History of the Church (1st-5th Century) - Full-length Documentary | Church History
Summary
TLDRThe study of church history explores the past events, councils, and affairs associated with the church. It provides valuable lessons by showing how the church has historically managed cultural and doctrinal issues, offering examples to emulate or avoid. Resources for study range from sacred texts like the Book of Acts to Roman records and writings of church fathers. Notable figures such as Paul and Gregory the Theologian contributed significantly to the spread and theological development of Christianity. Key events include the early persecutions, spread of Christianity, establishment of church councils like Nicea, and the development of monasticism. Understanding Gnosticism and Arianism is crucial as these heretical views were major challenges the early church faced. Through church history, one can observe how doctrines evolved, bishops' roles developed, and how the church’s unity was maintained despite differing practices.
Takeaways
- 📚 Church history helps understand past church events and teachings.
- 🔍 Offers insight into handling cultural versus doctrinal issues.
- 🕌 Discusses key figures like Gregory, Paul, and Ignatius of Antioch.
- 🗺️ Reflects on Christianity's spread and profound events like early councils.
- ❌ Examines and offers lessons from historical heresies like Arianism.
- 🙏 Demonstrates the evolution of church roles, like bishops and monastic communities.
- 📝 Highlights significant church events from birth to modern structures.
- 🌍 Provides a rich narrative of the Christian church’s growth and theological development.
- 📜 Discusses historical church documents aiding modern faith formulation.
- ✝️ Essential for understanding and applying historical context in current practices.
Timeline
- 00:00:00 - 00:05:00
Church history involves studying past events, councils, and church-related matters, offering insights from various resources such as the Acts for early church history, Roman records for the persecuted church, and writings from historians and early church fathers. Exploring church history helps understand how the church managed its affairs over the centuries and identify cultural versus dogmatic elements in the expression of orthodoxy.
- 00:05:00 - 00:10:00
The early church, born on the day of Pentecost, began spreading the Gospel under persecution from Jewish leaders. The church in Jerusalem faced martyrdoms, but the faith spread to Antioch and Damascus. Saul of Tarsus, a fervent persecutor, converted to Christianity and became Apostle Paul, preaching across regions despite his initial suspicion among believers.
- 00:10:00 - 00:15:00
As Paul and Barnabas led missionary journeys, disputes over Gentile conversion prompted the first council in church history, deciding Gentiles need not follow Jewish customs but avoid certain immoral practices. Paul's separation from Barnabas led to further extensive missionary work detailed in the Acts, establishing early Christian communities.
- 00:15:00 - 00:20:00
Throughout the first century, apostles wrote what became the New Testament to preserve Jesus' teachings. As disciples traveled, they sent letters to established communities, considered authoritative but were officially canonized much later. Various church sees formed, with Roman and Alexandrian churches influencing much early ecclesial structure.
- 00:20:00 - 00:25:00
The 2nd and 3rd centuries saw development in ecclesial hierarchy, response to Gnosticism, and establishing biblical canons. Church unity centered around one bishop with supporting clergy. Early canons of scripture formed through opposition to heresies like Marcionism, reinforcing the church's authoritative texts and combating divergent beliefs.
- 00:25:00 - 00:30:00
Historic debates generated crucial involvement in defining key Christian doctrines like Trinity and scripture canon. Eusebius and others documented these themes, grappling with differences in belief across early communities, and church consensus gradually formed despite differing textual authorities and regional variations.
- 00:30:00 - 00:35:00
Persecution from Roman emperors defined early Christian experiences, eventually leading to calendrical and theological resilience. Debates about martyrdom and reconciling apostates arose, with varying views from church leaders. Alexandria emerged as a hub of theological evolution, juxtaposing intellectual and cultural discourse for Christian thought.
- 00:35:00 - 00:40:00
Theological schools, notably Alexandria, pioneered Christian intellectual tradition, emphasizing deification and monastic wisdom, marking a contrast with Western variants. Figures like Origen advanced theological exploration with significant writings on spirituality and biblical interpretation, influencing future Christian theology.
- 00:40:00 - 00:45:00
The 4th century defined crucial church development, addressing Arian controversy, and contributing to monastic and theological traditions. Constantine's reign, post-conversion, brought Christianity prominence and ceased major persecution, with figures like Anthony inspiring monasticism and Athanasius defending against Arianism through ecumenical debates.
- 00:45:00 - 00:50:00
Cappadocian fathers were instrumental in understanding of Trinitarian doctrine, navigating various heretical threats. Councils like Constantinople solidified the church's theological standing, framing hypostasis and usia differentiation fundamental to contending against prominent erroneous beliefs while advancing Christian theology universally.
- 00:50:00 - 00:55:00
This era was telling for the church’s doctrinal direction as it adapted against formidable theological discourse, cultivating resilience and refinement in defining elements of faith. Establishing comprehensive doctrinal explanation and ecclesial cohesion required navigating disputes internally and externally, framing lasting theological structures.
- 00:55:00 - 01:00:00
Amidst ongoing theological challenges, figures like Chrysostom and Augustine left legacies shaping Western and Eastern Christian thought respectively. They addressed ecclesial disunity through eloquent theological discourse and writings that bridged philosophical, cultural, and doctrinal paradigms, elevating the church's intellectual rigor.
- 01:00:00 - 01:05:00
5th-century controversies peaked with councils addressing Christological disputes, most notably between Cyril of Alexandria and Nestorius' teachings on the nature of Christ, intertwining political shifts and ecclesial governance, redefining orthodoxy leading into prolonged schisms over two nature versus one nature Christology.
- 01:05:00 - 01:10:00
Cyril's theological insistence on unity in Christ navigated diplomatic reunification with Antioch, balancing one nature and two-nature formulations in theological discourse, seeing lingering division due to misunderstood Christological stances that fueled further debate amidst sporadic ecclesial consensus and division.
- 01:10:00 - 01:15:00
The dynamics of doctrinal contention crystallized around figures manipulating theological nuances, planting enduring discord leading into the Chalcedonian controversies, challenging continuity and ecclesiastical unity, underscoring doctrinal intricacies in Christ's personhood debated in theological and socio-political spectra.
- 01:15:00 - 01:20:00
Eutychian controversies illuminated tensions within Alexandrian allegiance to Cyril’s legacy amidst misinterpretations by figures like Eutyches, impacting debates leading to councils that analyzed theological articulations vis-à-vis Leo’s tome, exposing inherent discord in established ecclesiastical definitions and political maneuverings.
- 01:20:00 - 01:25:00
Chalcedonian definitions sparked further discord over language clarity and perceived betrayal of Cyril’s union concepts, with political alignments exacerbating inherent ecclesiastical tensions, fermenting longstanding schisms. Alexandria rejected definitions imposing perceived Nestorian implications, causing ecclesial strife.
- 01:25:00 - 01:30:00
Theological schisms, aggravated by political overlays, anchored divergences throughout the era. While councils struggled to unify Christological definitions, ecclesial divisions entrenched deeper, with Alexandria perceiving Chalcedonian formulations as circumstantial betrayals, feeding cyclic discord underpinned by political expediencies.
- 01:30:00 - 01:35:22
Eastern and Western church factions entrenched post-Chalcedon further, incapacity to reconcile theological definitions fueled extended schisms, the fidelity to councils and ideologies differing starkly, caused enduring theological impasses reflecting broader cultural and political shifts in Christendom, still echoing in theological discourse.
Mind Map
Video Q&A
What is church history?
Church history is the study of past events, councils, and affairs pertaining to the church.
Why should one study church history?
Studying church history helps understand how the church managed its affairs over centuries, learn from past examples, and distinguish cultural from doctrinal elements.
What are some primary resources for studying church history?
Primary resources include the Book of Acts, Roman records on the persecuted church, writings of early church fathers, and historical documents from church councils.
How does church history help in modern practice?
It helps identify what to emulate or avoid, distinguishes cultural elements, and formulates doctrines by understanding historical contexts.
Who are some notable figures in early church history?
Some notable figures include Ignatius of Antioch, Irenaeus of Lyons, Gregory the Theologian, and Paul of Tarsus.
What are some key events in early church history?
Key events include the spread of Christianity in the Roman Empire, early persecutions, the establishment of church councils, and the development of early church doctrines.
What are Gnosticism and Arianism?
Gnosticism was a belief that emphasized hidden knowledge for salvation, while Arianism questioned the divinity of Christ.
How did church councils impact church history?
Church councils like those in Nicea and Constantinople played crucial roles in formulating doctrines and addressing heresies.
What was the role of monasticism in church history?
