00:00:06
women's legal position was pretty much
00:00:09
the same as the legal position of felons
00:00:14
it's the need for freedom and rights and
00:00:18
civic respect and place in society women
00:00:22
had to have that it was inevitable that
00:00:27
race was going to play a major role in
00:00:29
the suffrage movement when national
00:00:31
leaders in order to achieve a national
00:00:33
victory had to have some southern states
00:00:36
it is not ladylike politics at all this
00:00:40
fight that is going to take place in the
00:00:43
halls of the Tennessee State Capitol
00:00:46
it's this incredibly dramatic moment and
00:00:50
the future of American women is being
00:00:53
decided right there
00:00:55
[Music]
00:01:01
[Music]
00:01:08
major funding for by one vote woman's
00:01:12
suffrage in the South is provided by the
00:01:15
Bethany fund Tennessee Civil War
00:01:19
National Heritage Area the Josey Davis
00:01:23
foundation in memory of Frances bond
00:01:26
Davis the Shane Foundation Cathy and
00:01:30
Martin Brown and the MSB Cockaigne fund
00:01:33
and by Carlene Libas and Harris hastin
00:01:38
additional support provided by First
00:01:41
Tennessee foundation an and Charles Roos
00:01:44
Hanna Paramore Breen Andrea Conti Lori
00:01:49
gold Eskin and the following
00:01:55
[Music]
00:02:02
and by members of NPT thank you on a
00:02:14
blistering hot August day in 1920
00:02:17
Seth Walker Speaker of the Tennessee
00:02:20
State House convened what he hoped would
00:02:22
be the final day of a special session
00:02:25
for three weeks the house had debated
00:02:28
whether to ratify the 19th amendment to
00:02:30
the US Constitution granting women the
00:02:33
right to vote a vote in the House
00:02:37
chamber was all that stood in the way of
00:02:39
Tennessee becoming the 36th and final
00:02:42
state needed to make the 19th amendment
00:02:44
the law of the land when the legislature
00:02:48
was called into session by Governor
00:02:50
Roberts
00:02:51
most of us expected it to be a routine
00:02:53
affair
00:02:54
actually we reach Nashville we learned
00:02:57
that what we thought was practically a
00:02:59
state issue was a national issue because
00:03:02
as when Tennessee so went the nation the
00:03:05
tension in the chamber is intense the
00:03:10
heat is intense you have women in their
00:03:14
long dresses drenched in perspiration
00:03:17
and in anxiety you have the visitors
00:03:22
galleries half of which are occupied by
00:03:26
the suffrage supporters half by the
00:03:28
anti-suffrage supporters each fearful
00:03:31
and anxious about what this roll call is
00:03:35
going to bring
00:03:37
tucked behind the brass bar in the back
00:03:40
of the chamber sue Shelton white of
00:03:43
Jackson Tennessee stood ready with
00:03:46
pencil and paper ready to keep a tally
00:03:48
of the votes sue white is part of that
00:03:51
third generation of suffragists who are
00:03:55
no longer willing to be so patient they
00:03:59
see their future in having a voice in
00:04:02
their government in having more equality
00:04:05
in other social and political aspects of
00:04:09
their lives and they want it now
00:04:12
in the balcony amongst the press of
00:04:16
suffragists and Dallas Dudley of
00:04:19
Nashville leaned into the rail ready to
00:04:22
defy her social upbringing and shout her
00:04:24
approval or disapproval and Alice Dudley
00:04:27
comes out of some Nashville nobility
00:04:31
she's a mother
00:04:32
she is beautiful and she counteracts all
00:04:36
the stereotypes that the anti
00:04:38
suffragists have used for decades across
00:04:43
the chamber in the opposite balcony
00:04:45
Josephine Pearson of Monteagle Tennessee
00:04:48
led the aunt eyes as president of the
00:04:50
Tennessee Association opposed to woman
00:04:53
suffrage and she seemed ideal she seemed
00:04:58
to be opposed to any rights for women
00:05:01
even though she herself was a single
00:05:04
woman who had been an independent
00:05:06
schoolteacher at one time as morning
00:05:10
turned into afternoon the heat rose in
00:05:13
the chamber the Speaker of the House
00:05:15
pushed for the vote that he believed
00:05:17
would be the defeat of the 19th
00:05:20
amendment the men are exhausted are
00:05:24
frightened for their political future
00:05:26
it's this incredibly dramatic moment and
00:05:30
the future of American women is being
00:05:33
decided right there after three weeks of
00:05:37
open and sometimes furtive lobbying
00:05:39
political betrayals illicit payoffs and
00:05:43
masterful legislative stalling tactics
00:05:46
the clerk began the roll call on the
00:05:48
vote for or against the ratification of
00:05:51
the 19th amendment Anderson well
00:06:01
the civic fate of millions of women
00:06:04
across the u.s. rested in the hands of
00:06:06
the all-male Tennessee House of
00:06:08
Representatives to reach this point
00:06:12
American women had spent decades
00:06:14
fighting through complex layers of
00:06:16
social political and racial constraints
00:06:19
but nowhere were there greater
00:06:22
challenges than in the south and the
00:06:24
roots of this battle went back even
00:06:27
before the Civil War
00:06:31
the social fabric had been torn asunder
00:06:34
by the Civil War and reconstruction and
00:06:37
now here's another movement that
00:06:39
promises to tear the fabric again and
00:06:49
the soul of women particularly and the
00:06:54
southern states did not support for
00:06:58
Selfridge a minimum can you see what's
00:07:02
in the doubtful power what was really
00:07:05
ironic that the final battle over a
00:07:08
woman's suffrage was going to happen in
00:07:10
a southern state after all this was the
00:07:12
region that was the most resistant the
00:07:14
suffragists had fought hard but with
00:07:17
little success when people today you're
00:07:19
looking back on this and they assumed
00:07:22
that there was going to be a victory at
00:07:24
the end of this fight they were assuming
00:07:27
a lot
00:07:28
[Music]
00:07:31
the woman suffrage movement began in the
