Social-Emotional Learning (SEL) | James Lindsay
Summary
TLDRThe video discusses transformative social emotional learning (SEL) as a tool for thought reform and societal change. The speaker highlights that SEL has been infused into education systems worldwide, emphasizing its use beyond schools to influence society at large. Driven by organizations like the World Economic Forum and the United Nations, SEL aims to promote social equity, sustainability, and inclusivity, aligning with global agendas such as ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) and sustainable development goals. Criticism centers on SEL’s role in indoctrinating students by embedding specific ideological frameworks into curricula, data mining to track and influence students' emotional and psychological states, and manipulating education to construct a new world order. Historical links to Marxist and Paulo Freire’s educational theories are noted, especially the goal of raising students' critical consciousness. The video underscores SEL's contentious nature, urging actions to mitigate its pervasive influence in education and societal structures.
Takeaways
- 🎓 SEL is used for thought reform, embedding ideological agendas in education.
- 🌍 Driven by global entities, SEL supports restructuring society for inclusivity and sustainability.
- 📊 Utilizes data mining to manage emotional, psychological states, influencing future behaviors.
- 📚 Transforms traditional education, instilling new social norms and values.
- 🏛️ SEL implementation aligns with global agendas like ESG and sustainable development goals.
- 🧠 Tied to Marxist theories, particularly Paulo Freire's concept of conscientization.
- 🚦 Advocates for policy reform to restrict its influence, focusing on genuine education.
- 🔍 Criticism includes indoctrination and misuse of student data for social credit systems.
- ⬆️ Prepares students to accept and thrive in a new societal model.
- ⚖️ Suggestions to legislate against data mining and psychological manipulation in schools.
Timeline
- 00:00:00 - 00:05:00
The video discusses the integration of social emotional learning (SEL) into education as a tool for thought reform, posing it as part of a larger agenda by significant entities like the World Economic Forum and the United Nations to transform society. SEL is portrayed as more than just an educational approach; it's a comprehensive strategy being implemented globally in collaboration with cultural teaching and envisaged as a system transformation, not limited to schools but infusing all societal aspects.
- 00:05:00 - 00:10:00
The video emphasizes that SEL is an agenda to install a new global system, mentioning organizations like the UN and the World Economic Forum as key proponents. It suggests that raising a generation alongside the creation of a new world order, supported by entities like Bill Gates, is imperative for a smooth societal transition, equating these changes with historic revolutionary attempts. There's a perceived urgency as these changes have gained visibility over the last two years, although they have been in motion for much longer.
- 00:10:00 - 00:15:00
Highlighting a lack of necessity to conform to the indoctrination, the speaker expresses discontent about current societal directions like SEL, suggesting they divert true educational intent. There's skepticism about emotional IQ's existence and a belief that SEL networks are intended for data mining children's social interactions to build a social credit world. SEL's broader selling point, including handling emotions in a complex world, is criticized as a guise for ulterior motives.
- 00:15:00 - 00:20:00
Paulo Freire's influence on education and faith is discussed, emphasizing churches' roles and a movement toward a prophetic church that predicts a new world. The video stresses Freire's alignment of liberation with education transformation, indicating a need for societal overhaul. It suggests the current educational transformations cannot be realized within existing systems and critiques societal underestimations of elite power, positioning SEL's rise as part of this transformative strategy.
- 00:20:00 - 00:25:00
The transformative agenda behind SEL, particularly a Marxist association, is linked to educational processes. The SEL, pushed by groups like Castle, aims at transforming students' social and emotional skills, masking it under principles like equity. The speaker stresses the end goal is societal restructuring into an envisioned ideal economy, powered by data from educational environments, which isn't merely an update of educational tools but a radical change.
- 00:25:00 - 00:30:00
SEL is argued to not be just educational modernization, but a fundamental societal change into a new economy, potentially unsustainable under laws like thermodynamics. The message is that current global entities want a society unaware of any economic model outside this 'circular economy.' The video suggests imposing SEL everywhere is reminiscent of a twisted educational version of dystopian control that shapes youth into fitting predetermined societal roles.
- 00:30:00 - 00:35:00
World economic challenges and sustainability fears play into SEL's narrative. Historical environmental concerns from figures like Marcuse resonate with current elite visions, pushing for less haphazard societal advancements to prevent system failures. Youth are taught to demand sustainable worlds, influenced by stakeholders managing these educational shifts. The tone suggests these fears are manipulated for broader controls over societal growth.
- 00:35:00 - 00:40:00
The video covers extensive criticisms from various ends, including corporate controls over psychological education data, and concerns about emotional intervention applications. Critics argue SEL is integral to market predictions, heavily influenced and sponsored by large global foundations. These interventions are presented as strategic, steering societal behaviors in directions aligning with broader economic goals such as controlled markets and populations.
- 00:40:00 - 00:45:00
Surveillance and data gathering through SEL is likened to modern tech inception into personal domains, drawing parallels with manipulations echoed during major historical education changes. The conversation extends to implications of surveillance through educational contexts, revealing how wearable technology engagement facilitates economic interests. Concerns include AI-driven educational corrections driven by real-time emotional states, under global elite narratives.
- 00:45:00 - 00:50:00
The implementation of SEL is contextualized within World Economic Forum's visions, exploring AI and technology's supporting roles in SEL's future. These strategies reflect a vision where education isn't confined to outdated methods but adapted to fit specific social units. Narratives are entwined with broader socio-political aspirations, ensuring education aligns with environments prioritizing sustainable operations, promoting inclusion over traditional educational focal points.
- 00:50:00 - 00:55:00
Some critical theorists point out SEL intertwines with political and economic spheres, suggesting inherent flaws in grounding children’s education on overt economic benefits while missing potential threats of corporate overreach. The focus on Fortune 500-like investors brings in new complexities, raising ideological and practical concerns over transforming educational landscapes to fit economic and political interests.
- 00:55:00 - 01:00:00
Further critiquing SEL's grand designs, educational inclusivity is questioned when schooling blends into life-management tools driven by constant interaction with data-monitoring technologies. The speaker criticizes organizations like World Economic Forum for orchestrating educational tools aligned with wider world agendas, arguing that these mechanisms drift far from actual educational objectives.
- 01:00:00 - 01:05:00
Continued push for a new educational environment involves piloting global strategies in national settings, examining broader impacts on curriculum changes. While organizations may see themselves as innovators, the discussion reveals an undiscussed convergence of data usage and perpetual monitoring within educational systems. The challenge lies in recognizing the educational aspects of SEL versus manipulations for power retention by influential bodies.
- 01:05:00 - 01:10:00
Highlighting Marxist philosophies underpinning some SEL frameworks, it’s purported the agenda drives towards complete institutional shifts rather than democratized education for society. Historical narratives which envelop educational models in transformative languages risk disguising broader societal restructuring agendas. Such shifts align with Marxist theories, connecting SEL with thought reform, further embedding society into frameworks that push regulated emotional and social conditioning.
- 01:10:00 - 01:15:00
SEL's transformation of societal norms isn't limited to educational transformations but extends to preparative cultural shifts that redefine values. The World Economic Forum's focus transcends educational goals, fostering an allegiance to stakeholder sentiments over autonomous individual educational pursuits. The focus on emotional and social skill development aligns with nefarious intents to control broader societal movements, presenting values for manipulated consent over traditional autonomy.
- 01:15:00 - 01:20:00
The video continues to discuss how SEL's foundation and Castle's emergence align with spiritual paradigms that transitioned into educational mainstream. SEL is tied to intricacies within moral and social training programs, growing from targeted interventions to broad societal implementations. The speaker connects macro agendas with education's shifting focus, warning about programs like these being packaged subtly under diverse educational reforms.
- 01:20:00 - 01:25:00
SEL's evolution, pivoting to manipulative tactics and societal roles, shifts focus from core education responsibilities. The speaker stresses coercive pressures driving educational adherence to standards that aren't just pedagogical but ideological. Manipulated inclusivity becomes a concern, rationalized under wider international benchmarks by major educational institutions, straying from traditional educational mandates.
- 01:25:00 - 01:30:00
Strong emphasis is placed on SEL's divergence from personal responsibility lessons to societal indoctrination tools, broadening through academic ecosystems. There's a warning against entire educational paradigms being swayed by scripted narratives that prioritize alignment with globalist agendas over individual growth. Contrasting SEL forms show potential for good when limited but highlight manipulations where educational motives shift towards transformative outcomes.
- 01:30:00 - 01:52:13
Concluding the discussion, the video asserts a need for urgent reevaluation of educational paradigms influenced by vested global entities. Resisting SEL's data mining, psychological manipulation, and potential indoctrination, the speaker urges for educational resets prioritizing privacy, authentic human development, and local responsiveness over top-down directives guided by unaccountable global organizations.
Mind Map
Video Q&A
What is transformative social emotional learning?
Transformative social emotional learning (SEL) is a model aimed at developing students' social and emotional skills while promoting critical consciousness and societal change. It is often linked to raising awareness of systemic inequalities.
Who are the main proponents of the transformative SEL agenda?
The World Economic Forum and the United Nations are mentioned as major proponents, along with organizations such as the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative.
What does the speaker mean by 'thought reform'?
Thought reform refers to indoctrinating students with specific ideological views through educational programs like SEL, reshaping their beliefs and attitudes towards social and emotional issues.
How is SEL implemented in education systems?
SEL can be integrated individually, through separate curricula, or systemically across all subjects in a school. Systemic implementation tends to embed SEL principles into all educational content.
Why is SEL considered controversial by the speaker?
The speaker argues that SEL is used to promote a specific ideological agenda, misuses data for social credit systems, and constitutes indoctrination rather than genuine education.
What historical figure's theories are linked to SEL?
Paulo Freire's theories, specifically focusing on conscientization or thought reform, are linked to the transformative SEL agenda.
