Aniruddh Yadav, IAS, Rank-08 | UPSC CSE 2022 | English Medium | Mock Interview | Drishti IAS English
概要
TLDRI denna video blir Anirudh Yadav, en officerstrainee i den indiska informationsombuden, intervjuad om olika samhälleliga och byråkratiska frågor i Indien. Han diskuterar de utmaningar som Indiens byråkrati står inför, inklusive korruption, brist på verklighetsförankring och attitydproblem bland byråkrater. Han belyser också varför många politiska åtgärder brister i effektivitet på grund av landets mångfald och bristen på specifika datadrivna strategier. Anirudh senare diskuterar övergången från regelbaserat till rollbaserat beslutsfattande inom den offentliga sektorn och hur AI-teknologier som ChatGPT integreras inom deras praktik för att förbättra kommunikations- och informationshantering. Dessutom tar han upp vikten av mediareglering inom en demokrati och vikten av att byråkrater är överens med fältverkligheten i sina roller. Genom hela intervjun betonar Anirudh sitt åtagande att använda sina privilegier och utbildning för att ge tillbaka till samhället och bidra till ett mer effektivt och etiskt byråkratiskt system.
収穫
- 🎥 Intervju med Anirudh Yadav om indisk byråkrati.
- 🗃️ Problem i byråkratin: korruption, arrogans och brist på verklighetskontakt.
- 🤖 AI och ChatGPT används i informationsspridning och för att bekämpa desinformation.
- 📜 Policys brister på grund av Indiens mångfald och behov för mer flexibel implementering.
- 👥 Betoning på övergång från regel- till rollbaserat beslutsfattande.
- 🔍 Anirudh betonar behovet av datadrivna åtgärder i policyutveckling.
- 📚 Anirudh känner en skyldighet att återbetala det samhälle som stöttat hans utbildning.
- 💬 Demokrati kräver rimliga restriktioner och regleringar av media.
- 📊 Vikten av att minska riskaversion genom byråkratisk innovation.
- 🏢 Diskussion om den indiska informationsmyndighetens roll och utmaningar.
タイムライン
- 00:00:00 - 00:05:00
Problemet som diskuteras är att folk inte känner till sin egen lokala självförvaltning och därmed inte känner till hur panchayatiras förhåller sig till yttrandefriheten. Frågor ställs kring varför regeringen ska kontrollera mediehus och varför vissa policyer inte fungerar i landet. Kandidaten Anirudh Yadav presenterar sig och beskriver sina studier och nuvarande träning inom den indiska informationsservicen.
- 00:05:00 - 00:10:00
Anirudh beskriver sin utbildning och träning inom indiska informationsservicen som intressant. Han lär sig om nya kommunikationsteknologier och hur AI används för att spåra fake news. Diskussionen rör också om krishantering och hur hans utbildning täcker olika aspekter av kommunikation. Han frågas även om byråkratins problem och förklarar att brist på fältkunskap, attitydproblem och korruption är stora utmaningar.
- 00:10:00 - 00:15:00
Diskussionen handlar om den planerade övergången från regelbaserat till rollbaserat beslutsfattande inom byråkratin. Anirudh menar att detta kan vara en utopisk idé eftersom regler är nödvändiga för att säkerställa ansvar och motverka korruption. Han betonar behovet av digital teknik för ökad effektivitet.
- 00:15:00 - 00:20:00
Intervjuaren ifrågasätter Anirudhs privilegierade bakgrund och dess påverkan på hans motivation och förmåga i civiltjänsten. Anirudh förklarar att hans beslutsamhet att ge tillbaka till landet är stark och oberoende av dessa privilegier. Diskussionen berör också lokal självstyrelse i hans hemstad, där han visar brist på kunskap om detaljer.
- 00:20:00 - 00:25:00
Samtalet skiftar till informationslaget om rätten att få information (RTI) och vilket departement som är ansvarigt för dess implementering. Anirudh diskuterar också effekterna av åldrande och hur det är klassificerat som en sjukdom av Världshälsoorganisationen. Han ger en antropologisk syn på sjukdomars roll i mänsklighetens evolution och betydelsen av att bevara hälsa vid åldrande.
- 00:25:00 - 00:30:00
I denna del diskuteras förebyggande av åldrande och dess betydelse både ekonomiskt och kulturellt. Anirudh lyfter fram möjligheterna att hjälpa socioekonomiskt utsatta grupper genom att minska vårdkostnader relaterade till åldrande, samtidigt som han erkänner utmaningarna med befolkningens tillväxt och resursutnyttjande.
- 00:30:00 - 00:39:17
Intervjun avslutas med diskussion om datahanteringslagar och förslaget om utländska universitet i Indien. Anirudh hoppas att dessa institutioner kan minska hjärnflykt och förbättra utbildningskvaliteten. Han erbjuder också råd för att fördröja åldrandet genom sömn, motion och ayurvediska metoder. Intervjun ger en positiv bedömning men rekommenderar vidare förberedelse inför potentiella frågor gällande hans fält.
マインドマップ
よくある質問
Vad handlar videon om?
Videon handlar om en intervju med Anirudh Yadav, en officerstrainee i den indiska informationsombuden, där han diskuterar byråkrati och politik i Indien.
Vem är Anirudh Yadav?
Anirudh Yadav är en officerstrainee i den indiska informationsombuden och huvudperson i intervjun.
Vilka är de huvudsakliga problemen med byråkrati enligt intervjun?
Problem som identifieras inkluderar brist på kontakt med verkligheten, arrogans och korruption bland byråkrater.
Varför fungerar inte policys i Indien enligt intervjun?
Policys fungerar inte på grund av India's storlek och mångfald, vilket kräver mer nyanserade och flexibla implementeringar.
Vad är syftet med Anirudh Yadavs tjänst i den indiska informationsombuden?
Hans syfte är att ge tillbaka till landet och hanterar frågor kring informationsspridning och hantering.
Hur används AI i Anirudh Yadavs arbete?
AI används för att följa och upptäcka falska nyheter och hjälpa till med pressmeddelanden.
Vilka problem nämns med riskaversion i byråkratin?
Riskaversion är ett problem som begränsar beslutsfattandet på grund av komplexa byråkratiska processer.
Varför är reglering av media viktigt enligt intervjun?
För att säkerställa rimliga restriktioner enligt Artikel 19.2 samt för att bevara offentlig ordning och sanning.
Vilka nya teknologier lärs ut under träningen för officerstraineer?
