00:00:00
foreign
00:00:03
[Music]
00:00:09
systems insights video series I'm Eric
00:00:11
stoffel president of stoffel systems
00:00:14
today's topic is pre-charge as used in a
00:00:17
Lithium-Ion battery pack
00:00:22
it is very important to have a pre-chart
00:00:24
circuit
00:00:25
in any high voltage battery pack
00:00:29
it greatly increases the safety of the
00:00:31
battery pack and the longevity of the
00:00:33
battery and the external components
00:00:35
connected to the battery let me show you
00:00:37
how
00:00:39
so a simplified schematic of a high
00:00:42
voltage lithium-ion battery pack
00:00:45
consists of a stack of cells
00:00:49
a main disconnect switch
00:00:52
and external terminals
00:00:56
where does the pre-chart circuit live
00:00:58
it lives in parallel with the main
00:01:01
disconnect switch
00:01:03
fundamentally
00:01:05
it consists of
00:01:07
a smaller disconnect switch
00:01:10
and a resistor
00:01:13
sometimes it fuse as well but I have
00:01:15
omitted that for Simplicity
00:01:18
so why is a pre-charge circuit necessary
00:01:20
in the first place
00:01:22
well typically
00:01:24
it's because the external system
00:01:26
connected to a Lithium-Ion battery pack
00:01:30
has a rather large or significant
00:01:33
capacitance
00:01:34
C
00:01:36
this can be a three-phase motor inverter
00:01:38
this can be a grid tie system for
00:01:42
charging a discharging there's a variety
00:01:44
of Power Electronics and typically they
00:01:46
have a filter capacitance for their high
00:01:48
frequency switching
00:01:50
and this capacitance makes it absolutely
00:01:53
necessary to have a pre-chart circuit
00:01:55
so what let's start with the case if we
00:01:57
did not have a pre-chart circuit what
00:01:59
would occur
00:02:01
well when the battery
00:02:04
is off
00:02:06
all the switches are open and say that
00:02:08
we're sitting at a voltage of 400 volts
00:02:12
and the system has been off for a while
00:02:14
so the voltage of the capacitor is zero
00:02:17
volts
00:02:18
so effectively in this situation there
00:02:22
are 400 volts
00:02:23
across this disconnect switch
00:02:27
and if you did not have a pre-charge
00:02:29
system
00:02:30
and you close this switch in this
00:02:32
condition
00:02:33
you would have a very large what's
00:02:35
called inrush current
00:02:37
because the fully charged battery would
00:02:40
be discharging into
00:02:42
the fully discharged capacitor
00:02:45
and you can have very very high levels
00:02:47
of current with this in Rush upwards of
00:02:49
thousands of amps
00:02:51
and that can lead to all sorts of
00:02:53
problems including
00:02:55
sparking type failures for the main
00:02:57
contactor here
00:02:59
so it could weld shut for example
00:03:02
or it could lead to excess heating or
00:03:04
damage to the capacitor Bank itself
00:03:08
so we want to avoid all that
00:03:10
and the pre-charge circuit is the best
00:03:12
way to do that
00:03:13
so let's look at the alternative case
00:03:15
where now we have a pre-chart circuit
00:03:17
that helps us avoid this inrush current
00:03:20
how does that work
00:03:22
well instead of just closing this main
00:03:24
disconnect contactor right away what we
00:03:28
do is first close this pre-charge switch
00:03:30
so that the current flow goes through
00:03:33
the battery
00:03:34
cross the switch through the resistor
00:03:37
and then to the capacitor
00:03:39
so now instead of having a very very
00:03:42
large amount of current flowing our
00:03:44
current is limited by the resistance of
00:03:45
this resistor
00:03:47
so how does that work
00:03:53
so let's give an example of the case
00:03:56
where we have a battery voltage
00:04:00
of 400 volts
00:04:02
and a resistor
00:04:05
of a thousand ohms foreign
00:04:09
typical values you might see in a
00:04:12
pre-chart system
00:04:13
remember the amount of current flowing
00:04:16
through a circuit
00:04:17
is the voltage divided by
00:04:20
the resistance
00:04:22
Ohm's law
00:04:23
so in this case we would have 400 volts
00:04:27
divided by
00:04:29
1000 ohms
00:04:32
