What are the ethical concerns of AI in pornography?

The ethical concerns include the potential for AI to exacerbate issues related to exploitation, privacy invasion, and the spread of harmful content.

How do AI systems like ChatGPT and Bard work with human input?

AI systems are designed to collaborate with humans by learning from human input and feedback, which guides them in understanding what is considered 'good' or valuable.

What is the comparison between AI and the story of Aladdin's genie lamp?

The story of Aladdin's genie lamp is used as an analogy to describe AI as a tool with immense power, providing whatever the user wishes for but also carrying the risk of unintended consequences.

Why is wisdom considered a superior wish in the context of AI's power?

Wisdom is considered superior because it helps manage the immense power of AI responsibly, reducing the risk of negative consequences associated with seeking secondary goods like wealth or power.

What happens when infinite power is applied to secondary desires?

Infinite power applied to secondary desires can lead to significant unintended consequences, amplifying negative side effects and creating imbalances.

How do AI models like Midjourney work?

AI models like Midjourney generate a variety of outputs (such as images), and users refine these results by selecting the most desirable ones, thus training the AI based on their preferences.

What is the role of human judgement in hybrid AI systems?

Human judgement is crucial in hybrid AI systems as it helps guide the AI in making qualitative decisions, leading to more refined and human-aligned outcomes.

Why do secondary goods create problems when coupled with infinite AI power?

When secondary goods are pursued with infinite AI power, it often leads to adverse and unintended consequences due to the misplaced prioritization of desires.

What is the philosophical insight shared in this discussion regarding AI's power?

The discussion centers on the philosophical insight that AI's immense power necessitates careful consideration of what is truly valuable and wise to pursue, akin to making wishes from a genie.

How does this discussion relate to the biblical story of Solomon?

The biblical story of Solomon highlights the wisdom of prioritizing insightful and meaningful desires over superficial ones when granted great power, a lesson applicable to the use of AI.

Money, AI and Infinite Power I Jordan Peterson I Jonathan Pageau

00:03:44

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvUkRAGw_To

Summary

TLDRThe speaker reflects on the implications of artificial intelligence, particularly in pornography, raising concerns about its potential impact. The discussion transitions to how AI systems like ChatGPT and Bard function through human guidance, comparing AI's capabilities to that of Aladdin's genie lamp, emphasizing caution in the desires it fulfills due to potential unforeseen consequences. This conversation further touches on the philosophy of wish-fulfillment stories, warning that seeking secondary goods, like wealth, with immense power from AI can lead to detrimental side effects. The speaker suggests that wisdom is the most appropriate desire when dealing with substantial power, drawing parallels to biblical stories such as Solomon's wish for wisdom. Human judgement is seen as essential in AI's hybrid systems to guide AI towards beneficial and ethical outcomes.

Takeaways

🤖 AI's impact on sensitive industries like pornography requires scrutiny.
🧠 Human input is critical in guiding AI's 'intelligence'.
🪔 AI resembles Aladdin's lamp, offering power but requiring wise wishes.
🎓 Wisdom should be prioritized over secondary desires with AI.
⚠️ Infinite power applied to superficial desires brings risks.
🎨 Models like Midjourney rely on user input for refinement.
🕹️ Hybrid AI systems blend human judgement with machine processing.
💡 Pursuing secondary goods with infinite AI power is risky.
📜 Historical analogies like Solomon's story teach AI use ethics.
🔍 AI ethics demand reflection on what is valuable to wish for.

Timeline

00:00:00 - 00:03:44
The speaker is pondering the application of AI in domains like pornography, suggesting it's a troubling thought. They've experimented with AI models like Chat GPT and Bard, highlighting a discussion on whether Bard believes in God. The speaker recalls encouraging Bard to consider questions from a machine's perspective, highlighting Bard's reasoned response. The conversation pivots to how AI's 'intelligence' is shaped by human input, drawing parallels to the story of Aladdin's Genie—a representation of technology's power requiring careful wish choices. The speaker further discusses the implications and potential risks of infusing desires with absolute power, likening it to moral narratives and wisdom found in stories like that of Solomon from the Bible, who famously prioritized wisdom over material gains. Aligning desires properly within limits is emphasized, warning against disproportionate power pursuit.

Mind Map

Frequently Asked Question

What are the ethical concerns of AI in pornography?
The ethical concerns include the potential for AI to exacerbate issues related to exploitation, privacy invasion, and the spread of harmful content.
How do AI systems like ChatGPT and Bard work with human input?
AI systems are designed to collaborate with humans by learning from human input and feedback, which guides them in understanding what is considered 'good' or valuable.
What is the comparison between AI and the story of Aladdin's genie lamp?
The story of Aladdin's genie lamp is used as an analogy to describe AI as a tool with immense power, providing whatever the user wishes for but also carrying the risk of unintended consequences.
Why is wisdom considered a superior wish in the context of AI's power?
Wisdom is considered superior because it helps manage the immense power of AI responsibly, reducing the risk of negative consequences associated with seeking secondary goods like wealth or power.
What happens when infinite power is applied to secondary desires?
Infinite power applied to secondary desires can lead to significant unintended consequences, amplifying negative side effects and creating imbalances.
How do AI models like Midjourney work?
AI models like Midjourney generate a variety of outputs (such as images), and users refine these results by selecting the most desirable ones, thus training the AI based on their preferences.
What is the role of human judgement in hybrid AI systems?
Human judgement is crucial in hybrid AI systems as it helps guide the AI in making qualitative decisions, leading to more refined and human-aligned outcomes.
Why do secondary goods create problems when coupled with infinite AI power?
When secondary goods are pursued with infinite AI power, it often leads to adverse and unintended consequences due to the misplaced prioritization of desires.
What is the philosophical insight shared in this discussion regarding AI's power?
The discussion centers on the philosophical insight that AI's immense power necessitates careful consideration of what is truly valuable and wise to pursue, akin to making wishes from a genie.
How does this discussion relate to the biblical story of Solomon?
The biblical story of Solomon highlights the wisdom of prioritizing insightful and meaningful desires over superficial ones when granted great power, a lesson applicable to the use of AI.

