The Real Reason Amelia Earhart’s Plane Crashed
Resumo
TLDRThe video explores the tragic last flight of Amelia Earhart in 1937, emphasizing how her lack of knowledge in physics and radio navigation led to her disappearance. The video hypothesizes that had Earhart toggled a specific radio switch, it might have saved her life. It covers how Earhart attempted to become the first female pilot to circumnavigate the globe, detailing the meticulous yet flawed planning involving navigation and radio communication. Despite exhaustive preparations, a series of miscommunications, technical failures, and a lack of thorough understanding of radio waves resulted in Earhart's final tragic message before disappearing over the Pacific. Emphasis is also placed on the importance of knowledge and responsibility in overcoming challenges, suggesting that greater communication understanding might have altered history.
Conclusões
- 🚀 Amelia Earhart aimed to be the first female pilot to fly around the world.
- 🎯 She chose a new, longer Equatorial route.
- 🗺️ Navigating the vast Pacific Ocean posed significant challenges.
- 📡 Radio communication was critical but failed due to technical issues.
- ⏳ Earhart missed relay signals that were crucial for navigation.
- 🚢 Support ships were not enough to assist due to miscommunication.
- 🔋 Knowledge gaps in radio technology contributed to her fate.
- 🗣️ Effective two-way communication was lacking on the Electra.
- 🔍 Mismanagement of resources and incorrect planning led to her demise.
- 📚 The tragedy underscored the need for knowledge and responsibility in challenging endeavors.
Linha do tempo
- 00:00:00 - 00:05:00
Amelia Earhart faced navigational troubles over the Pacific Ocean in 1937, exacerbated by a series of avoidable decisions due to a lack of physics knowledge. To maximize flight range, she stripped her plane of unnecessary weight, converting it into a flying gas can to cover the long distance across the Pacific, relying on the small Howland Island as a refueling stop.
- 00:05:00 - 00:10:00
Earhart lobbied successfully for a runway on Howland Island, showcasing her connections and determination. Navigational strategies included dead reckoning and celestial navigation, complicated by a stronger than expected headwind. Communication breakdowns with the ground highlighted dangers of her daring flight path near the Equator.
- 00:10:00 - 00:15:00
The radio technology of the time, key for navigation, faced challenges. Earhart's equipment aimed to use radio signals to triangulate her location but was hindered by technical and procedural issues. Miscommunications about signal frequencies and equipment capabilities further complicated navigation.
- 00:15:00 - 00:20:00
An experiment demonstrates radio wave direction finding using simple antennas. The inability to properly triangulate signals due to outdated or misaligned equipment was a critical flaw in Earhart's plan, illustrating the technological limitations and the complexity involved in aerial navigation of that era.
- 00:20:00 - 00:25:00
Earhart anticipated using radio signals to navigate close to Howland Island. However, miscommunication about signal frequencies and time zones with the Itasca led to missed connections. Equipment limitations and misunderstanding contributed significantly to the navigational failure.
- 00:25:00 - 00:30:00
Technical and administrative oversights coupled with Earhart's misunderstanding of her equipment capabilities resulted in a failed navigation attempt to Howland Island. Suggestions that her equipment could have been mishandled underline the importance of aligning knowledge with responsibility during such missions.
- 00:30:00 - 00:36:35
Amelia Earhart's tragic flight highlighted the need for deep technical understanding and effective communication in challenging expeditions. Even with adequate knowledge, the absence of clear responsibilities and procedural oversight turned small errors into a catastrophic event, depicted through the lens of KiwiCo's project-like endeavor in engaging with scientific curiosity and learning.
Mapa mental
Vídeo de perguntas e respostas
What was Amelia Earhart's goal in 1937?
Amelia Earhart aimed to become the first female pilot to fly around the world.
What factors contributed to Earhart's disappearance?
Her disappearance was largely due to miscommunications, technical failures, and a lack of thorough understanding of radio navigation.
How was Earhart's route different from others?
Earhart chose a longer Equatorial route rather than the shorter northern route that others had taken.
What error was made with radio communication?
There were miscommunications about frequencies between Earhart and the Itasca, along with a failure to utilize lower frequencies for directional finding.
What was the role of the support ships during her flight?
Support ships were deployed to assist with navigation by sending directional signals, but due to various communication mishaps, they could not effectively help.
What could have potentially saved Earhart?
Switching the radio receiver setting to pick up lower frequency signals might have guided her safely to Howland Island.
Why was Earhart's final destination difficult to find?
Howland Island is a very small speck in the Pacific Ocean, making it extremely challenging to spot without precise navigation.
What lesson does the video emphasize from Earhart's tragedy?
The importance of both knowledge and responsibility to prevent disasters in challenging tasks like aviation.
Ver mais resumos de vídeos
Coffee Roasting Explained
Demonstration of Stomata on a Leaf Peel - MeitY OLabs
Paper Chromatography - MeitY OLabs
Osprey Aether Plus 85L Review#best #hiking pack review
SHE KILLED HER BEST FRIEND AND TOOK OVER HER HOME: IF ONLY SHE KNEW (PART 2) ....#viralafricantales
SHE KILLED HER BEST FRIEND AND TOOK OVER HER HOME: IF ONLY SHE KNEW....#viralafricantales
- 00:00:00- [Derek] As the sun rose on July 2nd, 1937,
- 00:00:04Amelia Earhart knew she was in trouble.
- 00:00:07Over the radio, she called,
- 00:00:09"We must be on you but cannot see you.
- 00:00:11Gas is running low.
- 00:00:13Been unable to reach you by radio.
- 00:00:15We are flying at 1,000 feet."
- 00:00:18Beneath her was water
- 00:00:20in every direction as far as the eye could see.
- 00:00:24She got herself into this predicament
- 00:00:26through a series of unfortunate events and bad decisions.
- 00:00:30Many of them could have been avoided
- 00:00:32with a better knowledge of physics.