How does SEL relate to economic and social models?
SEL is seen as a tool to foster a circular economy and social equality, supporting a larger agenda to reshape societal structures towards a more sustainable and inclusive model.
What is the connection between SEL and data mining?
SEL uses extensive data mining to track students' psychological and emotional states, which can be exploited for creating social credit systems and targeted economic predictions.
How does SEL aim to affect future generations?
SEL is designed to shape students' mindsets to accept and thrive in a newly structured societal model, preparing them to demand sustainability and inclusivity.
What are the suggested actions against SEL?
Reforming education policies to ban data mining, challenging SEL’s legitimacy in courts, and pushing for legislative changes to limit such educational reforms are suggested actions.
View more video summaries
- 00:00:00now we're going to talk about the
- 00:00:03transformative social emotional learning
- 00:00:05and the social emotional learning
- 00:00:06environment the transformation and fact
- 00:00:08of social emotional learning and this
- 00:00:11General subject so this is in the broad
- 00:00:13scope of the themes of the lectures
- 00:00:15following kind of a continuous storyline
- 00:00:17we've had the theft of Education to
- 00:00:19replace it with a Marxist religious
- 00:00:21revival that overcomes the problem of
- 00:00:22reproduction it marks this religious
- 00:00:24revival focuses on constantization or
- 00:00:27thought reform which can be summarized
- 00:00:29as turning schools into groomer schools
- 00:00:32um which is uh to to like I said to
- 00:00:34create the process of thought reform and
- 00:00:36now we have to answer the question of
- 00:00:37why and how specifically are they
- 00:00:41um transforming education into social
- 00:00:43emotional learning what is the education
- 00:00:45of the future supposed to look like
- 00:00:47according to these people and so as a
- 00:00:50little through line continuing the story
- 00:00:52the primary tool for the consientization
- 00:00:55or the thought reform process that we
- 00:00:57just discussed is a program generally
- 00:00:59known as social emotional learning
- 00:01:02now I've mentioned lots of things
- 00:01:04culturally relevant teaching and so on
- 00:01:06that are also part and parcel with us
- 00:01:08with social emotional learning is the
- 00:01:10primary vehicle and as you will come to
- 00:01:12understand it is in fact being infused
- 00:01:14into literally everything it will not
- 00:01:16merely be in the schools it's meant to
- 00:01:18be everywhere in everything
- 00:01:21so by learning what social emotional
- 00:01:23learning is and who's pushing it
- 00:01:26what huge entities are pushing it we can
- 00:01:29learn that social emotional learning
- 00:01:31isn't just a vehicle for consientization
- 00:01:33in some small scale way
- 00:01:36it is in fact the key operating
- 00:01:40tool to achieve an agenda to install a
- 00:01:45completely new system in the world from
- 00:01:48top down bottom up and inside out all at
- 00:01:50once
- 00:01:52certain entities are pushing this agenda
- 00:01:55the world economic form of the United
- 00:01:57Nations are two that are really worth
- 00:01:59mentioning as far as you know Foundation
- 00:02:01type things go and they have figured out
- 00:02:04that to attempt a full-blown Revolution
- 00:02:07throughout the west or in accordance
- 00:02:10with the whole world it will require
- 00:02:12simultaneously building the new world in
- 00:02:15an economic and social model while
- 00:02:17raising the generation to fill it that
- 00:02:19has to occur at the same time and so
- 00:02:22then you unleash the new generation into
- 00:02:24the new world and everything transitions
- 00:02:26say through a great reset seamlessly the
- 00:02:30implementation of this two-pronged
- 00:02:32agenda then
- 00:02:33one from the top down one from the
- 00:02:35bottom up is the outstanding fact of the
- 00:02:38past 30 years of Our Lives that we've
- 00:02:40only become really aware of in maybe the
- 00:02:42last two years and so by the way that is
- 00:02:44a message of Hope
- 00:02:46this is a 50 plus year plan 30 years
- 00:02:49kind of in direct implementation and in
- 00:02:52two years we've already made it
- 00:02:53seemingly very untenable a very large
- 00:02:57number of people are aware of it a very
- 00:02:58large number of people are aware that
- 00:03:00it's not just something that's happening
- 00:03:02I keep having these conversations on
- 00:03:04flights where I'll end up sitting next
- 00:03:07to some person some business person and
- 00:03:09they'll tell me something like well
- 00:03:12looks like they're just going to get rid
- 00:03:14of cars I guess we're just going to have
- 00:03:15to that's just what we're gonna have to
- 00:03:17do now we're just gonna have to go along
- 00:03:18with it as though it's just like
- 00:03:20something we're fated to have to accept
- 00:03:21because they're doing it that's just
- 00:03:23what looks like we're just going to
- 00:03:24transition all to electric cars we just
- 00:03:26that's just what it is now that's just
- 00:03:28what we have to do that's just how it is
- 00:03:29cars all have some push button ignition
- 00:03:31with a microchip that's just how it was
- 00:03:34just that's just what we have to do we
- 00:03:35just have to adapt if there's no
- 00:03:36microchips we don't have any new cars
- 00:03:38looks like we're just going to have
- 00:03:39social emotional learning in the schools
- 00:03:40we're just going to go along with this
- 00:03:41and this is the big point you don't have
- 00:03:43to just go along with this
- 00:03:45you do not have to go along with the
- 00:03:47indoctrination or programming of your
- 00:03:49children you do not have to go along
- 00:03:51with the data mining of your children so
- 00:03:54that they can build out a social Credit
- 00:03:56World you don't have to go along with a
- 00:03:59social emotional learning program that
- 00:04:01hijacks and steals away from them
- 00:04:03genuine education or replaces it with
- 00:04:05something whether educating them or
- 00:04:08training them in Social and emotional
- 00:04:09literacy and so-called emotional IQ
- 00:04:12which we now have good reasons to
- 00:04:15believe doesn't even exist and probably
- 00:04:16has more to do with your linguistic
- 00:04:19capacity around emotional words that you
- 00:04:22can understand the fine-graded meanings
- 00:04:24between different emotionally sounding
- 00:04:26words like anger and rage
- 00:04:28as opposed to having some intuitive
- 00:04:30sense of what your emotions are or some
- 00:04:32maturity about your emotions
- 00:04:35of course social emotional learning is
- 00:04:37sold with a very pleasant
- 00:04:39um kind of Bill it's sold to us under
- 00:04:41the guys that well we're going to teach
- 00:04:42kids to navigate their social situations
- 00:04:44in a complex World we're going to teach
- 00:04:45them to manage their emotions we're
- 00:04:47going to teach them to manage the
- 00:04:48stresses that come with their academic
- 00:04:50experience with their life experience
- 00:04:51we're going to teach them to manage
- 00:04:53their interactions with one another so
- 00:04:55that they grow up more mature more
- 00:04:56accepting more inclusive more blah blah
- 00:04:58blah blah and of course if it were only
- 00:05:01that we might have reason to raise an
- 00:05:03eyebrow and say uh okay maybe that's not
- 00:05:05your job
- 00:05:07but it's not only that so we have
- 00:05:10reasons to scream you have to stop or
- 00:05:12we're going to put you in prison
- 00:05:15so as a reminder of what we're dealing
- 00:05:17with let's go back to Paulo Friday who
- 00:05:19is our Anchor Point for this thing this
- 00:05:22is from the 10th chapter of the politics
- 00:05:24of Education I just want to remind you
- 00:05:25of something I said earlier also
- 00:05:27at this point what's happening I said
- 00:05:29this in the Q a session I'd like to say
- 00:05:31it again what's happening in education
- 00:05:33is happening in parallel in faith in the
- 00:05:35churches both are seen as avenues for
- 00:05:38values education and I'm bringing up
- 00:05:39this point because I mentioned this is
- 00:05:41the 10th chapter of politics of
- 00:05:42education and if you bother to read that
- 00:05:44book or just skip to the 10th chapter
- 00:05:46and read that book you'll find out that
- 00:05:48the 10th chapter of that book talks
- 00:05:49about education for a couple of pages
- 00:05:51and after that it's literally just about
- 00:05:53the role of the church this is the
- 00:05:54education book that led to Paulo
- 00:05:56Ferrari's work being accepted throughout
- 00:05:58American schools and the 10th chapter is
- 00:06:00dedicated to Paula Ferrari getting on a
- 00:06:02soapbox and telling churches how they
- 00:06:03should organize themselves and there are
- 00:06:05three options for how churches can be
- 00:06:07that's not what this quote is about this
- 00:06:08is an aside they can be the traditional
- 00:06:11or reactionary Church which he's very
- 00:06:13against they can be the modernizing
- 00:06:15church just like a modernizing school
- 00:06:17that exchanges blackboards for
- 00:06:18projectors and achieves nothing
- 00:06:21or they can be the prophetic church that
- 00:06:24that makes a prophecy of a New World by
- 00:06:26denouncing the existing world to bring
- 00:06:28it into being the new world which is the
- 00:06:30thing in the forward written by Henry
- 00:06:33Giroux that he said was he said remember
- 00:06:36Paulo Ferrari's vision is prophetic
- 00:06:39specifically in that it seeks to bring
- 00:06:41the kingdom of God on Earth
- 00:06:43to make the kingdom of God on Earth in
- 00:06:45solidarity with the oppressed
- 00:06:49and in fact this is what we're going to
- 00:06:50read from this chapter 10 education for
- 00:06:52Liberation does not merely free students
- 00:06:54from the blackboards just to offer them
- 00:06:55projectors so we're going to elaborate
- 00:06:57on this quote on the contrary it is