00:07:35
Northeast and it was a direct offshoot
00:07:38
of the anti-slavery movement nearly
00:07:41
every woman who was involved in the
00:07:44
early women's rights movement was
00:07:46
involved in the anti-slavery movement
00:07:48
some of the first abolitionists to speak
00:07:51
publicly about the rights of women were
00:07:53
two sisters from Charleston South
00:07:55
Carolina
00:07:56
Sarah and Angelina Grimke in the early
00:08:00
1800s men and women were created equal
00:08:03
all I ask of our brethren is that they
00:08:07
will take their feet from off our necks
00:08:10
and permit us to stand upright on that
00:08:12
ground which God designed us to occupy
00:08:14
they begin to bring that sensibility of
00:08:18
southern women into the suffrage
00:08:22
movement decades earlier than it really
00:08:24
begins to coalesce as a movement in the
00:08:27
southern states fighting slavery led the
00:08:31
grim keys and other female abolitionists
00:08:33
to question the accepted cultural and
00:08:36
legal norms controlling a woman's life
00:08:38
her life was supposed to be centered on
00:08:41
the domestic sphere that's what it was
00:08:43
called
00:08:44
that meant home and hearth and family
00:08:47
and nothing else
00:08:48
women's legal position was pretty much
00:08:51
the same as the legal position of felons
00:08:54
married women had no rights to own
00:08:57
property to serve in juries they did not
00:09:00
have rights to their own children if
00:09:02
they got divorced any income from any
00:09:06
work that she did would be his the
00:09:09
clothing on her back would be his prior
00:09:12
to the Civil War most African American
00:09:16
women were enslaved in the American
00:09:18
South they therefore had no control
00:09:21
whatsoever over their own bodies over
00:09:24
their lives their families and children
00:09:27
could be taken away from them at any
00:09:29
time women in jail were basically
00:09:33
relegated to a position of second-class
00:09:35
citizenship but for black women they
00:09:38
wore a double burden not only did they
00:09:41
have to face
00:09:43
sexism but they also had to face racism
00:09:46
most women knew that they couldn't
00:09:48
support themselves long term so they had
00:09:51
to get married
00:09:52
and sometimes the pool was a little thin
00:09:54
and so she happened to marry someone who
00:09:57
became a brutal drunk she was stuck in
00:10:02
rising frustration at the lack of power
00:10:04
over their own lives a small group
00:10:08
organized a convention on the status of
00:10:10
women in 1848 the Seneca Falls
00:10:13
convention concluded with the
00:10:16
declaration of sentiments it was modeled
00:10:19
after the Declaration of Independence
00:10:22
which declared all men are created equal
00:10:25
despite the pleas of Abigail Adams to
00:10:28
remember the ladies these truths to be
00:10:31
self-evident that all men and women are
00:10:35
created equal that they are endowed
00:10:37
iived her of this first right of a
00:10:39
citizen the elective franchise thereby
00:10:42
leaving her without representation in
00:10:44
the halls of legislation he has so they
00:10:46
had a long list of things that they
00:10:48
wanted to address and the vote was just
00:10:51
really only one of them at that time
00:10:53
asking for the vote was considered to be
00:10:55
astonishingly radical the Seneca Falls
00:10:58
convention sparked what grew into the
00:11:01
main movement advocating for women's
00:11:04
rights and woman suffrage but most
00:11:07
southern women were not eager to join
00:11:10
the experiences that tended to create
00:11:12
suffrage ISM happened in the Northeast
00:11:15
earlier than they happened in the south
00:11:17
things like industrial development the
00:11:21
rise of women's voluntary associations
00:11:24
college education those things happened
00:11:27
earlier in the northeast and so Southern
00:11:29
women had a generation difference in the
00:11:32
opportunity to experience some of those
00:11:34
things
00:11:34
[Music]
00:11:44
the Civil War was in some ways a crisis
00:11:47
of gender in that when the Civil War
00:11:50
came and the male's of a household left
00:11:53
the women were left particularly in
00:11:56
rural areas as much of Tennessee was
00:11:59
women in Tennessee were left on their
00:12:01
own to fend for themselves many white
00:12:04
women entered the public sphere by
00:12:07
necessity managing farms alone or
00:12:10
becoming teachers nurses factory workers
00:12:13
at the end of the war the south also had
00:12:16
to contend with the social and economic
00:12:19
upheaval of emancipation reconstruction
00:12:23
was this critical point in American
00:12:25
history and which Americans were
00:12:27
reconsidering and redefining what it
00:12:30
meant to be a citizen and the debate
00:12:32
centered on the 14th and 15th amendment
00:12:36
black men were given citizenship and the
00:12:40
right to vote but women were left out
00:12:43
and that ended up causing a big rift
00:12:46
among suffragists and the women who had
00:12:49
fought really hard to bring slavery to
00:12:52
an end really felt betrayed
00:12:55
white Republicans very much wanted black
00:12:58
men who would have allegiance to the
00:13:01
Republican Party to have the vote
00:13:03
including women women of any race in the
00:13:08
Fifteenth Amendment was definitely too
00:13:11
controversial and was quite clear that
00:13:14
including women would have guaranteed
00:13:16
its failure when you ask for woman's
00:13:21
suffrage as opposed to manhood suffrage
00:13:25
you're asking for two major developments
00:13:28
to happen at the same time you're asking
00:13:31
on the one hand for a different way that
00:13:35
Americans view african-american men they
00:13:39
are no longer property they are now your
00:13:43
fellow citizens with all the same rights
00:13:45
that you have so that's a big thing
00:13:48
Americans can't really focus on two big
00:13:52
changes or very simply they don't want
00:13:56
