant
00:11:44
started playing her music and that
00:11:46
didn't sit right with Haley Haley
00:11:48
stylist mave asked a waitress to play
00:11:50
the song yummy by Justin Bieber and when
00:11:52
that request wasn't fulfilled Haley and
00:11:55
her table allegedly started yelling
00:11:57
Justin's name Haley Bieber would find
00:11:59
herself under the microscope yet again
00:12:01
following the release of her home
00:12:03
cooking show what's in my kitchen as it
00:12:05
shares a striking undeniable resemblance
00:12:08
to Selena Gomez cooking show Selena plus
00:12:11
Chef that debuted 2 years before Haley's
00:12:14
show let's start at the beginning Selena
00:12:16
show starts with a faux camera HUD
00:12:18
overlay to give that raw homemade
00:12:21
production quality feel Haley show also
00:12:24
starts with a faux camera HUD overlay
00:12:26
Selena points out that the show does in
00:12:28
fact take place place in her real home
00:12:30
this is my real home everything that
00:12:32
we're doing is at home Haley points out
00:12:34
that the show is actually recorded in
00:12:36
her real home yes we actually are in my
00:12:39
real Kitchen in my real house Selena has
00:12:42
her Nana introduce the dish they will be
00:12:44
cooking so Nana what do we call this
00:12:46
cheesy tortilla chip c Haley has her
00:12:50
Nana introduce the dish they will be
00:12:51
cooking and Nana what are we making
00:12:54
today Selena plus Chef would go on to
00:12:57
have four 11 episode seasons on HBO Max
00:13:01
as well as a spin-off that's still
00:13:02
currently airing titled Selena Plus
00:13:05
Restaurant while Haley Bieber's what's
00:13:06
in my kitchen would release five
00:13:08
episodes before being abandoned
00:13:10
completely after fans caught on to Haley
00:13:13
practically copying Selena word for word
00:13:16
things got even darker when they dug
00:13:18
into Haley's interviews I realized that
00:13:21
everybody else seemed to be narrating my
00:13:24
life for me yes so why don't I put
00:13:27
something out that is my of the story I
00:13:30
realized that I was able to tell my
00:13:33
story about who I was from my own mouth
00:13:36
instead of people from the outside being
00:13:39
able to tell my story for me that was
00:13:42
one of the moments where I was like I
00:13:43
don't have to be that 19-year-old body
00:13:46
shape anymore because I'm not that's the
00:13:49
other thing too that I I think I'm
00:13:52
learning is I'm not 19 anymore I'm 24
00:13:55
now I feel like my body has changed the
00:13:57
most even this last year
00:13:59
somebody asked me a while ago what's the
00:14:01
one thing you wish people knew about you
00:14:04
and I said I wanted it to be my heart
00:14:06
what do you wish more people knew about
00:14:08
you my heart people didn't really know
00:14:11
me they didn't know who I was they
00:14:13
didn't know Haley for Haley and I just
00:14:15
always had this constant battle where I
00:14:17
was saying I wish people just knew my
00:14:19
heart for what it's worth this last
00:14:21
Selena Gomez interview where she talks
00:14:23
about her heart isn't even easy to find
00:14:26
it comes from the Press circuit for the
00:14:28
movie R lless and at the time of this
00:14:30
recording only has
00:14:32
2,870 views and is seemingly only hosted
00:14:36
on a portuges Selena Gomez fan account
00:14:39
if Haley really did copy Selena's quote
00:14:42
and this is the same Source she stole it
00:14:44
from she would have had to have been far
00:14:47
down the Selena interview Rabbit Hole as
00:14:49
this clip was hard to find even knowing
00:14:51
what to search for it's almost comical
00:14:54
how many instances you can find of Haley
00:14:56
Bieber coincidentally doing doing
00:14:59
something Selena Gomez has already done
00:15:02
even extending to the ad campaign for
00:15:04
Haley's beauty company Road sharing a
00:15:06
striking resemblance to Selena's beauty
00:15:08
company a company that when not copying
00:15:11
Selena's is allegedly copying smaller
00:15:13