- 00:06:59concerned as a social Praxis with
- 00:07:00helping to free human beings from the
- 00:07:02oppression that strangles them and their
- 00:07:04objective reality
- 00:07:05so this is the goal of Education now
- 00:07:10it is and by the way objective reality
- 00:07:12when a Marxist says it means how
- 00:07:13marxists interpret interpret their lives
- 00:07:15it is not objective reality at all
- 00:07:19it is therefore political education just
- 00:07:21as political as the education that
- 00:07:23claims to be neutral although actually
- 00:07:24serving the power elite it is thus a
- 00:07:26form of Education that can only be put
- 00:07:28into practice systematically when the
- 00:07:30society is radically transformed I know
- 00:07:32I said this before we're revisiting this
- 00:07:34quote because the idea that Society has
- 00:07:36to be radically transformed before it's
- 00:07:37real
- 00:07:39is key to where we're going with SEL
- 00:07:43only the innocent he said could possibly
- 00:07:46think that the power elite would
- 00:07:47encourage a type of education that
- 00:07:48denounces them even more than they clear
- 00:07:50even more clearly than do all of the
- 00:07:52contradictions of their power structures
- 00:07:54such Navy also reveals a dangerous
- 00:07:56underestimation of the capacity and
- 00:07:58Audacity Of The Elite I'm reading it
- 00:08:00quickly because we've done it before
- 00:08:01truly liberating education can only be
- 00:08:03put into practice outside of the
- 00:08:05ordinary system that's the key takeaway
- 00:08:07here truly liberating education can only
- 00:08:09be put into practice outside of the
- 00:08:11ordinary system we need a new system we
- 00:08:14need a whole new system and even then
- 00:08:16with great cautiousness by those who
- 00:08:18overcame their naivety and commit
- 00:08:21themselves to authentic Liberation in
- 00:08:23other words by cultists
- 00:08:25and only cultists and like we said in
- 00:08:27the last lecture Friday framed all of
- 00:08:29this out in terms of his humanistic
- 00:08:30education through consentization and
- 00:08:33like you said as I quoted previously
- 00:08:34there just to remind you in truth there
- 00:08:36is no humanization without liberation
- 00:08:38just as there is no Liberation without a
- 00:08:40revolutionary transformation of the
- 00:08:42class Society
- 00:08:43for in the class Society all
- 00:08:45humanization is impossible that's where
- 00:08:46we're in the lecture on consentization
- 00:08:49we ran into lukacha's wall the problem
- 00:08:51of reproduction is that as long as class
- 00:08:54society which is held up automatically
- 00:08:56even by an oppositional class
- 00:08:58Consciousness do you still reproduce
- 00:09:00class Society you still reproduce
- 00:09:02dehumanization you're still thinking in
- 00:09:04terms of classes you still are going to
- 00:09:06become Stalin and install an oppressive
- 00:09:08regime that's not going to be correct
- 00:09:10Liberation he says becomes concrete only
- 00:09:13when Society has changed not when its
- 00:09:15structures are simply modernized I'm
- 00:09:16bringing this these two quotes back up
- 00:09:18because I want you to understand that
- 00:09:20the goal with transitioning into a
- 00:09:22social emotional learning model for
- 00:09:24consientization these are synonymous by
- 00:09:26the way
- 00:09:27transformative social emotional learning
- 00:09:29as Castle the primary organization
- 00:09:33selling and pushing social emotional
- 00:09:34learning today c-a-s-e-l Castle the
- 00:09:37collaborative for academic social and
- 00:09:39emotional learning transformative SEL is
- 00:09:41explicitly designed to use social and
- 00:09:43emotional techniques to raise a class
- 00:09:45Consciousness which you now know is
- 00:09:47maoist thought reform
- 00:09:50using psychological language instead of
- 00:09:52maoist prison language
- 00:09:55but what you have to understand is that
- 00:09:57the goal is that they are going to do
- 00:09:59this to have a fundamentally different
- 00:10:02Society the point of Social and
- 00:10:04emotional learning is to create a
- 00:10:07fundamentally different Society
- 00:10:08Liberation becomes concrete only when
- 00:10:12Society has changed not when its
- 00:10:14structures are simply modernized they're
- 00:10:16not modernizing the schools or not
- 00:10:17bringing technology into the schools do
- 00:10:19not believe a damn word Google tells you
- 00:10:21about this
- 00:10:23they are trying to fundamentally change
- 00:10:26the organization and operating
- 00:10:27principles of society they are not
- 00:10:30merely modernizing to digital technology
- 00:10:33the digital technology is the means not
- 00:10:35the end the end is the radical
- 00:10:38transformation of society to a new
- 00:10:41circular economy
- 00:10:44that your children will be consientized
- 00:10:46not to know how to live outside of
- 00:10:51so social and emotional learning
- 00:10:53is the new system of Education that's
- 00:10:56being put into place in conjunction with
- 00:10:58and in service to the radical
- 00:10:59transformation of society that they're
- 00:11:01doing elsewhere a new model like I said
- 00:11:04this is the circular economy which you
- 00:11:06can even hear in the name that's not
- 00:11:07going to work the second law of
- 00:11:09Thermodynamics didn't stop
- 00:11:11that's not going to work entropy still
- 00:11:13exists that's not going to work an
- 00:11:16economy where there's no waste in all
- 00:11:17waste is fed back in as the as the
- 00:11:19inputs
- 00:11:20I mean this like where you see Bill
- 00:11:21Gates like coming up to this big machine
- 00:11:23and he drinks a glass of water that he's
- 00:11:25like bragging was literally poop a few
- 00:11:26hours ago circular water
- 00:11:30I'm not kidding
- 00:11:32that he did that you can go watch the
- 00:11:34video yourself he's like hmm
- 00:11:37entity is like the world economic Forum
- 00:11:39in the United Nations understand that
- 00:11:40you have to build the new world and the
- 00:11:42people to fill it at the same time to
- 00:11:43make this work so that's kind of the big
- 00:11:44picture theme of why social emotional
- 00:11:46learning exists it's to facilitate the
- 00:11:48sustainable and resilient and inclusive
- 00:11:51actually the sustainable and inclusive
- 00:11:52new world that they're going to bring
- 00:11:54into being I did another podcast on the
- 00:11:56new discourses platform called
- 00:11:57sustainability of the tyranny of the
- 00:11:5821st century sustainability is the new
- 00:12:01word that means communism for me I don't
- 00:12:04even use them apart from one another
- 00:12:06anymore sustainability is neo-communism
- 00:12:09we're going to have a whole world system
- 00:12:10that is sustainable this is in line with
- 00:12:13the writers like Herbert marcuso that
- 00:12:14we've been talking about all along in
- 00:12:15the 1960s talking about how for example
- 00:12:19um capitalism is intrinsically
- 00:12:22not sustainable
- 00:12:24because what it does is it see because
- 00:12:26Advanced capitalism he said works so
- 00:12:27what does it do it satisfies your needs
- 00:12:28that's what it means to work you have a
- 00:12:30good life so in satisfying your needs
- 00:12:32but it still has to make a profit it has
- 00:12:34to make a whole new layer of new false
- 00:12:36needs the true needs and the false needs
- 00:12:38he talks about it a lot so it creates a
- 00:12:40new layer of things that you want and
- 00:12:42you start to get and those become needs
- 00:12:44too you don't know how to live without
- 00:12:45your phone
- 00:12:4620 years ago you could live without your
- 00:12:48phone no problem now you don't know how
- 00:12:49to live without your phone you don't
- 00:12:50know how to get anywhere like you don't
- 00:12:52know what to do you feel like you're
- 00:12:53naked because you forgot your phone
- 00:12:54somewhere
- 00:12:56whole new layer of need someone knows
- 00:12:58when capitalism steps in and satisfies
- 00:12:59those they just become basic needs and
- 00:13:02so it comes like a new layer of luxury
- 00:13:05goods that become the next layer of
- 00:13:06needs but where does this Tower stop
- 00:13:08nowhere never
- 00:13:10so it just creates more and more and
- 00:13:12more and more needs that people don't
- 00:13:13know how to live without and that's
- 00:13:14unsustainable
- 00:13:15eventually that's going to collapse that
- 00:13:18dovetails I'm talking about Marcus but
- 00:13:20we dovetail over to the world economic
- 00:13:21Forum in 1973 where in 1972 the year
- 00:13:25before there was a publication put out
- 00:13:27by the club of Rome which you're not
- 00:13:28even supposed to really talk about which
- 00:13:30was this weird
- 00:13:31um bunch of MIT scientists brought in by
- 00:13:34this weird Italian uh wealthy individual
- 00:13:38who is funding them to study the
- 00:13:40possible so-called limits to growth
- 00:13:42that's the book they published in 1972.
- 00:13:44limits to growth and they were convinced
- 00:13:46by the way in the book written in 1972
- 00:13:49they predicted that we would run out of
- 00:13:51metal and collapse oral economy in the
- 00:13:53year 2000.
- 00:13:55that's what they said non-renewable
- 00:13:56resources will run out and it will cause
- 00:13:58a complete break in the capacity of the
- 00:14:01world to continue growing and then we're
- 00:14:04going to set ourselves up for a Calamity
- 00:14:05where maybe six seven billion people can
- 00:14:07live on the planet but will break the
- 00:14:09system so that only two or three billion
- 00:14:10can live and we're going to end up
- 00:14:11killing billions of people by collapsing
- 00:14:13the system so why not start getting
- 00:14:15controls on this so things don't get out
- 00:14:16of hand sooner because this is
- 00:14:18unsustainable growth now bring that up
- 00:14:20because in 1973 Klaus Schwab was so
- 00:14:23moved by this crackpot report done on
- 00:14:26computer modeling in 1970
- 00:14:29Punch Cards no kidding that said that
- 00:14:32the world was going to collapse Itself
- 00:14:33by 2000 or at least definitely by 2100.