- 00:00:35But even so,
- 00:00:36there was one thing she could have done in this moment,
- 00:00:39one switch she could have flipped
- 00:00:41that would likely have saved her life and changed history.
- 00:00:48This video is sponsored by KiwiCo.
- 00:00:50More about them at the end of the show.
- 00:00:54Amelia Earhart was vying to become the first female pilot
- 00:00:57to fly around the world.
- 00:00:58- I hope to accomplish something
- 00:01:00really scientifically worthwhile for aviation.
- 00:01:04- And she wasn't taking any shortcuts.
- 00:01:06Other successful circumnavigations
- 00:01:08had followed a northern route,
- 00:01:10mostly staying close to land.
- 00:01:13But Earhart's route would be the longest
- 00:01:15by following a path close to the Equator.
- 00:01:19This meant the last part of her journey was the hardest,
- 00:01:23crossing the full width of the Pacific Ocean.
- 00:01:26The starting point for this crossing was Lae,
- 00:01:29a city on the eastern side of New Guinea.
- 00:01:32At the time, it was one of the world's busiest airports,
- 00:01:35a hub of traffic from Asia and Australia.
- 00:01:39At 10:00 a.m. on a hot July day,
- 00:01:41Earhart piloted her Lockheed Electra down the runway
- 00:01:44and took off on what would be her final flight.
- 00:01:52The Pacific Ocean is huge.
- 00:01:55It's way bigger than the Atlantic.
- 00:01:57I mean, if you look at the globe from that side,
- 00:02:00you see almost no land.
- 00:02:02The problem was, in 1937,
- 00:02:05most planes could only fly a maximum
- 00:02:07of a few thousand kilometers,
- 00:02:10so Earhart removed everything unnecessary from her plane.
- 00:02:14She ripped out the insulation to reduce weight,
- 00:02:17but that made the engine noise so overwhelming
- 00:02:20she had to communicate with her navigator
- 00:02:22sitting right beside her
- 00:02:23using written notes.
- 00:02:26She packed almost nothing, telling her husband,
- 00:02:29"Extra clothes and extra food
- 00:02:31would have been extra weight and extra worry."
- 00:02:34She replaced the passenger seats with fuel tanks,
- 00:02:38effectively turning her plane into a flying gas can.
- 00:02:42But even so, the Electra's maximum range
- 00:02:45was between 6,600 and 7,200 kilometers in perfect weather.
- 00:02:50It could be just enough to reach Hawaii from Lae,
- 00:02:53or she might come up disastrously short.
- 00:02:58So Earhart needed a place to stop and refuel along the way.
- 00:03:03Now, it might seem like there's no land here,
- 00:03:05but if you zoom in,
- 00:03:07there is this tiny island
- 00:03:09halfway between Australia and Hawaii.
- 00:03:12Howland Island is just over two kilometers long
- 00:03:16and less than one kilometer wide.
- 00:03:18The US had claimed it
- 00:03:20as part of the Guano Islands Act of 1856.
- 00:03:22But in 1937, it was barely inhabited
- 00:03:25with just a handful of colonists.
- 00:03:28It would be an ideal location to refuel,
- 00:03:31if only it had a runway.
- 00:03:34Fortunately for Earhart,
- 00:03:35by the time of her around the world flight,
- 00:03:37she was already famous.
- 00:03:40In 1928, she became the first female passenger
- 00:03:43to cross the Atlantic by airplane.
- 00:03:45This made her an international celebrity.
- 00:03:48- [Announcer] She said she could, and she did it.
- 00:03:50(lively music)
- 00:03:54- [Derek] But she wanted to fly herself, saying,
- 00:03:57"Maybe someday I'll try it alone."
- 00:03:59So, in 1932,
- 00:04:01she attempted to pilot a plane solo across the Atlantic
- 00:04:05heading for Paris.
- 00:04:06She brought with her only a toothbrush,
- 00:04:08one container of soup and three cans of tomato juice.
- 00:04:12(thunder booms)
- 00:04:15But storms, ice, and dense fog battered her small plane.
- 00:04:20A seam in the exhaust manifold cracked
- 00:04:22and flames from the engine spewed out into the night.
- 00:04:26Gas leaked down her neck from a broken tank,
- 00:04:29and after 14 hours,
- 00:04:30she landed in a pasture in Northern Ireland.
- 00:04:33Her face was so covered in grease,
- 00:04:35a farmhand couldn't tell if she was a man or a woman.
- 00:04:39He asked if she had flown far.
- 00:04:41"From America," she replied.
- 00:04:44- I wish I could have done it faster.
- 00:04:46- [Derek] These adventures brought her
- 00:04:48into the orbits of powerful people,
- 00:04:50like the First Lady, Eleanor Roosevelt.
- 00:04:52- And Mrs. Roosevelt,
- 00:04:53won't you go for a ride tonight over Washington?
- 00:04:56It's really lovely from the air at night.
- 00:04:58- And using her new connections,
- 00:05:00she lobbied the president to hire her friend, Eugene Vidal,
- 00:05:03to head the Bureau of Commerce.
- 00:05:05Vidal had promised Earhart a runway on Howland Island,
- 00:05:09but red tape stalled progress
- 00:05:11only months before her planned takeoff.
- 00:05:14So Earhart wrote directly to President Roosevelt.
- 00:05:18She explained that the airstrip funds
- 00:05:19required immediate approval,
- 00:05:21writing, "Please forgive troublesome female flyer
- 00:05:24for whom this Howland Island project is key
- 00:05:27to world flight attempt."
- 00:05:29The president approved the project four days later,
- 00:05:32and three runways were soon cleared.
- 00:05:37So she had a place to land,
- 00:05:39but how would she find this tiny speck of an island
- 00:05:43in a vast ocean?
- 00:05:46Well, flying with her in the Electra
- 00:05:48was her navigator, Fred Noonan,
- 00:05:50and he would calculate the flight plan.
