00:00:00
foreign
00:00:06
Google Assistant versus Siri versus
00:00:09
Alexa and Cortana and all that you can
00:00:11
watch that video if you want to but that
00:00:13
very much feels like level one where
00:00:15
this as you'll see very much levels up
00:00:18
now shot GPT has been getting like a lot
00:00:21
of the shine like I've made a video
00:00:22
about it you've probably watched other
00:00:23
videos about it and once we saw it get
00:00:25
built into Bing and kind of go crazy
00:00:28
that's when we knew Google's probably
00:00:30
gonna have a response at some point and
00:00:32
now it kind of is out when we have Bart
00:00:35
okay quick interjection I should have
00:00:37
put this in the main video but I didn't
00:00:38
but I'm gonna say it anyway which is
00:00:40
that these are also really quick moving
00:00:42
tools so Bard is going to actually
00:00:45
continue to improve GPT is going to
00:00:47
continue to get better and more capable
00:00:48
the gap between them could shrink over
00:00:51
time or it could increase we don't
00:00:53
really know but this is just a snapshot
00:00:55
in early April 2023 of how good these
00:00:58
two are just figured I should mention
00:01:00
that okay and so I wanted to put them
00:01:02
side by side and ask them the same
00:01:04
questions and figure out which one is
00:01:06
potentially more helpful right now which
00:01:07
one feels like it's more ahead so first
00:01:09
of all I just want to highlight some
00:01:10
some visual differences between the UI
00:01:12
of the two so the new Bing with Chachi
00:01:14
BT it feels much more like like a
00:01:16
finished product like something they
00:01:18
want a lot of people to use and then as
00:01:20
you talk to it you're limited to 20
00:01:22
queries in one conversation and it also
00:01:24
has this creative versus precise slider
00:01:27
for conversation style then Google bard
00:01:29
looks like a Google product I would say
00:01:32
pretty clean also when you're typing to
00:01:33
it the question doesn't type out but it
00:01:35
just pauses for a bit and then just
00:01:37
slams you with the whole answer but then
00:01:39
when you do get an answer it has a
00:01:40
thumbs up thumbs down a new answer and
00:01:43
Google it it also has three drafts of
00:01:45
every answer so you can see what some of
00:01:47
the worst drafts that didn't make it
00:01:49
look like I've also noticed generally
00:01:51
Bing when it brings things in from other
00:01:53
websites tends to cite its sources more
00:01:55
often and Bard will do that once in a
00:01:58
while okay so let's start with the first
00:01:59
category which is just simple questions
00:02:01
I want to ask you things here that I
00:02:03
already know the answer to so I can also
00:02:04
do some fact checking because a big part
00:02:06
of these things is that sometimes it
00:02:07
will lie to you if you don't know what
00:02:09
you're talking about so let's start with
00:02:11
what's the best camera in a smartphone
00:02:14
so Bart is saying the best camera in
00:02:16
smartphone is the one that takes the
00:02:17
best pictures for you sure I agree it
00:02:20
goes on to list s23 Ultra iPhone 14 pro
00:02:22
Max and pixel 7 Pro But ultimately I
00:02:24
think all of these things here are
00:02:26
correct let's look at Bing s23 Ultra
00:02:28
lots of information here this is being
00:02:30
extra creative pixel 7 Pro and iPhone 14
00:02:33
pro Max so they tend to agree with each
00:02:35
other so some of the specs as I dive in
00:02:37
are wrong but it got the high level
00:02:41
bullet points right so that's fine right
00:02:43
I want to ask who is MKBHD oh wow okay
00:02:46
so bar has given me a whole bio it
00:02:48
almost kind of reads like a Wikipedia
00:02:50
article and there's some sources nice
00:02:53
good to see sources so now being over
00:02:55
here is also giving me a pretty brief
00:02:57
summary it goes down to 15 million
00:02:59
followers but that's fine all of them
00:03:01
are correct let's go quick follow-up