- 00:14:37uh that he brought them to the world
- 00:14:39economic forum and this
- 00:14:41existential emergency has been a
- 00:14:43significant part of their thinking ever
- 00:14:45since
- 00:14:46that's where most of their if you read
- 00:14:48that book which I bothered to most of
- 00:14:50that book is about how unsustainable the
- 00:14:52current world trajectory is and that if
- 00:14:55you break the if you go too far and you
- 00:14:57break it you break the entire system and
- 00:14:58it goes from being able to support
- 00:15:00however many people to many many fewer
- 00:15:02than that many people we go back in time
- 00:15:03to Marcus a warning about this in
- 00:15:05one-dimensional man
- 00:15:06in 1964 and at the end he has this weird
- 00:15:10set of paragraphs I don't have them here
- 00:15:12to quote for you but he has this weird
- 00:15:13set of paragraphs where he indicates he
- 00:15:15says well of course
- 00:15:17a sustainable future requires a
- 00:15:19reduction in the future population of
- 00:15:21the world when it was 3.9 billion in
- 00:15:231964. so this fear that there are too
- 00:15:26many people for a sustainable system has
- 00:15:29been along for the ride for a very long
- 00:15:31time
- 00:15:33this environmental catastrophism that's
- 00:15:35motivating them has been around for a
- 00:15:37very long time so changing the world to
- 00:15:39this new circular economy managed by
- 00:15:41we'll say a council of stakeholders
- 00:15:43that's a stakeholder capitalism model
- 00:15:45where we don't we don't meet shareholder
- 00:15:47Demand anymore we we meet stakeholder uh
- 00:15:50analysis like the stakeholders in covid
- 00:15:53who said that we had to do all these
- 00:15:54things that Ron DeSantis decided not to
- 00:15:55do and we see how that worked out we
- 00:15:58have stakeholders like Bill Gates
- 00:15:59telling us how we're supposed to manage
- 00:16:01farmland or food we have stakeholders
- 00:16:03like Klaus Schwab we have these other
- 00:16:04experts that they bring as stakeholders
- 00:16:06to tell us the experts they know how
- 00:16:07we're supposed to manage all of our
- 00:16:09systems these this Council of
- 00:16:11stakeholders and I say Counsel on
- 00:16:12purpose because the Russian word for
- 00:16:14Council is Soviet are going to make all
- 00:16:16of our decisions for us and make sure
- 00:16:18that the economy is governed correctly
- 00:16:20with ESG Environmental
- 00:16:23social and corporate governance policies
- 00:16:26that make sure that we developed a
- 00:16:28sustainable and inclusive world this is
- 00:16:30the tyranny of the 21st century I talk
- 00:16:31about all those things except the club
- 00:16:33of Rome thing in that podcast that I did
- 00:16:35it's neo-communism it's how they this
- 00:16:38Council of stakeholders seizes means uh
- 00:16:41the means of the production of
- 00:16:43everything in society so that we can
- 00:16:45enter into what they call a circular
- 00:16:46economy which is apparently facilitated
- 00:16:48by us eating bugs for our protein needs
- 00:16:52that's the plan and they want to make
- 00:16:53your children think that we have to have
- 00:16:55this world or else it's probably going
- 00:16:56to catch on fire in 12 years because AOC
- 00:16:58said it on TV and she's uh you know a
- 00:17:01celebrity
- 00:17:02oh my God
- 00:17:04she has a tick tock or something
- 00:17:06the Chinese aren't spying on that at all
- 00:17:09before turning to this whole mess of of
- 00:17:12world economic Forum though I want to
- 00:17:14actually point out that even this has
- 00:17:15been criticized by critical theorists
- 00:17:17who are like whoa hold up so there's a
- 00:17:19guy who comes from a critical theory
- 00:17:20perspective his name is Ben Williamson
- 00:17:22in 2019 he wrote a paper in the Journal
- 00:17:25of educational policy talking about
- 00:17:27social or emotional learning the title
- 00:17:29of the paper is psycho data
- 00:17:32disassembling the psychological economic
- 00:17:34and statistical infrastructure of social
- 00:17:36emotional learning and this is a weird
- 00:17:38paper when you read it I'm going to read
- 00:17:39a couple of quotes from it to you to
- 00:17:41tell you what social emotional learning
- 00:17:43is really about this is a guy who's
- 00:17:45analyzing it you get the sense that he's
- 00:17:47kind of warm to it but he doesn't want
- 00:17:49the corporations controlling it because
- 00:17:51he's a critical theorist
- 00:17:53and so what he says is the political
- 00:17:55economy of psycho economic expertise as
- 00:17:58a section begins social emotional
- 00:18:01learning
- 00:18:02needs to be understood as part of a
- 00:18:04political economy in which the
- 00:18:05measurement of humans psychological
- 00:18:07attributes is seen as integral to
- 00:18:10economic forecasting and political
- 00:18:11management of populations
- 00:18:13that's why they're doing SEL in the
- 00:18:15schools
- 00:18:16because it's integral to economic
- 00:18:18forecasting they can make predictions
- 00:18:20about the market behaviors of your
- 00:18:22children when they have a full-blown
- 00:18:23think like remember back in 2016 and we
- 00:18:25all crapped our pants about Cambridge
- 00:18:27analytica and how it used big big data
- 00:18:30the ocean model to the the five
- 00:18:33attributes what is it openness
- 00:18:35neuroticism something
- 00:18:37conscientiousness empathy I don't know
- 00:18:39there's something ocean the five big
- 00:18:41personality traits and where they make
- 00:18:43you took all these quizzes like which
- 00:18:45Little Mermaid are you and which Ninja
- 00:18:47Turtle are you and you took all these
- 00:18:49quizzes and they were fun on Facebook
- 00:18:50and you'd share them with all your
- 00:18:51friends you're like oh my gosh I'm this
- 00:18:53oh my gosh I'm Michelangelo oh my gosh
- 00:18:56which classical painter are you which
- 00:18:57you know whatever it is which horse
- 00:18:59racer are you you know things nobody
- 00:19:00cares about which Gobot are you if
- 00:19:02anybody remembers the GoBots from the
- 00:19:0480s and he took all these quizzes but
- 00:19:06really what they were were personality
- 00:19:07profiles and they're aggregating lots
- 00:19:09and lots of data about you and using
- 00:19:10that to tailor your algorithms so that
- 00:19:12they could do political messaging to you
- 00:19:14or marketing messaging to you now
- 00:19:17imagine that on steroids is really good
- 00:19:19AI
- 00:19:22the point of social emotional learning
- 00:19:24is that it needs to be understood as
- 00:19:25part of a political economy in which the
- 00:19:28measurements of human psychological
- 00:19:29attributes
- 00:19:30is seen as integral to economic
- 00:19:32forecasting and the political management
- 00:19:35of populations
- 00:19:37your children are their guinea pigs
- 00:19:39that's why they're going through social
- 00:19:40emotional learning
- 00:19:42he doesn't even say specific stuff
- 00:19:44within it that's the point of social
- 00:19:45emotional learning that's how it needs
- 00:19:46to be understood he says he says social
- 00:19:48emotional learning SEL interventions
- 00:19:51practices and policies are the products
- 00:19:53of a combination of techniques measures
- 00:19:55and practices developed by psychological
- 00:19:58behavioral and economics experts
- 00:20:00stakeholders
- 00:20:01not you as the parents you don't know
- 00:20:04anything
- 00:20:05whose straddle National borders and
- 00:20:07public private sector boundaries now of
- 00:20:09course if you know anything about the
- 00:20:10world economic Forum by the way they say
- 00:20:12that they're trying to form
- 00:20:12public-private Partnerships that's
- 00:20:14straddle National borders and
- 00:20:19public-private sector boundaries
- 00:20:22huh weird
- 00:20:24production of numerical accounts of
- 00:20:26students non-cognitive capacities is a
- 00:20:28core objective of SEL advocates
- 00:20:31numerical accounts of students
- 00:20:33non-cognitive capacities what does that
- 00:20:35mean emotional capacities for example
- 00:20:37referring to quote character education
- 00:20:40Bull and Allen describe quote
- 00:20:42considerable conceptual messiness across
- 00:20:45various sites and practices of policy
- 00:20:46work popular culture schooling and so on
- 00:20:49noting that quote perhaps it is the most
- 00:20:52Perhaps it is this very messiness and
- 00:20:54incoherence that enables a productive
- 00:20:57malleability to meet a variety of
- 00:21:00agendas and interests end quote while
- 00:21:03adding that the various interest groups
- 00:21:05all face similar difficulties in
- 00:21:07producing a scientific evidence base
- 00:21:10what do you need more data
- 00:21:12give your kids a chipped up iPad
- 00:21:19similarly in an extensive scientific
- 00:21:21review of SEL research and policy osher
- 00:21:23at all conclude that significant gaps in
- 00:21:26statistical measurement of SEL limit
- 00:21:28investigators and policy makers ability
- 00:21:31to fully utilize the research findings
- 00:21:33and therefore recommend the field needs
- 00:21:35practical measures with psychometric
- 00:21:37evidence psychometric evidence of your
- 00:21:39children to address this Gap in the
- 00:21:42psychometric evidence-based contemporary
- 00:21:43approaches to sel therefore Center on
- 00:21:45the production of Novel forms of
- 00:21:47psychodata about students as statistical
- 00:21:49insights for policy influence and
- 00:21:51intervention the turn to intensive
- 00:21:54psychometric measurement of social
- 00:21:56emotional learning is a means to produce
- 00:21:57policy relevant data is the core focus
- 00:22:00of this article that's what they're
- 00:22:01doing they then name a lot of entities
- 00:22:04that are involved in this social
- 00:22:06emotional learning data mining projects
- 00:22:08so that they can create interventions
- 00:22:10for economic forecasting and population
- 00:22:12control in fact they bring up those