- 00:05:53They knew the direction of Howland,
- 00:05:55so they could use the onboard compass
- 00:05:57to set their bearing toward it.
- 00:05:59They knew their air speed
- 00:06:00and could figure out their ground speed
- 00:06:02by subtracting or adding the wind,
- 00:06:05and then they could calculate how long it should take
- 00:06:07to reach the island.
- 00:06:09This method is known as dead reckoning.
- 00:06:13But they wouldn't aim directly at the island,
- 00:06:15because if they did that
- 00:06:16and they didn't see it at the prescribed time,
- 00:06:19they wouldn't know in which direction they were off.
- 00:06:22So instead, they intentionally picked a point
- 00:06:25either north or south of the island.
- 00:06:27Let's say they picked south.
- 00:06:29They estimated the trip would take 18 hours,
- 00:06:32so they would fly through day and night.
- 00:06:36And once they had traveled
- 00:06:37for the calculated length of time,
- 00:06:39they could confidently turn north and spot the island.
- 00:06:44Before takeoff, the ground crew estimated
- 00:06:46they would encounter a headwind of 24 kilometers per hour.
- 00:06:50But just 20 minutes after takeoff,
- 00:06:52Lae radioed Earhart to warn
- 00:06:54that the headwinds would be stronger.
- 00:06:56She didn't acknowledge their message.
- 00:07:00Knowing the correct wind speed was critical
- 00:07:02because it would affect how long it would take
- 00:07:04to reach the island.
- 00:07:05If it took longer, Earhart would have to turn later.
- 00:07:08So she couldn't rely on dead reckoning alone
- 00:07:11to reach Howland.
- 00:07:14As an independent check on their location,
- 00:07:16Noonan would take measurements of the sun, moon, and stars.
- 00:07:20This is known as celestial navigation.
- 00:07:24He had an almanac that listed 58 navigation stars
- 00:07:27and the point on Earth each one would be directly overhead
- 00:07:31for the day and time of his measurement.
- 00:07:34If they found themselves directly under a navigation star,
- 00:07:37well, then they would immediately know their position.
- 00:07:40But generally they would not be that lucky,
- 00:07:43so Noonan would measure the angle above the horizon
- 00:07:46to a navigation star
- 00:07:48and use that to work out how far away they were
- 00:07:51from the point on the Earth
- 00:07:53where that star would be directly overhead.
- 00:07:55So he could trace out a circle on the globe
- 00:07:58of possible locations,
- 00:08:00and then he would measure the angle
- 00:08:01to another navigation star
- 00:08:03and draw out a second circle.
- 00:08:06And now they must be
- 00:08:07at one of these two circle intersections.
- 00:08:11Normally the circles were so large
- 00:08:13that only one of the intersections
- 00:08:14would be a plausible position.
- 00:08:17That way they could continually update their location
- 00:08:20and adjust bearings as needed.
- 00:08:22But even with celestial navigation,
- 00:08:24errors could accumulate over long trips.
- 00:08:27Earlier in the journey, when Earhart crossed the Atlantic,
- 00:08:30they missed their intended airport in hazy conditions.
- 00:08:34Noonan's calculations were reasonable,
- 00:08:36but small errors put them off course.
- 00:08:39Luckily, in Africa,
- 00:08:40there were plenty of other places to land safely.
- 00:08:43The same could not be said for Howland.
- 00:08:48So, for the flight across the Pacific,
- 00:08:50Earhart commandeered three US Navy and Coast Guard ships.
- 00:08:54The Itasca would be stationed at Howland Island,
- 00:08:57the Ontario would be halfway along the route,
- 00:09:00and the Swan was positioned midway
- 00:09:02between Howland and Hawaii.
- 00:09:05The Itasca would send out smoke signals
- 00:09:07as Earhart approached to help her spot the island.
- 00:09:11But even more importantly,
- 00:09:12all ships were equipped with radio.
- 00:09:16Now, in 1937, radio was still fairly new tech.
- 00:09:20German physicist Heinrich Hertz discovered radio waves
- 00:09:23in the late 1880s.
- 00:09:24He excited electrons to oscillate back and forth
- 00:09:27in his transmitter,
- 00:09:29and a few meters away his receiver was a loop of wire
- 00:09:32with a small gap in it.
- 00:09:34When Hertz looked at it through a microscope in the dark,
- 00:09:37he saw faint sparks jumping across the gap.
- 00:09:41The sparks were strongest when the receiving loop was flat.
- 00:09:44If it was vertical, then no sparks were observed.
- 00:09:48This demonstrated that radio waves are transverse waves
- 00:09:51with electric and magnetic fields
- 00:09:53oscillating perpendicular to each other
- 00:09:56and perpendicular to the direction of the wave motion.
- 00:09:59When the receiving loop was aligned
- 00:10:01with the direction the wave was traveling,
- 00:10:03the changing magnetic field through the loop
- 00:10:05induced an EMF that created the spark.
- 00:10:08But if the loop was facing the transmitter,
- 00:10:11then there was no change in magnetic flux through the loop,
- 00:10:14and so no spark was observed.
- 00:10:18Now, Hertz couldn't see the future he had ushered in.
- 00:10:21He said, "I do not think
- 00:10:23that the wireless waves I have discovered
- 00:10:25will have any practical application."
- 00:10:28But within a few years,
- 00:10:29people started sending messages using radio.
- 00:10:32And by the 1920s, radio entertainment broadcast took off.
- 00:10:36Ships and planes routinely used radio to send Morse code,
- 00:10:39and some, including Earhart,
- 00:10:41could send and receive voice messages.
- 00:10:46In fact, Earhart had five radio antennas around the plane,
- 00:10:50each for a specific purpose.
- 00:10:52The largest antenna could be reeled in and out
- 00:10:55like a fishing line behind the plane.