Teknologier som AI och ChatGPT för att hantera kommunikation och informationsarbete.
ビデオをもっと見る
- 00:00:04tell me what is the problem with our
- 00:00:06bureaucracy you don't know about your
- 00:00:09own local self government how will you
- 00:00:10know about the panchayatiras in relation
- 00:00:12with the freedom of a speech
- 00:00:14why should government control media
- 00:00:16houses why don't policies work in our
- 00:00:19country aren't you too privileged
- 00:00:22to become a civil server
- 00:00:23[Music]
- 00:00:31yes thank you sir
- 00:00:34good morning sir good morning good
- 00:00:36morning sir please be seated good
- 00:00:37morning sir good morning sir thank you
- 00:00:40sir
- 00:00:43please give a brief introduction about
- 00:00:44yourself so my name is anirudh yadav I
- 00:00:47was born in Chandigarh in 1996 so I've
- 00:00:49completed my schooling from Delhi and
- 00:00:51subsequently I went on to do my
- 00:00:53engineering in biochemical engineering
- 00:00:54and biotechnology from IIT Delhi So
- 00:00:57currently I'm serving in the Indian
- 00:00:58information service as an officer
- 00:01:00trainee
- 00:01:01and some of my hobbies include studying
- 00:01:03the prevention and causes of Aging and
- 00:01:06also playing football in squash sir
- 00:01:07under the when did you join
- 00:01:11so my training started in January this
- 00:01:13year so January this year are you
- 00:01:15finding your training so it's very
- 00:01:17interesting so it's um so getting to
- 00:01:19learn a lot about the ministry about uh
- 00:01:22the different aspects of communications
- 00:01:24how do you collaborate with other
- 00:01:25Ministries
- 00:01:27um so there is mostly the
- 00:01:29um primary source of collaboration is
- 00:01:31through the pib there is an individual
- 00:01:33who's posted in every Ministry uh who is
- 00:01:36responsible for the release of the press
- 00:01:38releases and organizing press
- 00:01:39conferences Etc that's the primary
- 00:01:41source of interactions okay you're
- 00:01:44undergoing training tell me what new
- 00:01:48technologies are taught to the
- 00:01:51provisioners in that training module so
- 00:01:54with respect to Technologies uh So
- 00:01:56currently we had a session very recently
- 00:01:58on how artificial intelligence is being
- 00:02:00used to track fake news
- 00:02:02so additionally we are also um so there
- 00:02:05was a session on chat GPT how we can use
- 00:02:06it to make press releases and how we can
- 00:02:09detect different things that are made by
- 00:02:11AI using AI itself so AI is something
- 00:02:13that is there in the communication which
- 00:02:16agency gave the presentation on chat GPT
- 00:02:18and AI Technologies so our um so the
- 00:02:21faculty of the iimc the Indian Institute
- 00:02:23of mass communication a faculty from
- 00:02:25there itself okay
- 00:02:28and did you get any training in the
- 00:02:31crisis to deal with crisis communication
- 00:02:33also so we had an individual who spoke
- 00:02:36about his anecdotal experiences but um
- 00:02:38so he spoke about the topic was Crisis
- 00:02:40communication but he tried to give the
- 00:02:43message through anecdotes okay
- 00:02:45you are a second generation bureaucrat
- 00:02:48isn't it so your father was also a part
- 00:02:50of the bureaucracy tell me what is the
- 00:02:52problem with our bureaucracy
- 00:02:54[Music]
- 00:03:04so I feel um so very recently the prime
- 00:03:07minister in his address in on the civil
- 00:03:09services they also pointed out that the
- 00:03:12first one of the primary problems is
- 00:03:14that the bureaucrats are often uh
- 00:03:17they're not cognizant of what is going
- 00:03:19on on the field sir because they're
- 00:03:20caught up in the rigmarole of work or
- 00:03:22for any other reason so second is an
- 00:03:24issue of attitude so often times it is
- 00:03:27seen that a lot of bureaucrats are
- 00:03:29ostensibly seen to be arrogant perhaps
- 00:03:31because they are busier because they
- 00:03:33can't take out time so the solution to
- 00:03:36this would be to have a people-centric
- 00:03:37approach meet everyone who's coming Etc
- 00:03:39and so the third is the bane of
- 00:03:41corruption sir because corruption is
- 00:03:43something that has pervaded many parts
- 00:03:45of the bureaucracy and has been seen in
- 00:03:47the past what are the issues like
- 00:03:49indecision
- 00:03:51risk aversion on the part of a
- 00:03:53bureaucrats absolutely sir sir I agree
- 00:03:55that there is so because of the system
- 00:03:57of bureaucracy or so it can also be due
- 00:04:00to Legacy challenges there is a lot of
- 00:04:03risk aversion and decision making why
- 00:04:05don't policies work in our country so I
- 00:04:07believe that India is such a big country
- 00:04:09and there are many nuances in a country
- 00:04:11like India so policy formulation itself
- 00:04:14requires large data sets of what is
- 00:04:16happening on the field so I believe at
- 00:04:18the stage of formulation there are
- 00:04:19issues with respect to data light policy
- 00:04:22making on the scale of implementations
- 00:04:24often we have seen that the second Arc
- 00:04:27also noted that there is a
- 00:04:28one-size-fits-all so India is a land of
- 00:04:31tremendous diversity right from
- 00:04:32geographical cultural social etcetera
- 00:04:34and sir I believe that there needs to be
- 00:04:36little Nuance there needs to be a little
- 00:04:38wiggle room for the IIs IPS and other
- 00:04:40officers on the field to ensure that
- 00:04:42implementation is it can be a catered to
- 00:04:46the specific audience so thirdly I
- 00:04:48believe the regulation is the third
- 00:04:49front that regulatory bodies for
- 00:04:51Implement uh for seeing how the policy
- 00:04:54is being implemented and additionally
- 00:04:56having a feedback mechanism to improve
- 00:04:58policy so these are the three challenges
- 00:05:00okay the emphasis of the government is
- 00:05:03to switch over from
- 00:05:06rule-based decision making to role-based
- 00:05:09decision making
- 00:05:10with a little experience which you have
- 00:05:13had in the bureaucracy and the long
- 00:05:15experience where your father had in the
- 00:05:16bureaucracy do you think it is a
- 00:05:18implementable and it is a doable
- 00:05:20proposition so I feel that the fact that
- 00:05:22the bureaucracy is currently called Rule
- 00:05:24based is because there is a plethora of
- 00:05:26rules that constrained bureaucrats from
- 00:05:29taking decisions
- 00:05:30so to move to the objectives or I
- 00:05:33believe is something to move to a role
- 00:05:34based is something that is currently
- 00:05:36utopian sir because rules are what not
- 00:05:39only restricted bureaucrats but also
- 00:05:40ensure that there is less corruption