- 00:22:13points again and again and I'm not going
- 00:22:14to belabor it by reading a bunch of them
- 00:22:16the paper is fairly horrifying
- 00:22:18they named UNESCO as a huge backer of
- 00:22:21this project that's the United Nations
- 00:22:23they name the oecd they named the World
- 00:22:26Bank which is interesting to see they
- 00:22:29named the world economic Forum
- 00:22:30explicitly and devote a paragraph or two
- 00:22:32to them they name as major funders the
- 00:22:34Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation the
- 00:22:36Chan Zuckerberg initiative and on the
- 00:22:39neoconservative side the Templeton
- 00:22:41Foundation as the major contributors
- 00:22:44supporters and funders of this new
- 00:22:46vision
- 00:22:47their goal with SEL is to create models
- 00:22:50of your children through psycho data
- 00:22:52that they can use for economic
- 00:22:53forecasting which by the way that's
- 00:22:55going to work in a circular fashion they
- 00:22:57will have a perfect marketing portfolio
- 00:22:59of your children they'll know which
- 00:23:01emotional triggers work for your
- 00:23:02children they'll know exactly what their
- 00:23:04psychological profile looks like they'll
- 00:23:06know exactly if they're wearing their
- 00:23:07little apps on their wearable
- 00:23:09Technologies they'll know exactly what
- 00:23:11kind of emotional responses might
- 00:23:12trigger the ideal time to hit them with
- 00:23:14an ad for a particular kind of product
- 00:23:16and you'll have excellent ability to
- 00:23:18forecast what they might want to buy
- 00:23:20here's an example that's not your
- 00:23:22children this is John Deere tractors did
- 00:23:24you know if you buy a John Deere tractor
- 00:23:25now you don't own it
- 00:23:27costs like half a million dollars but
- 00:23:28you don't own it you know why you don't
- 00:23:30own it because the tractor runs a piece
- 00:23:31of software that has a copyright on it
- 00:23:33that John Deere owns and you can't own
- 00:23:34their copyright and the tractor doesn't
- 00:23:37work without the software so they you
- 00:23:39can't own the tractor
- 00:23:40this has a lot of consequences like you
- 00:23:42can't fix your own tractor if you're a
- 00:23:43farmer you have to wait till they come
- 00:23:44out and type in the code that says they
- 00:23:46fixed your tractor which is great for if
- 00:23:48you have an emergency something breaks
- 00:23:49down and you've got a harvest right now
- 00:23:51real great right but it's even worse
- 00:23:53than this what this software does is it
- 00:23:55actually enables something very useful
- 00:23:57and very great for Farmers all kinds of
- 00:23:59sensors built into these modern tractors
- 00:24:01they're not merely like super powerful
- 00:24:02little funny trucks that can have lots
- 00:24:05of torque or whatever and giant wheels
- 00:24:06in fact they can measure through the way
- 00:24:09that the wheels interact with the soil
- 00:24:10the soil density they can measure the
- 00:24:12moisture level of the soil they can
- 00:24:13measure certain chemical compositions in
- 00:24:15the soil to the point where you can make
- 00:24:16a centimeter by centimeter grid of an
- 00:24:19entire Farm in terms of what its soil
- 00:24:20quality is for the growing of various
- 00:24:22types of crops pretty useful if you're a
- 00:24:24farmer you log into your John Deere
- 00:24:25account you got your tractor you paid a
- 00:24:27lot of money for and then here's this
- 00:24:28map of your farm and exactly where the
- 00:24:30dry areas are you can irrigate them
- 00:24:32better exactly where the minerals are
- 00:24:34poor you can go fertilizer or amplify
- 00:24:36those minerals you can you know throw
- 00:24:38out some uh you know copper or whatever
- 00:24:40it is that you need to get into the soil
- 00:24:42to get the optimal growing conditions
- 00:24:43for what you're growing really useful
- 00:24:44centimeter by centimeter grid is really
- 00:24:46small
- 00:24:48but you own the data that you generated
- 00:24:50with your tracker no you don't own the
- 00:24:51data that you generated with the tractor
- 00:24:52John Deere does and what do they do they
- 00:24:53sell it to Futures traders to bet
- 00:24:55against your farm because they can
- 00:24:56forecast what your yields will be
- 00:25:01and now they're doing that not with John
- 00:25:03Deere tractors but with your children's
- 00:25:04psychological and emotional data that
- 00:25:07they're Gathering through iPads Etc
- 00:25:09that's what this is about and it's not
- 00:25:13just so that they can Market to them
- 00:25:14flawlessly it's not just so they can
- 00:25:16make economic forecasts and plans and
- 00:25:18Futures Trading guess at behaviors of
- 00:25:20the market
- 00:25:22prevent boom and bust Cycles by
- 00:25:24psychologically nudging people to act
- 00:25:25differently through marketing campaigns
- 00:25:27Etc it's also for the control of people
- 00:25:31psychologically it could be political
- 00:25:33propaganda that gets them to act and
- 00:25:35react in ways that the regime needs them
- 00:25:36to act and react at a given moment
- 00:25:39perfectly tailored by AI perfectly
- 00:25:42tailored to your child's specific
- 00:25:44psychology yours if they could get it
- 00:25:46but you're an adult
- 00:25:47captive audience in the schools they can
- 00:25:49gather it from the children very very
- 00:25:51easily by forcing them to be on these
- 00:25:53like canvas programs where you can't get
- 00:25:55an education any other way than being
- 00:25:56opted into these things
- 00:25:59so what did the world economic Forum
- 00:26:01have to say about this stuff World
- 00:26:02economic Forum wrote a white paper in
- 00:26:042016 about the education of the future
- 00:26:06so social emotional learning it's titled
- 00:26:09a new vision for Education fostering
- 00:26:11social and emotional learning through
- 00:26:12technology
- 00:26:14this is an astonishingly scary document
- 00:26:16if you can read through their typical
- 00:26:18corporate problem
- 00:26:19it says to thrive in the 21st century
- 00:26:22students need more than traditional
- 00:26:23academic learning did you know that
- 00:26:26it's not by the way spoiler alert
- 00:26:28they're not going to tell you that your
- 00:26:29kids need to learn how to learn because
- 00:26:31there's a highly rapidly changing
- 00:26:33environment Technology's changing new
- 00:26:36jobs coming into being et cetera they're
- 00:26:38not going to tell you your kids need to
- 00:26:39learn how to learn it's not what you
- 00:26:40need they must be Adept at collaboration
- 00:26:43communication and problem solving which
- 00:26:45are some of the skills developed through
- 00:26:47social and emotional learning
- 00:26:49sort of
- 00:26:51coupled with Mastery of traditional
- 00:26:52skills social and emotional proficiency
- 00:26:54will equip students to succeed in the
- 00:26:56swiftly evolving digital economy
- 00:26:59research suggests that early childhood
- 00:27:01is the critical period for fostering
- 00:27:02social and emotional learning children
- 00:27:04are at their most receptive to sel and
- 00:27:07strategies targeting this stage are most
- 00:27:09likely to have a lasting impact
- 00:27:11guess we need that Pre-K education
- 00:27:15right
- 00:27:16but research also indicates that SEL at
- 00:27:19later stages is necessary and effective
- 00:27:21and offers opportunities to attain
- 00:27:22skills in other words social emotional
- 00:27:24learning skills are teachable at all
- 00:27:26ages so this is actually a document
- 00:27:28though that they don't just justify or
- 00:27:29claim to justify that we need social
- 00:27:31emotional learning or that it creates
- 00:27:32the soft skills they give a list of like
- 00:27:3418 competencies I don't want to go
- 00:27:36through that all in detail it's not just
- 00:27:39about developing these soft social
- 00:27:40emotional skills and and resilience
- 00:27:42skills and inclusion skills which is
- 00:27:44what they name focusing on equity which
- 00:27:46they name it's not just about that they
- 00:27:49also want to integrate technology that's
- 00:27:51what it says social and emotional
- 00:27:52learning through technology is to be
- 00:27:54fostered that way
- 00:27:55so they Envision all kinds of high-tech
- 00:27:57applications so they talk about the
- 00:27:59different things that are happening now
- 00:28:01using iPads using technology in the
- 00:28:03classroom Etc and they talk about how
- 00:28:05you know it's potentially possible that
- 00:28:07they could rate engagement in the same
- 00:28:09way that video games write engagement by
- 00:28:12how often people are pushing buttons or
- 00:28:14paying attention or whatever they talk
- 00:28:15about how the camera on the the thing
- 00:28:17could potentially do eye tracking to
- 00:28:19find out what kids are actually paying
- 00:28:20attention to in the lesson more than
- 00:28:21other things they talk about all these
- 00:28:24kinds of things but then they start
- 00:28:24talking about future possible
- 00:28:26applications and they start talking
- 00:28:28about uh particularly AI driven apps and
- 00:28:32wearable Technologies
- 00:28:34Etc so wearable Technologies I'm going
- 00:28:36to tell you a Horror Story given that
- 00:28:37we're talking about kids in education
- 00:28:38but I have a friend and my poor friend
- 00:28:40is getting dragged through it by me
- 00:28:42telling the story over and over again
- 00:28:43she has one of those watches that
- 00:28:44measures everything about you
- 00:28:46and we're fairly close friends and so we
- 00:28:49talk about you know
- 00:28:51things that fairly close friends would
- 00:28:52be willing to talk about and so she very
- 00:28:54rather embarrassingly to her at the
- 00:28:56beginning of the year though she thought
- 00:28:57it was hilarious sent me a text message
- 00:28:58and said my whoop app
- 00:29:01told me the top three reasons I lost
- 00:29:03sleep in 2021 and number two was