- 00:10:57It was 76 meters long,
- 00:10:59which was necessary
- 00:11:00to efficiently send and receive Morse code
- 00:11:03via the 4 or 500 kilohertz radio waves
- 00:11:06used by ships and remote stations.
- 00:11:09Ideally, an antenna should be at least 1/4 of the wavelength
- 00:11:12of the radio wave it's transmitting or receiving.
- 00:11:15This improves the efficiency
- 00:11:16of the conversion from electrical energy
- 00:11:19to radiated electromagnetic energy.
- 00:11:22Earhart's trailing antenna
- 00:11:23was only around 1/8 of the wavelength.
- 00:11:26But it was connected to a high-power transmitter,
- 00:11:29so its signals could still be detected
- 00:11:31over 1,000 kilometers away.
- 00:11:33Next were two antennas for voice communications
- 00:11:36on higher frequencies.
- 00:11:38A transmitting V antenna on the roof of the plane
- 00:11:40and a receiving antenna along its belly.
- 00:11:44Higher frequencies were useful for two reasons.
- 00:11:47First, they require smaller antennas,
- 00:11:49which save weight and can be better accommodated
- 00:11:52on small sparse planes.
- 00:11:54And second, high frequency radio waves
- 00:11:56can travel long distances
- 00:11:58by bouncing off a layer of the atmosphere
- 00:12:00called the ionosphere.
- 00:12:02Starting about 50 kilometers above Earth's surface,
- 00:12:05radiation from the Sun splits electrons off molecules
- 00:12:09forming a layer of ions and free electrons.
- 00:12:12Radio waves with certain frequencies
- 00:12:15interact with these free electrons
- 00:12:16and are effectively reflected back to Earth.
- 00:12:19It's as if they've bounced off
- 00:12:21a big wobbly mirror in the sky.
- 00:12:24This effect is called skipping
- 00:12:26and it scatters radio waves all over the place.
- 00:12:29These radio waves can then reflect off the ocean
- 00:12:32and back off the ionosphere,
- 00:12:34making multiple hops to travel thousands of kilometers.
- 00:12:39During the daytime,
- 00:12:39the intense radiation from the sun
- 00:12:41means the ionosphere starts lower in denser atmosphere.
- 00:12:45And because of this,
- 00:12:46lower frequency radio waves are more likely
- 00:12:49to be absorbed than reflected.
- 00:12:51So aviators would typically use the higher 6210 kilohertz
- 00:12:55to skip their signals during the day,
- 00:12:57and then the lower 3105 kilohertz at night
- 00:13:00once the bottom of the ionosphere had lifted
- 00:13:02into thinner air.
- 00:13:07Four hours after takeoff,
- 00:13:08Earhart radioed an update to Lae
- 00:13:10on her daytime frequency of 6210.
- 00:13:13She reported her altitude at 7,000 feet
- 00:13:16and speed at 140 knots
- 00:13:18before concluding with
- 00:13:19her typical sign-off, "Everything okay."
- 00:13:23But she never acknowledged calls from Lae
- 00:13:25about the headwind.
- 00:13:26They radioed again at 11:20 and 12:20,
- 00:13:30but never got a response from Earhart.
- 00:13:33In all likelihood, she never heard them.
- 00:13:36She did radio six hours into her flight
- 00:13:38to report stronger headwinds,
- 00:13:40but she makes no mention of Lae's earlier warnings.
- 00:13:44It's possible the receiving belly antenna
- 00:13:46was broken, fell off,
- 00:13:48or something in the receiving electronics wasn't working.
- 00:13:52But her ability to receive voice messages
- 00:13:55was clearly impaired.
- 00:13:58Nine hours into the flight,
- 00:13:59Earhart expected to come upon the Ontario.
- 00:14:03She listened for Morse code Ns on 400 kilohertz,
- 00:14:07but she heard nothing.
- 00:14:11The original plan was
- 00:14:13that the Ontario would wait for her to radio them
- 00:14:16to request that they start transmitting.
- 00:14:18But the day before takeoff,
- 00:14:20Earhart realized she had made a mistake.
- 00:14:23The Ontario had told her
- 00:14:25they wouldn't be able to receive any high frequency signals,
- 00:14:28which meant no voice communication.
- 00:14:31So she sent an urgent telegram asking the Ontario
- 00:14:34to transmit the Morse code Ns repeatedly
- 00:14:3710 minutes after each hour.
- 00:14:41The purpose of the Morse code from the Ontario
- 00:14:44was actually to allow Amelia Earhart
- 00:14:46to make use of her two final antennas.
- 00:14:48So she had a loop antenna just like this one
- 00:14:52and a sense antenna.
- 00:14:54These were designed to allow her
- 00:14:55to locate the source of radio waves.
- 00:14:58This was the final and most critical way
- 00:15:00that Earhart planned to stay on course
- 00:15:02and locate Howland Island.
- 00:15:04She wrote, "I doubt if I'd try the flight
- 00:15:06to tiny Howland Island
- 00:15:07without it supplementing Fred Noonan's skill."
- 00:15:11Woo. Alright, so I have an antenna here
- 00:15:16and I'm aligning it vertically in this tree.
- 00:15:18How are we, how are we there?
- 00:15:20So the Ontario was sending out Morse code signals
- 00:15:23on their antenna,
- 00:15:25and here we have a transmitter tuned to about 3.6 megahertz.
- 00:15:29I'm gonna put on this blindfold
- 00:15:32and use the loop antenna to try to locate the transmitter.
- 00:15:37And because I already know where the transmitter is,
- 00:15:38we'll spin me around a few times to really disorient me.
- 00:15:41So, Clifford. Oh, sorry.
- 00:15:43- [Clifford] Oh, which way are you going?
- 00:15:47- Alright. Whoa, I'm a bit dizzy.
- 00:15:51So the radio waves are gonna be emitted in all directions
- 00:15:56radially away from the antenna,
- 00:15:57the electric field will be oscillating up and down,
- 00:16:00and the magnetic field will be oscillating back and forth.
