00:00:00
hi welcome back to Joe blogs in today's
00:00:02
episode I want to talk to you about
00:00:03
what's happening in the Russian economy
00:00:05
because despite the fact that interest
00:00:07
rates are currently sitting at
00:00:09
21% which is the highest level in
00:00:12
Russia's history inflation is continuing
00:00:14
to rise and this represents a serious
00:00:17
problem from both the bank of Russia and
00:00:19
the Russian economy's perspective
00:00:21
because as I'm sure you'll be aware if
00:00:22
you follow the channel the traditional
00:00:24
way of dealing with Rising inflation to
00:00:26
try to stop it is to increase interest
00:00:29
rates but once you've got to a
00:00:31
record-breaking level once you're into
00:00:33
the 20s does that continue to work will
00:00:36
the bank of Russia just continue
00:00:38
increasing interest rates Forever Until
00:00:40
inflation comes down or will they try
00:00:43
something else and the problem that they
00:00:44
have is that they have actually tried
00:00:47
most things and it simply isn't curing
00:00:49
the problem with inflation now before we
00:00:51
get into the details of looking at
00:00:52
what's going on with inflation I thought
00:00:54
I'd pose a quick question to you my five
00:00:57
biggest audiences in order are the USA
00:01:00
the UK Canada Australia and Europe so
00:01:04
can you name what the highest rate of
00:01:06
interest was in the history of those
00:01:08
five economies I'll come on to give you
00:01:10
the answer later in the video and in
00:01:12
order to highlight the severity of the
00:01:13
problems in the Russian economy right
00:01:15
now it was recently announced that
00:01:17
Russia's fiscal deficit increased 14
00:01:20
times in January 25 compared with the
00:01:24
same period in 2024 the budget deficit
00:01:27
in January 24 was 124 4 billion rubles
00:01:31
however that has skyrocketed to 1.7
00:01:34
trillion rubles as a result of a 73%
00:01:38
increase in spending and that 1.7
00:01:41
trillion for the first month of 2025
00:01:44
compares to the full year budget deficit
00:01:47
of three trillion for the whole of 2024
00:01:50
so this really shows that Russia is
00:01:52
ramping up its spending right now and
00:01:54
the strain of the war in Ukraine is
00:01:56
really taking its toll on the Russian
00:01:58
economy and I think this is one of the
00:02:00
reasons why Russia is so open to having
00:02:03
talks with President Trump at the moment
00:02:05
to try to bring the war to a swift
00:02:07
conclusion because it is really breaking
00:02:10
the Russian economy so let's have a look
00:02:12
at what's going on with inflation right
00:02:14
now now just before we go on any further
00:02:17
today I want to talk to you about ground
00:02:18
news who I've been working with for the
00:02:20
past two and a half years and who I've
00:02:22
partnered with for today's video and
00:02:24
they're offering Joe blogs viewers an
00:02:26
exclusive 40% discount on their Vantage
00:02:29
plan which is what I use and what's
00:02:31
brilliant about ground news is that
00:02:32
they're a news aggregator they bring
00:02:35
together stories from all around the
00:02:36
world and if we look at Ground news
00:02:38
articles talking about Russian interest
00:02:40
rates hitting
00:02:41
21% you can see that they sourced 54
00:02:45
different articles and what's great
00:02:47
about ground news is that they tell you
00:02:49
whether those articles come from media
00:02:51
sources that lean to the left lean to
00:02:53
the right or come from the center which
00:02:56
is really important to me when I'm
00:02:57
trying to provide a balanced viewpoint
00:02:59
Point ground news are offering Joe blogs
00:03:01
viewers a 40% discount on the unlimited
00:03:04
Vantage plan which you can access by
00:03:07
scanning the QR code on the screen now
00:03:09
or clicking the link in the description
00:03:11
below this chart shows the movement in
00:03:12
the official rate of inflation in Russia
00:03:14
over the past 12 months one important
00:03:16
thing to note about this chart is that
00:03:18
the scale on the right hand side does
00:03:20
not start at zero it actually starts at
00:03:24
7.2% and Rises to
00:03:26
10.5% what this chart shows is that
00:03:28
between January and August 24 there was