- 00:05:42there is more accountability Etc so as
- 00:05:45an example so there are rules as to how
- 00:05:46much money can be spent on a official
- 00:05:49dinner or an official lunch so this
- 00:05:51requires a lot of paperwork to be filled
- 00:05:53out so the Tida firms for instance that
- 00:05:55one fails they're very long and take a
- 00:05:57lot of time however sir this is only to
- 00:05:59ensure accountability and so to move to
- 00:06:01a role-based system so either we need to
- 00:06:03use technology to pre-fill these forms
- 00:06:05or to ensure that there is a digital way
- 00:06:08of ensuring accountability so I believe
- 00:06:10that is the way forward to move to a
- 00:06:12rule essentially the bureaucracy is
- 00:06:14basically the principles or the basic
- 00:06:16tenets of barricacies based on mistrust
- 00:06:18indeed don't you think that this High
- 00:06:21Time the country should switch over from
- 00:06:24our move from this idea of mistress to
- 00:06:28the idea of trust survival believe that
- 00:06:31the fact that the bureaucracy is
- 00:06:32essentially based on mistrust so it is
- 00:06:34because of the fact like
- 00:06:36um
- 00:06:37sir cortelia noted that corruption in a
- 00:06:40place like a bureaucracy is like a fish
- 00:06:42drinking water so it has to be on
- 00:06:43mistrust because so there is the public
- 00:06:46funds this is the taxpayers money that
- 00:06:48is being used and so there must be a
- 00:06:50system of checks and balances there must
- 00:06:51be a system of ensuring accountability
- 00:06:53of individuals so giving
- 00:06:56um so ensuring that there is a lot of
- 00:06:58trust would certainly do good for
- 00:07:00efficiency however sir it will be very
- 00:07:02difficult to find out the troublemakers
- 00:07:03or the notorious elements in the
- 00:07:05bureaucracies
- 00:07:06okay thank you Andrew thank you sir
- 00:07:08hello
- 00:07:12I can see that you just
- 00:07:15you just you
- 00:07:16from Delhi
- 00:07:18father is IPS officer you stay in China
- 00:07:22ke Puri studied from sanskritis and you
- 00:07:26too privileged to become a civil servant
- 00:07:29I mean it's good you can be IIs officer
- 00:07:31fine maybe corporate law of service
- 00:07:33officer but these privileges you have
- 00:07:36will be detrimental for your good work
- 00:07:40in services like IAS isn't it IIT so I
- 00:07:44feel so my primary motivation for
- 00:07:46joining the services was indeed to give
- 00:07:48back to the country that has given me so
- 00:07:50much so like you mentioned sir I have
- 00:07:52lived in a government house all my life
- 00:07:53so my college education was government
- 00:07:55funded the school I went to was built on
- 00:07:58government land that was subsidized my
- 00:07:59fees for subsidized because of the same
- 00:08:01fact so I owe a huge debt everything I
- 00:08:04am today is because of the government
- 00:08:06and Sir uh so all the privilege that
- 00:08:08privileges that you also mentioned are
- 00:08:09because of the government itself and sir
- 00:08:11I owe my life to the government in that
- 00:08:14sense and I believe working in the civil
- 00:08:15services is a way of repaying that debt
- 00:08:17that's that's only about the uh the
- 00:08:20internal motivation you're talking about
- 00:08:21my concern is that because of these
- 00:08:23privileges so your personality uh in
- 00:08:27fact like certain things for example
- 00:08:29that you might your father might already
- 00:08:31have I mean he might become not be
- 00:08:33coming from as privileged background as
- 00:08:36you're coming from so if you compare
- 00:08:38your background with his background and
- 00:08:41then you'll realize that isn't it that
- 00:08:43you have imbibed certain values which
- 00:08:46are detrimental to become good IAS or
- 00:08:50IPS IIs is fine so it is my
- 00:08:53understanding that's a privilege is not
- 00:08:55the primary factor that drives one one
- 00:08:58straights or um so the different virtues
- 00:09:00at a person imbibes so it is a factor of
- 00:09:03so your internal thinking the way you've
- 00:09:05been brought up by your parents the
- 00:09:07challenges that you're faced in your
- 00:09:08life and so well privilege a thing like
- 00:09:10privilege can certainly ensure that
- 00:09:12living in a rural area perhaps might be
- 00:09:13tough or also living
- 00:09:15um you know far-flung area might be
- 00:09:17tough so but my perspective is that that
- 00:09:18is a challenge I want to overcome so I
- 00:09:20want to give back to the country and I
- 00:09:23want to ensure that by going there I can
- 00:09:25understand the true nature of India or
- 00:09:27which I've only read about in books
- 00:09:28you're coming from China so what is the
- 00:09:32local self-government structure there uh
- 00:09:34so that the local self so it's a
- 00:09:36municipal Council sir the ndmc New Delhi
- 00:09:40Municipal what are the electrical
- 00:09:41elected components in Indians so there
- 00:09:44is a mayor in in DMC sir and so there is
- 00:09:47there is an elected mayor in India how
- 00:09:51many watts are there in India elections
- 00:09:53to take place how many words are there
- 00:09:56in ndmc where elections take place sir
- 00:09:58I'm not sure have you ever voted in an
- 00:10:00Indian selection uh no sir then why are
- 00:10:03you saying there are electric component
- 00:10:04in ndmc because I'm for the first time
- 00:10:06I'm hearing somebody saying ndmc has
- 00:10:08electric components
- 00:10:21anyways you're currently sitting is
- 00:10:23Officer provisioner indeed I think we
- 00:10:26can discuss right to information with
- 00:10:28you what is the nodal department for
- 00:10:30right to right to information RTI uh so
- 00:10:32the noodle department so there's an
- 00:10:34information officer that is in every
- 00:10:36department and so that's true but what
- 00:10:38is the nodal Department in the ministry
- 00:10:41which Ministry so the central
- 00:10:42information commission sir comes under
- 00:10:44which Ministry who the the grants for
- 00:10:48Central information commissioner will be
- 00:10:51from which department so I believe it is
- 00:10:53under the so the ministry of a person
- 00:10:55else so htopd so why not information
- 00:10:59Ministry I mean there is a minister of
- 00:11:01information already you're an officer
- 00:11:03there and then RTI should be under you
- 00:11:05why dopt sir I believe that the reason
- 00:11:07for this is that the right to
- 00:11:09information act so number one is to
- 00:11:11ensure that information can be gathered
- 00:11:13from all the Ministries and so it is it
- 00:11:16is more of an of a human resources
- 00:11:18challenge rather than an information
- 00:11:19challenge so because ensuring that the