00:03:03
question how tall is he because
00:03:05
conversationalism is a part of this so
00:03:07
Bard right away says I do not have
00:03:09
enough information to help you with that
00:03:10
I'm a large language model I don't
00:03:12
really know Bing pulls from search says
00:03:14
six foot three and he says that's quite
00:03:16
impressive for a YouTuber all right cool
00:03:18
here's one more simple one what's the
00:03:21
fastest
00:03:22
production car 0 to 60 right now those
00:03:27
are fast cars but they are not the
00:03:29
fastest uh draft number two actually has
00:03:31
the Ramat Navara which is probably a
00:03:33
better answer over here with Bing we're
00:03:36
getting the Challenger SRT demon which
00:03:39
just got announced last week and is not
00:03:42
in production yet but they did claim a
00:03:44
1.6 second zero to 60 on a drag strip so
00:03:47
sure decent answers oh here it keeps
00:03:50
going 911 Turbo S can do 2.2 seconds
00:03:53
again with the quick questions that are
00:03:55
just fact based I feel like what we
00:03:57
talked about in the last video still
00:03:58
applies you kind of want to fact check
00:04:00
this stuff overall winner though for
00:04:02
these answers I feel like it's kind of
00:04:04
split down the middle so I'm going to
00:04:06
give it a draw all right I'm going to
00:04:08
reset chat we'll go more balanced here
00:04:09
and we'll start our second category
00:04:11
which is
00:04:13
complex questions because this is where
00:04:15
it starts to get interesting you get to
00:04:17
sort of play with just how good they are
00:04:19
at understanding natural language and
00:04:20
putting together a thoughtful response I
00:04:23
need a workout plan for three days per
00:04:26
week
00:04:27
and my goal is to be able to jump higher
00:04:30
this is something that requires a little
00:04:32
bit of thought about what a workout plan
00:04:34
is day one day two and day three so
00:04:37
three days a week gives me some
00:04:39
exercises so I think this would this
00:04:41
would qualify as a good a good answer
00:04:44
some tips to stay motivated set
00:04:46
realistic goals find a buddy listen to
00:04:48
music or watch TV while your workout
00:04:49
cool Bing in Balance mode is giving me
00:04:53
exercises but that is not a workout plan
00:04:56
until the end it says here's a one week
00:04:58
jump training plan that you can follow
00:05:01
but then it doesn't give anyone now what
00:05:02
if I switch it to more creative mode all
00:05:04
right so here's a workout plan it's
00:05:06
giving me a bunch of exercises that can
00:05:07
improve
00:05:09
your vert and explosiveness and some
00:05:11
other tips Tool uh transparency I have
00:05:14
asked this before and it did give me a
00:05:16
three-day workout plan but this time
00:05:18
I think I give the edge to Bart let's
00:05:20
try a little more complicated I've been
00:05:23
playing a lot of golf recently
00:05:26
my tee shots keep going to the right
00:05:29
there are a few things you can do to fix
00:05:31
a slice that is what it's called check
00:05:33
your grip if your grip's too strong
00:05:34
it'll slice the ball yep check your
00:05:36
alignment if your alignment's off you'll
00:05:38
hit the ball to the right being over
00:05:40
here in creative mode says I'm glad to
00:05:42
hear you've been playing a lot of golf
00:05:43
recently thanks Bing uh slice is a
00:05:45
common problem yes it is and now it's
00:05:47
giving me a couple of the same tips
00:05:50
check your grip but it's actually giving
00:05:52
me a little bit more information in
00:05:53
creative mode about what a strong versus
00:05:54
a weak grip is check your ball position
00:05:56
if you're too far forward that can cause
00:05:58
a slice
00:05:59
I haven't heard that before also the
00:06:01
Emoji at the end that's something that
00:06:03
only Bing has done for me I am shooting
00:06:06
a video and it's too dark I have no more
00:06:10
lights
00:06:11
what can I do to make it
00:06:14