so we would have 400 milliamps
00:04:36
of current flow
00:04:39
that is a far more gentle situation than
00:04:43
thousands of amps in an uncontrolled
00:04:45
inrush
00:04:46
so already we're doing well
00:04:49
but what does it look like after we
00:04:51
close that switch what happens then
00:04:54
[Music]
00:04:55
so if we go on over here and we plot
00:05:00
the voltage
00:05:02
of the capacitor
00:05:05
I'll use blue for this
00:05:10
eventually
00:05:11
we want to charge it up to the same
00:05:13
battery voltage so that we have no
00:05:16
current flow through this circuit
00:05:19
and the way that works
00:05:20
is that
00:05:22
T equals zero
00:05:24
we close the pre-charge circuit switch
00:05:27
and we start charging the capacitor
00:05:30
and it follows an RC time constant
00:05:33
resistor capacitor time constant
00:05:36
until it gets to a close enough bound
00:05:38
with the battery voltage that we can now
00:05:41
close the main disconnect relay or
00:05:45
contactor and have minimal inrush
00:05:48
current and minimal sparking and minimal
00:05:50
thermal and high current flow damage
00:05:53
issues that we mentioned before
00:05:56
so how long does this curve need to
00:06:00
charge how long does this capacitor need
00:06:02
to charge for us to feel comfortable
00:06:04
closing the main contactor switch
00:06:07
while RC
00:06:09
curves
00:06:11
are dictated by their time constants or
00:06:14
Tau in a time constant is determined by
00:06:20
the resistance times the capacitance so
00:06:23
this is called an RC time constant
00:06:26
one towel or one time constant is
00:06:30
approximately 63 percent of the battery
00:06:33
voltage two time constants is
00:06:35
approximately 87 and then three time
00:06:39
constants is approximately 95 and on and
00:06:42
on and on it gets closer asymptotically
00:06:44
to the battery voltage
00:06:46
so using our example again
00:06:49
say that we have a capacitance
00:06:55
of 400
00:06:57
microfarads
00:06:59
this is a fairly typical capacitance you
00:07:01
might see an electric vehicle inverter
00:07:04
so if we have a thousand Ohm resistor
00:07:07
and 400 microfarads of capacitance
00:07:11
so we'll multiply
00:07:13
400 microfarads
00:07:15
times 1000 ohms
00:07:21
what is the time for that
00:07:23
well a thousand times 400 micro
00:07:26
that is 400 milliseconds or four tenths
00:07:29
of a second
00:07:31
so in this situation
00:07:33
one time constant of this pre-charged
00:07:36
circuit
00:07:38
would be 400 milliseconds two time
00:07:40
constants would be 800 milliseconds and
00:07:42
three time constants would be 1200
00:07:44
milliseconds or 1.2 seconds
00:07:47
so in this situation we would expect
00:07:50
that in 1.2 seconds our voltage would be
00:07:54
within five percent of the battery
00:07:57
voltage so in this case 95 percent of
00:08:00
the total battery voltage
00:08:03
and generally speaking that is
00:08:04
considered enough to close the main
00:08:08
contactor for a system
00:08:10
some systems you might want to select
00:08:12
the Threshold at 90 percent or 97
00:08:14
percent there's some Advanced
00:08:16
calculations there but generally
00:08:17
speaking three time constants or 95
00:08:19
percent is considered sufficient to
00:08:22
close your main switch
00:08:25
okay
00:08:27
so now that we've determined all this
00:08:30
we have selected a resistor of a
00:08:33
thousand ohms because of this time as
00:08:36
you can imagine if we want the
00:08:38
pre-charge time to be reduced we have to
00:08:40
select a smaller resistance value so for
00:08:43
example if we wanted to select 500 ohms
00:08:45
instead of a thousand ohms that would
00:08:47
take our time constant from 400
00:08:50
milliseconds to 200 milliseconds
00:08:53
and likewise if we have an application
00:08:55
that could accommodate a larger
00:08:56
pre-charge time we could choose a higher
00:08:58
resistance value
00:08:59
now you might ask why not just choose a
00:09:02
very small resistance value
00:09:03
well the challenge is the thermal
00:09:06
limitation
00:09:08
so the heat generated in a resistor or