- 00:11:22human resources of all Ministries have
- 00:11:25the department so ensuring that the
- 00:11:27guidelines under section 4 of
- 00:11:28proactively giving out the information
- 00:11:30but none of them actually know what
- 00:11:32information is you guys are trained uh
- 00:11:34to understand what information is what
- 00:11:36information is valuable what information
- 00:11:38is to be disseminated and you are kept
- 00:11:40out of it out of it why so the primary
- 00:11:43Mandate of the information and
- 00:11:44broadcasting Ministry is so in the three
- 00:11:46departments is to take out the
- 00:11:48information of the government and take
- 00:11:50it to the public sir then
- 00:11:55so with respect to the RTI there needs
- 00:11:57to so there needs to be a central
- 00:11:58Ministry to ensure that all the other
- 00:12:00Ministries are doing their work and
- 00:12:02additionally so in the in the Mandate of
- 00:12:05the RTI for instance in section 4
- 00:12:07section 8 Etc there needs to be a
- 00:12:10supervisory mechanism so the information
- 00:12:11and broadcasting Ministry is primarily
- 00:12:13only focused on ensuring that
- 00:12:15information of the central government
- 00:12:17goes out such as schemes Etc recently a
- 00:12:20former Governor actually made a claim in
- 00:12:22the uh interview in an interview that
- 00:12:25the list of guests visitors to the
- 00:12:30president of India are is vetted by pmo
- 00:12:35right if I want to find out this through
- 00:12:37RTI will this information be supplied to
- 00:12:40me who will supply this or it is against
- 00:12:43the national interest and cannot be
- 00:12:44given
- 00:12:45what's your take as an IIs officer sir I
- 00:12:48believe that it depends on whether the
- 00:12:49information is being
- 00:12:50um if the information being seeked is
- 00:12:52before or after the event has taken
- 00:12:54place so if it is before perhaps they
- 00:12:56will
- 00:12:57not release the information till after
- 00:12:59the event is complete and sir I believe
- 00:13:02that the info RTI would be have to be
- 00:13:04filed with the pmo which is making the
- 00:13:06decisions you've taken anthropology as
- 00:13:08your option and you you mentioned that
- 00:13:11you uh is working or you like to work on
- 00:13:14the causes of Aging thing let's talk
- 00:13:16about disease is aging a disease
- 00:13:19technically speaking
- 00:13:21so very recently so the world length
- 00:13:23organization has indeed classified aging
- 00:13:25as a disease and so this is as of 2017.
- 00:13:29if it is a disease what kind of disease
- 00:13:30it is so currently it is understood to
- 00:13:33be a lifestyle disease lifestyle disease
- 00:13:34tell me uh since you have studied
- 00:13:38anthropology what is the role of
- 00:13:39diseases in evolution of humankind so it
- 00:13:43is said the diseases have actually made
- 00:13:45humans what they are so about 11 percent
- 00:13:47of our DNA comes from the DNA of viruses
- 00:13:50in bacteria
- 00:13:51so it is seen that diseases are the
- 00:13:53primary driver of what is called
- 00:13:55survival of the fittest it's in other in
- 00:13:57other words what you're saying that the
- 00:14:00treatments the medical science is
- 00:14:02disruption to evolution
- 00:14:04is it so speaking from a biological
- 00:14:06sense yes sir it's disruption too so why
- 00:14:09do you want to prevent aging then
- 00:14:11why do you want to disrupt Evolution so
- 00:14:13with regard to prevention of Aging sir
- 00:14:15the focus is on ensuring that the latter
- 00:14:17years of one's life are healthy and so
- 00:14:20because uh in the latter years one faces
- 00:14:23diseases such as cancer Etc so not only
- 00:14:25are there psychological burden on the
- 00:14:27family but additionally they also are a
- 00:14:29huge financial stress especially uh two
- 00:14:32large parts of the Indian population and
- 00:14:34so the reason for healthy aging is to
- 00:14:35ensure a healthy latter part of your
- 00:14:37life where one can ensure that they are
- 00:14:40happy enjoyed their retired life but if
- 00:14:42you look at what is happening in France
- 00:14:43it understand that people want to stop
- 00:14:45aging so that they can push human being
- 00:14:48to work even more
- 00:14:49unfair isn't it indeed so I believe that
- 00:14:53if even if we look at history so aging
- 00:14:55has always we are always in a fight
- 00:14:57against aging so the life expectancy
- 00:14:591900 was 40 globally and it was about 27
- 00:15:02in India So currently it is it is at
- 00:15:05about 72.5 and so because it happened in
- 00:15:08a span of 100 years and because we lived
- 00:15:10through it we don't look at it as
- 00:15:12prevention of Aging so the entire field
- 00:15:14of Medical Science is indeed uh is
- 00:15:17indeed doing the same thing of
- 00:15:18prevention preventing Aging in the lung
- 00:15:20cancer anyways thank you so
- 00:15:31argument with you
- 00:15:33if you prevent aging and kind of
- 00:15:36becoming
- 00:15:37the most populous country in the world
- 00:15:41how good Matlab we would be like
- 00:15:43anything
- 00:15:44nobody would be after us there would be
- 00:15:46huge gap
- 00:15:48India would be doing means a number of
- 00:15:50people would be their population wise I
- 00:15:52would say so
- 00:15:53does it okay or people should die on as
- 00:15:56per their age or why should we intervene
- 00:15:59basically so I believe the idea is to
- 00:16:02ensure that when an individual grows old
- 00:16:04so for instance there are a lot of
- 00:16:06individuals who at the age of 60 through
- 00:16:08their vast experience in their life have
- 00:16:10learned so much so for instance if we
- 00:16:12compare someone like Mr Rakesh junjun
- 00:16:14Walla and Mr Warren Buffett so the only
- 00:16:16difference is that Mr Rakesh Mala died
- 00:16:18early Mr Warren Buffett made a majority
- 00:16:21of his wealth after the age of 18. it
- 00:16:23means we are focusing or we have to
- 00:16:27focus on few individuals they have to
- 00:16:30live long
- 00:16:31who have that much who have gained that
- 00:16:33much of knowledge or in their particular
- 00:16:35field like Rakesh Union Wala or per se
- 00:16:38you can say Michael Jackson or somebody
- 00:16:40who is very famous renowned
- 00:16:42India
- 00:16:56what about the common people why not we
- 00:17:00work for the labors or for the people
- 00:17:02who are very well who are not privileged
- 00:17:06I would say absolutely so sir I believe
- 00:17:08that any uh therapy to prevent and
- 00:17:10prevent the causes of Aging will benefit
- 00:17:14um so the lower socioeconomic starter
- 00:17:16the most so this is because so a
- 00:17:18majority of their expenses are out of
- 00:17:19pocket expenses and are associated with