- 00:29:06masturbating
- 00:29:07and so hahaha you know we're all
- 00:29:09laughing that's funny that's cute and
- 00:29:11I'm like that's not funny oh my God your
- 00:29:12watch knew what you were doing
- 00:29:14your watch was able to discern by
- 00:29:16measuring your heart rate perspiration
- 00:29:18Etc that you were touching yourself
- 00:29:20you're you didn't tell it you were
- 00:29:23I asked
- 00:29:24your watch figured it out by what your
- 00:29:27physiological responses were that it
- 00:29:28could measure
- 00:29:31and so maybe you're more suggestible
- 00:29:33after such a thing or after other things
- 00:29:35maybe you get a big scare and you're
- 00:29:37more susceptible to buy life insurance
- 00:29:38maybe you get a big moment of
- 00:29:40frustration and you're more likely to
- 00:29:41buy Ben and Jerry's ice cream or
- 00:29:43something who knows they can measure
- 00:29:44your emotional state and that's what
- 00:29:45this white paper talks about explicitly
- 00:29:46they want to measure the emotional state
- 00:29:48of children in the classroom so they can
- 00:29:50Target more accurately educational
- 00:29:52interventions to make it more successful
- 00:29:54and also to teach them to manage the
- 00:29:56emotions that are coming up they're
- 00:29:57frustrated with their math lesson well
- 00:29:59you can get a thing that cop pops up as
- 00:30:01their digital friend or whatever and it
- 00:30:03talks them down calms them down gets
- 00:30:04them to refocus and then you also gather
- 00:30:06data on what part of the math lesson the
- 00:30:09kid gets stressed out about so you can
- 00:30:10figure out ways different ways to
- 00:30:11present that kind of lesson to people
- 00:30:13with that particular personality profile
- 00:30:14so that you eventually have a digital
- 00:30:16Socrates or something that's your own
- 00:30:17private tutor and you have no actual
- 00:30:19teacher you have a algorithm controlled
- 00:30:22in some remote server room that's
- 00:30:25teaching your kids everything they need
- 00:30:27to know about the world they never even
- 00:30:28have to look out the window they never
- 00:30:29even look outside they don't have to see
- 00:30:31anything with their your eyes except
- 00:30:32what's on their screen and that's how
- 00:30:33they'll be taught this is the education
- 00:30:35of the future and it's measuring their
- 00:30:37psychological data and I thought well
- 00:30:39that's way out there that's crazy I know
- 00:30:40about these wearable texts and the
- 00:30:41things that they're capable of and then
- 00:30:43I'm in Florida a couple weeks ago and
- 00:30:44somebody says that in their County their
- 00:30:46schools they're already experimenting
- 00:30:47with heart math I mentioned that the
- 00:30:49other day heart math where they're
- 00:30:50strapping heart monitors onto kids like
- 00:30:52these watches to find out how their
- 00:30:53physiological responses go while they're
- 00:30:55going through mathematics lessons so
- 00:30:57they can pause the lesson when there's a
- 00:30:58certain amount of psychological stress
- 00:31:00being detected by the apps in the in the
- 00:31:03devices and they can calm everybody down
- 00:31:05and talk about how Mass stresses people
- 00:31:07out and they can get the kids that are
- 00:31:08getting disengaged and do targeted
- 00:31:10interventions with them Etc et cetera
- 00:31:13sounds pretty cool
- 00:31:16except when you realize everything that
- 00:31:17it might do and then you look at the AI
- 00:31:19apps part they just released a document
- 00:31:2314 companies that are leading the way in
- 00:31:26social emotional learning blah blah blah
- 00:31:28the world economic Forum did
- 00:31:29Technologies they gave them some kind of
- 00:31:31award you know the 14 leaders
- 00:31:3412 of the 14. I remember the the thrust
- 00:31:38of 13 out of 14 I remember the 14th one
- 00:31:40but 12 out of the 13 are all AI driven
- 00:31:43apps
- 00:31:45one of the 14 is the Trevor Project
- 00:31:50which I don't know why that's there
- 00:31:51that's allegedly a Suicide Prevention
- 00:31:54Hotline that is for gender dysphoric
- 00:31:57teens and children that they use to
- 00:31:59affirm their identities to do social
- 00:32:01transition and in fact has all this
- 00:32:03stuff built into it so the kids can push
- 00:32:04a single button and delete all of the
- 00:32:06chat history with all the people that
- 00:32:07they've been chatting with so their
- 00:32:09parents can't possibly see it or find it
- 00:32:10the Trevor Project is one of those
- 00:32:12things you have to be very careful
- 00:32:13talking about honestly on the internet
- 00:32:15because you will get kicked off of the
- 00:32:16internet if you talk too much about the
- 00:32:17Trevor Project it'd be really worth some
- 00:32:19investigative people digging into that
- 00:32:21organization and finding out what's
- 00:32:22going on with it so that's one of the 14
- 00:32:2412 of the 14 are AI driven digital
- 00:32:27buddies and so on
- 00:32:29digital friends
- 00:32:32so you have an AI driven app that
- 00:32:34becomes your friend that gets to know
- 00:32:36you you tell it your secrets it's just a
- 00:32:38computer it's not even a real person you
- 00:32:39tell it whatever your feelings are
- 00:32:40you're telling it all this stuff and
- 00:32:41it's recording all this data about you
- 00:32:43and that thing becomes your friend that
- 00:32:45walks you through life it's like you
- 00:32:46know you play the video games these days
- 00:32:48when I played video games as a kid they
- 00:32:50were effing hard you know the slightest
- 00:32:52idea what you're supposed to do you get
- 00:32:53stuck in some maze you don't know what
- 00:32:54you remember this game when I was a kid
- 00:32:56this is dorky it's called ikari Warriors
- 00:32:57and I got to like the Boston level
- 00:32:59there's like four levels and I never got
- 00:33:01past level three because you get to the
- 00:33:03boss into some like alien face green
- 00:33:05face monster thing behind like a desk
- 00:33:07it's probably Cloud Schwab and you
- 00:33:10you have I never figured I got to this
- 00:33:13point in the game like a thousand times
- 00:33:15and I never figured out what you're
- 00:33:16supposed to do to get past it the game
- 00:33:18never tells you when you play games now
- 00:33:19and you have like a little digital ferry
- 00:33:21that flies around and it's like why
- 00:33:22don't you kick it in the beat you know
- 00:33:24or whatever it tells you what you're
- 00:33:25supposed to do you don't have to figure
- 00:33:27anything out
- 00:33:28and so your digital app becomes your
- 00:33:30little digital assistant that's spying
- 00:33:31on you constantly
- 00:33:33and telling you how to navigate life hey
- 00:33:36did you know if you're feeling stressed
- 00:33:37out you could go do a mindfulness
- 00:33:38exercise let's breathe together or
- 00:33:40something like this 12 out of the 14
- 00:33:42things the world economic Forum
- 00:33:44recommended are AI driven applications
- 00:33:46of that sort
- 00:33:47that's what's leading this and again
- 00:33:49that's going to get tied in and get more
- 00:33:50and more accurate as they gather more
- 00:33:52and more psychological data but hey
- 00:33:53let's take a quiz let's take a quiz
- 00:33:55let's find out what kind of Crystal you
- 00:33:57are everybody wanted to know what kind
- 00:33:58of dinosaur you might grow up to be you
- 00:34:00know whatever it happens to be do you
- 00:34:02feel like a boy or a girl today oh you
- 00:34:04can feel like whatever you want let's
- 00:34:05talk about it you know these are the
- 00:34:07things that are winning the world
- 00:34:08economic forum's vision and this is what
- 00:34:10in their white paper in 2016 they said
- 00:34:12is the future of social emotional
- 00:34:14learning so that it can become tailored
- 00:34:16all the way down to the exact individual
- 00:34:18to into to integrate into those 18 or
- 00:34:21whatever it is competencies that they
- 00:34:23see as the soft skills necessary for the
- 00:34:25future economy something like three or
- 00:34:27four of the 18 are like academic skills
- 00:34:30all the rest of these social and
- 00:34:32emotional things that are going to be
- 00:34:33tied into having certain attitudes about
- 00:34:36how you navigate social and emotional
- 00:34:38experience
- 00:34:40the white paper itself we just talked
- 00:34:43about it in that Williamson paper with
- 00:34:44the world economic Forum paper turns out
- 00:34:47it mentions the same people who's paying
- 00:34:49for this who's pushing him primarily
- 00:34:51they name UNESCO as one of the primary
- 00:34:55people pushing this and they say
- 00:34:57explicitly that it's being done in
- 00:34:59accordance with agenda 2030 and the
- 00:35:01sustainable development goals of the
- 00:35:02United Nations they susp they
- 00:35:04specifically name the World Bank as
- 00:35:05being significantly behind this which is
- 00:35:08they say specifically interested in
- 00:35:10connecting data being gathered through
- 00:35:13social and emotional learning technology
- 00:35:15to fill gaps in future employment
- 00:35:18so they're trying to map out which job
- 00:35:20you might have so the Soviet can decide
- 00:35:21I mean the Council of stakeholders can
- 00:35:23decide which job your kids are supposed
- 00:35:24to have in the new digital economy
- 00:35:27it's a perfectly managed economy on the
- 00:35:29other side of this
- 00:35:30they go so far as to say that social and
- 00:35:33emotional learning has to be completely
- 00:35:34systemic it's not enough for social
- 00:35:37emotional learning to happen at school
- 00:35:38and you go home and your kid your
- 00:35:40parents can deprogram you or maybe some
- 00:35:41kids God forbid are homeschooled and
- 00:35:43they don't get exposed to it that's not
- 00:35:45enough
- 00:35:46they even talk about a pilot program
- 00:35:48that they that was run in France that
- 00:35:49they hold up as an Exemplar in this 20