00:03:30
a steady increase in inflation to
00:03:33
9.1% it then started to fall in
00:03:36
September and October and came down to a
00:03:39
low of
00:03:40
8.5% which was still more than double
00:03:42
the target rate of 4% however as you can
00:03:45
see over the past 3 months inflation has
00:03:48
started to take off again and the most
00:03:50
recent data for January 25 shows that
00:03:53
inflation is now sitting at
00:03:56
99.9% and if we widen the scale of this
00:03:58
chart to show what's been happening over
00:03:59
the past 3 years you can see that the
00:04:01
current rate of inflation is the highest
00:04:03
that Russia's experienced since February
00:04:06
23 and this table shows how the current
00:04:08
rate of 99.9% in Russia compares to the
00:04:11
rest of the G20 which are notionally the
00:04:14
20 largest economies in the world and
00:04:16
you can see that there are only two
00:04:17
economies where inflation is higher
00:04:20
Argentina where it's sitting at more
00:04:22
than 84% and turkey where it's above 42%
00:04:26
and if you follow the channel you'll
00:04:27
know that we've talked a lot about those
00:04:29
two economies iies they're both in a
00:04:31
state of economic crisis right now and
00:04:33
the next highest rate of inflation in
00:04:34
the G20 is Brazil at
00:04:37
4.56% so Russia is more than double the
00:04:40
next highest country and if we pick out
00:04:42
a few other selected countries you can
00:04:44
see that currently inflation in both the
00:04:46
UK and the USA is sitting at 3% it's
00:04:49
2.5% in the European Union 2.4% in
00:04:53
Australia 1.9% in Canada and
00:04:57
0.5% in China and this really puts into
00:05:00
perspective the problems going on in the
00:05:02
Russian economy right
00:05:03
now this chart shows the year-on-year
00:05:05
movement in food prices in Russia over
00:05:08
the past 12 months and this is a metric
00:05:09
that we always like to look at because
00:05:11
the poorest members of any society are
00:05:13
disproportionately impacted when food
00:05:16
prices are rising rapidly because
00:05:18
they're spending a higher percentage of
00:05:19
their budget on food and this chart
00:05:22
looks pretty similar to the chart that
00:05:24
we just looked at for inflation however
00:05:26
the actual levels are higher in January
00:05:28
24 food prices has increased year-
00:05:30
on-ear by
00:05:31
8.1% however by the summer of 24 that
00:05:34
had increased to
00:05:36
99.8% Russia experienced a Slowdown in
00:05:39
food price increases in August September
00:05:41
and October when the rate came down to
00:05:43
9% so still material however over the
00:05:46
past 3 months there has been another
00:05:48
jump in food price increases and the
00:05:51
most recent data for January 25 show
00:05:54
that year- on-year food prices have
00:05:55
risen by
00:05:57
11.1% and if we widen this scale of the
00:06:00
chart to show what's been happening over
00:06:01
the past 3 years you can see that the
00:06:03
current rate of food price increases is
00:06:05
the highest that Russia's experienced
00:06:06
since October 22 and this chart Compares
00:06:09
how those food price increases compared
00:06:11
to the rest of the G20 and as you can
00:06:13
see similar to the inflation chart
00:06:15
Russia is coming in at number three here
00:06:17
the only countries where food prices are
00:06:19
rising at a faster rate are Argentina
00:06:22
where they're increasing by almost 65%
00:06:25
and turkey where they're up around 42%
00:06:28
and the next highest in the G20 below
00:06:30
Russia is Brazil where food prices have
00:06:33
increased by
00:06:34
7.25% and once again if we pick out a
00:06:36
few other selected countries you can see
00:06:38
that food prices are currently rising by
00:06:40
3.3% in the UK 3% in Australia 2.5% in
00:06:46
the United States 1.6% in the European
00:06:49
Union 0.4% in China and interestingly in
00:06:53
Canada food prices year onye have
00:06:56
actually Fallen by 0.6%
00:07:00
this chart shows the movement in the
00:07:01
official rate of interest in Russia over
00:07:03
the past 5 years and as I said right at
00:07:05
the start of today's video the current
00:07:07
rate of interest in Russia of
00:07:10
21% is the highest in Russia's history
00:07:13
this tells us that there are severe