- 00:17:22the issues of Aging such as cancer such
- 00:17:25as high blood pressure such as heart
- 00:17:27issues so it is estimated that on
- 00:17:29average a family spends more than 60
- 00:17:31percent of its saving so on average is
- 00:17:33it good for a country like India so to
- 00:17:36spend this much on uh Healthcare health
- 00:17:38care and then population wise India is
- 00:17:40the top country indeed so that is the
- 00:17:44goal of the those people would be
- 00:17:45burdened on all resources so I believe
- 00:17:47that population is is
- 00:17:50um is potential for a country sir purana
- 00:18:03Quran and Lord Krishna if we talk about
- 00:18:06how many chapters are there in
- 00:18:07srimad-bhagavad-gita I said I'm not
- 00:18:09aware of the number of chaps why we talk
- 00:18:11about uh ramraj we used to talk about
- 00:18:14sir what is the concept of Rama so I
- 00:18:18believe that the idea of ramraja so for
- 00:18:20instance as understood by gandhiji he
- 00:18:22said that ramraja is gram rajya we need
- 00:18:25to ensure that the villages are the
- 00:18:28center of development we need to ensure
- 00:18:30that could you compare with your idea of
- 00:18:32prevention of raging
- 00:18:37why we talk about Rama Raja not Krishna
- 00:18:39rajya sir I am not aware of okay why uh
- 00:18:44means it is generally said that media is
- 00:18:46biased what does it mean so it is
- 00:18:48generally seen uh that the media all
- 00:18:51media houses tend to have a specific
- 00:18:53bias with uh for instance in the in a
- 00:18:57country like the United States there is
- 00:18:58a very clear division with channels such
- 00:19:00as and there is no biased in the mindset
- 00:19:03of a Babu who is sitting in the
- 00:19:04government working for the government
- 00:19:07why a country a democratic country if I
- 00:19:11would say as per kind of Indian
- 00:19:12democracy
- 00:19:13in a democratic system why we should
- 00:19:16control the opinion ideas and a number
- 00:19:21of things and that is not
- 00:19:23in relation with the freedom of a speech
- 00:19:26why should government control media
- 00:19:28houses so I believe that media houses
- 00:19:30should not be controlled only regulated
- 00:19:32so to this extent we have seen that even
- 00:19:35the regulation taken out by the
- 00:19:36government such as the Press councils
- 00:19:37act so most of these are self-regulatory
- 00:19:40bodies with individuals from within the
- 00:19:43Press houses regulating the information
- 00:19:45so only very recently in the IIT rules
- 00:19:47uh I'm just asking in a democratic
- 00:19:50country
- 00:19:51why
- 00:19:52these controls or I would say
- 00:19:55regulations
- 00:19:56should be there so I believe that the
- 00:19:58only restriction through regulation on
- 00:20:01the media should be on the basis of
- 00:20:03Article 19 too which gives the
- 00:20:05reasonable restrictions of freedom and
- 00:20:07speech of speech and expressions such as
- 00:20:09public order incitement of violence Etc
- 00:20:11okay what are the differences between
- 00:20:14and similarities between print and
- 00:20:16digital media so both the sources of
- 00:20:18information so we see that the print
- 00:20:20media is now shifting to digital media
- 00:20:22all the newspapers are slowly but surely
- 00:20:24moving so we are seeing that the entire
- 00:20:28print industry a lot of large so
- 00:20:31centuries-old newspapers such as the New
- 00:20:33York Times Etc are under tremendous
- 00:20:35pressure because they're not being
- 00:20:36they're not viable anymore because in
- 00:20:38the print media space and are moving to
- 00:20:40digital media so I believe there is more
- 00:20:41of a transition from print to digital
- 00:20:43cell should not be stopped this kind of
- 00:20:45print media because everybody is moving
- 00:20:47towards digital media and that would be
- 00:20:49also
- 00:20:50for the benefit of environment so I
- 00:20:53believe that print media is the primary
- 00:20:55source of information especially in
- 00:20:56rural areas so a lot of individuals are
- 00:20:59not they don't have access to server
- 00:21:02mobile phone or a mobile Tower or an
- 00:21:03iPad so in print media with a lot of
- 00:21:06individuals are illiterate and it is one
- 00:21:07individual in the village who's reading
- 00:21:09out the news to everyone that was a case
- 00:21:11in 70s and 80s nowadays everybody else
- 00:21:14is mobile phone any smartphone
- 00:21:16I would say you're talking about 70 is
- 00:21:1980 is a little isn't it sir I've read
- 00:21:22articles where even today during covid
- 00:21:24uh read an article where all the covered
- 00:21:26news was read out in a village in
- 00:21:28Maharashtra by one individual who was
- 00:21:29elected over there this was a tribal
- 00:21:31community
- 00:21:32okay madam
- 00:21:34I am really fascinated by your uh you
- 00:21:38know work which you are doing causes and
- 00:21:40prevention of Aging right a bit of more
- 00:21:43elaboration I would like to from you
- 00:21:46first what kind of method you are
- 00:21:48actually using for studying such kind of
- 00:21:50researches
- 00:21:52so what is the research method you have
- 00:21:54been used I'm the primary method of
- 00:21:56research that is used in Laboratories is
- 00:21:58a double-blind placebo-controlled method
- 00:22:01wherein different supplements different
- 00:22:04exercises different Lifestyle Changes
- 00:22:06individuals with certain habits are put
- 00:22:09in one control group and one active
- 00:22:11group and the efficacies of different
- 00:22:14systems is listed
- 00:22:16okay so it's a controlled experiment if
- 00:22:19I would say
- 00:22:20okay
- 00:22:22tell me that you have been studying the
- 00:22:26causes of Aging
- 00:22:28you know what are the causes the
- 00:22:29diseases are actually leading to aging
- 00:22:31right as I could make out from the
- 00:22:33discussion you have been doing now I
- 00:22:35believe that diseases are a little
- 00:22:37Downstream of the core cause of Aging
- 00:22:38okay so tell me that is pregnancy a kind
- 00:22:41of disease also no ma'am I do not
- 00:22:43believe that uh pregnancy but it brings
- 00:22:45a lot of changes in the body
- 00:22:48so how can it be you know dealt with for
- 00:22:51instance we see a lot of natural
- 00:22:53occurrences in the body such as puberty
- 00:22:55and Adolescence which bring a lot of
- 00:22:57changes in the body ma'am all of these a
- 00:22:59lot of these changes associated with
- 00:23:00growth and development mamdi and even
- 00:23:03though biologically we might age and the
- 00:23:05problem with aging is not the
- 00:23:07chronological age but the fact that
- 00:23:09there are negative diseases and lack of
- 00:23:12efficiency in the body associated with