Monasticism provided a refuge for Christians seeking spiritual development and played a crucial role in preserving Christian texts and practices.
How did the role of bishops evolve in the church?
Bishops evolved to encompass several roles, maintaining unity, and guiding theological and administrative matters within the church.
View more video summaries
- 00:00:00what is church history where do i find resources on church history
- 00:00:06why would i study history to begin with these are all valid questions that many of us have
- 00:00:13this series aims to answer these questions before we delve into historical events of
- 00:00:19church development i want to shed light on the benefits we can learn from church history
- 00:00:26church history is the study of past events councils and affairs pertaining to the church
- 00:00:33we learn about historical events from multiple resources for example we learn about the birth
- 00:00:40of the early church from the book of acts we can learn about the persecuted church
- 00:00:46from roman records the writings of historians such as josephus and the writings of the early
- 00:00:52church fathers such as ignatius of antioch we can learn about the liturgical life of the church
- 00:00:59from individuals such as justin the martyr we can learn about the expansion of the church during
- 00:01:06the time of the apostles and beyond their times from irenaeus of leon's's against the heresies
- 00:01:13or the ecclesial history of the church by eusebius we can learn about the councils of the church
- 00:01:21from their written minutes or the writings of the fathers who participated in these councils
- 00:01:27like gregory the theologian who wrote about his experience at the council of constantinople in 381
- 00:01:35many other resources can be found to explore church history
- 00:01:40but i will stop listing them as you will see them throughout the episodes of this series
- 00:01:46the question of why study church history might still be going through your mind the study of
- 00:01:53church history gives you an idea of how the church handled her affairs throughout the centuries
- 00:02:00there are things you can learn to emulate in the event and there are things you can learn to avoid
- 00:02:06for example you can learn to imitate paul and bernabbus who despite having a conflict
- 00:02:12did not quit service but rather continued on their separate routes and brought the gospel
- 00:02:17to different locations you can learn to avoid mingling the church with the political world
- 00:02:23when you read about the council of chelsean where the fight for power put on a theological
- 00:02:29mask and left the church in schism and the list goes on studying history can help you identify
- 00:02:37the cultural elements versus the dogmatic elements of your expression of orthodoxy
- 00:02:43for instance the fathers of the church were able to utilize the language of their culture
- 00:02:48to formulate doctrines such as that of the trinity christology or soteriology
- 00:02:56in doing so they were able to use the culture of the time without conforming to the evils
- 00:03:03associated with paganism this can be a lesson in how we deal with our own culture whether it's
- 00:03:11western or eastern gregory of nissa in his book life of moses where he was likely influenced by
- 00:03:19origin of alexandria tells his readers that the israelites plundered the egyptians and as much as
- 00:03:26they took gold and silver from them to use it later on for the building of god's tabernacle
- 00:03:33likewise christians can use secular philosophical language to formulate their orthodox theology that
- 00:03:41being said in studying how the fathers spoke the language of their time to spread and simplify the
- 00:03:48message of the gospel we might be able to further spread the gospel using the very same strategy
- 00:03:59let us turn to historical events pertaining to church development in the early centuries
- 00:04:05of christianity the church was born on the day of pentecost a jewish feast marking the
- 00:04:12gathering of the harvest into barns the church's pentecost marked her sharing in her faith which
- 00:04:20was harvested throughout the time jesus walked on earth with everyone in the world on the day of
- 00:04:27pentecost the holy spirit came upon the disciples as prophesied by joel in joel chapter 2 verse 28.
- 00:04:43and as promised by christ in john chapter 14 verse
- 00:04:4826. the spirit came in the form of divided tongues of fire which rested upon the heads
- 00:05:01of those who were gathered in the upper room and they began speaking in tongues
- 00:05:07simultaneously there was a sound of great wind happening outside
- 00:05:14when the disciples left the room speaking in tongues the masses which witnessed the wind and
- 00:05:20saw them speak in tongues were astonished and began speculating what was happening
- 00:05:27to end their speculations peter gave the masses a summary of the gospel
- 00:05:33the sermon captivated the hearts of three thousand men who became the first batch of
- 00:05:39believers joining the kingdom of god on earth the church the disciples continued to preach in
- 00:05:47jerusalem predominantly but some began to move around to preach the good news to the gentiles
- 00:05:53those in jerusalem experienced early persecution from the jewish high priests
- 00:05:59stephen was the first martyr followed by james who was pushed off a building peter
- 00:06:06was imprisoned but god sent an angel to free him prior to the day of his execution this did not
- 00:06:12stop the disciples from preaching the good news when persecution was stirred some began moving to
- 00:06:20antioch and damascus antioch was the place where the followers of jesus were called christians
- 00:06:38leading the jewish persecution of christians was a man named saul of tarsus or paul
- 00:06:44of tarsus he was a committed pharisee from the tribe of benjamin who found christianity to be
- 00:06:51a jewish heresy that ought to be eliminated after persecuting christians in jerusalem to
- 00:06:57the point where they fled to antioch he requested that the jewish authorities grant him permission
- 00:07:04to continue eliminating the followers of jesus beyond israel his wish was granted and he began
- 00:07:11his travel with a number of helpers to damascus on the way he was surrounded by light and had
- 00:07:18a mystical experience where he saw jesus christ after a short dialogue with the resurrected christ
- 00:07:26paul lost his eyesight and was not eating or drinking for three days when he was ready
- 00:07:33to become christian christ appeared to ananias and commanded him to heal paul and baptize him
- 00:07:41with some hesitation ananias conceded and paul became a preacher of the gospel he once persecuted
- 00:07:49there are two accounts of the events following the conversion of paul
- 00:07:54one is recorded by his companion luke in the book of acts and another is recorded by paul
- 00:08:00himself in the episode to the galatians both accounts emphasize and omit different events
- 00:08:08according to acts paul begins preaching to jews around him in the synagogues understandably
- 00:08:15he is met with doubts about his loyalty to the gospel then paul leaves the city in secret and
- 00:08:23heads to jerusalem to meet the disciples according to the account in galatians paul goes to arabia
- 00:08:30first on a retreat with god then to damascus three years later paul would see cephas and james only
- 00:08:50returning to the original circle of disciples peter had an encounter with an italian centurion
- 00:08:57named cornelius after a vision where peter is commanded by god not to call anything or anyone
- 00:09:04he made unclean peter sees cornelius and preaches to him the gospel upon cornelius acceptance of the
- 00:09:12gospel peter baptizes him and all his household peter would then become ever convinced that the
- 00:09:20gentiles have a place in the church peter then moves to antioch while paul begins traveling
- 00:09:27with his companion barnabas to preach the good news to both jews and gentiles unfortunately
- 00:09:35the first dispute begins then zealous jews insisted that gentiles ought to become jewish
- 00:09:43first through circumcision and keeping of the sabbath and only then can they become christians
- 00:09:51this brings the first missionary trip to a halt as paul and barnabas return to the apostles
- 00:09:58and the first council in church history begins in jerusalem there the disciples unanimously and
- 00:10:06under the guidance of the spirit decreed that gentiles ought not to keep the customs of the
- 00:10:13jews but rather abstain from blood animals that are strangled and sexual immorality
- 00:10:22paul and barnabas then resumed their journey but this time with john mark barnabas nephew
- 00:10:29according to tradition during the journey john mark abandons paul and barnabas as the second
- 00:10:37journey would begin paul and barnabas got in an argument over whether mark should join or not
- 00:10:45they separate path and paul takes silas with him while bernabbis takes mark paul later went on a
- 00:10:53third missionary journey with luke and silas which is recorded in great detail in the book of acts
- 00:11:01the first journey of paul was approximately two thousand kilometers and the second and
- 00:11:06third journey both involved over four thousand kilometers traveling was largely done on foot
- 00:11:14the last details we hear about paul come from acts where he is under house arrest in rome
- 00:11:20preaching the gospel historians are divided as to what happens afterward some suggested that he was
- 00:11:28freed and that he went as far as spain and then was arrested once more and was executed then
- 00:11:35others believe that he was eventually put on trial and executed after the house arrest
- 00:11:50during the first century many of those who have seen and heard christ began to pass away
- 00:11:57in fear of losing the memory of jesus the apostles began writing what justin the martyr calls the
- 00:12:04memoirs of the apostles these came later to be known as the four accounts of the gospel known to