to focus on these two big changes to
00:13:59
American society by the 1870s and 80s a
00:14:03
growing number of unusually bold white
00:14:05
Southern women began advocating for
00:14:08
women's rights within 20 years their
00:14:11
impassioned pleas convinced national
00:14:13
leaders to look south in the 1890s white
00:14:17
Southern Democrats were trying to regain
00:14:19
political power they were trying to keep
00:14:22
black men from voting or to counter its
00:14:25
effect and southern and northern
00:14:27
suffragists saw an opportunity in this
00:14:30
and they develop sort of a Southern
00:14:33
Strategy ironically they borrowed some
00:14:37
of their ideas from Henry blackwell a
00:14:39
northern abolitionists who said you can
00:14:42
accomplish your goal not by
00:14:44
disfranchising black men but giving the
00:14:47
votes to women you're for millions of
00:14:51
southern white women will counterbalance
00:14:53
your for millions of Negro men and women
00:14:56
and thus the political supremacy of your
00:14:59
white race will remain unchanged
00:15:03
they sent professional recruiters into
00:15:06
the area Susan De'Anthony and Carrie
00:15:08
Chapman can't win on major speaking
00:15:11
tours throughout the region and
00:15:13
everywhere spreading this message when
00:15:17
those two suffers leaders came to
00:15:19
Memphis they of course spoken very
00:15:22
racialized settings there's no record of
00:15:25
exactly what they said to the black
00:15:27
women but you can just understand it's
00:15:30
going to be a little different from what
00:15:31
they're saying to the white woman but
00:15:33
the thing is there's an understanding
00:15:35
that maybe we need to address suffrage
00:15:39
as an issue that can be pushed by both
00:15:42
by women in both communities it was
00:15:45
inevitable that race was going to play a
00:15:47
major role in the suffrage movement and
00:15:50
national leaders in order to achieve a
00:15:52
national victory had to have some
00:15:54
southern states and southern suffragists
00:15:57
were working for the vote in the midst
00:15:59
of a regional movement to restore white
00:16:01
political supremacy twenty-five years
00:16:06
after losing the battle to include women
00:16:08
in the Fifteenth Amendment national
00:16:11
suffrage leaders discouraged that
00:16:13
arguments based on justice were falling
00:16:16
on deaf ears were willing to resort to
00:16:18
political expediency this moral
00:16:22
compromise came into stark relief at
00:16:24
their conventions held in the south in
00:16:27
an attempt to woo white Southerners to
00:16:30
their cause because they needed to have
00:16:32
a national constituency leaders of the
00:16:36
National American Woman Suffrage
00:16:38
Association decided to hold conventions
00:16:41
in the south they did however accept the
00:16:45
idea of segregation they also at the
00:16:48
same time were a sort of circus Lee
00:16:51
wooing black women so they were playing
00:16:54
both sides of the game at this point
00:16:57
trying to attract black women but to do
00:17:00
it surreptitiously so that they would
00:17:02
not offend white people it's about the
00:17:04
turn of the century state legislators
00:17:07
throughout the South found other means
00:17:10
of preventing african-american men from
00:17:13
voting
00:17:14
such as
00:17:15
poll taxes and understanding clauses all
00:17:19
assisted by rulings from the Supreme
00:17:22
Court when the laws did not work well
00:17:25
enough they turn to physical
00:17:28
intimidation and those impacted black
00:17:30
women as well and the more active and
00:17:34
high-profile a black woman was the more
00:17:36
likely she was to be subject to such
00:17:39
intimidation after that that whole
00:17:43
Southern Strategy was exposed as
00:17:46
ineffective and the movement more or
00:17:50
less went dormant in the South until the
00:17:54
last decade of the suffrage movement
00:17:57
[Music]
00:17:59
the social and economic upheaval of the
00:18:02
Civil War had provided the impetus for
00:18:04
building a southern suffrage movement as
00:18:06
it thrust women into the public sphere
00:18:09
in the face of great need they defied
00:18:13
convention and threw themselves into
00:18:15
rebuilding their families their lives
00:18:17
and their communities in the aftermath
00:18:20
of the civil war you see women joining
00:18:23
together and creating organizations on a
00:18:27
local level that are capable of working
00:18:30
together to build institutions like
00:18:34
churches like schools when you look at
00:18:39
organizations within the black church
00:18:41
with any church women are the doers the
00:18:44
other organizes so they took those
00:18:47
skills that they had in the church they
00:18:50
honed it in the community they knew how
00:18:53
to galvanize people church groups are
00:18:56
providing a mechanism for women to start
00:18:58
gathering and that becomes more
00:19:00
politicized and moves more into civic
00:19:02
work and public work as women to find
00:19:04
their roles in society as taking on
00:19:07
problems in the community that need
00:19:09
attention and it is cumulative from
00:19:12
their own in 1885 a young widow Lizzie
00:19:17
Crozier French chafed at the limited
00:19:19
life women led in her conservative
00:19:22
hometown of Knoxville Tennessee suffrage
00:19:25
would have been too radical an issue for
00:19:27
most women in her community to start
00:19:29
broadening their minds French founded
00:19:32
the AUSA Li circle as a women's book
00:19:34
club the club was very successful but
00:19:37
after a certain period of time she got
00:19:39
sort of bored with him discussing things
00:19:42
that were sort of ancient questions and
00:19:44
so she is reported to have stood up in
00:19:46
the middle of one of the meetings and
00:19:48
said ladies Dante is dead now let's move
00:19:52
on with things that can help the people
00:19:53
now and so she tried to change it more
00:19:56
into a social action group the Asli
00:20:00
circle grew to be a powerful force for