- 00:16:04So if I hold up this loop like this
- 00:16:08sort of parallel to the direction
- 00:16:10that the waves are traveling,
- 00:16:12then the magnetic field is gonna be changing
- 00:16:14through the loop.
- 00:16:15And because of that,
- 00:16:16it's going to create an EMF and current
- 00:16:18and I can pick that up
- 00:16:20because I'm tuned to the right frequency here.
- 00:16:23So I got a fairly strong signal.
- 00:16:24Woo, it's very strong.
- 00:16:27But if I rotate the loop like that,
- 00:16:29well, now the magnetic field is oscillating back and forth
- 00:16:32but not changing through the loop itself
- 00:16:34because it's parallel to the loop.
- 00:16:36And so, in this orientation, I'm gonna get a null reading.
- 00:16:40If I turn it this way, there's a null.
- 00:16:44But if you turn it 90 degrees,
- 00:16:47now all the magnetic field is passing through this loop
- 00:16:50and so I can hear a maximum here.
- 00:16:53So this is what Earhart wanted to measure
- 00:16:55using her loop antenna
- 00:16:56to detect the repeated N Morse code from the Ontario.
- 00:17:00She would turn it until she found the null
- 00:17:03and then she would know the direction to the ship.
- 00:17:06Something that's interesting is, if I turn it away,
- 00:17:10we get another null because again
- 00:17:12there's no magnetic flux passing through this loop.
- 00:17:16Now, the first time she picked up the signal,
- 00:17:18she would probably be heading straight towards the ship
- 00:17:22or close enough,
- 00:17:23so she would know that it's roughly that way.
- 00:17:27But there's a chance that she's gone past it.
- 00:17:30And if you go past it, well, then you also get a null,
- 00:17:33but the ship is behind you, not in front of you.
- 00:17:36So that's where the sense antenna comes in.
- 00:17:38The sense antenna gives you a cardioid pickup pattern
- 00:17:41so it has a single null instead of two nulls,
- 00:17:44and so that allows you to determine
- 00:17:46whether it is in front or behind you.
- 00:17:49- [Clifford] If you walk a bit,
- 00:17:50you'll know if it's getting weaker or stronger.
- 00:17:53- Alright, I feel like I've picked the wrong direction.
- 00:17:57I'll try the sense antenna to see if I can figure it out.
- 00:18:01With the sense antenna,
- 00:18:03the only null points directly away from the transmitter,
- 00:18:06so it's easy to use the sense antenna
- 00:18:09to check which null is correct
- 00:18:11but then only use the loop when navigating
- 00:18:13because it gives a sharper null.
- 00:18:15I think using the sense antenna
- 00:18:17that the transmitter's right in front of me now.
- 00:18:22I'm looking for another null here.
- 00:18:25Oh, there's a null.
- 00:18:29- [Clifford] Give it a go.
- 00:18:32- There, there. Definitely louder, louder.
- 00:18:39Oh, it's funny 'cause you move a little bit
- 00:18:43and then you start hearing signal again.
- 00:18:46This does not feel like I'm walking in the right direction.
- 00:18:48- [Clifford] Well, that's either the right way to go
- 00:18:49or it's the wrong way to go.
- 00:18:51- Oh no. (Clifford laughs)
- 00:18:52- Trying to fly a plane and do this would be very hard,
- 00:18:56especially with the sound of that engine
- 00:18:59would have been roaring.
- 00:19:03Oh, I feel like it's getting loud.
- 00:19:07It's really loud here.
- 00:19:09It drops out right there.
- 00:19:11I mean, there's a null here.
- 00:19:13And I was convinced this was the right way.
- 00:19:16Yeah, this is a clear null right here.
- 00:19:21Whoa. Loud, loud, loud.
- 00:19:24I feel like I've gotta be close.
- 00:19:26(antenna humming)
- 00:19:30It's gotta be like right here.
- 00:19:33Whoa! Ah! (laughs)
- 00:19:37This worked amazingly well.
- 00:19:39I had no idea I was that close, that's impressive.
- 00:19:43- On the nail. - That's awesome.
- 00:19:46Now, aviators could have used where the signal is loudest
- 00:19:49and try to go in that direction,
- 00:19:52but it's actually easier to get a precise null,
- 00:19:55a point where the signal drops out.
- 00:19:57The loud section could range for quite a distance
- 00:20:01and so you wouldn't really know where it is,
- 00:20:03but the null is more precise
- 00:20:04so that's why they would look for the point
- 00:20:06where the signal drops out.
- 00:20:08If Earhart could hone in on the Ontario
- 00:20:10using her radio direction finding loop,
- 00:20:12that would ensure she was on course
- 00:20:14and eliminate any navigation errors
- 00:20:16that may have occurred to that point.
- 00:20:19But her telegram asking the Ontario
- 00:20:21to transmit 10 minutes after each hour
- 00:20:24didn't make it to the ship in time.
- 00:20:26And since Earhart couldn't talk to the Ontario,
- 00:20:29they never sent out any signals.
- 00:20:32So they passed like ships in the night.
- 00:20:37By this point, Earhart was around halfway to Howland.
- 00:20:40With no other landing strips within 1,000 kilometers,
- 00:20:44she would have to find the tiny island or return to Lae now.
- 00:20:48But multiple delays had already plagued her journey.
- 00:20:53In fact, this was not Earhart's first attempt
- 00:20:55to fly around the world.
- 00:20:57Earlier that year, in March of 1937,
- 00:21:00she had taken off from California for Hawaii,
- 00:21:03heading west instead of east.
- 00:21:06On board were Fred Noonan
- 00:21:07and another crew member, Harry Manning.
- 00:21:11As a Merchant Marine captain,
- 00:21:12he was an expert in radio, Morse code,
- 00:21:15and traditional navigation.
- 00:21:17He was also a pilot.