- 00:12:12us as matthew mark luke and john the last of those accounts might have been written with the dawn of
- 00:12:20the second century as the disciples would preach the gospel and then move to the next country they
- 00:12:27are about to preach in they would send letters to reach out to those who have already believed
- 00:12:33confirming them in the faith and advising them to walk worthy of the calling by which they were
- 00:12:38called these letters were immediately seen as authoritative by those who received them
- 00:12:46however no one would see them as a canon of scripture until the end of the second century and
- 00:12:53the beginning of the third century when we would see the first list of books of the new testament
- 00:13:00other edifying writings were composed such as the shepherd of hermes local
- 00:13:07churches had different ideas of what books were authoritative and what books were not
- 00:13:13for example the second episode of peter james and jude were seen by some as authoritative
- 00:13:21while others saw them as simply letters or even disputed letters
- 00:13:27the major seas of christianity began forming throughout the first century
- 00:13:32eusebius and irenaeus of leon gives us a record of how peter and paul together established the church
- 00:13:40of rome which emerged as a number of bishoprics that came later to be united under one bishop
- 00:13:48with the preaching of mark considered a disciple of peter by irenaeus the church of alexandria
- 00:13:55was established mark would write a gospel around the year 60 a.d and compose a liturgy which was
- 00:14:04later edited by the alexandrian pillar of faith cyril of alexandria in the 5th century paul and
- 00:14:12andrew would preach in greece and what would later become the church of constantinople it is believed
- 00:14:19that one of the churches there was presided over by onesimus the slave paul freed through his plead
- 00:14:27with his master philemon in a letter which would later become part of the new testament antioch as
- 00:14:36mentioned earlier had peter paul and bernabbus play a role in its establishment the church of
- 00:14:43antioch would bring forth a bishop named ignatius of antioch who would compose a number of letters
- 00:14:49that would tell us plenty about the ecclesial life in the second century of christianity
- 00:15:05it is difficult to pinpoint historical events during the second and third centuries these
- 00:15:11two centuries mark various processes of ecclesial development such as ecclesial
- 00:15:18hierarchy annihilation of gnosticism canonization of scripture determining the date of easter etc
- 00:15:28let's begin with ecclesial hierarchy church unity meant to many early christian thinkers that the
- 00:15:35believers gather around one bishop celebrating the one eucharist with a choir of presbyters and
- 00:15:44deacons assisting him the title bishop encompassed other roles and titles that were confirmed as
- 00:15:53ranks in the church in subsequent centuries such as metropolitans or the bishop of a mother city
- 00:16:00or a capital hoary episcopus or a bishop in charge of a village the role of the hoary episcopus later
- 00:16:11becomes that of an auxiliary bishop who works in conjunction with a metropolitan patriarchs the
- 00:16:20head of a major sea such as alexandria or antioch and arge bishops who were similar to patriarchs
- 00:16:29but were not in charge of a major sea they usually had more than one bishop report to them
- 00:16:38the title presbyter encompassed priests as we know them now but also hiero monks a monk who is also
- 00:16:46a priest arch priests arkham managerite or the head of a large monastery or group of monasteries
- 00:16:55and hegemons who was an elder priest typically a monk in the past who would take precedence among
- 00:17:03other priests or monks especially with regard to administrative matters the title deacon included
- 00:17:11deacons archdeacons and proto-deacons who had presidents when serving with other deacons
- 00:17:19developing these roles certainly took much longer than the second and third centuries however the
- 00:17:26beginning of such development begins then as we see in the writings of saint ignatius of antioch
- 00:17:33who writes in his letters you must follow the lead of the bishop as jesus christ followed that of
- 00:17:40the father follow the presbyter as you would the apostles reverence the deacons as you would god's
- 00:17:48commandment wherever the bishop appears there let the people be even as wheresoever christ jesus is
- 00:17:58there is the catholic church the clear difference we see here between bishops and presbyters
- 00:18:05was not present in the first century where often the two titles were used interchangeably
- 00:18:20gnosticism emerged as a mixture of platonic thought with greek egyptian and mesopotamian
- 00:18:28mythology along with the christian doctrine they believed in a good god and in an evil god the
- 00:18:37latter of whom created the material world in order to be saved you had to have the special knowledge
- 00:18:46the gnosis that is free from all that is material christ was sent as the logos of the good god
- 00:18:54to free us from the material world created by the evil god who was often associated with the god of
- 00:19:02the old testament among the prominent figures of gnosticism was a man named marcion marcion
- 00:19:11created an edited version of the gospel of luke and the episodes of paul where nothing about
- 00:19:18the material world appears marcion together with other figures before him
- 00:19:24such as valentinus were vemently opposed by the church through figures like ignatius of antioch
- 00:19:32and irenaeus of leon in irenaeus of leon's opposition to marcion the former realized
- 00:19:40the necessity of forming a list of the books the church considers as canonical scriptures
- 00:19:54there are various lists that circulated during the second and third centuries which
- 00:20:00attempted to compile the books accepted as authoritative texts within the new testament
- 00:20:07irenaeus of leon makes a formal mention of the four gospels and alludes to other books of the
- 00:20:15new testament others like eusebius of caesarea and athanasius of alexandria give a formal list
- 00:20:24on which books should be included as authoritative or authentic new testament books irenaeus composed
- 00:20:35his list in his masterpiece against the heresies in which he commented gnosticism
- 00:20:42irenaeus was among the first christian thinkers to associate the four accounts of the gospel with
- 00:20:49the four incorporeal beasts carrying the throne of god in the book of revelation irenaeus writes
- 00:20:57the gospels could not possibly be either more or less in number than they are since there are
- 00:21:04four zones of the world in which we live and four principal winds while the church has spread
- 00:21:11over all the earth and the pillar and foundation of the church is the gospel and the spirit of
- 00:21:18life it fittingly has four pillars everywhere breathing out in corruption and revivifying men
- 00:21:26from this it is clear that the word the artificer of all things being manifested to men gave us the
- 00:21:34gospel fourfold in form but held together by one's spirit as david said when asking for his coming
- 00:21:43o sitter upon the cherubim show yourself for the cherubim have four faces and their faces are
- 00:21:50images of the activity of the son of god for the first living creature it says was like a lion
- 00:21:58signifying his active and princely and royal character
- 00:22:03the second was like an ox showing his sacrificial and priestly order the third had the face of a man
- 00:22:11indicating very clearly his coming inhuman guise and the fourth was like a flying eagle
- 00:22:19making plain the giving of the spirit who broods over the church now the gospels in which christ
- 00:22:27is enthroned are like these eusebius provides a commentary in his famous book on church history
- 00:22:35on the new testament's writings that are accepted or rejected in different christian communities
- 00:22:42he also includes a list of writings that were considered debatable as eusebius puts it
- 00:22:49it is proper to sum up the writings of the new testament
- 00:22:53which have been already mentioned first then must be put the holy quaternion of the gospels
- 00:23:00following them the acts of the apostles the epistles of paul the epistle of john
- 00:23:07the episode of peter after them is to be placed if it really seemed proper
- 00:23:13the apocalypse of john concerning which we shall give the different opinions at the proper time
- 00:23:20these then belong among the accepted writings among the disputed writings or anti-lagomina
- 00:23:29which are nevertheless recognized by many are extant the so-called episode of james and that of
- 00:23:36jude also the second episode of peter and those that are called the second and third of john
- 00:23:44whether they belong to the evangelist or to another person of the same name
- 00:23:51among the rejected writings must be reckoned also the acts of paul and the so-called shepherd and
- 00:23:58the apocalypse of peter and in addition to these the extant episode of barnabas and the so-called
- 00:24:06teachings of the apostles and besides as i said the apocalypse of john if it seemed proper
- 00:24:14which some as i said reject but which others class with the accepted books you certainly can see
- 00:24:22how some writings such as the apocalypse of john was seen differently by different communities
- 00:24:29the catholic epistles were debated since the times of eusebius who lived between 236 to 339 a.d
- 00:24:40syriac copies of the new testament did not include the catholic episodes
- 00:24:45until much later prominent figures such as ephraim the syrian and john chrysostom used
- 00:24:53bibles that only included the pauline literature including hebrews without the catholic episodes
- 00:25:01hebrews was another debated book as its authorship was attributed to different people
- 00:25:06from the first century such as paul or apollos who was an unknown disciple of either paul or barnabas