00:09:12
power dissipation of that resistor
00:09:15
is calculated by V squared over r
00:09:19
so if we have a 400 volt battery system
00:09:24
and a thousand Ohm resistor
00:09:26
the amount of power dissipation we would
00:09:29
see at the beginning
00:09:31
of this pre-charge cycle
00:09:33
would be 400 volts
00:09:37
squared
00:09:39
over
00:09:41
1000 ohms
00:09:44
and that would be equal to
00:09:47
160 Watts
00:09:49
now that is a very
00:09:52
high power dissipation
00:09:54
through a resistor not just the normal
00:09:56
board Mount resistor would work for this
00:09:59
so best practices to use a dedicated
00:10:01
pre-charge rated or high pulse rated
00:10:04
resistor or a chassis Mount resistor
00:10:07
that can have significant overage power
00:10:09
dissipation without being damaged
00:10:12
now the good news is the heat generated
00:10:15
as you can imagine is only maximized at
00:10:18
this very first point as the voltage
00:10:20
Delta between
00:10:24
the battery and the capacitor
00:10:27
decreases so does your current flow and
00:10:31
so does your heat generation
00:10:33
so if I were to plot current flow in
00:10:36
this color
00:10:37
we would see a pulse of current flow
00:10:38
here
00:10:40
and then it would decay
00:10:42
according to a very similar RC curve
00:10:44
down to essentially zero
00:10:49
so the heat generation is the multiplied
00:10:51
amount by the voltage Delta and the
00:10:55
amount of current flow
00:10:57
so
00:10:59
a couple other things to think about
00:11:00
with pre-charged design
00:11:03
you want to enable
00:11:05
some checking in a fault system of your
00:11:07
BMS or battery management system to
00:11:10
ensure that everything's working as
00:11:11
expected
00:11:12
so one case to consider
00:11:15
is the case where there is now actually
00:11:19
a short circuit
00:11:22
across this capacitor or some sort of
00:11:24
other fault with this external system
00:11:27
this actually can be a real occurrence
00:11:30
if the polarity of the system is flipped
00:11:32
so for example if someone accidentally
00:11:34
connects the negative terminal to the
00:11:36
positive terminal and vice versa
00:11:38
then you can essentially have a short
00:11:40
circuit from positive to negative
00:11:42
and what's helpful about a pre-chart
00:11:44
circuit is it will actually allow you to
00:11:46
detect that when properly coupled with a
00:11:48
BMS you can actually raise a fault flag
00:11:50
to indicate that something's wrong like
00:11:52
that so for example if in this scenario
00:11:56
we had a short circuit instead of the
00:12:00
current flow going like this and the
00:12:01
voltage going Rising like this you would
00:12:04
expect to see a current flow staying
00:12:07
flat
00:12:08
and then your voltage level
00:12:11
would also stay flat or relatively flat
00:12:15
and that would indicate to the BMS that
00:12:17
something's wrong because the voltage is
00:12:19
not rising in the manner that's expected
00:12:23
and that alone can yield numerous safety
00:12:25
benefits because now the battery pack
00:12:28
will not close its main High current
00:12:30
capable switch
00:12:31
unless it has assessed that the output
00:12:35
capacitor or the capacitor connected to
00:12:38
the output of the battery pack is rising
00:12:40
at the level expected
00:12:42
so you can detect short circuits you can
00:12:45
also detect situations where the
00:12:46
capacitance is significantly different
00:12:48
than you would expect
00:12:50
so you can have what's called a
00:12:51
pre-charged timeout fault so that if
00:12:54
this does not occur in the expected 1.2
00:12:56
seconds perhaps if it takes more than
00:12:58
two seconds to get above 95 percent the
00:13:01
BMS would raise a fault flag and say
00:13:03
something's wrong with the system
00:13:05
there are a number of advanced topics
00:13:07
with the pre-charge system but these are
00:13:09
the basics to consider when reviewing a
00:13:11
pre-charged design
00:13:13
thanks for watching see you next time
00:13:17
[Music]
00:13:19
thank you
00:13:20
[Music]