- 00:21:20The flight to Hawaii was successful
- 00:21:22thanks in part to Manning using the loop antenna
- 00:21:25to hone in on a radio beacon on the destination island.
- 00:21:31Three days later, the trio set off for Howland Island.
- 00:21:35But just as they were taking off,
- 00:21:36the plane drifted to the right.
- 00:21:38Earhart corrected by throttling back the left motor,
- 00:21:41but it was too much.
- 00:21:43The plane turned to the left
- 00:21:44and the right wing dipped down.
- 00:21:46Going up on one wheel, the right landing gear collapsed,
- 00:21:49then the left.
- 00:21:51The plane skidded out on its belly,
- 00:21:53spinning around to face the way it had come.
- 00:22:01Thankfully, no one was hurt,
- 00:22:03but the Electra took months to repair.
- 00:22:06And during that time, the seasonal winds shifted.
- 00:22:09So, on her next attempt,
- 00:22:10Earhart would have to fly east instead of west.
- 00:22:13And most importantly, Captain Manning left the crew.
- 00:22:18Officially, the press reported
- 00:22:19that he needed to return to the Merchant Marines,
- 00:22:22but rumors spread that he had lost confidence in Earhart,
- 00:22:25or that Earhart believed
- 00:22:27Noonan was a better navigator than Manning
- 00:22:29and she could operate the radio on her own.
- 00:22:32Whatever the case,
- 00:22:33when Earhart took off again three months later,
- 00:22:35she was accompanied only by Noonan.
- 00:22:40And now they had made it 80% of the way around the world.
- 00:22:44And in the dark of night,
- 00:22:46Earhart had to make the critical decision
- 00:22:48whether to keep going or turn back.
- 00:22:51The lack of signal from the Ontario
- 00:22:53must have been concerning,
- 00:22:54but maybe they never got her telegram.
- 00:22:57And she knew that at Howland,
- 00:22:59the Itasca would be transmitting the letter A
- 00:23:02over Morse code every half hour,
- 00:23:04even if they didn't hear from her.
- 00:23:06And they could send and receive voice signals.
- 00:23:09They promised to be ready
- 00:23:11on a range of different frequencies.
- 00:23:13So she flew on.
- 00:23:17Around 6:15 a.m. local time,
- 00:23:19radiomen aboard the Itasca heard Earhart clearly.
- 00:23:23"Please take a bearing on 3105.
- 00:23:25We'll whistle into the mic.
- 00:23:27We are about 200 miles out."
- 00:23:29She then began to whistle.
- 00:23:33But the men were confused.
- 00:23:35They expected Earhart to take a bearing on them,
- 00:23:38not the other way around.
- 00:23:40And while they had told her
- 00:23:41that they had radio direction finding equipment,
- 00:23:44the signal needed to be lower frequency,
- 00:23:46between 270 and 550 kilohertz.
- 00:23:50Her voice frequency would skip off the ionosphere
- 00:23:53and reflect off the ocean,
- 00:23:55scattering in all directions.
- 00:23:57So there would be no way to find a null
- 00:23:59because the signal would be coming
- 00:24:01literally from everywhere.
- 00:24:04In the Electra, Earhart heard only static.
- 00:24:09By now, she must have been worried
- 00:24:11that they hadn't heard anything from either ship.
- 00:24:13Almost blind from the rising sun
- 00:24:16and deaf from the roar of the engines,
- 00:24:18Earhart twisted the radio dial,
- 00:24:20listening for Itasca's response. Nothing.
- 00:24:27She may have expected Howland
- 00:24:29to have a high frequency radio direction finder
- 00:24:31called an Adcock antenna array.
- 00:24:34These systems solve the skipping problem
- 00:24:36with five vertical antennas
- 00:24:37at the corners and center of a square.
- 00:24:40The direction of the radio wave
- 00:24:42can be calculated from the slightly different arrival times
- 00:24:45and signal strengths at each antenna.
- 00:24:48But these antennas were massive,
- 00:24:50so they were really only installed at larger airports.
- 00:24:55Now, as it happens,
- 00:24:56there was a portable high frequency radio direction finder
- 00:24:59on Howland Island,
- 00:25:01but the operator reported that Earhart's transmissions
- 00:25:03didn't last long enough for him to take a bearing.
- 00:25:06And trying to conserve his low battery,
- 00:25:09he missed parts of the later transmissions.
- 00:25:13Around 6:45, Earhart again asked them
- 00:25:15to take a bearing on 3105 kilohertz
- 00:25:18and report back in a half hour.
- 00:25:20But a bearing taken now and reported back in a half hour
- 00:25:23would be at best outdated and at worst misleading.
- 00:25:28This confusion likely had to do with time zones.
- 00:25:32Earhart was using Greenwich Civil Time,
- 00:25:35but the Itasca set their clocks to their current position
- 00:25:38which was GCT -11.5 hours.
- 00:25:41And to make matters worse,
- 00:25:43Howland Island used Hawaii Time,
- 00:25:45which back in those days was GCT -10.5 hours.
- 00:25:50So the three parties attempting a rendezvous
- 00:25:52on a tiny island in the middle of the Pacific
- 00:25:55were on three different time zones.
- 00:25:57And crucially, Earhart's hours didn't even line up
- 00:26:01with the others.
- 00:26:02Earhart told the Itasca she would be using GCT,
- 00:26:05but somehow it never made it to the radiomen.
- 00:26:10So, when the Itasca heard Earhart's request,
- 00:26:12it was 6:45 a.m.
- 00:26:14But in the cockpit, it was 6:15 p.m.
- 00:26:17So Earhart likely didn't say "in a half hour"
- 00:26:20but "on the half hour,"
- 00:26:22which for her was only 15 minutes away.
- 00:26:25And also it was a prearranged time
- 00:26:27that Earhart would be listening for them.
- 00:26:30Earhart was careful to set times she would transmit
- 00:26:33and times she would listen for the ship
- 00:26:35because she could only power one antenna at a time.