- 00:25:15athanasius of alexandria in his 39th festival letter also mentions the books
- 00:25:22of the new testament that are considered canonical athanasius's list resembles the canon of the new
- 00:25:29testament we see in scripture today he says again it is not tedious to speak of the books of the new
- 00:25:38testament these are the four gospels according to matthew mark luke and john afterwards the acts of
- 00:25:47the apostles and episodes called catholic seven this of james 1 of peter 2 of john 3 after these
- 00:25:59one of jude in addition there are 14 episodes of paul written in this order the first to the romans
- 00:26:08then two to the corinthians after these to the galatians next to the ephesians then to
- 00:26:15the philippians then to the colossians after these two to the thessalonians and that to the hebrews
- 00:26:24and again two to timothy one to titus and lastly that to philemon and besides the revelation of
- 00:26:35john these are fountains of salvation that they who thirst may be satisfied with the
- 00:26:42living words they contain and these alone is proclaimed the doctrine of godliness
- 00:26:50let no man add to these neither let them take out from these for concerning these
- 00:26:57the lord put to shame the sadducees and said you are wrong not knowing the scriptures
- 00:27:05and he reproved the jews saying search the scriptures for these are they that testify of me
- 00:27:15it was obvious to the readers of the four accounts of the gospel that there are discrepancies and
- 00:27:21rough edges between the different accounts regarding the same event how many were
- 00:27:27present at the feeding of the followers of christ five thousand or seven thousand
- 00:27:34how many loaves were there five or seven how many times did jesus appear after his resurrection
- 00:27:41and to whom these were questions that the early believers had but did not concern themselves
- 00:27:48with them as much as we do today since they did not read scripture as a mere historical account
- 00:27:56they continued to regard all four accounts as authoritative even as they struggled with such
- 00:28:02questions or as they sometimes refer to them as stumbling blocks attempts to harmonize
- 00:28:10such texts was prominent in the second and third century as david bentley hart puts it the four
- 00:28:17gospels were regarded as authoritative from a very early date though they were often read
- 00:28:24not as discrete documents but in a combined harmonized form the most virtuosic of these
- 00:28:31harmonies was called the diatesseron which literally means taken from the fore which was the
- 00:28:38work of the christian philosopher tatian in the year 185 a.d a second century hellenized syrian
- 00:28:49tatian of adiabean sought to combine all the material of the four gospels that of matthew of
- 00:28:57mark luke and john into a single narrative that accounts for jesus's life and death
- 00:29:06someone like origen of alexandria claimed that the questions or stumbling blocks were placed
- 00:29:14providentially by the holy spirit that the reader may look for the deeper meaning behind these
- 00:29:20discrepancies origen would associate christ's words of blessed are the peacemakers for they
- 00:29:28shall be called sons of god with the theologians who would harmonize various texts of scripture
- 00:29:43eusebius of caesarea records the events of the controversy surrounding the date of easter at the
- 00:29:51time of pope victor the first around 190 a.d it was common for the churches of asia to celebrate
- 00:30:01easter on the 14th day of the jewish month of nisan regardless of whether it was a sunday or not
- 00:30:10as such they observed the feast of christ's pasca and resurrection whenever the jews did
- 00:30:19the churches in the rest of the world would determine the day of easter
- 00:30:23being a sunday the controversy reached a climax when pope victor the first contemplated
- 00:30:31excommunicating those who celebrated the feast of the resurrection on the fourteenth day of nisan
- 00:30:39he was however rebuked by erenaeus of leon in a letter to irenaeus
- 00:30:46the difference in practices while maintaining communion with the churches confirmed the unity
- 00:30:53of faith at this point the church agreed to disagree when it came to the dating of easter
- 00:31:01the fathers of the early church were aware that unity is not equated with uniformity
- 00:31:09the challenge was identifying and maintaining coherence and unity within a diverse body
- 00:31:16the church would later determine the date of easter and the council of nicaea in 325 a.d
- 00:31:24and most orthodox churches continue to follow the date as determined by the formula of nicaea
- 00:31:32however there are exceptions today such as the orthodox church of finland the armenian
- 00:31:39apostolic oriental orthodox church and the roman catholic church regardless the celebration itself
- 00:31:48and its place theologically and spiritually greatly surpass the timing of the celebration
- 00:32:02the early church suffered immense persecution since her birth especially in rome and alexandria
- 00:32:10the persecution differed with different emperors and rulers but there was almost always persecution
- 00:32:18if persecution was not imperial throughout the empire
- 00:32:22there was certainly local waves of persecution
- 00:32:26when an imperial persecution took place it often came with the goal of exterminating christianity
- 00:32:34the persecution and bloodshed compelled an early christian thinker named tertilian to say
- 00:32:42the more you mow us down the more we grow the blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church
- 00:32:51examples of waves of persecution were experienced under maximinous thrax around 235 a.d dcs
- 00:33:02around 250 a.d valyrian around 257 a.d and the great persecution under diocletian around 302 a.d
- 00:33:17cyprian of carthage and sixtus ii of rome were among the bishops who fell victims of
- 00:33:24the persecution of valerian diocletian's persecution was too vicious that it marked
- 00:33:32the beginning of an ecclesial calendar adopted in alexandria known as the calendar of the martyrs
- 00:33:41although such waves of persecution would end with many devout christians who shed their
- 00:33:47blood for christ as martyrs or confessors some felt weak under the yoke of persecution
- 00:33:54and apostatized this compelled the church to answer questions such as should one run toward
- 00:34:02martyrdom should one avoid martyrdom what do we do with apostates who desire to return to the church
- 00:34:11theologians such as origen of alexandria encouraged pursuing martyrdom as a teenager
- 00:34:19he himself tried to be martyred but because his mother hid his clothes he was embarrassed to leave
- 00:34:25the house however he died because of his wounds at an old age cyprian of carthage preferred that
- 00:34:33people avoid persecution lest they fall weak and apostatize if one is caught and tortured
- 00:34:42cyprian would say they should not deny christ whether in reality or in appearance as some
- 00:34:49would pretend to deny christ so they could escape persecution while still believing in their hearts
- 00:34:58cyprian considered those who denied christ whether in reality or in appearance as apostates
- 00:35:07when an apostate desired to return to the church there was a controversy as to how
- 00:35:13they ought to be received some insisted that they would not be accepted into the church
- 00:35:19after having apostatized cyprian had a more moderate position which required them to live in
- 00:35:27repentance and not approach the chalice or partake of the holy communion until they are on their
- 00:35:34deathbed this controversy caused minor schisms and carthage and its surrounding regions in africa
- 00:35:50carthage was an important sea of africa but it certainly did not compare in importance
- 00:35:57to the sea of alexandria and its school the unparalleled attributes in egypt
- 00:36:04made it a rich environment in which the gospel and theology could flourish as philip
- 00:36:10schaff puts it alexandria was the metropolis of egypt the flourishing seat of commerce
- 00:36:18of grecian and jewish learning and of the greatest library of the ancient world and
- 00:36:25was destined to become one of the great centers of christianity the rival of antioch and rome
- 00:36:33there the religious life of palestine and the intellectual culture of greece commingled and
- 00:36:41prepared the way for the first school of theology which aimed at a philosophic comprehension and
- 00:36:48vindication of the truths of revelation the school of alexandria was not limited to the teaching
- 00:36:56of christian theology rather it began with secular science moral and religious philosophy
- 00:37:04christian theology was divided over three major sections a course for catechumens
- 00:37:11who were candidates for baptism and were being introduced to the principles of christianity
- 00:37:17a course on christian morals and ethics and an advanced course on divine wisdom
- 00:37:23and christian spirituality among the greatest teachers of the school of alexandria
- 00:37:30was origen who composed voluminous commentaries on scripture george leonard prestige records
- 00:37:38how one of origin's famous students felt about learning under his guidance he says
- 00:37:46to be under the intellectual charge of origin says gregory probably the thaumaturgos was
- 00:37:53like living in a garden where fruits of the mind sprang up without toil to be happy with gladness
- 00:38:00by the happy occupants he truly was a paradise to us after the likeness of the paradise of god
- 00:38:09to leave him was to renascent the experience of adam after the fall few teachers
- 00:38:16have ever won so remarkable a testimonial from their pupils father tadrus mality records the
- 00:38:25main characteristics of the school of alexandria in his book on the school of alexandria before
- 00:38:32origin among these characteristics are first the centrality of deification second the centrality