- 00:35:51some odd page document they put out
- 00:35:53where they were training nurses
- 00:35:57in social emotional learning and in
- 00:35:59social emotional learning education to
- 00:36:01go work with pregnant mothers so that
- 00:36:03the mothers could learn to do social
- 00:36:04emotional learning from birth with their
- 00:36:07children
- 00:36:08this is actually the program you don't
- 00:36:09know about social emotional learning yet
- 00:36:11social emotional learning is in the
- 00:36:12schools it's in all the schools
- 00:36:16but the goal is for social and emotional
- 00:36:18learning to be in everything
- 00:36:20your church should have social emotional
- 00:36:22learning your school should have social
- 00:36:23emotional learning your parents and your
- 00:36:25community should have social emotional
- 00:36:27learning skills that reflect what's
- 00:36:28happening at the schools
- 00:36:32this is the vision that they paint in
- 00:36:34these actual policy docs or policy or
- 00:36:37white papers not policy documents
- 00:36:38proposal documents that they put out in
- 00:36:40say 2016 2019 et cetera about what the
- 00:36:43future of Education looks like and what
- 00:36:45social emotional learnings role in it is
- 00:36:47that's not what you read on the castle
- 00:36:48website by the way castle.org
- 00:36:51c-a-s-e-l-o-r-g
- 00:36:54so what does the world economic Forum or
- 00:36:56apparently UNESCO or the World Bank or
- 00:36:58the oecd or the bill of Melinda Gates
- 00:37:01Foundation or any of these people what
- 00:37:03do they want with social emotional
- 00:37:04learning what we turn to let's say their
- 00:37:06Godfather class Schwab who we just made
- 00:37:09fun of
- 00:37:09he's insistent he wrote a book this year
- 00:37:11that is the great reset book two it's
- 00:37:14it's title excuse me is
- 00:37:17I kid you not the great narrative for a
- 00:37:19better world
- 00:37:23oh for a better future I'm sorry I
- 00:37:24looked it up it's for a better future
- 00:37:25the great narrative for the better
- 00:37:26future they're going to tell us the
- 00:37:27narrative so that we'll all go along
- 00:37:29with it like a bunch of idiots
- 00:37:31or we're going to be brainwashed into it
- 00:37:33through constantizing social emotional
- 00:37:34learning and he's insistent in this book
- 00:37:36that ESG is the key to a better future
- 00:37:39it's what enables us to have a more in
- 00:37:41the words he uses over and over and over
- 00:37:42again in almost all of his documents a
- 00:37:45more sustainable and inclusive future
- 00:37:48he insists that the way we get there is
- 00:37:50by breaking down our resistance to a
- 00:37:52public-private partnership in order to
- 00:37:54place to to enact this from the top down
- 00:37:58and that's going to put tremendous
- 00:37:59pressure on corporations and eventually
- 00:38:00individuals to want to comply with ESG
- 00:38:03because there's this top-down pressure
- 00:38:04being put in through a public-private
- 00:38:06partnership where we break down the
- 00:38:08barrier between the public sector and
- 00:38:10the private sector he says explicitly
- 00:38:11but there's also going to be a bottom-up
- 00:38:13movement so if you don't if you think
- 00:38:15you can resist the top down pressure and
- 00:38:16you don't want to go along with it and
- 00:38:18you're going to conduct business or your
- 00:38:19life the way that you want to he says
- 00:38:21that's not going to work because your
- 00:38:22customers your clients your friends
- 00:38:24your employees are going to demand it
- 00:38:26because we're going to make sure that
- 00:38:28the young people he specifically names
- 00:38:30the Millennials in Generation Z are
- 00:38:32going to be led to need to demand a
- 00:38:35world that doesn't cheat them that
- 00:38:37doesn't threaten them with existential
- 00:38:38crises like pandemics like
- 00:38:42climate change and so on
- 00:38:44so there's going to be a bottom-up
- 00:38:45movement also demanding an ESG
- 00:38:48compliance social and political world
- 00:38:49which will force other corporations to
- 00:38:52participate because they won't be able
- 00:38:54to get employees that nobody wants to
- 00:38:56work in a company that's on the wrong
- 00:38:57side of History they won't be able to
- 00:38:59um
- 00:39:00keep customers because customers will
- 00:39:02start making their buying decisions and
- 00:39:04their their other decisions in terms of
- 00:39:07social activism and thus you create
- 00:39:09these ESG metrics that are supposed to
- 00:39:11somehow facilitate that and they say
- 00:39:13well ESG is going to predict long-term
- 00:39:15survivability while they're in while
- 00:39:17they're literally trying to create a
- 00:39:18customer base that won't buy anything
- 00:39:19else so it's all a huge scam ESG is a
- 00:39:22huge scam again ESG is environmental
- 00:39:25social and governance scoring for
- 00:39:27investment capital in the corporate
- 00:39:30sector that's then reinforced in the
- 00:39:32public sector our SEC here in the United
- 00:39:34States is already trying to back up ESG
- 00:39:37compliance that's a public-private
- 00:39:38partnership the old word for that under
- 00:39:40Mussolini back in the day was fascism
- 00:39:43but there's also going to be a bottom-up
- 00:39:45youth Cultural Revolution and that's
- 00:39:49where you need
- 00:39:50consientization that's where you need
- 00:39:52thought reform that's where you need
- 00:39:54ferrarian education that's where you
- 00:39:56need social emotional learning he
- 00:39:58insists that shifting the culture this
- 00:39:59way doesn't just produce a bottom-up
- 00:40:01movement
- 00:40:02it also produces a new social contract
- 00:40:07he in fact says the old social contract
- 00:40:09has to go and we have to rewrite it
- 00:40:11so that we have a social contract
- 00:40:12befitting a sustainable and inclusive
- 00:40:14future that means we need a cultural
- 00:40:16revolution he doesn't say those words
- 00:40:18but it's needed and it's all but
- 00:40:20guaranteed if they're allowed to push
- 00:40:21social emotional learning through to the
- 00:40:23degree that they want to so young people
- 00:40:25will demand through SEL they will come
- 00:40:28to demand ESG they will come to demand a
- 00:40:30new society and a new culture and so his
- 00:40:33education of the future
- 00:40:35based in SEL is going to make sure that
- 00:40:37young people are groomed into believing
- 00:40:39that an ESG sustainable driven world or
- 00:40:41sustainable and inclusive better future
- 00:40:43is the only possible way forward and
- 00:40:45they won't be able to live outside of
- 00:40:47that world in other words they will have
- 00:40:48a new sensibility they will have a
- 00:40:50biological foundation for socialism
- 00:40:52driven into the level of their vital
- 00:40:53needs
- 00:40:55to quote from Klaus I could do this at
- 00:40:57length I'm just going to do one short
- 00:40:59part of about six paragraphs
- 00:41:01collectively redefining the terms of our
- 00:41:04social contracts is an epical task that
- 00:41:07binds the substantial challenges of the
- 00:41:09present moments to the hopes of the
- 00:41:10future this is cloud Schwab's book as
- 00:41:12Henry Kissinger reminded us the historic
- 00:41:14challenge for leaders is to manage the
- 00:41:17crisis while building the future failure
- 00:41:19could set the world on fire
- 00:41:21that's kind of happening right maybe
- 00:41:23they're failing take hope
- 00:41:25while reflecting on the Contours we
- 00:41:27think a future social contract might
- 00:41:29follow we ignored or Peril the opinion
- 00:41:31of the younger generation who will be
- 00:41:33asked to live with it their adherence is
- 00:41:36decisive and thus to better understand
- 00:41:38what they want we must not forget to
- 00:41:40listen this is all the more significant
- 00:41:42because the younger generation is likely
- 00:41:44to be more radical in its demands in the
- 00:41:46refashioning of our social contract so
- 00:41:50the goal of social emotional learning is
- 00:41:51to get the young people to demand a new
- 00:41:53world order
- 00:41:55the goal of them is to build at the
- 00:41:58public-private partnership level the new
- 00:42:00world order that they're going to demand
- 00:42:01in other words they're capturing Supply
- 00:42:03that's them and they're building demand
- 00:42:05in your children using social emotional
- 00:42:07learning that's what that's really about
- 00:42:09this is what you would call if you were
- 00:42:11a Marxist analysis or analyst a
- 00:42:14two-headed Vanguard or a two-pronged
- 00:42:16Vanguard movement Schwabs Marxism is a
- 00:42:19Vanguard movement in other words you
- 00:42:20have an elite class that moves it along
- 00:42:22for the proletariat that won't do it
- 00:42:23itself and it has two prongs a top-down
- 00:42:27Lenin style public-private partnership
- 00:42:29and a bottom-up youth-driven cultural
- 00:42:31revolution movement
- 00:42:33whose vital needs have been reorganized
- 00:42:36by social emotional learning and the
- 00:42:38purpose is to make the world ESG and
- 00:42:41sustainable development goals compliant
- 00:42:43in both the supply and demand dimensions
- 00:42:45in other words to build the new world
- 00:42:47that's the supply and find the people
- 00:42:49who will fill it that's the demand at
- 00:42:51the same time and then to snap the Trap
- 00:42:54into the great reset into a new world
- 00:42:57that's what the agenda is the two heads
- 00:43:00of the snake the two hearts the Beast or
- 00:43:02whatever metaphor you want to use are
- 00:43:04ESG and social emotional learning if you
- 00:43:07want to end the Tyranny you bomb them
- 00:43:10both repeatedly you target the
- 00:43:11foundations and those are the two
- 00:43:13foundations
- 00:43:14SEL is particularly vulnerable to a
- 00:43:17number of things you don't have to
- 00:43:18despair SEO is particularly vulnerable
- 00:43:20that if you find ways to legislate