- 00:26:39And the ships used the same antenna
- 00:26:42for receiving and transmitting,
- 00:26:43so if they both broadcasted at the same time,
- 00:26:46they would miss each other's messages.
- 00:26:48If Earhart sent another message
- 00:26:50at a quarter after the hour,
- 00:26:52the Itasca blocked it with their own message.
- 00:26:54"Cannot take a bearing on 3105 very good.
- 00:26:58Please send on 500, or do you wish to take a bearing on us?
- 00:27:01Go ahead please."
- 00:27:03There was no response.
- 00:27:05But she couldn't transmit on 500 kilohertz anyway
- 00:27:08because she had removed the long trailing antenna
- 00:27:11that could transmit lower frequencies.
- 00:27:13Since it could only be used for Morse code,
- 00:27:16something neither she nor Noonan
- 00:27:17were particularly well versed in,
- 00:27:19she saw it as dead weight after Manning left.
- 00:27:22So, after the Hawaii crash, it was removed during repairs.
- 00:27:26So she had no way of sending radio waves
- 00:27:29that would allow the Itasca to take a bearing on her.
- 00:27:33But she could take a bearing on the Itasca
- 00:27:36using her loop antenna,
- 00:27:38if they sent her the right frequency.
- 00:27:41Before the trip, the Itasca had asked Earhart
- 00:27:43to specify the frequency they should broadcast.
- 00:27:46Earhart was unsure,
- 00:27:47so she consulted a radio expert in Lae
- 00:27:50and they recommended the Itasca send Morse code A,
- 00:27:53just repeated dot dashes,
- 00:27:55on the half hour at 750.
- 00:27:58But at that time it was typical to talk about radio waves
- 00:28:01using their wavelength,
- 00:28:02so the expert had meant 750 meters or 400 kilohertz.
- 00:28:07But Earhart made a terrible mistake
- 00:28:10relaying this plan to the Itasca.
- 00:28:12She requested the signal be sent on 7,500 kilohertz
- 00:28:16instead of 750 meters or 400 kilohertz.
- 00:28:20But she did explicitly say,
- 00:28:23"If frequencies mentioned unsuitable, inform me."
- 00:28:27But no one ever corrected her.
- 00:28:31At 7:42 a.m.,
- 00:28:33Earhart's voice came through so loud
- 00:28:36men even went above deck to see if they could hear a motor
- 00:28:39or spot the plane.
- 00:28:41She said, "We must be on you but cannot see you.
- 00:28:45But gas is running low.
- 00:28:46Been unable to reach you by radio.
- 00:28:49We are flying at 1,000 feet."
- 00:28:51On Howland, the high frequency radio direction finder
- 00:28:54was so low on battery
- 00:28:56the radiomen didn't even hear Earhart's message,
- 00:28:58much less take a bearing on it.
- 00:29:0110 minutes later, Earhart said,
- 00:29:03"We are circling but cannot hear you.
- 00:29:05Go ahead on 7,500."
- 00:29:08The Itasca immediately sent As on 7,500 kilohertz.
- 00:29:12In the Electra, Earhart heard the stutter stop of As
- 00:29:16filling the cabin.
- 00:29:17The relief of finally hearing something
- 00:29:20must have been overwhelming.
- 00:29:22She quickly turned her radio direction finding loop
- 00:29:24to locate the null,
- 00:29:26but the signal never dropped out.
- 00:29:29The frequency was too high,
- 00:29:31so the radio waves from the Itasca were reflecting
- 00:29:33and arriving from different directions.
- 00:29:36Joseph Gurr, a radio mechanic who worked on Earhart's plane,
- 00:29:39later said that they knew there were limitations
- 00:29:41to high frequencies
- 00:29:42which had a tendency to skip and bend,
- 00:29:45creating a false radio direction bearing.
- 00:29:48Without a minimum, she was still lost.
- 00:29:53Earhart frantically called Itasca.
- 00:29:56"We received your signals but unable to get a minimum.
- 00:29:59Please take a bearing on us and answer with voice."
- 00:30:02Itasca attempted to explain the problem.
- 00:30:05"Your signals received okay.
- 00:30:07It is impractical to take a bearing on your voice."
- 00:30:10No response. Without the belly antenna,
- 00:30:12she probably never heard any of their communications.
- 00:30:16And it wouldn't have mattered
- 00:30:17if the Itasca had sent low frequency signals
- 00:30:20because Earhart's loop was tuned to pick up 7,500 kilohertz.
- 00:30:27So, why didn't the Itasca
- 00:30:29correct the frequency she suggested?
- 00:30:32Commander Thompson of the Itasca
- 00:30:33was aware of her radio direction finding limits.
- 00:30:36He had received messages
- 00:30:37both from Earhart's husband, George Putnam,
- 00:30:40and the Coast Guard's San Francisco division
- 00:30:43stating Earhart could only take bearings
- 00:30:44on frequencies between 200 and 1,500 kilohertz.
- 00:30:49But he either thought Earhart knew more
- 00:30:51about her radio equipment,
- 00:30:52or that it wasn't his place to make suggestions
- 00:30:55and take more responsibility for her flight.
- 00:30:59When she asked the Itasca
- 00:31:00to tell her if these frequencies weren't suitable,
- 00:31:02she could have been referring to the ship's capabilities
- 00:31:05rather than her own.
- 00:31:06The Itasca said they'd be ready
- 00:31:07on the frequencies she wanted and more
- 00:31:10instead of giving specific suggestions.
- 00:31:14San Francisco's Coast Guard division
- 00:31:16tried to get Commander Thompson to take more responsibility
- 00:31:19for Earhart's radio communications
- 00:31:21by suggesting they directly tell Earhart
- 00:31:23which frequencies to use.
- 00:31:25But Thompson essentially told them to butt out.
- 00:31:28The Itasca communicated directly with Earhart from then on.