- 00:38:41of soteriological theology third the oneness of the life among the students and teachers
- 00:38:50fourth a life of repentance fifth the usage of theological terms from greek philosophy
- 00:38:58sixth minimal time spent on defining theological terms and seventh an ecumenical spirit
- 00:39:07where students from different dioceses were equally welcomed into the school of alexandria
- 00:39:20the second and third centuries were blessed with a number of christian theologians who shaped the
- 00:39:27expression of the early church's faith we will explore three figures in this episode namely
- 00:39:36ignatius of antioch justin the martyr and origin of alexandria let's begin with ignatius of antioch
- 00:39:46ignatius of antioch was born around 50 a.d in rome in syria and was martyred around the year of
- 00:39:55a.d in rome as he was devoured by beasts in a roman arena
- 00:40:01his remains or his relics are now buried in saint peter's basilica
- 00:40:08not a lot of details about his life are known and virtually all we know
- 00:40:13about him comes from the seven letters he composed on his way to be executed in rome
- 00:40:20he was known for his opposition to judaisers who taught that it was necessary to adopt
- 00:40:28the jewish customs and practices in order to become a christian
- 00:40:34he also opposed docetists a branch of gnosticism
- 00:40:39scholars speculate that he might have known the apostle john some of the main themes
- 00:40:46that appear in his writings include the double identity of christ as god and man martyrdom as
- 00:40:54unity with christ and the unity of the church gathered around one bishop and one eucharist
- 00:41:04justin the martyr was born around the year of 100 a.d in flavia palestine and was martyred in 165
- 00:41:14a.d in rome after a long journey of exploring philosophy justin came to find the fullness of
- 00:41:22truth around the year 130 a.d he continued to appreciate the elements of truth in philosophy
- 00:41:31as he continued to wear the philosopher's cloak even after his conversion he wrote two apologies
- 00:41:39or statements in the defense of christianity to roman rulers of his time in these two apologies he
- 00:41:47juxtaposed christianity with paganism and other philosophies showing the former to be superior
- 00:41:56justin recorded in these apologies a coherent summary of christian theology and life for example
- 00:42:05justin summarizes the events of the liturgy in the following quote on the day called sunday
- 00:42:12there is a gathering together in the same place of all who live in a given city or rural district
- 00:42:20the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read as long as time permits
- 00:42:27then when the reader ceases the president in a discourse admonishes and urges the imitation of
- 00:42:34these good things next we all rise together and send up prayers when we cease from our
- 00:42:42prayer bread is presented in wine and water the president in the same manner sends up prayers
- 00:42:50and thanksgivings according to his ability and the people sing out their ascent saying the amen
- 00:42:59a distribution and participation of the elements for which things have been given is made to
- 00:43:05each person and to those who are not present they are sent by the deacons those who have
- 00:43:13means and are willing each according to his own choice gives what he wills and what is collected
- 00:43:20is deposited with the president he provides for the orphans and widows those who are in need on
- 00:43:28account of sickness or some other cause those who are in bonds strangers who are sojourning
- 00:43:36and in a word he becomes the protector of all who are in need justin was convinced
- 00:43:43that philosophies of his time included elements of the truth which he titled seeds of the logos
- 00:43:52the fullness of the logos however is only found in christ as confessed in christianity
- 00:43:59as justin's voice of preaching kept getting louder he was arrested for treason and was killed
- 00:44:06as he said if we are punished for the sake of our lord jesus christ we hope to be saved
- 00:44:16origen was born in 184 a.d in alexandria and died after he was arrested and tortured in
- 00:44:25253 a.d entire in lebanon origen acted as a presider or dean of the school of alexandria
- 00:44:36due to arguments between origen and the patriarch of alexandria demetrius
- 00:44:42origen chose to leave alexandria and was ordained a priest in lebanon
- 00:44:48some believe that the arguments between origen and demetrius were theological
- 00:44:54while the majority of scholars believe that they were the result of demetrius's concern
- 00:45:00with origin's popularity compromising his own authority as patriarch of alexandria
- 00:45:08though origen died in communion with the church he was anathematized or his
- 00:45:15teachings were renounced in the council of constantinople ii in the year 553 a.d
- 00:45:25origen died having left the church with a legacy of writings that reached approximately six
- 00:45:32thousand works including on first principles hundreds of commentaries on scripture
- 00:45:39and the hexapola which is a document where origen compared different translations and versions of
- 00:45:47the biblical verses of the old testament years after his death basil of caesarea and gregory
- 00:45:55of naziensis relied on origin in learning the christian philosophy and theology they compiled
- 00:46:02his spiritual sayings on prayer in what came to be known as the filo calia of origin of alexandria
- 00:46:17the fourth century marks critical elements of church development as foundational doctrines
- 00:46:23were being formulated in ecumenical councils and as christianity was becoming part of the empire
- 00:46:30after centuries of persecution the fourth century marks the birth of monasticism in egypt
- 00:46:38and later in the rest of the empire until it reached rome and ireland
- 00:46:45after a complex history of internal battles within the empire constantine who lived between 272 to
- 00:46:55337 a.d became the emperor of rome according to eusebius constantine beheld a vision of a cross
- 00:47:05with which he would conquer constantine marked his banners with the sign of the
- 00:47:10cross and triumphed in battle when he became emperor he decreed that there would be a policy
- 00:47:18of religious tolerance of christianity in the edict of milan in 313 a.d theodosius the great
- 00:47:29was one of his successors who made christianity the state's religion the christening
- 00:47:36of the roman empire led waves of persecution to come to an end and christianity flourished
- 00:47:51when waves of persecution came about many who knew their potential weakness before the
- 00:47:57edge of the sword retreated to the desert where they dedicated their lives to god
- 00:48:04when persecution came to an end some who could not offer their life to god through martyrdom
- 00:48:11chose to offer it to him through the monastic vocation
- 00:48:16organized monasticism appeared first in egypt under the leadership of saint anthony the great
- 00:48:23who lived between 251 to 356 a.d and who lived in seclusion in the mount of the red sea
- 00:48:33for approximately 20 years in which he reached spiritual maturity
- 00:48:39later he would disciple a large number of ascetics some of whom would become monastic leaders
- 00:48:46themselves such as macarius of egypt macarius of egypt who lived between 300 to 391 a.d retreated
- 00:48:58to the western desert of egypt where he began a monastic community which remains to this day
- 00:49:06like anthony his disciples lived in secluded life of contemplation unlike anthony however macarius
- 00:49:14required his disciples to meet once a week on sunday to partake of the eucharist and potentially
- 00:49:22hold a spiritual meeting or share a common meal pachomios of egypt who lived between 292
- 00:49:32to 348 a.d was a pagan soldier who was captivated by the hospitality of christians in upper egypt
- 00:49:41and he decided to consecrate himself to the god of christians pachomios would establish a number
- 00:49:49of monastic communities and monasteries where monks lived in a communion of love
- 00:49:55under one roof he commissioned his sister to lead a similar life and convents for women who desired
- 00:50:04the monastic vocation monasticism was taken to the west at the hands of athanasius who shared
- 00:50:12the monastic way with the people of ireland in one of his exiles the formal transmission of monastic
- 00:50:20wisdom to the west came about at the hands of john cassian who lived between 360-435 a.d
- 00:50:31john went through the eastern deserts collecting monastic wisdom and customs
- 00:50:38which he recorded in his books on the conferences and the institutions
- 00:50:46in the 5th century benedict who lived between 480 to 546 a.d would start a revival of western
- 00:50:56monasticism that would create numerous monasteries dedicated for the service of the masses
- 00:51:10in the 4th century a famous alexandrian priest with the name arius claimed that christ
- 00:51:18was god and as much as he is greater than us but he is not equal to the father in reality
- 00:51:27aries said that there was a time when the son was not he propagated his ideas with the use of
- 00:51:35music and chance which captivated the hearts of illiterate christians this caused immense
- 00:51:44turmoil and disturbed the peace of the church and the empire consequently constantine called for a
- 00:51:52council of 318 bishops to settle the matter in nicaea in 325 a.d in nicaea the faith of arius
- 00:52:04was anathematized or denounced and the creed was written down until we believe in the holy spirit
- 00:52:13nicea upheld the consubstantiality of the son with the father or that the son is of the same
- 00:52:22essence or of the same substance as the father before all ages and that he is true
- 00:52:29god from true god in every sense this did not settle the matter as the successors of constantine
- 00:52:39would adopt nicean orthodoxy at times and arianism other times athanasius was a learned deacon