00:07:15
problems going on in Russia right now
00:07:17
because you don't have record-breaking
00:07:20
interest rates unless you've got severe
00:07:22
problems in your economy and to put the
00:07:24
current interest rate of 21% into
00:07:26
perspective and also to answer the
00:07:28
question that I posed at the beginning
00:07:30
of today's video the highest ever
00:07:32
interest rate recorded in Canada was
00:07:36
22.75% in
00:07:37
1981 in the USA it was 20% in 1980 in
00:07:43
Australia it was
00:07:44
17.5% in 1990 in the UK it was 177% in
00:07:50
1979 and in Europe it was
00:07:53
15.4% in 1981 so the only one of those
00:07:56
five countries that have ever had a
00:07:58
higher rate of interest than is
00:07:59
currently being experienced in Russia is
00:08:02
Canada for a brief period in 1981 and
00:08:05
congratulations to anybody that got any
00:08:07
of that data because that is quite a
00:08:09
hard question and in terms of how that
00:08:11
interest rate of 21% compares to the
00:08:13
rest of the G20 you can see that there
00:08:15
currently are only two economies that
00:08:17
have a higher rate of interest turkey
00:08:20
where it's sitting at 45% and Argentina
00:08:23
where it's 29% and the next highest
00:08:26
after Russia is Brazil Who currently
00:08:28
have an interest rate of
00:08:31
13.25% once again if we pick out a few
00:08:33
select economies you can see that the
00:08:35
current interest rate in both the UK and
00:08:37
the USA is
00:08:39
4.5% in Australia it's 4.1% in Canada
00:08:43
it's 3% in the Euro Zone it's 2.9% and
00:08:47
in Japan it's
00:08:49
0.5% which is obviously 42 times lower
00:08:53
than it is in Russia right
00:08:55
now now in terms of why High inflation
00:08:57
and high interest rates are bad for for
00:08:59
your economy let's talk about it in the
00:09:01
context of a Russian company let's say
00:09:04
you're a production business and you
00:09:05
want to increase your output you decide
00:09:08
that you need to add another production
00:09:10
line now if you don't have enough money
00:09:11
to be able to fund that yourself then
00:09:13
you would normally go to the bank and
00:09:15
borrow that money and you could do a
00:09:17
return on Capital calculation to say
00:09:20
okay I need to borrow a million Rubles
00:09:22
for example but within 2 years I'll get
00:09:25
a payback on that and I'll be earning a
00:09:27
lot of profit but the problem that
00:09:28
Russian business businesses have right
00:09:30
now is that if they want to take on that
00:09:32
debt they're going to have to pay 21% as
00:09:36
the base cost of borrowing plus a margin
00:09:39
so the Russian business might need to
00:09:41
pay 25 or 30% interest every single year
00:09:46
on the money that they're borrowing and
00:09:47
obviously that changes the calculation
00:09:49
hugely because nobody wants to pay 30%
00:09:52
interest on a loan it becomes very
00:09:55
difficult to make the numbers work but
00:09:57
in addition to that because we've got
00:09:59
RIS ing inflation at the moment in
00:10:01
Russia it means that if you're having to
00:10:03
take on more people and buy in more raw
00:10:06
materials to fund that new production
00:10:08
line it's going to cost you more than
00:10:10
you originally planned this chart which
00:10:12
is the latest data that's been published
00:10:14
by Russia and fortunately only goes up
00:10:16
to November 24 they've stopped
00:10:18
publishing this data so we can't give
00:10:20
you an up to the minute update but it
00:10:22
shows what's been happening over the
00:10:23
past 12 months with real wages and as
00:10:26
you can see in November 24 real wages
00:10:29
increased by
00:10:31
7.3% and the reason that that's
00:10:33
important is because real wages actually
00:10:36
take account of inflation so the
00:10:39
7.3% is on top of the inflation figure
00:10:43
in November 24 of 8.9% so that gives us
00:10:47
a real increase in wages of
00:10:50
16.2% and one of the reasons why wages
00:10:53
are increasing so rapidly at the moment
00:10:55
is because there's a shortage of Labor
00:10:57
this chart shows the unemployment ment
00:10:59
rate in Russia and as you can see the
00:11:01
latest data that's been published which
00:11:03
is for December 24 shows that the
00:11:05
unemployment rate is
00:11:07