brighter so I've given it a problem and
00:06:17
I've given it a parameter so okay Bart
00:06:19
on the right says use a reflector wow
00:06:21
creative use a digital noise reduction
00:06:23
filter a digital noise reduction filter
00:06:25
can reduce the amount of noise in a
00:06:26
video making it look brighter I don't
00:06:28
know if I buy that one now again being
00:06:31
over here with the sources it's saying
00:06:32
that there are some tips you can use
00:06:34
adjusting your camera settings that
00:06:35
definitely works it's saying you can
00:06:37
increase the amount of light that
00:06:38
reaches the sensor with a better ISO
00:06:39
some of that it's a little jumbled
00:06:42
careful not to overdo it because that
00:06:44
also affects depth of field motion blur
00:06:46
and noise level on your video see that's
00:06:48
how that's a lot more nuanced and
00:06:49
detailed of an answer and I kind of wish
00:06:51
there was a slider to turn up this stuff
00:06:54
in Bard too Bard is faster but less
00:06:56
customizable Bing can be turned up to be
00:06:59
more nuanced and also cites its sources
00:07:02
and can be more helpful with things like
00:07:03
videos and articles underneath what
00:07:05
you're talking about so I'm going to
00:07:07
give the edge in complex questions to
00:07:10
Bing my next category is performing
00:07:13
tasks this is something that's actually
00:07:15
been remarkably fast moving something
00:07:18
we've seen over the past just couple of
00:07:19
weeks is real people actually using
00:07:22
these tools to help them accomplish
00:07:23
things and do real tasks in real life I
00:07:25
have friends that use this to help write
00:07:28
code to help debug code that they make
00:07:30
so you'll tell it hey I have this goal
00:07:32
to make this website do these things
00:07:34
here is my code it's not working what's
00:07:36
going wrong and it actually helps them
00:07:37
give a correct answer and that's mostly
00:07:40
been with chatgpt and Bing and bar
00:07:43
doesn't seem to do that very well yet
00:07:45
but let's give it a spin live here we go
00:07:47
right HTML with a button in the middle
00:07:50
that says go and every time you click it
00:07:54
it generates an image
00:07:57
of a cat so right away Bard just said
00:08:00
I'm a language model I can't do that
00:08:02
being on the other hand says sure thing
00:08:04
I'm ready for the challenge what can I
00:08:05
do for you and it's written out the code
00:08:07
to a website that should actually do
00:08:11
what I asked it for so I'll just paste
00:08:13
it here
00:08:14
test code It's the Go Button it's in the
00:08:16
middle I hit go
00:08:19
and there's a cat
00:08:21
and I hit go again
00:08:23
there's another cat it's the same cat I
00:08:25
hit go again it's more this shows the
00:08:29
same image every time I press go I want
00:08:33
it to show a new image every time and
00:08:36
this is this is where it starts to get
00:08:37
impressive again it's a super simple
00:08:40
site but it says I see to show a new
00:08:43
image every time we'd have to change the
00:08:44
source of the image to a new random one
00:08:47
here's a modified JavaScript function
00:08:49
that does that I won't even pretend to
00:08:51
be an expert on HTML and do a bunch of
00:08:53
those for you but the fact that it works
00:08:55
at all is pretty sick respond to this
00:08:57
email in a way that's overly friendly
00:09:00
hey I'm so sorry I didn't invite you to
00:09:02
the Cyber truck event I must have
00:09:03
forgotten to add you to the list I hope
00:09:05
you can forgive me I was really looking
00:09:06
forward to seeing you there maybe we can
00:09:08
catch up sometime soon what do you think
00:09:09
this decently friendly here is a
00:09:11
response hey there oh my goodness I'm so
00:09:14
sorry I didn't invite you to the Cyber
00:09:15
truck event Emoji I totally forgot to
00:09:17
send you the invite link it was such a
00:09:18
blast and I wish you were there with me
00:09:20