- 00:52:49a disciple of anthony the great and a disciple of alexandrius of alexandria
- 00:52:56athanasius assisted alexandrius of alexandria and combating arianism in the council of nicaea
- 00:53:04later athanasius would become the patriarch of alexandria who would suffer exile five times
- 00:53:12at the hands of successors of constantine whether before his elevation to the patriarchal throne
- 00:53:20or in exile or in his sea athanasius spared no effort to write and educate his people
- 00:53:28through theological texts such as against the aryans or on the incarnation or against the
- 00:53:36heathens or the four letters of serapion or spiritual texts such as the life of anthony
- 00:53:52aside from the council of nicaea's decisions against arianism it unified
- 00:53:58the date of easter which would be determined by the patriarch of alexandria
- 00:54:04finally ending a controversy that took place as early as the second century the council dictated
- 00:54:12that there would be no kneeling on sunday and that there should be only one bishop per jurisdiction
- 00:54:20the council was by no means conclusive as it did not put an end to the controversy
- 00:54:28the churches of the east were divided among themselves as some were aryans some adhered fully
- 00:54:35to the nicean faith and others adhered to the nicean faith but could not accept the theological
- 00:54:43formulation of homo osios or the consubstantiality of the father with the son that is the father
- 00:54:52and the son share the same substance or essence the west was committed to the nicean cause in
- 00:55:01terms of theology formulation and pastoral decisions in the east some who were aryans began
- 00:55:09to accept the consubstantiality of the father and the son but rejected the divinity of the spirit
- 00:55:17athanasius had to combat them in four letters he sent to serapion a bishop in egypt
- 00:55:24in which he elucidated the doctrine of the holy spirit athanasius would die before the controversy
- 00:55:33around the holy spirit and his legacy would be upheld after him by the cappadocian fathers
- 00:55:50the three cappadocian fathers are basil the great who lived between 329
- 00:55:57to 379 a.d his brother gregory of nissa who lived between 335 to 394 a.d and his friend
- 00:56:09gregory of niziensis who lived between 330 to 389 a.d basil and gregory of nissa lived in the same
- 00:56:22household where they were heavily influenced in their theology and spirituality by their sister
- 00:56:28macrina who consecrated herself to christ after the passing away of the man she was betrothed to
- 00:56:37basil received education to be a lawyer and an orator with his friend gregory
- 00:56:44of naziensis under the influence of macrina basil became an ascetic then a priest
- 00:56:52until he became bishop of caesarea in 370 a.d basil was dedicated to the nicean cause
- 00:57:01along with the expansion of ministry for the poor and marginalized and the geographical expansion
- 00:57:09of his diocese to prevent aryan bishops from rising to influential ecclesial rings
- 00:57:17in the course of the geographic expansion of his diocese basil appointed his brother gregory a
- 00:57:24bishop over nissa where he spent the rest of his life serving until he was exiled out of the empire
- 00:57:33gregory of nissa unlike his brother was a married man a philosopher and a mystic
- 00:57:41gregory believed in universal salvation though he was not anathematized with originists in the
- 00:57:48fifth ecumenical council who followed origen's view on universal salvation
- 00:57:56gregory of nissa may be described as a man of sorrows as he lived through the death of
- 00:58:03the most influential figures of his life his brother basil and his sister macrina
- 00:58:11gregory of niziensis was also known as gregory the theologian the title only given to him
- 00:58:19and john the evangelist in the oriental orthodox churches and to simeon the new theologian as well
- 00:58:27in the eastern orthodox church after finishing his studies with basil gregory sought solitude
- 00:58:36and became an ascetic his ascetic life was interrupted by his father gregory the elder
- 00:58:43who needed assistance in shepherding his flock as such gregory the theologian became involved in the
- 00:58:52ecclesial life he moved between different dioceses like niziensis and constantinople
- 00:59:00which was not accepted by other bishops as it opposed the decrees of nicaea
- 00:59:07gregory accepted the disapproval of some bishops who opposed his shifts of jurisdiction
- 00:59:15and he returned to live an ascetic life toward the end of his life basil with gregory the theologian
- 00:59:24compiled the filocalia of origin basil composed a treatise on the human condition another titled
- 00:59:33six days of creation or the hexamiron and a defense on the doctrine of the holy spirit
- 00:59:42gregory of nissa composed biographies such as the life of moses and the life of macrina
- 00:59:50he composed a number of theological writings such as the great catechism on the soul
- 00:59:57and resurrection against eunomius the creation of man and on virginity
- 01:00:07gregory the theologian is mostly known for his orations and numerous letters
- 01:00:14his five theological orations are what earned him the title theologian
- 01:00:28the time of the cappadocian fathers was a difficult time for the church sabilianism
- 01:00:35and apollinarianism were on the rise while the danger of arianism and pneumatomachians persisted
- 01:00:46sabilianism claimed that there is only one hypostasis or person which was manifested
- 01:00:53in three different ways the father in the old testament the son in the new testament and the
- 01:01:01holy spirit after the ascension please note the term hypostasis refers to an underlying reality
- 01:01:12or a substance this may sometimes refer to a concrete thing or a person
- 01:01:21apolinarius was initially committed to the nicean cause and often supported athanasius
- 01:01:29in his commitment to the divinity of christ and oneness of christ after the incarnation
- 01:01:35he fell into the extreme of believing that christ had flesh without a soul in other words
- 01:01:43he was not a rationally animated being this was considered by the cappadocian fathers
- 01:01:51a compromise of the humanity of christ and the economy of the incarnation how can christ not
- 01:01:59have a rational mind or a soul he must be a perfect human being in order to save humans
- 01:02:10pneumatomachians is a name for those who considered the holy spirit as inferior to
- 01:02:16the father and the son and counted the holy spirit with the angels seeing that these controversies
- 01:02:26were dividing churches especially in antioch which had four bishops at one point emperor theodosius
- 01:02:34deemed it fix that he calls for a council of 150 bishops in constantinople in the year 381 a.d
- 01:02:45the council dealt with the aforementioned heresies together with pastoral and jurisdictional matters
- 01:02:54the council is credited with having completed the creed from after the clause we believe in the holy
- 01:03:02spirit until the end the formulation of the doctrine of the spirit entailed him being
- 01:03:10called the lord and giver of life who is to be worshipped with the father and the son the fathers
- 01:03:19at the council standardized the use of the terms usia and hypostasis putting an
- 01:03:27end to the trinitarian controversy usia refers to the general or the essence of god in the trinity
- 01:03:36and hypostasis refers to the particular or the person in the trinity methods of
- 01:03:44receiving the heretics and schismatics into the catholic church were discussed and formalized
- 01:03:53the church of constantinople was elevated as the second rome
- 01:03:58which would deal with jurisdictional issues as a court of appeal for other churches despite
- 01:04:07timothy of alexandria's presence and precedence over the council of constantinople along with
- 01:04:15others such as malicious of antioch gregory of niziensis and nictarius of constantinople
- 01:04:24the council was not acknowledged by alexandria for a while before it became universally acceptable
- 01:04:32it was deficient as a council that it had to be followed up by two local councils
- 01:04:38in 382 and 383 a.d the theological success of the council of constantinople was not immediately
- 01:04:49recognized the fact that it did not reach conclusive solutions for jurisdictional issues
- 01:04:57and its failure to resolve the antiochian schisms topped off this lack of recognition the council
- 01:05:05only received its status as an ecumenical council in the year 451 a.d in the council of chalcedon
- 01:05:24though the lives of saints such as athanasius of alexandria basil the great gregory of nissa
- 01:05:32and gregory the theologian have been addressed one cannot conclude the fourth century without
- 01:05:38mentioning the greatest christian author of western christianity augustine of hippo
- 01:05:45and the greatest christian orator of eastern christianity john chrysostom
- 01:05:52john was born in antioch around 347 a.d and died in exile in the year 407 a.d
- 01:06:02he was raised by his widowed mother to be a rhetorician
- 01:06:06then later a theologian after he became committed to christianity john was a reader in the church
- 01:06:15for a number of years until he became an ascetic opposing all offers of priesthood
- 01:06:23against his will he was ordained a deacon then a priest and finally archbishop of constantinople
- 01:06:32in 398 a.d because of his strong views about the behavior of the emperor his popularity in
- 01:06:41the palace deteriorated immensely at the hand of the empress along with theophilus of alexandria
- 01:06:49john chrysostom was exiled twice during the second exile john was not assigned a place of exile
- 01:06:57this meant that he was to walk with no determined destination until his soul leaves his body
- 01:07:06having died excommunicated by alexandria john's name was later reinstated in the diptychs
- 01:07:13of alexandria by cyril of alexandria who was theophilus's nephew and who would succeed him to