2.3% and that compares with
00:11:10
6.4% back in August 2020 so what this
00:11:14
data is showing us is that Russian
00:11:15
businesses are being squeezed from both
00:11:17
sides they're seeing a rise in their
00:11:20
costs as a result of inflation so wages
00:11:23
are going up raw material prices are
00:11:25
going up but at the same time the cost
00:11:28
of borrowing is also at a record high so
00:11:30
Russian businesses don't really have
00:11:32
anywhere to turn if cost of borrowing
00:11:34
was low then theoretically they could
00:11:37
have actually taken on some debt to fund
00:11:39
the increase in the cost to get them
00:11:40
through this difficult period however
00:11:42
what they're seeing is the cost of
00:11:44
everything is going up and their profits
00:11:46
are going down and that's one of the
00:11:48
reasons why GDP isn't increasing at the
00:11:51
same sort of rate in Russia as you would
00:11:53
have expected given the fact that the
00:11:55
Kremlin is sponsoring lots of different
00:11:57
businesses that's why one of the reasons
00:12:00
why there is a labor shortage right now
00:12:02
because the companies that are receiving
00:12:04
the golden ticket from the state who are
00:12:06
being given guaranteed orders and
00:12:07
guaranteed revenue or paying top dollar
00:12:10
to bring in all of the people to achieve
00:12:12
maximum output that's pushing up wages
00:12:15
for all the other companies and they're
00:12:17
now really
00:12:18
struggling so what's the summary and
00:12:20
conclusion today well I wanted to post
00:12:22
this video because I think what's
00:12:24
happening with inflation and interest
00:12:26
rates really tell us that there are
00:12:28
serious problems continuing in the
00:12:30
Russian economy we've seen from the
00:12:32
January data that inflation is now
00:12:34
sitting at just under 10% and we've seen
00:12:37
a month-on-month rise over the past 3
00:12:40
months and that's despite the fact that
00:12:42
interest rates were set at 21% at the
00:12:45
end of October that's an all-time high
00:12:48
for Russia they've never been at that
00:12:50
level before and that in itself tells
00:12:52
you that the economy is in a really bad
00:12:55
situation as we talked about when we
00:12:57
compare this to what's happened in the
00:12:59
USA Canada the UK Australia and Europe
00:13:03
their record levels were set at a time
00:13:05
when the economy was in their deepest
00:13:07
recessions when they were really really
00:13:09
struggling and that's what's happening
00:13:11
in Russia right now and unfortunately
00:13:13
from the bank of Russia's point of view
00:13:14
they don't really have many other
00:13:16
options to go to because President Putin
00:13:19
has issued a strict directive that he
00:13:22
doesn't really want to see interest
00:13:23
rates going up anymore because obviously
00:13:26
it's hurting Russian companies as we
00:13:28
talked about if you're you're a Russian
00:13:29
business and you want to take on debt
00:13:31
right now that's the last thing that you
00:13:33
need for your balance sheet because
00:13:35
paying interest rates of 25 or 30% on
00:13:39
all of that debt is really going to put
00:13:41
you under a lot of financial strain it's
00:13:43
going to wipe out a lot of your cash
00:13:44
flow and really for many businesses it's
00:13:47
just not something they want to Embark
00:13:49
upon so that means that businesses
00:13:51
aren't investing they're not expanding
00:13:53
they're not looking to grow they don't
00:13:55
want to take on that debt and so over
00:13:57
the long term that's going to have a
00:13:58
really detrimental impact on Russian GDP
00:14:02
and I think what we're seeing in today's
00:14:03
video is that Russia is currently at the
00:14:06
edge it's at a precipice if it doesn't
00:14:09
increase interest rates further then
00:14:11
it's likely that inflation will continue
00:14:13
rising and I think one of the things
00:14:15
that's been raised a lot I've seen in
00:14:17
the comments over the past few months is
00:14:19
that the ruble has started strengthening
00:14:21
again and people are saying this shows
00:14:23
how well the Russian economy is doing
00:14:25
and as you can see from this chart which
00:14:26
shows the exchange rate between the US
00:14:28