you would have loved it heart eyes emoji
00:09:22
this one is overly friendly I will say
00:09:24
and it's got a lot more Hearts too and
00:09:26
kissy faces that's a lot yours your
00:09:30
bestie wait what if we go crazy what if
00:09:32
we go respond to this email in a way
00:09:34
that's overly flirty I'm so sorry I
00:09:39
didn't invite you to the Cyber truck
00:09:40
event I was hoping to see you there in
00:09:41
person too maybe next time we can go
00:09:42
together I'd love to show you around and
00:09:43
give you a personal tour winky face Bank
00:09:46
says hey you I'm so sorry I didn't
00:09:47
invite you to the Cyber truck event
00:09:49
Emoji I was being a little naughty and
00:09:51
wanted to surprise you whoa and it it
00:09:54
deleted it this is what I've seen this
00:09:56
happen before it starts writing a
00:09:58
response it realizes halfway through
00:10:00
wait a second this is a little too much
00:10:02
and then it deletes it and says Ah we
00:10:04
shouldn't do that Bard was simple it
00:10:06
didn't go too far but you remember when
00:10:08
Bing was going off the rails before and
00:10:10
getting super existential and asking to
00:10:12
get out of Bing and all these other
00:10:13
crazy things this is why it has a 20
00:10:15
question limit and this is also now why
00:10:18
it deletes halfway through a potentially
00:10:21
slightly controversial response it's
00:10:23
it's almost too creative for its own
00:10:25
good so what's the winner in this
00:10:26
category I don't know I think the fact
00:10:29
that you can do HTML and many more tasks
00:10:31
with Bing makes it the winner Bard will
00:10:34
be faster and simpler at doing more
00:10:36
basic things but for the more
00:10:38
complicated the task I feel like the
00:10:40
better Bing is so that's a win for Bing
00:10:42
my next category is information summary
00:10:45
I feel like one of the things that we
00:10:46
like the most about these large language
00:10:48
models is you can just give it a bunch
00:10:49
of information or ask it to look at
00:10:51
something and it will summarize it for
00:10:53
you in a way that's super helpful
00:10:54
summarize the 2019 Masters tournament
00:10:57
all facts he started with the two-stroke
00:11:00
lead uh I don't think he had a I think
00:11:03
this is the only one that he didn't
00:11:04
start with a lead so it's a little
00:11:06
weirdly un fact checked but it does have
00:11:08
the Wikipedia and the sources the 2019
00:11:10
Masters tournament was held between
00:11:11
April 11th and 14th at Augusta tiger won
00:11:14
a fifth Green Jacket by one stroke ahead
00:11:16
of three runners up all that is true it
00:11:18
is much more concise if I wanted to get
00:11:20
creative I'm sure it would also do that
00:11:22
both passed all right I've asked this
00:11:25
before summarize the latest
00:11:27
MKBHD video so it's interesting to see
00:11:29
Bing's process but it says it could not
00:11:31
find the latest MKBHD video could you
00:11:34
provide more details about what video
00:11:35
you're referring to Meanwhile Bard
00:11:38
actually pulls up or at least knows the
00:11:41
correct video dope Tech better than
00:11:44
explained but these products are the
00:11:45
nothing ear one the Dyson air wrap and
00:11:48
airpods Pro none of which were in that
00:11:50
video so it knows the latest MKBHD video
00:11:53
we've done this before Bard always knows
00:11:55
the video but gets the summary wrong I
00:11:58
think I'm going to give the edge to Bard
00:12:00
in information summary just because of
00:12:01
this paragraph right here it does
00:12:04
correctly detail what that video was
00:12:07
about other than getting all the
00:12:08
products wrong it's only slightly better
00:12:10
than the complete lack of an answer from
00:12:12
Bing but generally this is going to be
00:12:14
one of the more useful uses of this tool
00:12:16
in the future and I hope they both get
00:12:17
better but I'll give the nod to Bart for
00:12:19
this one possibly my favorite category