00:20:02
women's reform efforts in Knoxville
00:20:05
throughout the segregated south african
00:20:08
american women's clubs
00:20:10
also thrived there were hundreds of
00:20:13
african-american women's clubs that had
00:20:15
thousands of members throughout the
00:20:17
south they did differ slightly from the
00:20:21
white women's clubs in that they were
00:20:23
all very serious they didn't seem to
00:20:26
engage very much in trivial pursuits
00:20:30
rather they stuck to issues of education
00:20:33
reform and political empowerment by the
00:20:36
late 1800s the women's Christian
00:20:39
Temperance Union had become one of the
00:20:41
most popular organizations in the South
00:20:43
moving well beyond its initial mandate
00:20:46
of prohibition the WCTU allowed women to
00:20:50
organize and act upon a variety of
00:20:54
subjects whether its schools or public
00:20:57
life politics all the time creating
00:21:00
activities that allowed women to learn
00:21:03
how to run a meeting learn how to raise
00:21:05
money learn how to talk to politicians
00:21:08
the women's Christian Temperance Union
00:21:11
was the golden key that unlocked the
00:21:14
prison doors of pent-up possibilities it
00:21:17
was the generous Liberator the joyous
00:21:20
iconoclast the discoverer the developer
00:21:23
of southern women
00:21:26
as they moved into the public sphere
00:21:28
these women were interested in reforming
00:21:31
things like working conditions and child
00:21:33
labor and incredibly to raise the age of
00:21:38
consent which in some southern states
00:21:40
was as low as ten years old they began
00:21:45
to see that the power they lacked in
00:21:48
making these suggestions was the ballot
00:21:52
box they could come to the state capitol
00:21:54
and talk to the lawmakers here but until
00:21:58
they could vote for those lawmakers they
00:22:01
had no power from post-civil war church
00:22:16
groups to temperance action to community
00:22:19
civic groups women are claiming their
00:22:21
space in society and there was no
00:22:23
repressing that or holding it back it's
00:22:26
the need for freedom and rights and
00:22:28
civic respect and place in society women
00:22:33
had to have that the vote for women was
00:22:36
the logical outcome
00:22:40
[Music]
00:22:42
by 1900 and even more by 1910 the army
00:22:48
of women was there they had had another
00:22:50
generations worth of experiences in
00:22:52
women's clubs another generation had
00:22:55
been to college the moment seemed to
00:22:57
have arrived by 1911 there were
00:23:00
organized suffrage groups in all the
00:23:02
major Tennessee cities by 1910 you've
00:23:18
suddenly got some younger women coming
00:23:20
along that add a little more energy to a
00:23:25
group of women that have become rather
00:23:27
set in their ways
00:23:28
take for example and Alice Dudley
00:23:31
she was from what would be regarded as a
00:23:34
good family and yet she went to a
00:23:38
suffrage meeting there's a direct
00:23:40
correlation between how tough it was to
00:23:43
argue for suffrage in this region and
00:23:46
the fact that it that these elite women
00:23:48
were the ones doing it because only they
00:23:50
could get away with it a new breed the
00:23:53
career woman also joined the ranks of
00:23:56
the suffrage movement sue Shelton white
00:23:59
was the first female court stenographer
00:24:02
in Jackson Tennessee so she's that
00:24:05
third-generation of suffragists who sees
00:24:09
the future sees what the vote might
00:24:13
benefit her in many many ways even more
00:24:16
than just the vote it's the sense of
00:24:18
equality of opportunity opening up and
00:24:21
she wants it
00:24:25
this movement really was grabbing the
00:24:28
imagination of the every woman in
00:24:31
America because it promised a kind of
00:24:36
opening not just for the vote but for a
00:24:39
new kind of role for women in society
00:24:44
African American women also saw the
00:24:46
promise of a new role but their fight
00:24:49
proved more complex a Delahunt Logan
00:24:53
from Tuskegee Alabama was one of the few
00:24:56
who openly advocated for suffrage while
00:24:59
still living in the south I've come
00:25:02
across no evidence that african-american
00:25:05
women moved outside of their own
00:25:07
communities to promote suffrage for
00:25:10
women what they did do for example at
00:25:14
Tuskegee Institute in that protected
00:25:17
African American environment those women
00:25:20
sometimes did indeed hold rallies for
00:25:23
women voting but they wouldn't have done
00:25:25
so in the town of Tuskegee or have done
00:25:28
so in the city of Atlanta as the
00:25:31
movement gained strength in the south
00:25:34
national leaders continued to try to
00:25:37
appease white Southerners on the race
00:25:39
issue and they were very very wary of
00:25:42
how anything they said about race was
00:25:44
going to be used against them by the
00:25:47
anti suffragists and so they continued
00:25:51
to tolerate discrimination and they
00:25:54
played down the role of black women in
00:25:56
the movement
00:25:58
former Tennesseans Mary Church Terrell
00:26:01
and Ida B wells actively worked for
00:26:04
women's suffrage but in their adopted
00:26:07
hometowns of Washington DC and Chicago
00:26:09
Illinois in 1913 they were confronted
00:26:14
with the racial politics of the movement
00:26:16
when they were asked to march at the
00:26:18
back of a massive suffrage parade on the
00:26:20
nation's capitol Mary Church Terrell she
00:26:25
led a group in that March while they
00:26:29
marched they marched in the back on the
00:26:31
other hand you have how to be Wells but
00:26:35
what she does is that she steps out when
00:26:39
the Chicago delegation is walking and
00:26:41
she walks with that Chicago delegation
00:26:45
with white women I think what that
00:26:47
parade incident tells us is that first
00:26:51
of all there is no one way of responding
00:26:53
ah to be well says well no I'm not going
00:26:57
to do it she was very uncompromising