- 00:23:13the process so I'm to that extent I
- 00:23:15don't believe that pregnancy or
- 00:23:17adolescent puberty is aging a disease
- 00:23:20okay tell me that recently you know
- 00:23:24global global uh Buddhist Summit
- 00:23:26actually took place right so what is the
- 00:23:29relevance of this Buddhist Summit in
- 00:23:32India
- 00:23:33um firstly India is the birthplace of
- 00:23:34Buddhism I am secondly in the
- 00:23:36international sphere we see that uh
- 00:23:39India while it cannot compete with China
- 00:23:41in the hard power sense soft power plays
- 00:23:43a crucial role China being a primarily
- 00:23:46Buddhist country and additionally India
- 00:23:49if it can become the flag bearer of
- 00:23:51Buddhism it can certainly gather a lot
- 00:23:53of support from a lot of neighboring
- 00:23:55Buddhist countries such as Myanmar such
- 00:23:57as Sri Lanka such as countries in
- 00:23:59Southeast Asia okay so it's politically
- 00:24:01driven otherwise no relevance of
- 00:24:04Buddhism in India ma'am India has a
- 00:24:06large Buddhist population and mam
- 00:24:07culturally India was like I mentioned
- 00:24:09the birthplace of course okay so what
- 00:24:10are the four teachings of Buddha
- 00:24:14the first was non-violence ma'am II was
- 00:24:18ensuring controlling the senses through
- 00:24:21meditation ma'am these are the only two
- 00:24:22icons okay no issue you're from Delhi
- 00:24:25right
- 00:24:26so tell me that how can you know one
- 00:24:29protect uh Dead River like yamuna I
- 00:24:32consider it a dead River you know while
- 00:24:34I am coming
- 00:24:35here on my way the stinking uh you know
- 00:24:38that smell actually suffocates me right
- 00:24:41so it's almost it's not a river now it's
- 00:24:43a drain
- 00:24:45so how can this Dead River be revived
- 00:24:48and as a student of anthropology what is
- 00:24:51the cultural relevance of river I am to
- 00:24:53revive a river such as the yamuna in the
- 00:24:56current state that it is ma'am four-step
- 00:24:58process can be used a folk wronged
- 00:25:00approach so I'm the first being
- 00:25:02monitoring of all the industrial
- 00:25:04affluence that are released into the
- 00:25:05yamuna and the second being ensuring
- 00:25:08that there is flood plain management
- 00:25:09when the flood planes are often called
- 00:25:11the a vital part of the health of the
- 00:25:13river ensuring that these areas are
- 00:25:15green construction doesn't happen on
- 00:25:16these areas Etc
- 00:25:18and the third is bioremediation of the
- 00:25:20river itself using natural causes now
- 00:25:23for instance there are plants there are
- 00:25:25a lot of microorganisms that can be used
- 00:25:27to clean up the river itself and through
- 00:25:29a process which is called bio mining
- 00:25:31unfortunately man the use of sewage
- 00:25:33treatment plants and wastewater
- 00:25:35treatment plants that is pumping the
- 00:25:37river of the yamuna into these plants
- 00:25:39where it is cleaned and put further and
- 00:25:42the fifth would be to I mean extra point
- 00:25:44would be just to ensure that the natural
- 00:25:45flow of the river if it is maintained as
- 00:25:48we saw in the covet crisis the Nature
- 00:25:50has a remarkable tendency to heal itself
- 00:25:52okay so what is the sociological
- 00:25:54relevance of uh River of any River
- 00:26:00is something that is Central to society
- 00:26:02it is said the thousands have lived
- 00:26:03without love but not one without water
- 00:26:05ma'am Rivers have traditionally been one
- 00:26:07of the foremost sources of water
- 00:26:10individuals have always uh large
- 00:26:13civilizations have always been made on
- 00:26:15the banks of what is the cultural
- 00:26:17relevance
- 00:26:18for instance I'm in the yamuna we see
- 00:26:20that a lot of the rights associated with
- 00:26:22death Etc
- 00:26:24the last remains are often flown into
- 00:26:26the river and there are a lot of
- 00:26:29um
- 00:26:30pujas Etc that happen on the banks of
- 00:26:32the river
- 00:26:33ma'am often it is said in India to
- 00:26:34cleanse your sins you need to take a dip
- 00:26:37in the ganga cleanse yourself and make
- 00:26:39the River polluted
- 00:26:42so you agree so there is no cultural
- 00:26:44relevance among the cultural relevance
- 00:26:46is the fact that our very being our
- 00:26:47understanding of the universe around us
- 00:26:49our understanding of the world do we
- 00:26:51have any policy
- 00:26:52over this do we have any robust policy
- 00:26:55I'm specifically for Rivers yes we have
- 00:26:57the ganga action plan for the yamuna
- 00:27:00also there was a yamuna board that was
- 00:27:02created specifically for the purpose of
- 00:27:04cleaning it now okay thank you anirudh
- 00:27:06thank you
- 00:27:07that
- 00:27:11playing football is one of your hobbies
- 00:27:13right up so did you watch the last FIFA
- 00:27:16World Cup indeed okay right see in these
- 00:27:20international events we often hear that
- 00:27:22you know they the the body the officials
- 00:27:26of these bodies are actually you know
- 00:27:28requested to may make a statement of on
- 00:27:31International contentious issues for
- 00:27:33example it was a Russian Ukraine issue
- 00:27:35at that
- 00:27:36more moment of time similarly in the
- 00:27:38past there was Tibetan crisis you know
- 00:27:40Tibetan issue in Olympics so do you find
- 00:27:44it okay or you know you would like to
- 00:27:47have more independent space for
- 00:27:49international sports bodies sir I
- 00:27:51believe Sports is something that brings
- 00:27:52the world together it crosses National
- 00:27:54boundaries and has the unique power of
- 00:27:57uniting people
- 00:27:59so be it a football match would be it uh
- 00:28:01Athletics in the Olympics and to that
- 00:28:03degree sir I believe that Sports so what
- 00:28:05is often called Sports washing that
- 00:28:07Sports should not be used as an excuse
- 00:28:09by your country or by any International
- 00:28:10Organization or to bring up a certain
- 00:28:12political issue or to cleanse so things
- 00:28:16that have happened in the past in that
- 00:28:17particular countries okay see where do
- 00:28:20you see Indian football today do you
- 00:28:22think that you know in certain uh time
- 00:28:25down the line you know India will be
- 00:28:28able to participate in FIFA World Cup so
- 00:28:30I certainly hope so but I think that a
- 00:28:32day is about at least 12 to 16 years
- 00:28:35away so what would you like to do sir I
- 00:28:38believe that firstly so we need to scout
- 00:28:40the talent because it's a lot of talent
- 00:28:42but uh harnessing it and identifying it
- 00:28:45early is the key challenge so secondly
- 00:28:48we see that in countries like Europe and