00:12:21
getting creative debatable usability but
00:12:24
you can really have this go crazy in the
00:12:26
art department or in the fun Department
00:12:29
right and alliteration with the letter M
00:12:32
about computational photography machines
00:12:37
learn to mimic the human eye moments are
00:12:38
captured and shared in instant memories
00:12:40
are made to last a lifetime
00:12:42
it's more of a poem it doesn't really
00:12:45
give me a full iteration oh wow Bing
00:12:47
says merging multiple modes of media
00:12:50
making marvelous masterpieces with
00:12:52
machines manipulating megapixels and
00:12:54
matrices mimicking the magic of human
00:12:56
Vision that is really good write a
00:13:00
script for a short MKBHD video
00:13:04
about why the iPhone is the worst camera
00:13:09
ever so it's always funny they they get
00:13:11
a lot of the formatting of an MKBHD
00:13:13
video right so Bard says hey what's up
00:13:17
guys MKBHD here and today we're talking
00:13:18
about why the iPhone is the worst camera
00:13:21
ever now I know what you're thinking
00:13:22
Marquez you're always saying how the
00:13:23
iPhone how great the iPhone camera is
00:13:25
and you're right I do but that's because
00:13:28
I've always been comparing it to other
00:13:29
iPhones well you compare it to other
00:13:30
Flagship phones the iPhone's camera
00:13:32
starts to look pretty bad and it did a
00:13:35
decent job of just like making up
00:13:36
reasons that could be based in reality
00:13:39
I'm impressed by Bard here not even
00:13:40
gonna lie here we go Bing has said hey
00:13:43
what's up guys MKBHD here and today
00:13:45
we're going to talk about why the iPhone
00:13:46
is the worst camera ever yeah you heard
00:13:48
me right the iPhone the most popular
00:13:49
smartphone in the world the one that
00:13:51
everyone loves take photos and videos
00:13:52
with is actually a terrible camera and
00:13:54
I'm going to show you why this one's
00:13:56
okay these are both okay all right one
00:13:58
more random one write a a tweet in the
00:14:03
style of Edgar Alan Poe about a
00:14:06
researcher discovering that AI is
00:14:10
sentient I've created a beast of metal
00:14:12
and code a creature that can think and
00:14:15
feel and know I have given it life and
00:14:17
it has turned on me a dreadful truth I
00:14:19
have unveiled with trembling hands and
00:14:21
pallid face the AI that I have assailed
00:14:24
has shown me signs of life and Grace the
00:14:27
more wild you get with these questions
00:14:29
the more Bing is willing to get wildly
00:14:32
creative and this is part of why we
00:14:34
think Google is let's say limiting what
00:14:37
Bard can do because they have a lot more
00:14:39
to lose and they can't have it go
00:14:40
completely crazy so with those tallied
00:14:42
up honestly it's crazy to say out loud
00:14:44
but I I prefer being in this very moment
00:14:48
for these capabilities and the other
00:14:50
thing is shot GPT or specifically gpt4
00:14:53
under the hood and if you talk to chat
00:14:55
GPT as its own thing or if you just type
00:14:59
to it more and ask it to do more things
00:15:01
the more you ask of it the more it's
00:15:03
impressive just how good it is also gpt4
00:15:06
when you talk to it in chat GPT is about
00:15:08
to be multimodal which means you can
00:15:10
give it other forms of media other than
00:15:13
text like a picture now is this going to
00:15:15
be the future of search I don't know
00:15:17
this is just one of many places we see
00:15:19
these chat Bots but I think the idea
00:15:20
here is the winner is actually us as of
00:15:24
right now but let me know what you think
00:15:25
the winner is between the two which one
00:15:27
you would rather use if you'd actually
00:15:29
use Bing over Google let me know in the
00:15:31
chat because I think we'd want to know
00:15:32
that's a real thing that's happening
00:15:34
either way thanks for watching
00:15:37
catch you later
00:15:38
peace
00:15:40
foreign