lesser known Brands even down to the
00:15:16
descriptions Haley's greatest life
00:15:18
achievement will be marrying Justin
00:15:20
Bieber and just for a bit let's give her
00:15:23
some credit like most girls during the
00:15:25
Bieber Fever era she wanted nothing more
00:15:27
than to be with Justin and through her
00:15:29
Relentless ambition world class hating
00:15:32
and a meticulously orchestrated plan
00:15:34
Haley spent 9 years building connections
00:15:38
with people to put herself around Justin
00:15:40
as much as possible from befriending the
00:15:42
Jenner Sisters and working with fan
00:15:44
accounts to feed her Intel on Justin's
00:15:46
every move to booking countless hotel
00:15:49
rooms just to bump into him in the
00:15:51
elevator and then traveling to the next
00:15:53
hotel to pretend to coincidentally be
00:15:55
dining there that evening Haley set her
00:15:57
eyes on the prize put in the work and
00:15:59
found herself across the altar from
00:16:01
Justin Bieber I don't even know what to
00:16:03
call it because it's so beyond iconic
00:16:05
that there needs to be a new word
00:16:06
invented for what Haley Baldwin has done
00:16:08
Haley Baldwin went from trying to bump
00:16:11
into Justin Bieber at the saai London to
00:16:15
married is so iconic like everyone's
00:16:17
making a joke that it was her 10year
00:16:18
plan like didn't we stand Haley baldman
00:16:21
she did that do not give up like that's
00:16:23
inspirational you can do anything in
00:16:26
life because Haley Baldwin did that what
00:16:28
other cases of a pop music stand miring
00:16:31
their Idol can you think of she might be
00:16:33
the only one to ever do it and she at
00:16:35
least deserves some credit for that
00:16:37
however after spending a third of your
00:16:39
life fighting another woman for your man
00:16:42
what are you left with you arrived at
00:16:44
the destination but is it as fun as the
00:16:46
journey you took getting there perhaps
00:16:48
this is why after 6 years of marriage to
00:16:50
Justin we still see Haley copying in
00:16:52
clowning on Selena perhaps Haley can't
00:16:55
help herself because it's all she's
00:16:56
really known well most people spend in
00:16:59
ages 13 to 22 discovering who they are
00:17:02
and finishing school Haley spent those
00:17:04
formative years indulging herself in a
00:17:06
childhood fantasy it also has to hurt
00:17:09
that after announcing your pregnancy to
00:17:11
the world Selena Gomez your husband's
00:17:13
ex-girlfriend started trending on
00:17:15
Twitter and not you your husband or your
00:17:18
baby it seems we're not the only ones
00:17:20
pondering these questions as despite the
00:17:23
pregnancy announcement the relationship
00:17:25
seems to be on the Rocks Steven Baldwin
00:17:28
Haley's father has asked people to pray
00:17:30
for Justin and Haley on Instagram while
00:17:33
divorce rumors swirl around the internet
00:17:35
with some people pointing out that Haley
00:17:37
and Justin arrive and leave events in
00:17:40
separate cars and others speculating
00:17:43
that they haven't lived together for
00:17:45
some time all while blind item after
00:17:47
blind item alleged depression substance
00:17:50
abuse and cheating from Justin always
00:17:52
take blind items with a grain of salt
00:17:55
but something often alleged is that
00:17:57
Justin and Selena's four month stint in
00:17:59
2018 just months before Justin's
00:18:02
marriage to Haley came as the result of
00:18:04
an unexpected pregnancy with Selena
00:18:06
followed by a miscarriage this could
00:18:08
potentially give some added context to
00:18:11
why Selena checked herself into a
00:18:12
wellness Retreat and why Justin flipped
00:18:15
from Haley to Selena to marrying Haley
00:18:17
all in less than a year regardless one
00:18:20
thing is for certain if Selena goes left
00:18:23
Haley Goes left if Selena goes right
00:18:25
Haley goes right but could Haley for the
00:18:28
first time in almost a decade have a new
00:18:30
blueprint
00:18:32
[Music]