- 01:07:21the patriarchal throne now the term diptyx refers to the official lists of the living and departed
- 01:07:29that are commemorated by the church during the liturgical gatherings
- 01:07:35john left behind him a collection of six books on the priesthood a number of letters
- 01:07:43and countless homilies ranging from commentaries on the scripture
- 01:07:48to christian morals and ethics such as marriage fasting and giving alms
- 01:07:56augustine was born in 354 a.d in algeria to a middle-class family and died there in 430 a.d
- 01:08:07before the siege of hippo at the hands of the barbarians who put an end to the presence
- 01:08:14of christianity in the 6th century augustine received first class education through his parents
- 01:08:22who borrowed money to ensure that he received proper education augustine had an immense interest
- 01:08:30in philosophy but lived a hedonistic lifestyle indulging in sensual pleasures which resulted
- 01:08:38in a child born in adultery his mother monica was in sorrow and tears desiring the repentance
- 01:08:48of her son eventually augustine would repent and become an ascetic then later a bishop in 395 a.d
- 01:08:58though augustine composed numerous theological writings and commentaries on scripture it should
- 01:09:04be noted that he did not know hebrew and greek as such he relied exclusively on the vulgate which
- 01:09:13is the latin translation of scripture and which as some scholars suggest contains inaccuracies
- 01:09:21in its translation which would eventually affect augustinian theology and augustine's perception of
- 01:09:29the ancestral sin the purgatory and the filioque augustine's legacy included treatises such as on
- 01:09:40christian doctrine on the trinity the confessions city of god and numerous commentaries on scripture
- 01:09:56the fifth century is packed with numerous theological controversies
- 01:10:02which left the church in schisms that persist to this very day despite being a tragic century
- 01:10:10in this sense it included numerous figures who upheld the orthodox faith as received
- 01:10:18from the apostles through the fathers of the fourth century to those of the fifth century
- 01:10:25with the dawn of the fifth century a new patriarch named nistorius was elevated to
- 01:10:32the patriarchal throne of constantinople after john chrysostom had died in exile
- 01:10:41like chrysostom nestorius was a committed disciple of the school of antioch and its leader
- 01:10:48theodore of mob sowestia in contrast to the school of alexandria the school of antioch
- 01:10:57emphasized the distinction between the divinity and the humanity in the person of jesus christ
- 01:11:06the school of alexandria however emphasized the unity of christ's being and did not focus on the
- 01:11:14distinction between humanity and divinity nistorius used the rationale of his school
- 01:11:22to form a new opinion where he refused to call mary the mother of god or theotokos
- 01:11:30and preferred to call her christotokos mother of christ or anthropotokos mother of the man this was
- 01:11:40based on the proposition that mary gave birth to an ordinary man who later became conjugated with
- 01:11:48the logos or the word of god this claim was based on the school of antioch's teachings the claim
- 01:11:58that mary was the mother of christ or man was met with resistance from the people of constantinople
- 01:12:10cyril of alexandria who was the nephew and successor of theophilus the one who had
- 01:12:16excommunicated john chrysostom the predecessor of nestorius was highly displeased with such notions
- 01:12:25and began exchanging letters with nestorius when the exchange of letters failed to end
- 01:12:32the controversy emperor theodosius ii convened a council of 200 bishops in ephesus in 431 a.d
- 01:12:44the council took place during the reign of pope selastian of rome and his deacon leo
- 01:12:51who were not present at the council but rather sent delegates on their behalf leo would later
- 01:12:58become the pope of rome during the time of the council of chalcedon in 451 a.d
- 01:13:07alexandria's representatives were cyril and his deacon dioscoros from constantinople nestorius
- 01:13:15was present with his bishops his supporters from antioch headed by john of antioch arrived late
- 01:13:24to the council so that the council began its sessions prior to their arrival the council of
- 01:13:31ephesus consisted of seven sessions which ran from june 22 until july 31st the council condemned the
- 01:13:42heresy of nestorius and upheld the orthodoxy of the title theotokos used by cyril of alexandria
- 01:13:52nostorius was exiled deposed from his office and replaced with flavian of constantinople
- 01:14:02cyril's theology was predicated upon the unity of christ in cyril's conception jesus christ
- 01:14:10was one incarnate nature meaning one subject and one hypostasis after the incarnation
- 01:14:20cyril used the terms nature and hypostasis interchangeably as did the alexandrians and
- 01:14:27some antiochians hypostasis denotes a concrete reality that may be simple or composite
- 01:14:37in the case of christ the one hypostasis encompassed the divinity and humanity
- 01:14:45in their fullness yet christ remained one subject and one hypostasis to cyril christ's oneness does
- 01:14:56not compromise the distinction of the divinity and humanity from which the one christ is composed
- 01:15:04though this distinction is in contemplation alone or in one's thoughts alone
- 01:15:12this language which cyril used together with the fact that the council began prior to
- 01:15:18the arrival of the antiochian party caused the church of antioch to impeach communion
- 01:15:25with the church of alexandria when a schism was clearly emerging cyril of alexandria approached
- 01:15:33john of antioch to reunite and compose a formula of reunion which ended the schism between the two
- 01:15:41churches the formula of reunion allowed the antiochians to use the two nature language
- 01:15:50instead of the one nature language initially used by cyril and the alexandrians though only
- 01:15:57if it is accompanied by sufficient qualifications that preserve the unity
- 01:16:04as john mcgugan puts it cyril had no intention of using such language i.e the two-nature or
- 01:16:12the diphysite language himself and in the letter to yologius and that the christ is one
- 01:16:20he says explicitly that he regarded their whole way of thinking and arguing as obscure
- 01:16:28he admitted that diophysite terms could be orthodox on two grounds the first was that the
- 01:16:35natures in question mean natural properties not independent subject entities and therefore one was
- 01:16:44talking about states or conditions and not persons the second was that their continuing coexistence
- 01:16:53should be radically qualified by sufficient indications that these two realities had actually
- 01:17:00been united made one were inseparable in mutual communion or only notably separable like body
- 01:17:10and soul and not practically divisible cyril seems to have reassured them i.e the cerulean party his
- 01:17:19own party on the basis that it was a concession to be understood in terms of his previous teaching
- 01:17:27not as an amendment of it as such it became clear that the decrees of the council and the formula
- 01:17:36of reunion were to be always paired together to formulate the christology of the church
- 01:17:43the tension between the one and two nature or thesis formulations continue to persist
- 01:17:50especially with extremists at both ends of the spectrum
- 01:17:55an example of this is yutikis a constantinopolitan archaemenidrite who had minimal theological
- 01:18:04training and who planted the seeds of a church schism that would persist to this very day
- 01:18:20ut keys who lived between 378 to 456 a.d had a large group of monks
- 01:18:29following him he was sincerely committed to the alexandrian formula of the one nature
- 01:18:36which cyril coined and the council of ephesus upheld because of his ignorance
- 01:18:44eutikis made a false claim entailing that christ's humanity was overwhelmed by the divinity
- 01:18:52and that christ's humanity ceased to have real existence and as such
- 01:18:59the only nature in christ is the divine nature when flavian bishop of constantinople heard this
- 01:19:07he excommunicated yutikis and contacted leo who was the pope of rome after celestine passed away
- 01:19:18leo responded to flavian in a letter that came to be known as the tome of leo
- 01:19:25the letter elucidated the erroneous teachings of eutikis in combating yutikis's faulty definition
- 01:19:34of the one nature leo did not adhere to the explanation of the one nature formula
- 01:19:42but rather appealed to the formula of reunion and used the two-nature formula in an exclusive manner
- 01:19:51that could be misinterpreted as crypto nestorian yutike's feeling misunderstood appealed to emperor
- 01:20:01theodosius ii and dioscoros the pope of alexandria who succeeded cyril of alexandria theodosius ii
- 01:20:10convened a second council in ephesus in the year 449 a.d co-headed by the ascorus of alexandria
- 01:20:20and juvenile of jerusalem this was later known as the second council of ephesus in this council
- 01:20:30yutiki's anathematized or denounced the teachings of nestorius and apollinarius and admitted in a
- 01:20:39written confession that he who is the word of god came down from heaven without flesh and was made
- 01:20:47flesh in the holy virgin's womb unchangeably and unalterably as he himself knew and willed
- 01:20:57and he was always perfect god before the ages was also made perfect man in the end of days
- 01:21:07yutikes claimed that this had been always his faith and that flavian accused him of heresy
- 01:21:14based on this confession consequently flavian was condemned by the council as a heretic
- 01:21:22and the letter or the tome of lao was not read the same council anathematized ibass of edessa
- 01:21:31and theodorette of cyrus based on their nestorian writings in which they vemently attacked cyril and
- 01:21:39his legacy which has been confirmed by the council of ephesus in 431 a.d it is claimed