00:27:00
mary church terrell would have looked
00:27:04
for the compromise for the good of the
00:27:06
whole but they're all working for the
00:27:09
same thing
00:27:12
by then the woman suffrage movement had
00:27:16
made major gains in other regions
00:27:18
especially in the West but southern
00:27:21
legislators were still resistant
00:27:23
Tennessee suffragists did have enough
00:27:26
support in the major cities to organize
00:27:28
May Day parades with hundreds of cars
00:27:31
and women be decked and suffrage yellow
00:27:33
at the first parade in Nashville in 1914
00:27:38
according to the local paper and Alice
00:27:41
Dudley gave the first open-air speech by
00:27:44
any woman in Tennessee a southern woman
00:27:47
should be happy and content in her home
00:27:51
on her pedestal and here they're coming
00:27:54
down to the pedestal into the mud of the
00:27:56
streets and saying uh-uh
00:27:58
things are not alright and that was
00:28:01
really pretty radical if the most
00:28:04
privileged person in the society
00:28:07
rejected its fundamental hierarchical
00:28:09
structure and demanded to have equal
00:28:13
representation and power than that kind
00:28:16
of suggested the corruption of the
00:28:18
entire system
00:28:21
Antti suffragists had an arsenal of
00:28:24
ideology and arguments against women's
00:28:27
suffrage that fell into basically five
00:28:29
categories biological biblical or
00:28:33
religious sociological arguments racial
00:28:36
arguments and states rights arguments
00:28:39
remember that woman's suffrage means a
00:28:42
reopening of the entire Negro suffrage
00:28:44
question loss of state rights and
00:28:47
another period of reconstruction horrors
00:28:50
southerners had worked so hard since the
00:28:54
civil war to take away all the rights of
00:28:57
African American men regarding politics
00:29:01
and now this would open this whole can
00:29:04
of worms of who should be voting and is
00:29:08
it the federal government's
00:29:09
responsibility to determine who can vote
00:29:12
inside a state and who cannot by the
00:29:16
mid-nineteen tends the woman's suffrage
00:29:18
movement gained enough momentum to
00:29:21
require an organized opposition
00:29:24
manufacturers did not want women to have
00:29:26
the right to vote
00:29:28
because they would probably start
00:29:30
pushing for regulations over these
00:29:34
factories the liquor industry opposed
00:29:38
women having the right to vote because
00:29:40
they blamed women for prohibition and
00:29:45
finally there were the railroads they
00:29:48
had a very significant voice in the
00:29:52
hallways and back rooms where the deals
00:29:55
were cut here at the General Assembly
00:29:59
while these business interests worked
00:30:01
the halls of state legislatures
00:30:03
throughout the south women provided the
00:30:06
public face of organized anti-suffrage
00:30:09
groups in tennessee josephine pearson of
00:30:14
monaco emerged as the leader this is
00:30:18
what was so unbelievable about josephine
00:30:21
pearson she had never married she was a
00:30:23
totally independent woman and yet she
00:30:26
was a very effective spokesman telling
00:30:30
people why women shouldn't have the
00:30:32
right to vote
00:30:34
posing Woman Suffrage in their view
00:30:36
isn't opposing their own self-interest
00:30:39
it's protecting those other areas of
00:30:42
their self-interest their economic
00:30:45
self-interest their class
00:30:47
self-interest their region's political
00:30:50
structure all of those things that they
00:30:53
benefit from they're choosing to protect
00:30:58
by 1917 women had won either full or
00:31:02
partial suffrage in seventeen states but
00:31:06
the southeastern states remained
00:31:08
steadfastly resistant as national
00:31:12
leaders turned their organizational
00:31:14
strength towards a federal
00:31:16
constitutional amendment Southern women
00:31:19
had to face political reality it's
00:31:22
probably safe to say southern
00:31:24
suffragists were very practical at this
00:31:27
point there were just so many states
00:31:29
that we're never going to enact woman
00:31:31
suffrage if they really wanted it to be
00:31:33
nationwide it was going to have to come
00:31:35
by federal amendment with the outbreak
00:31:40
of war a rift between the two national
00:31:43
suffrage groups grew wider Carrie
00:31:47
Chapman Catt president of the National
00:31:50
American Woman Suffrage Association or
00:31:53
the National encouraged all her members
00:31:56
to turn their energy toward the war
00:31:58
effort she hoped their actions would
00:32:01
convince president woodrow wilson that
00:32:03
women deserve the full right of
00:32:05
citizenship however Alice Paul leader of
00:32:10
the National Woman's Party refused to
00:32:13
stop her aggressive tactics designed to
00:32:15
embarrass the president the whole idea
00:32:19
of women standing up and being this
00:32:24
aggressive on top of just being
00:32:26
suffragists which was considered
00:32:27
aggressive enough kind of puts it over
00:32:30
the pale and so both southern men find
00:32:34
it very offensive and southern women
00:32:37
even southern suffrages
00:32:42
sue Shelton white however found the bold
00:32:45
tactics appealing she changed
00:32:48
affiliations eventually moving to
00:32:50
Washington DC to work for Alice Paul she
00:32:54
served her time in the mainstream
00:32:56
suffrage organization she's gotten
00:32:59
frustrated and so she joins the women's
00:33:01
Party because she thinks they are going
00:33:04
to be more aggressive and more
00:33:06
confrontational in demanding the vote
00:33:08
and she's willing to do that now the
00:33:10
majority of Tennessee suffragists
00:33:12
however followed Carrie Chapman Catt
00:33:14
SCID vice to join the war effort Carrie
00:33:18
Chapman Catt who is a political
00:33:20
pragmatist and she gambled having her
00:33:23
legions of activists enter the war
00:33:26
effort and for her that was a real
00:33:29
sacrifice because she was a committed