- 00:28:50Brazil there is a certain craze of
- 00:28:52football the same way we have a craze of
- 00:28:54cricket which makes individuals drive
- 00:28:57forward in football so thirdly is the
- 00:28:59facilities the infrastructure so
- 00:29:01ensuring that there are coaches so in
- 00:29:03the Western World we have dietist
- 00:29:05nutritionists geneticists often working
- 00:29:07with football teams and so ensuring that
- 00:29:09there is a little more funding towards
- 00:29:11the professional aspect of the same and
- 00:29:13so fourthly there would be the coaching
- 00:29:14industry so India has not uh does not
- 00:29:17have any preeminent coaches in football
- 00:29:19and so coaching it is said can create an
- 00:29:22average player into an extraordinary
- 00:29:23player so these four steps I believe
- 00:29:25would okay see in this month India's
- 00:29:27external affairs minister will be on a
- 00:29:30visit to Latin America and Caribbean you
- 00:29:34know countries right so what I know what
- 00:29:38do these countries you know hold for
- 00:29:40India in terms of you know uh many
- 00:29:42things so the Latin American countries
- 00:29:44in the Caribbean countries hold immense
- 00:29:46significance to India especially in the
- 00:29:48current scenario so firstly because we
- 00:29:50have seen that a lot of Technologies
- 00:29:53especially related to lithium so have
- 00:29:55been will be transferred there are talks
- 00:29:57going on with Bolivia
- 00:29:58so secondly we see that um
- 00:30:01sir countries such as Brazil are part of
- 00:30:04major International organizations and
- 00:30:06ensuring
- 00:30:07ensuring that we have relations with all
- 00:30:10South American countries can certainly
- 00:30:11increase our uh so the fact that India
- 00:30:14needs more votes often in United Nations
- 00:30:16that is there sir so thirdly the
- 00:30:18diaspora of India is not too much in
- 00:30:20South America so that is not a reason
- 00:30:22for concern sir and so fourthly I
- 00:30:25believe the fact that
- 00:30:27uh so South America shares a border with
- 00:30:30the Pacific Ocean and with the Pacific
- 00:30:31Ocean now being called the indo-pacific
- 00:30:33and becoming into and coming into
- 00:30:35increased relevance so that is also a
- 00:30:38factor that needs to be considered thank
- 00:30:39you
- 00:30:40what is the status of data protection
- 00:30:44Bill and digital India bill so the data
- 00:30:47protection bill is currently uh it has
- 00:30:49been revised and will be brought in
- 00:30:50during the monsoon sessions and digital
- 00:30:52indiable
- 00:30:56yeah I've had the exposure to MIT also
- 00:31:00isn't it so my Visa application was
- 00:31:02canceled sir you didn't go to so I
- 00:31:04couldn't go to MIT but I was part of the
- 00:31:05team I was supposed to go so okay I
- 00:31:07attended it virtually okay and did you
- 00:31:10go to Vienna or you didn't go to Vienna
- 00:31:12that was a three month long internship
- 00:31:13sir so I'd gone there you had to go on
- 00:31:14there so you must have had some exposure
- 00:31:16of
- 00:31:18academics in uh the European countries
- 00:31:22in the new education policy government
- 00:31:24is trying to attract foreign University
- 00:31:26is to set up campuses in our country
- 00:31:31in your opinion
- 00:31:34is it a pragmatic proposition will
- 00:31:37reputed universities from the world war
- 00:31:40will come and set up campuses in India
- 00:31:43indeed so I do believe that it is a
- 00:31:45valuable proposition so firstly because
- 00:31:48we see that there are a lot of
- 00:31:49individuals going from India abroad in
- 00:31:52search of these universities and foreign
- 00:31:53degrees so this money can not only stay
- 00:31:56in India but the brain drain that is
- 00:31:57happening can stay in India so secondly
- 00:32:00I believe that India right now so only
- 00:32:01today there was an article saying the
- 00:32:03number of people who give GRE in India
- 00:32:05and USA is the same that is India is
- 00:32:07concerned do you think that foreign
- 00:32:08universities will be attracted and
- 00:32:10should be financially and economically
- 00:32:13viable proposition for them to set up a
- 00:32:16campuses in our country certainly so I
- 00:32:18believe that in India so because there
- 00:32:21are so many people graduating every year
- 00:32:22in search of quality education so these
- 00:32:25uh a lot of these institutes that come
- 00:32:27in will come in with a tag of a foreign
- 00:32:29University that is often in demand in a
- 00:32:31country like India and students who are
- 00:32:33paying upwards so there are students
- 00:32:34paying upwards of 10 lakhs 15 lakhs for
- 00:32:36engineering seats sir add something at a
- 00:32:39price point such as this in India they
- 00:32:41will certainly be financially viable as
- 00:32:43well sir one last question before we let
- 00:32:45you go can you prescribe a prescription
- 00:32:48to me by which by I can delay my aging
- 00:32:52absolutely so tell me what is the
- 00:32:54prescription so the first and foremost
- 00:32:56would be to sleep eight hours a day so
- 00:32:58because that is the number one causal
- 00:33:00region for stress Etc that exacerbates
- 00:33:03everything else so second would be
- 00:33:05exercise so ensuring that 220 minutes of
- 00:33:07exercise done is something that should
- 00:33:09everyone should do so third is the use
- 00:33:11of what we call ayurvedic supplements
- 00:33:15Etc so eating chavan crash daily is the
- 00:33:18most beneficial thing one can do for
- 00:33:19their immunity and ensuring that the
- 00:33:21self-healing system works well so having
- 00:33:24haldi regularly something that is
- 00:33:26especially good for everyone so for
- 00:33:29instance if you have a clove of garlic
- 00:33:31every day so you can certainly ensure
- 00:33:33that your heart heart health remains
- 00:33:35fine so that there are a lot of other
- 00:33:37biohacks as well so there is something
- 00:33:39called a Soleus push-up which everyone
- 00:33:41can do just while sitting so this
- 00:33:43ensures that LDL the bad cholesterol in
- 00:33:45our body reduces by about 25 percent
- 00:33:48only if we do this about one to two
- 00:33:49hours a day and this is as simple as
- 00:33:51just raising your calf
- 00:33:54yeah every about 10 seconds if you're
- 00:33:56sitting for two hours thanks a lot for
- 00:33:58your valuable suggestions
- 00:33:59nice talking to you your interview is
- 00:34:01over you may go now thank you thank you
- 00:34:03thank you
- 00:34:06[Music]
- 00:34:16thank you
- 00:34:18this is your second or third this is my
- 00:34:21third interview sorry interview
- 00:34:23marks first interview marks cyber 119
- 00:34:27the first one 190 second interview marks
- 00:34:29173 170.