View more video summaries

Get instant access to free YouTube video summaries powered by AI!

Subtitles

Auto Scroll:

00:00:00
I've been been thinking about about the
00:00:03
the application of AI on the pornography
00:00:05
front I mean that's that's a terrible
00:00:08
terrible thing to contemplate because
00:00:10
it's certainly the case already I I've
00:00:12
used chat GPT a lot in the last month
00:00:16
and it's and Bard too they're very
00:00:18
interesting to toy with I asked Bard if
00:00:20
it believed in God by the way that was
00:00:22
extremely interesting first of all said
00:00:24
it was just a large language model and
00:00:26
couldn't answer such questions and so I
00:00:27
said well pretend that you were a
00:00:29
machine that could answer such questions
00:00:31
how would you answer and it gave quite
00:00:33
an elaborate reason for why it believed
00:00:35
in God now I should have asked it
00:00:38
perhaps why it didn't believe in God you
00:00:41
know I mean just to balance it out but
00:00:43
um anyways it was extremely interesting
00:00:46
to watch one of the ways I've been
00:00:47
thinking about AI I did a video on that
00:00:49
just recently is is actually the story
00:00:51
of Aladdin or the story of the Genies
00:00:53
lamb yeah that seems to be in my my
00:00:56
because I've been thinking a lot about
00:00:58
we talk about artificial intelligence
00:00:59
and and we've been talking about this we
00:01:01
talked about with Jim Keller you know
00:01:03
and one of the points I was trying to
00:01:04
make was that the intelligence doesn't
00:01:06
seem to come from the machine the
00:01:07
intelligence comes from us that is the
00:01:09
AIS now are hybrid AI right they get
00:01:12
qualitative judgment from Human people
00:01:16
human people tell the AI what's good and
00:01:18
then the AI based on that will then
00:01:20
continue its work but it's always propos
00:01:23
right it's generating variability and
00:01:25
then someone selects and says that one
00:01:28
that one right that's what happens in
00:01:29
mid Journey too you know mid Journey you
00:01:31
have a refining process where you it it
00:01:34
generates a bunch of images and then you
00:01:36
say you tell it that one and so you're
00:01:37
training the AI as you're using it uh
00:01:40
and so that's what the genie lamp is
00:01:42
right the genie lamp is just the power
00:01:43
of Technology you know it's it's
00:01:46
artificial light you know it's a it's
00:01:47
light it's it's a machine that makes you
00:01:49
have light in the dark when you can't
00:01:52
usually when there's no light of the Sun
00:01:54
so it's like portable light you could
00:01:55
say uh and so it is it's just power and
00:01:59
all what it's asking for is what do you
00:02:01
want yeah and then what it does is it
00:02:04
gives you what you want with infinite
00:02:06
power yeah and so and that's the that's
00:02:09
what's amazing about that story yes so
00:02:11
be careful what you want which is always
00:02:13
the variant of the of the three wishes
00:02:15
story that's right it's always about
00:02:16
that and so but you can understand it
00:02:18
like technically in the sense that well
00:02:20
there's a version of that story in the
00:02:22
Bible where God asks Solomon one wish
00:02:26
right what do you give you can have one
00:02:28
wish and then Solomon answer properly
00:02:30
Solomon says I want wisdom right right
00:02:33
and so the the problem is that if you
00:02:35
ask for secondary Goods right if you ask
00:02:38
for a bunch of money if you ask for a
00:02:39
bunch of women or you ask for secondary
00:02:41
goods and you put infinite power you
00:02:43
made it with a dwarf but you put
00:02:45
infinite power behind that wish then all
00:02:48
the side effects of the wish will
00:02:50
manifest itself right and that's just
00:02:53
it's like an unbalance of the
00:02:54
relationship of how much power you put
00:02:56
towards a certain goal and so the only
00:02:59
thing that would would would would
00:03:00
handle well you know there's a there's a
00:03:02
definition of God lurking in there I
00:03:04
would say you know is that you know you
00:03:07
just talked about the pathologies that
00:03:09
will inevitably emerge if you wish for
00:03:11
the wrong thing which is the same thing
00:03:13
as celebrating a less of deity or with
00:03:16
too much power because you're allowed to
00:03:18
wish for a sandwich right if I'm hungry
00:03:20
and I wish for a sandwich that's fine
00:03:22
but the problem is like if I wish for a
00:03:24
sandwich with like infinite power behind
00:03:27
behind me and I'm and I'm like I'm going
00:03:30
into this infinite power to get this
00:03:32
secondary good like it's okay to wish
00:03:34
for to have money but if you if you put
00:03:36
all the resources of everything into get
00:03:39
money me it's okay to wish for that if
00:03:40
it's in its proper place in the yeah
00:03:43
that's the way to see it yeah