00:33:32
pacifist but the gamble paid off Woodrow
00:33:35
Wilson eventually came out and supported
00:33:38
the federal amendment
00:33:41
only five months after the Armistice
00:33:44
Tennessee suffragists introduced a bill
00:33:47
to the state legislature allowing women
00:33:49
to vote in presidential and municipal
00:33:52
elections and their appeal to Tennessee
00:33:56
men the suffragists emphasized women's
00:33:59
contributions to winning the war as well
00:34:02
as how many women could already vote in
00:34:05
other states all the women of the West
00:34:08
some millions of the north and many
00:34:10
thousands of the south are already
00:34:13
voters what made the women of Tennessee
00:34:15
expect of you that is what finally
00:34:19
tipped a scale when there were so many
00:34:22
states that had supported it that the
00:34:27
politicians in both political parties
00:34:29
begin to sense that women were going to
00:34:33
get the vote you were going to double
00:34:35
the electorate and which side of that
00:34:37
did you want to be on
00:34:40
on April 14 1919 Tennessee women won the
00:34:45
right to vote in presidential and
00:34:47
municipal elections adding even more
00:34:50
momentum to the building tidal wave of
00:34:52
Pro suffrage sentiment less than two
00:34:56
months later with President Wilson
00:34:58
support both houses of the US Congress
00:35:01
passed the 19th amendment to become law
00:35:05
the amendment now had to be ratified by
00:35:08
36 states as the fight for the federal
00:35:13
amendment went to the states for
00:35:14
ratification Tennessee suffragists
00:35:17
immediately put their new state voting
00:35:20
rights into action creating a list of
00:35:22
reforms they wanted and organizing a
00:35:25
voter registration drive Catherine
00:35:28
Kenney spearheaded the efforts in
00:35:30
Nashville and an extraordinary alliance
00:35:52
rarely seen in the south Kenny teamed
00:35:55
with dr. Mattie Coleman and J Frankie
00:35:58
Pierce influential leaders in the black
00:36:00
community to register approximately
00:36:04
2,000 african-american women in
00:36:06
Nashville I have found very little
00:36:09
evidence that indicates that black women
00:36:12
and white women worked together in the
00:36:15
south adela Logan tried to encourage the
00:36:18
National Association of colored women to
00:36:20
join in efforts with white groups of all
00:36:23
sorts but for the most part those
00:36:25
efforts were not very successful the
00:36:28
white women weren't open to it for the
00:36:29
most part by September 1919 every major
00:36:33
city in the state reported remarkable
00:36:36
numbers of women black and white
00:36:39
registry
00:36:40
[Music]
00:36:42
by late March 1920 only one more state
00:36:46
was needed to ratify the federal
00:36:47
amendment but few viable options
00:36:50
remained a spring warmed into summer
00:36:54
suffragists hopes of being able to vote
00:36:56
in the 1920 presidential election were
00:36:59
repeatedly dashed as state legislators
00:37:02
rejected the amendment our governor's
00:37:05
refused to call special sessions in all
00:37:08
but one state Tennessee
00:37:11
so the suffragists are very nervous when
00:37:15
they realize that the last battle may
00:37:17
have to be fought in a southern state
00:37:20
because again most of the southern
00:37:24
states have already rejected the 19th
00:37:26
amendment so there's this sense of
00:37:30
anxiety and well placed by the
00:37:32
suffragists they don't get it now they
00:37:34
may not get it after the 1920 election
00:37:38
it'll be too hard to regain momentum
00:37:41
Tennessee Governor Albert Roberts
00:37:43
resisted enormous pressure even from
00:37:47
President Wilson to call a special
00:37:49
session vote against his election was
00:38:01
coming up right away and he didn't want
00:38:04
them to have ago and I said why you know
00:38:08
if you give them the book they'll have
00:38:10
to talk to you
00:38:13
so he weighed the political liability of
00:38:16
this decision before he announced that
00:38:21
he would call the special session the
00:38:24
caveat being that the special session
00:38:26
would convene after the August primary
00:38:31
so the message was very clear women if I
00:38:36
don't win the Democratic nomination for
00:38:38
governor
00:38:40
you can probably write off having the
00:38:43
special session it will not take place
00:38:48
as Tennessee suffragists threw
00:38:51
themselves into organizing support
00:38:53
battle-hardened Carrie Chapman Catt
00:38:56
offered her sober assessment no matter
00:38:59
how well the women may work ratification
00:39:03
in Tennessee will go through the work
00:39:05
and action of men and the great motive
00:39:08
that will finally put it through will be
00:39:11
political and nothing else we have long
00:39:15
since recovered from our previous faith
00:39:18
in the action of men based upon the love
00:39:20
of Justice and they began a physically
00:39:28
demanding and tireless crusade going
00:39:32
across the state whether it be on the
00:39:35
train in the wagon meeting with every
00:39:38
member of the Tennessee General Assembly
00:39:41
attempting to persuade them of the
00:39:45
justice the righteousness of this cause
00:39:49
I remember going in while counting their
00:39:54
pasta there's three of them
00:39:58
this is Camry rose in it and just way
00:40:03
before the time of bus says Norway are
00:40:07
negated I and get to the courthouse
00:40:10
worse arrive in the counted with the
00:40:15
mailman he's at me - they will nature
00:40:20
today the auntie suffragists are also
00:40:24
organizing they go from Memphis to
00:40:27
Nashville to Chattanooga trying to get
00:40:29
support for halting preventing the
00:40:33
governor from calling a special session
00:40:35
and if that fails at least to promising
00:40:40
to vote against ratification as the
00:40:45
summer heat and sticky humidity
00:40:47
descended on Nashville
00:40:48
national leaders of all factions arrived
00:40:51