- 00:31:34The radiomen continued to try to reach Earhart,
- 00:31:37and just before 9:00 a.m.,
- 00:31:38Earhart's voice suddenly burst through again.
- 00:31:41"We are on the line 157-337.
- 00:31:44We will repeat this on 6,210 kilohertz.
- 00:31:48We are running on line north and south."
- 00:31:51Her voice was desperate.
- 00:31:53It sounded as if she was
- 00:31:54about to burst into tears or scream.
- 00:31:57This was the last message the Itasca heard.
- 00:32:02There are a number of conspiracy theories
- 00:32:04about what happened to Earhart after that,
- 00:32:06but the evidence seems clear.
- 00:32:09She ran out of fuel somewhere over the Pacific
- 00:32:11and crashed into the sea.
- 00:32:14Two hours after her last message,
- 00:32:16the Itasca left Howland
- 00:32:17to search north and west for the Electra.
- 00:32:21Other Navy and Coast Guard ships and planes
- 00:32:23joined the search for over two weeks.
- 00:32:26To that point in US history,
- 00:32:28it was the most intensive and expensive
- 00:32:31search and rescue operation,
- 00:32:33costing around $4 million,
- 00:32:35which is almost 100 million in today's money.
- 00:32:40No one has ever found a trace of Noonan, Earhart,
- 00:32:44or her Electra.
- 00:32:46All of these mistakes could have been resolved
- 00:32:49if Earhart had two-way communication,
- 00:32:51but her belly antenna somehow malfunctioned.
- 00:32:54Some theories suggest
- 00:32:55it fell off during takeoff in New Guinea,
- 00:32:57but without physical evidence,
- 00:32:59it's impossible to say.
- 00:33:01But Earhart did confirm receiving signals
- 00:33:04on her loop antenna.
- 00:33:06Her loop could only direction find with lower frequencies,
- 00:33:09but it could receive signals on a wide range.
- 00:33:12If she had switched to using the loop
- 00:33:14for all communications,
- 00:33:17she could have received Itasca's voice messages
- 00:33:20and then the Itasca could have requested
- 00:33:22she take a bearing on a lower frequency,
- 00:33:25which would have guided her safely to Howland Island.
- 00:33:31When I began researching this video,
- 00:33:33I expected to find
- 00:33:34that Amelia Earhart's demise was inevitable.
- 00:33:37That what she was trying to do was just so difficult
- 00:33:41that nothing could have saved her.
- 00:33:43But instead, I found the opposite.
- 00:33:45There were at least a half dozen things
- 00:33:47that if they went differently
- 00:33:49would have allowed her to land safely.
- 00:33:52So to me, this story comes down to two things.
- 00:33:55Knowledge and responsibility.
- 00:33:58Earhart lacked knowledge of radio systems,
- 00:34:00which would've allowed her to specify
- 00:34:02the right direction finding frequency.
- 00:34:05But Commander Thompson of the Itasca had that knowledge.
- 00:34:08He knew her direction finding limits,
- 00:34:10but he didn't take on the responsibility to correct her.
- 00:34:14When attempting any challenging endeavor,
- 00:34:17you need someone with the right knowledge
- 00:34:19who will also take responsibility for getting things right.
- 00:34:23That's what you need
- 00:34:24to battle the inherent chaos and disorder of the universe.
- 00:34:29Otherwise, what you get is disaster.
- 00:34:38This video was sponsored by KiwiCo,
- 00:34:40so I thought it would be appropriate
- 00:34:42to build their radio-controlled delivery bot.
- 00:34:46But my oldest kid was out for the afternoon,
- 00:34:48so I sat down to make it by myself,
- 00:34:50but very quickly I was joined
- 00:34:52by my 4-year-old and 6-year-old
- 00:34:54who were really excited to help.
- 00:34:56You know, we have been getting KiwiCo delivered to our door
- 00:34:58for years now
- 00:34:59and it's one of my kids' favorite things to do with me.
- 00:35:03They have a lot of fun
- 00:35:04while we're also spending quality time together.
- 00:35:07And somewhat secretly, they're also learning,
- 00:35:10not only technical knowledge,
- 00:35:11but also knowledge of how simple and understandable
- 00:35:14machines that at first appear complex can be.
- 00:35:18I think it's great that they're getting hands-on
- 00:35:21with wheels and motors and radio transmitters.
- 00:35:24I think it enables them to build up this resilience
- 00:35:27and an attitude that, well, I can understand that,
- 00:35:31I could probably build that.
- 00:35:33And KiwiCo takes responsibility
- 00:35:35for ensuring everything you need is right in the box,
- 00:35:38which means no extra trips to the store.
- 00:35:40When a crate turns up,
- 00:35:42you can sit down right away and get into it.
- 00:35:45They have something for kids of all ages
- 00:35:48and each crate is designed by experts
- 00:35:50and rigorously tested by kids
- 00:35:52to make sure it promotes learning and engagement
- 00:35:54and is just generally really fun to do.
- 00:35:57I noticed that their instructions keep getting better
- 00:35:59with helpful hints to ensure
- 00:36:00you've done everything correctly.
- 00:36:02And with KiwiCo Labs for ages six and up,
- 00:36:05kids use the problem-solving skills they've developed
- 00:36:08to engineer cool games, robots, or everyday products.
- 00:36:12(child laughing)
- 00:36:13So if you wanna try out KiwiCo,
- 00:36:15use my code, Veritasium,
- 00:36:16to get 50% off your first crate of a monthly club.
- 00:36:19And with the holidays around the corner,
- 00:36:21KiwiCo makes a great gift for families.
- 00:36:23Head to kiwico.com/veritasium
- 00:36:26to check out their great club options today.
- 00:36:29So I wanna thank KiwiCo for sponsoring this video
- 00:36:32and I wanna thank you for watching.
- Amelia Earhart
- aviation
- navigation
- radio waves
- Pacific Ocean
- disappearance
- 1937
- Howard Island
- flight
- Veritasium