- 01:21:47that dioscorus of alexandria and juvenile of jerusalem used rather stern measures in dealing
- 01:21:55with bishops and resolving conflicts consequently leo of rome called the second council of ephesus
- 01:22:04the robber council not long afterward theodosius ii fell off his horse and died marcion a general
- 01:22:15in theodosius ii's army succeeded him after marrying pulcheria who was theodosius ii's sister
- 01:22:24pulcheria and marcion were more sympathetic towards constantinople and rome
- 01:22:30and had little tolerance towards alexandria unlike their predecessor theodosius as father
- 01:22:38john mayendorf puts it there is no doubt however that marcian and pulcheria had definitely decided
- 01:22:46to put an end to the de facto power of the bishop of alexandria for decades the latter was able to
- 01:22:54impose his will upon the universal church without paying any attention to the honorary position
- 01:23:02acquired by constantinople in the year 381 a.d that is the year of the council of constantinople
- 01:23:13the imperial couple felt the need to put an end to alexandria's immense ecclesial power the
- 01:23:20rumors concerning the use of force and violence at the council of ephesus ii in 449 a.d did not
- 01:23:29help the situation although the use of force and violence was common of church councils in this era
- 01:23:38two years after ephesus ii in 449 a.d emperor marcion called for the council of chalcedon
- 01:23:48to set aside ephesus ii and the church of alexandria
- 01:24:00though the council of chalcedon had political elements to it
- 01:24:04the gathered bishops dealt with theological jurisdictional and pastoral matters
- 01:24:12the council of chalcedon is credited with universalizing the acceptance of the council
- 01:24:20of constantinople the first which was conducted in 381 a.d and which was not universally recognized
- 01:24:29before chalcedon the council coined a substantial list of canons assisting in church governance
- 01:24:38the council also deposed eutecus on theological grounds given his vacillating or wavering behavior
- 01:24:47which was expressed before and during the council of ephesus ii in 449 a.d negative elements of the
- 01:24:57council of chalcedon are seen in its framing of dioscoros as the sole responsible individual
- 01:25:05for all the inadequacies that took place in ephesus ii despite the council being headed
- 01:25:13by both dioscoros of alexandria and juvenile of jerusalem when dioscoros saw the way he was
- 01:25:22framed he refused to appear before the council as per the protocol of ecclesial councils he
- 01:25:30was deposed after having been summoned three times and refused to appear before the council dioscoros
- 01:25:40as such was deposed on procedural grounds rather than theological grounds as it became apparent
- 01:25:48in the council that he did not share the erroneous thoughts of eutecus another negative element of
- 01:25:57the council was its leniency towards theodorate of cyrus and abbas of edisa who were readmitted
- 01:26:06into communion and were rehabilitated as bishops despite their nestorian allegiance
- 01:26:14finally the council endorsed the tome of leo which he had sent to flavian as the authoritative
- 01:26:23definition of faith despite a number of bishops finding ambiguous statements in the tome
- 01:26:32there was yet another definition of faith composed by the council in 451 a.d which goes as
- 01:26:40follows therefore following the holy fathers we all with one accord teach men to acknowledge one
- 01:26:50and the same son our lord jesus christ at once complete and godhead and complete in manhood
- 01:26:59truly god and truly man consisting also of a reasonable soul and body of one substance with the
- 01:27:08father as regards his godhead and at the same time of one substance with us as regards his manhood
- 01:27:17like us in all respects apart from sin as regards his godhead begotten of the father before the ages
- 01:27:27but yet as regards his manhood begotten for us men and for our salvation of mary the virgin
- 01:27:35the god-bearer one and the same christ son lord only begotten
- 01:27:43recognized in two natures without confusion without change without division without separation
- 01:27:52the distinction of natures being in no way annulled by the union but rather the
- 01:27:58characteristics of each nature being preserved and coming together to form one person and subsistence
- 01:28:08not as parted or separated into two persons but one and the same son and only begotten
- 01:28:16god the word lord jesus christ even as the prophets from earliest times spoke of him
- 01:28:24and our lord jesus christ himself taught us and the creed of the fathers has handed down to us
- 01:28:40the alexandrians and some antiochians were not fond of the treatment of the ascorus of
- 01:28:47alexandria in the council of chalcedon or the way the tome of leo was imposed on all the churches
- 01:28:55indeed some saw the council as a betrayal of cyril of alexandria because it canonized the language of
- 01:29:02the two natures which he had only conceded to for the sake of reunion as in the formula of reunion
- 01:29:11but he had never established it as the standard statements in the tome of lao such as the one
- 01:29:19of these shines out in miracles referring to the divine nature the other succumbs to
- 01:29:26injuries referring to the human nature seemed to be betraying the line of thinking of cyril where
- 01:29:33all attributes and activities are to be attributed to the person rather than the individual natures
- 01:29:42in other words only one person namely christ can be born suffer or perform a miracle
- 01:29:49rather than ascribing hunger thirst and suffering to the human nature as an isolated nature
- 01:29:57from the divinity which in that case would only perform miracles consequently the divinity
- 01:30:05wouldn't be in full unity with the humanity the tome of leo sounded both ambiguous and unfit
- 01:30:13to be the standard of faith due to its usage of the latin term such as persona which could be
- 01:30:21translated to mean prosopon in reference to the unity between the divinity and humanity
- 01:30:28rather than the hypostatic union the unity of the divine and human natures at the level of the
- 01:30:35persona implied external realities becoming united as opposed to hypostatic union or
- 01:30:43natural unity which is a more of an internal union in other words cyril was inclined to
- 01:30:51emphasize the union of the divine nature and human nature in one composite nature
- 01:30:57to affirm the reality of the union being natural that is hypostatic and internal
- 01:31:06the latin reading of the tome of leo however could imply the unity to be between a divine
- 01:31:13and a human person thus rendering the unity to be a mere conjunction that is prosopic and external
- 01:31:23this implication raised skepticism on the side of a number of the attending bishops
- 01:31:29including those who subscribed to chalcedon and those who rejected it these factors together with
- 01:31:37the political elements of deposing dioscoros of alexandria for example without deposing juvenile
- 01:31:45of jerusalem who had attended with dioscoros the second council of ephesus in 449 a.d and
- 01:31:53the readmission of abbas of edessa enfioteret of cyrus was seen by the antichalcedonians negatively
- 01:32:02and one that is leaning towards the teaching of nestorius this caused a violent schism between
- 01:32:09the calcidonians and anticalcedonians the chalcedonians accused the antichalcedonians
- 01:32:16of being monophysites or eutychians who were those that adopted the single nature
- 01:32:23form of christology where christ's humanity was engulfed by the divinity to form a single nature
- 01:32:31the anti-calcidonians accused the chalcedonians of being an astorian viewing them as ones who
- 01:32:38believed in two separate natures in christ this caused riots and mobs to cause disturbance within
- 01:32:46alexandria and antioch a lot of blood was shed to the extent that ten thousand anticalcidonian
- 01:32:55christians in alexandria were killed at one time for choosing their own patriarch rather
- 01:33:02than succumbing to the imperially appointed chalcedonian patriarch the anti-calcidonians
- 01:33:09have also been accused of murdering one of the calcidonian patriarchs who acted as both
- 01:33:15patriarch and prefect or governor simultaneously his attempts to subdue anti-calcidonians were seen
- 01:33:23as attempts of colonization under the veil of accepting the council
- 01:33:31the schism in the east was treated by the henotikon a formula of faith coined by
- 01:33:37emperor zeno in 481 a.d the emperor that was christologically satisfactory to both sides
- 01:33:47and as much as the henotikon clarified that both sides had the same faith regarding christ
- 01:33:54however its omission of anything related to chalcedon was infuriating for the church of rome
- 01:34:01thus rome impeached communion with all the bishops of the east who signed the document as it was seen
- 01:34:09as a betrayal of the perfection of chalcedon this schism came to be known as the occasion
- 01:34:16schism after achakius bishop of constantinople who accepted the henotikon despite felix of rome not
- 01:34:25accepting it alexandrians were no less suspicious of chalcedon and the henotikon and wished that
- 01:34:32chalcedon may be fully omitted from church history anti-calcidonian masses were suspicious of their
- 01:34:40own patriarchs and bishops who would sign the henotikon in a way the schism persisted because
- 01:34:47of the fundamentalism of anticalcedonians in alexandria and the fundamentalism of chalcedonians
- 01:34:54in rome the former party saw calciton in a purely negative light whereas the latter perceived
- 01:35:03chalcedon's authority to be authoritative and unquestionable eventually the reunion
- 01:35:10of the henotikon would ultimately fail and the schism would persist after zeno died in 491 a.d
- church history
- early church
- persecution
- councils
- monasticism
- theology
- doctrine
- orthodoxy
- Christianity
- spread of Christianity