to rally their troops sue white returned
00:40:55
to her home state eager but anxious with
00:40:58
only limited resources from the National
00:41:01
Woman's Party both Carrie Chapman Catt
00:41:03
president of the National and Josephine
00:41:06
Pearson president of the Tennessee State
00:41:09
Association opposed to woman suffrage
00:41:11
took rooms at the elegant hermitage
00:41:14
hotel
00:41:16
so you've got these two women on
00:41:18
different floors of the Hermitage hotel
00:41:20
where the scene of the fight is going to
00:41:25
take place it becomes known as the War
00:41:28
of the Roses because the ant eyes wore
00:41:30
red roses red flowers and the
00:41:33
suffragists wore yellow roses or yellow
00:41:36
flowers was a table they want different
00:41:45
floors punch each other as July gave way
00:41:57
to August legislators arrived for the
00:42:00
special session and were met by legions
00:42:02
of women hoping to pen a yellow or red
00:42:05
rose on their lapels the suffragists had
00:42:08
done their homework they were indeed
00:42:10
much more organized than the ant eyes
00:42:13
were so when the session convened they
00:42:16
really thought they had a very
00:42:19
comfortable margin and yet this is at
00:42:23
the point when the ant eyes really began
00:42:26
to work so everyone converges on the
00:42:31
hermitage and the lobby is just a swarm
00:42:34
of people debating and arguing and
00:42:37
lobbying and perhaps bribing on the 8th
00:42:54
floor of the hotel
00:42:55
despite prohibition laws liquor
00:42:58
lobbyists set up what came to be known
00:43:00
as the Jack Daniels suite luring
00:43:03
legislators they're hoping to turn
00:43:05
yellow roses into red
00:43:16
[Music]
00:43:23
within the first few days of the special
00:43:26
session suffragists saw the effects of
00:43:29
the anti x' lobbying efforts powerful
00:43:32
political allies who had pledged to lead
00:43:34
the efforts for ratification turned anti
00:43:38
including Speaker of the House
00:43:43
[Music]
00:43:54
[Music]
00:44:02
it is not ladylike politics at all this
00:44:06
fight that is going to take place in the
00:44:09
halls of the Tennessee State Capitol the
00:44:12
arguments are fierce the ridicule and
00:44:17
humiliation of the suffragists were on
00:44:50
the fifth day of the special session
00:44:53
Friday the 13th the Tennessee Senate
00:44:56
overwhelmingly voted to ratify the
00:44:58
amendment suffragists now had to contend
00:45:02
with the ever-shifting House of
00:45:04
Representatives led by their unexpected
00:45:06
adversary Seth Walker a master of
00:45:10
legislative stalling tactics in
00:45:22
Nashville at the time with each delay in
00:45:28
the Tennessee House the suffragists
00:45:32
became more and more anxious
00:45:34
the
00:45:34
because on a daily basis as the men
00:45:37
convened they saw men who had supported
00:45:41
ratification men who had worn yellow
00:45:44
roses now appearing in the House chamber
00:45:47
wearing red roses when the Sun rose on
00:45:53
the tenth day of the special session all
00:45:55
the leaders of the many suffrage
00:45:58
factions counted who remained on their
00:46:01
list of supporters and all came up short
00:46:05
even most of Nashville's representatives
00:46:08
personally pledged buy and Alice Dudley
00:46:11
had defected to the auntie's the vote
00:46:15
would finally happen in this one moment
00:46:18
and this unlikely place rested the civic
00:46:22
fate of millions of women the House
00:46:29
clerk continued the roll call for the
00:46:31
final vote on the ratification of the
00:46:34
19th amendment
00:46:41
Harry Berne was the first time
00:46:43
legislature from Nyota Tennessee and the
00:46:46
youngest member of the house at only 24
00:46:48
years old it so happens that after I had
00:46:51
gotten to Nashville people from all over
00:46:54
the country had gone into my County that
00:46:56
had indignation meetings they caused the
00:46:58
courts to adjourn so that they might
00:47:00
pass resolutions and they were my
00:47:02
constituency where was in a great state
00:47:04
of turmoil I don't know yet exactly what
00:47:08
the majority favored but anyway there's
00:47:11
lots of feeling existed so much so that
00:47:13
when I would go home on a weekend I
00:47:15
would generally keep a body guard around
00:47:17
so that no one would attack me with the
00:47:20
intense pressure from Republican leaders
00:47:22
and constituents back home Bern had
00:47:25
voted with an ties all along despite his
00:47:28
personal support for suffrage he had
00:47:31
hoped his vote would not matter in the
00:47:34
final outcome
00:47:35
but a last-minute change by West
00:47:38
Tennessee legislature banks Turner meant
00:47:41
the final vote would likely end in a tie
00:47:45
he is so torn
00:47:48
he is so conflicted here he is does he
00:47:52
do what personally what his conscience
00:47:54
feels is right or does he do what would
00:47:59
be better for him for his re-election
00:48:01
campaign and he's done the math and
00:48:03
realized that with banks Turner flipping
00:48:07
towards the amendment he may be the
00:48:11
deciding vote it's just what he didn't
00:48:13
want to happen in a fortuitous bit of
00:48:17
timing Bern received a letter from his
00:48:19
mother Feb Ensminger Bern right before
00:48:23
he walked into the house chamber my
00:48:27
mother was the college woman she was a
00:48:30
student of national and international
00:48:31
affairs she took an interest in all
00:48:34
public issues she could not vote and yet
00:48:38
the tenant farmers on our farm some of
00:48:41
whom were illiterate good vote fat-burn
00:48:45
had been closely following the reports
00:48:47
of the Tennessee legislature in her
00:48:49
local newspaper nestled amongst folksy
00:48:52
news of his hometown Byrnes mother gave
00:48:55
her son some advice Hirai vote for
00:48:59
suffrage and don't keep him in doubt
00:49:02
I've been waiting to see how you stood
00:49:04
but have not seen anything yet don't
00:49:06
forget to be a good boy and help mrs.