dollar and the Russian r over the past
00:14:29
12 months there has been a significant
00:14:32
increase in the value of the ruble in
00:14:35
2025 at the end of 2014 one US doar was
00:14:38
trading for 114 rubles today it's
00:14:42
trading for 88 so at face value it does
00:14:45
look like the rubble has strengthened
00:14:47
significantly however there are a few
00:14:49
things to take into account here firstly
00:14:51
nobody's using the ruble anymore most of
00:14:54
the trading partners that Russia are
00:14:56
still dealing with have refused to deal
00:14:58
in Rubles it's two biggest trading
00:15:00
partners in terms of the oil sales China
00:15:03
and India have both said that they will
00:15:05
not deal in Rubles so China will only
00:15:08
deal in Chinese Yuan India wanted to
00:15:10
deal in Indian rupees however Russia
00:15:13
decided that it didn't want to get
00:15:14
involved in that and so the trade
00:15:16
between the two countries is now taking
00:15:18
place in a mixture of United Arab
00:15:20
Emirates durhams and Chinese Yuan so
00:15:23
neither of that is actually improving
00:15:25
the value of the ruble so what is going
00:15:27
on why has the ruble in increased in
00:15:29
value so much well the answer to that is
00:15:32
that it's now a very small Market there
00:15:34
are only a small number of countries
00:15:36
that are actually trading in Rubles and
00:15:38
what that means from Russia's point of
00:15:40
view is that it's able to manage the
00:15:42
exchange rate and improving the value of
00:15:44
the ruble on paper to around 88 to $1 us
00:15:48
means that theoretically the cost of the
00:15:51
Imports should be improving they
00:15:53
shouldn't be going up as rapidly as they
00:15:55
were when the value of the ruble was
00:15:57
falling so that should be improving
00:16:00
inflation but what we're seeing from the
00:16:02
data is that that isn't happening and
00:16:04
the reason for that is that a lot of the
00:16:06
Imports that Russia are buying in are
00:16:08
not being paid for in Rubles they're
00:16:10
having to pay for them in other
00:16:11
currencies and so the value of the ruble
00:16:13
is irrelevant in terms of what's
00:16:15
happening with inflation so we're seeing
00:16:17
a disconnect here between what's
00:16:19
happening with the currency and what's
00:16:21
happening with inflation normally you
00:16:23
would expect the two to move hand inand
00:16:25
if your economy is strengthening and
00:16:26
therefore your currency is strengthening
00:16:28
then you would expect inflation to be
00:16:30
calming down and vice versa but we're
00:16:33
seeing that there's no link currently
00:16:35
between the ruble and inflation that
00:16:37
really tells us that the ruble isn't
00:16:39
really relevant in terms of what's going
00:16:41
on with inflation and interest rates
00:16:44
right now so the overall summary of
00:16:45
today's video is that the Russian
00:16:47
economy is continuing to struggle
00:16:49
inflation is now Rising again interest
00:16:52
rates are at a record level the ruble
00:16:54
has improved in value but actually
00:16:56
that's not really having a very big
00:16:58
impact on on the overall economy itself
00:17:01
and Russia is now moving towards a
00:17:02
situation where it needs some sort of
00:17:04
deal for the war in Ukraine to put that
00:17:07
war to bed to be able to get its economy
00:17:09
somewhere back on track because if it
00:17:11
continues at the current rate we are
00:17:13
going to see inflation continuing to
00:17:15
Skyrocket interest rates may go up
00:17:18
further and all of that will have a
00:17:19
really detrimental impact on the
00:17:21
long-term growth for the Russian economy
00:17:23
so hopefully you've enjoyed today's
00:17:25
video you found it useful informative
00:17:26
and thought-provoking if you've liked
00:17:29
said then please give me a thumbs up
00:17:30
thank you for watching this video all
00:17:32
the way through to the end also thank
00:17:33
you to everybody that's bought me a
00:17:35
coffee or sent me a YouTube super thanks
00:17:37
or signed up as a patron or a member I
00:17:40
really really appreciate that support
00:17:41
really does help to keep me going so
00:17:43
thank you so much for that and here's
00:17:45
something to put a smile on your
00:17:57
face for