- 00:34:32anything between 170 to 200 no doubt
- 00:34:36about it excellent communication skill
- 00:34:38your ideas are very clear confident no
- 00:34:41issues with that
- 00:34:42now
- 00:34:44your interview will be
- 00:34:48conducted
- 00:34:50with a different ethos now you are
- 00:34:52already a member of Indian Civil Service
- 00:34:55earlier occasions you are aspiring to
- 00:34:57become a member this year we will be
- 00:34:59going as a member of Indian civil
- 00:35:02service
- 00:35:03so lot of questions you should expect
- 00:35:05about the role of services in the making
- 00:35:07of our country that is very important
- 00:35:10what are the positive sides what are the
- 00:35:12negative sites and all that and you must
- 00:35:15be aware of all that that's because your
- 00:35:17father also happened to be in the
- 00:35:20bureaucracy and particularly in the
- 00:35:21department of police and all that so
- 00:35:24negative perception about the police the
- 00:35:26police reforms what are your suggestions
- 00:35:28the community policing and all that the
- 00:35:32issues faced by because The Cutting Edge
- 00:35:35level of constability and all that those
- 00:35:38funding issues and all that so you
- 00:35:41should expect questions regarding that
- 00:35:43now you are a member of Indian
- 00:35:45information service
- 00:35:47so read thoroughly about
- 00:35:50your service what exactly because there
- 00:35:53won't be a very direct question it will
- 00:35:55only be a situational question and a
- 00:35:58problem
- 00:36:00to oppose before you what is the need of
- 00:36:03Indian information system in the Modern
- 00:36:05Age so there you have to justify the
- 00:36:08need and what way it
- 00:36:11regulates it can't be controlling how
- 00:36:14hard does it regulate and all that
- 00:36:17in that case in that respect only the
- 00:36:20right to Information Act and all that it
- 00:36:23comes handy who controls print media
- 00:36:26which agency controls digital media Ott
- 00:36:29platform and all that expect questions
- 00:36:32on all that RTI
- 00:36:35read it thoroughly is very important
- 00:36:37because I was not expecting you to get
- 00:36:40confused on the issue of RTI and dopt is
- 00:36:43the nodal Ministry for that one another
- 00:36:45department for that so as a civil
- 00:36:49servant it should not be wanting on such
- 00:36:51issues and all that
- 00:36:53and then you are a product of IIT issues
- 00:36:58with regard to IIT issues with regard to
- 00:37:00higher education problems in the IIT per
- 00:37:03se besides Dropout rates and all that
- 00:37:06those issues are also relevant must
- 00:37:09remain growth of iits or so you may be
- 00:37:13asked to compare the
- 00:37:15new upcoming iits with uh yeah so that
- 00:37:19is another why other private
- 00:37:21institutions can't come up to the level
- 00:37:23of iits and all that so larger issue of
- 00:37:26our Indian education system and all that
- 00:37:29so you are a boy from Delhi
- 00:37:32Delhi should prepare thoroughly from all
- 00:37:35angles so because we should expect beat
- 00:37:38a issue of pollution be it issue of
- 00:37:41landfills BTC of Transport problems and
- 00:37:45so on so forth is a long long list isn't
- 00:37:48it and you have studied from a school
- 00:37:50called sanskriti I believe so issue
- 00:37:54surrounding areas what are the problems
- 00:37:56they have seen and all that so that will
- 00:37:58may bring you to the question of Slum
- 00:38:00dwelling and all that that is also an
- 00:38:03important area and uh the bills which
- 00:38:05are in the offering the details of those
- 00:38:08bills related to your ministry that that
- 00:38:10is very important for you
- 00:38:12and uh try to get intent of the question
- 00:38:16you have one question you heard on the
- 00:38:18wrong side the question was asked about
- 00:38:21ndmc and you spoke about MCD then later
- 00:38:24on you realized that you are giving so
- 00:38:27don't
- 00:38:28ensure that such occasions don't arise
- 00:38:30okay
- 00:38:32otherwise you are a wonderful candidate
- 00:38:33and you have proved your Metro twice so
- 00:38:36nothing much to add to what we have told
- 00:38:38you so work thoroughly on your
- 00:38:41departments working on the bureaucracy
- 00:38:44or bureaucracy has contributed so far or
- 00:38:48should contribute in the future what
- 00:38:50changes do you recommend in the way our
- 00:38:53bureaucracy works and all that your
- 00:38:55views on natural entry and so on so
- 00:38:57forth so all those issues are there but
- 00:38:59you are a wonderful candidate and if you
- 00:39:00have really done well in your Mains
- 00:39:03examination
- 00:39:04God willing will be in the list of
- 00:39:07Indian United States such as offices
- 00:39:09okay thank you all the best days thank
- 00:39:11you sir
- 00:39:12foreign
- Anirudh Yadav
- byråkrati
- Indien
- mediaregelering
- AI
- ChatGPT
- politik
- policy
- officerstrainee
- korruption