00:49:09
cat with her rats so when it came
00:49:12
Harry's turn to vote Harry with his very
00:49:15
quiet vote voted aye
00:49:18
I vote for the suffrage cause Harry has
00:49:26
changed his vote
00:49:28
can you believe it the roll call
00:49:31
continued through to the teas Travis
00:49:35
Tucker Turner
00:49:39
Turner the clerk mark Turner is not
00:49:44
voting in the roll call continued to the
00:49:46
end at that point it will be a tied vote
00:49:51
which means suffrage will go down to
00:49:55
defeat even with Harry burns affirmative
00:49:58
vote what happens next is whatever's
00:50:03
going through banks Turner's mind he
00:50:06
says to the clerk there's a moment of
00:50:15
complete utter stunned silence because
00:50:19
everyone realizes this is it this is
00:50:23
that one vote margin and ratification
00:50:27
has passed then there's an explosion of
00:50:33
emotion the ant eyes are furious they
00:50:39
thought they had this deal sealed and
00:50:43
now they are furious the suffragists our
00:50:46
emotional beyond belief crying hugging
00:50:50
each other
00:50:50
[Applause]
00:51:00
it was the next day before the press
00:51:04
caught up with Harry T Byrne Harry
00:51:08
why did you change your mind all the
00:51:11
reporters wanted to know the answer to
00:51:13
that question and so Harry told the
00:51:16
reporters simply I always take my
00:51:21
mother's advice on that roll call when I
00:51:24
was confronted for the fact that I was
00:51:26
going to go on record for time and
00:51:28
eternity on the merits of the question I
00:51:30
voted in favor of ratification
00:51:35
there were all manner of shenanigans
00:51:38
being pulled politically to try to get
00:51:41
yet another vote but the vote held and
00:51:45
so somewhat reluctantly I think governor
00:51:49
Roberts finally said bring me the
00:51:53
document I'm going to sign it and it was
00:51:55
signed and immediately put on the train
00:51:58
to go back to Washington to be presented
00:52:02
to the secretary of state across the
00:52:04
nation women who had worked for suffrage
00:52:07
some their entire lives celebrated this
00:52:11
hard-won civil right for some southern
00:52:14
suffragists however the ratification by
00:52:17
federal amendment was a bittersweet
00:52:19
victory
00:52:21
it only remains for the outward and
00:52:23
visible sign of our freedom to be put in
00:52:25
the hands of Southern women by the
00:52:27
generous men of other states a situation
00:52:31
that hurts our pride into which we
00:52:33
submit with deep regret but not apology
00:52:37
[Music]
00:52:39
most southern suffer just really wanted
00:52:43
to get the vote by state action because
00:52:46
of what that symbolizes what it
00:52:49
symbolized is that the your men the men
00:52:52
in your life the men in your state see
00:52:54
you as their political equal
00:52:58
passage of the 19th amendment also did
00:53:01
not mean african-american women would be
00:53:04
treated as political equals
00:53:07
african-american women in the south were
00:53:09
faced with in many instances the failure
00:53:13
to enforce the provisions of the
00:53:16
Fifteenth Amendment many of them wanted
00:53:18
to vote many of them tried to vote but
00:53:20
they face the same barriers to voting
00:53:22
that african-american men did in other
00:53:26
words they were limited by provisions of
00:53:28
poll taxes by physical intimidation they
00:53:33
understood that they were going to be
00:53:34
you know some restrictions and
00:53:36
restraints placed upon them but they
00:53:38
also understood that with fortitude with
00:53:42
perseverance that they could get through
00:53:46
it and be active participants in the
00:53:50
political system the ratification of the
00:53:55
19th amendment was only the first step
00:53:59
in a long series of battles culminating
00:54:04
in the 1960s with the Civil Rights Act
00:54:08
and the Voting Rights Act but even those
00:54:12
who are not the end who gets to vote in
00:54:15
this country is still being debated a
00:54:19
hundred years later looking back at
00:54:23
history you can see that rights are
00:54:25
given rights are taken away so the fact
00:54:27
that we won this right to vote doesn't
00:54:30
mean it's always there it needs to be
00:54:33
defended it needs to be protected and
00:54:36
that's an important lesson in democracy
00:54:38
it doesn't take away from what was
00:54:41
achieved but it shows that you can't
00:54:44
just pass laws it's not that simple
00:54:48
having the legal right particularly
00:54:51
guaranteed in the Constitution is an
00:54:53
enormous first step that doesn't mean
00:54:55
that the world changed that's just
00:54:58
that's just the tool with which we can
00:55:00
change the world
00:55:01
but we have to continue the processor
00:55:04
Italy Road I think looking at the long
00:55:07
history of women's suffrage what we can
00:55:10
take away is that sometimes change
00:55:13
happens over a very very long period of
00:55:17
time but they do change and the wheel of
00:55:22
progress just keeps right on turning
00:55:26
with a few maybe backward rotations but
00:55:29
it keeps turning the overall story of
00:55:33
the southern suffrage movement is one of
00:55:36
failure but the fact that southern
00:55:39
suffragists managed to get four states
00:55:42
to ratify and that Tennessee ratified
00:55:46
despite all the pressure that was being
00:55:48
applied to get it not to now that's a
00:55:52
story in what sheer persistence can
00:55:55
accomplish in the face of great
00:55:57
obstacles
00:56:02
you
00:56:07
[Music]
00:56:20
you
00:56:23
you
00:56:24
[Music]
00:56:38
you
00:56:42
major funding for by one vote woman's
00:56:45
suffrage in the South is provided by the
00:56:48
Bethany fund Tennessee's Civil War
00:56:52
National Heritage Area the Josie Davis
00:56:56
foundation in memory of Frances bond
00:56:59
Davis the Shane Foundation Cathy and
00:57:04
Martin Brown and the MSB Cockaigne fund
00:57:06
and by Carlene Libas and Harris hastin
00:57:11
additional support provided by First
00:57:14
Tennessee foundation an and Charles Roos
00:57:17
Hanna Paramore Breen Andrea Conti Laurie
00:57:22
gold Eskin and the following
00:57:26
[Music]
00:57:35
and by members of NPT thank you
00:57:42
[Music]