- 00:43:22against data mining children they're
- 00:43:23screwed
- 00:43:25doesn't take that much
- 00:43:26you find ways to legislate against a
- 00:43:28psychological and emotional manipulation
- 00:43:30of children by non-professionals in
- 00:43:32uncontrolled non-therapeutic
- 00:43:34environments they can't do it
- 00:43:37you attack SEL for what it really is
- 00:43:40you dismantle the bottom-up part of the
- 00:43:42program ESG is also fragile you don't
- 00:43:45need that many corporate leaders to
- 00:43:46start flipping on this to say what it
- 00:43:48really is to say that it's a cartel
- 00:43:50that's running a racketeering scheme you
- 00:43:53have State Attorneys General you have
- 00:43:54state treasurers now West Virginia Utah
- 00:43:57Kentucky Florida speaking up already in
- 00:43:59these terms Senators Tom Cotton has
- 00:44:01spoken out explicitly calling it a
- 00:44:03racketeering cartel
- 00:44:05these two things are the basis
- 00:44:07everybody's like what do we do what do
- 00:44:09we do what do we do I can tell you not
- 00:44:11nearly enough people have realized that
- 00:44:13the foundation of their whole program is
- 00:44:16under two acronyms ESG and SEL
- 00:44:21en either one of them and it's like
- 00:44:23cutting one of their legs off ruin them
- 00:44:25both and they're going nowhere if you
- 00:44:27want a third acronym it's sdg which is
- 00:44:29sustainable development goals and that's
- 00:44:31the United Nations several of the ties
- 00:44:33from more Nations to the United Nations
- 00:44:34this thing starts collapsing like
- 00:44:36dominoes get a president in the White
- 00:44:39House who says we're pulling out of the
- 00:44:40United Nations we're not doing it
- 00:44:42anymore we're defunding our portion of
- 00:44:44the United Nations you defang this snake
- 00:44:46tremendously there are tremendous
- 00:44:48vulnerabilities in their plan they
- 00:44:49depend on a lot of people never figuring
- 00:44:51it out as I often say every Communist
- 00:44:54Revolution has in common the same thing
- 00:44:55that the people who were put through it
- 00:44:58figured out what was happening one day
- 00:45:00too late
- 00:45:02you figure it out ahead of time you bomb
- 00:45:04these foundations and you it's
- 00:45:06incredibly fragile this all can be
- 00:45:09stopped you don't have to despair I do
- 00:45:11want to point out though that this has a
- 00:45:12long trajectory you know I like to do
- 00:45:14the historical thing so let's read what
- 00:45:16Marcus was talking about this is what
- 00:45:17SEL is designed to facilitate it took
- 00:45:20him a long time to get to it this is an
- 00:45:21essay on Liberation in 1969
- 00:45:24this is the part about the biological
- 00:45:26foundation for socialism it's a couple
- 00:45:27of paragraphs the Advent he says of a
- 00:45:29free society would be characterized by
- 00:45:31the fact that the growth of well-being
- 00:45:33turns into an essentially new quality of
- 00:45:35life
- 00:45:36this qualitative change must occur in
- 00:45:39the needs in the infrastructure of man
- 00:45:42itself a dimension of the infrastructure
- 00:45:44of society man creates Society creates
- 00:45:46man creates Society by the Praxis and
- 00:45:48inversion of Praxis wheel of Marxism
- 00:45:50which is like a circular human economy
- 00:45:54the New Direction the new institutions
- 00:45:56and relationships of production must
- 00:45:58Express the ascent of needs and
- 00:45:59satisfactions very different from an
- 00:46:02even antagonistic to those prevalent and
- 00:46:04the exploitative societies what does it
- 00:46:07mean we need to have these new
- 00:46:08sustainable institutions
- 00:46:11everything has to be geared toward ESG
- 00:46:13something fundamentally different and
- 00:46:15antagonistic to what we have been doing
- 00:46:17we don't need shareholder economy
- 00:46:18anymore we need stakeholder capitalism
- 00:46:21instead
- 00:46:23such a change would constitute the
- 00:46:25instinctual basis for Freedom which the
- 00:46:28long history of class Society has
- 00:46:29blocked
- 00:46:31Freedom would become the environment of
- 00:46:32an organism which is no longer capable
- 00:46:34of adapting to the competitive
- 00:46:36performances required for well-being
- 00:46:38under domination what did I tell you the
- 00:46:40point of critical theory is to make it
- 00:46:42so that people who have fallen into its
- 00:46:45trap can not adapt to a
- 00:46:49competition-driven environment they have
- 00:46:52to be in a culture of dependency they
- 00:46:55have to be taken care of they don't know
- 00:46:57how to live in a world that doesn't
- 00:46:59service them
- 00:47:00it's for inducing the psychological
- 00:47:03profile of somebody who doesn't know how
- 00:47:05to be an adult
- 00:47:07who's psychologically and emotionally
- 00:47:09broken
- 00:47:12of an organism which is no longer
- 00:47:13capable of tolerating the aggressiveness
- 00:47:16brutality and ugliness of the
- 00:47:18established way of life the Rebellion
- 00:47:20would then have taken root in the very
- 00:47:23nature the biology of the individual and
- 00:47:26on these new grounds the rebels would
- 00:47:28redefine the objectives and the strategy
- 00:47:30of the political struggle in which alone
- 00:47:32the concrete goals of Liberation can be
- 00:47:34determined
- 00:47:36it's almost like these things fit right
- 00:47:39together
- 00:47:40like the big spoon and the little spoon
- 00:47:42skipping a paragraph for the world of
- 00:47:45human Freedom cannot be built by the
- 00:47:46established societies
- 00:47:48we need a whole new system
- 00:47:50no matter how much they may streamline
- 00:47:52and rationalize their Dominion
- 00:47:55the modernizing church isn't enough we
- 00:47:57have to have a prophetic Church
- 00:47:59their class structure and the perfected
- 00:48:02controls required to sustain it to
- 00:48:04generate needs satisfactions and values
- 00:48:06which reproduce the servitude of the
- 00:48:09human existence we have to get
- 00:48:10completely outside of the existing
- 00:48:11system we need a whole new social
- 00:48:13contract which provides a new
- 00:48:14sensibility a new way of thinking about
- 00:48:16the world
- 00:48:17this voluntary servitude voluntary in as
- 00:48:20much as it is interjected into the
- 00:48:22individual you've been brainwashed by
- 00:48:24Society to think you have to live this
- 00:48:25way which is secretly in servitude that
- 00:48:27you don't recognize
- 00:48:29this voluntary servitude which justifies
- 00:48:31the benevolent Masters
- 00:48:33can be broken only through a political
- 00:48:35practice which reaches the roots of
- 00:48:37containment and contentment in the
- 00:48:40infrastructure of man
- 00:48:41you have to make people unstable you
- 00:48:44have to destabilize them they cannot be
- 00:48:45content you have to break that
- 00:48:49a political practice of methodological
- 00:48:52disengagement from and refusal of the
- 00:48:54establishment aiming at a radical
- 00:48:56transvaluation of values
- 00:48:58such a practice involves a break with
- 00:49:01the familiar the routine ways of seeing
- 00:49:03hearing feeling understanding things so
- 00:49:06that the uh the organism may become
- 00:49:08receptive to the potential forms of a
- 00:49:11non-aggressive
- 00:49:13non-exploitative world
- 00:49:15this is where he says what you need is a
- 00:49:17new sensibility people need a new
- 00:49:19reality to live in with a new
- 00:49:21rationality to understand it with new
- 00:49:23values to be interjected into the bio
- 00:49:25biological Foundation of who they are so
- 00:49:28that they adopt a new sensibility about
- 00:49:29how life should be what is that new
- 00:49:31Sensibility
- 00:49:32sustainability
- 00:49:35we have to live in a sustainable way
- 00:49:36everything has to be sustainable if it's
- 00:49:39not sustainable it's unsustainable and
- 00:49:40that's going to be an existential crisis
- 00:49:43the new sensibility the tyranny of the
- 00:49:4521st century is sustainability
- 00:49:48a total sustainability mindset for a
- 00:49:51sustainable and inclusive future so
- 00:49:52sustainability and inclusivity are the
- 00:49:54two pillars and that's your
- 00:49:56environmental and your Social and then
- 00:49:58governance is how you're going to manage
- 00:49:59that there's your ESG presaged here in
- 00:50:03Herbert Marcus in 1969.
- 00:50:06how do you get these new values these
- 00:50:09new sensibility this new rationality
- 00:50:10into the in the Rebellion the refusal
- 00:50:13into the very biological vital needs of
- 00:50:15the people in other words into their
- 00:50:17psychology how do you destabilize them
- 00:50:18to not be able to live in a world other
- 00:50:20than this
- 00:50:21social emotional learning particularly
- 00:50:26transformative social emotional learning
- 00:50:28T Cell as it's sometimes abbreviated
- 00:50:30trans cell as it sometimes appears so
- 00:50:34what is sel and how does it work now you
- 00:50:36know what it's for
- 00:50:38and it ain't anything good and it ain't
- 00:50:40the well-being of your kids
- 00:50:42what is it I'm going to turn first to
- 00:50:44give you an unfortunate answer from a
- 00:50:47wonderful researcher by the name of
- 00:50:48Jennifer McWilliams who digs into these
- 00:50:51things she's one of the so-called
- 00:50:52hashtag expel SEL Crusaders on the
- 00:50:55internet brilliant researcher
- 00:50:58and she actually traces the origins of
- 00:51:01the castle organization the
- 00:51:02collaborative for academic and social
- 00:51:04emotional learning
- 00:51:05uh to a project at the Fetzer
- 00:51:09Institute which was founded by John
- 00:51:10Fetzer who is a new age spiritualist
- 00:51:13in case you wondered if this was really
- 00:51:15religious it's all focused on
- 00:51:17mindfulness and all of these new values
- 00:51:19the trans valuation of values that
- 00:51:21you're going to bring in
- 00:51:23and what the Fetzer Institute was
- 00:51:24actually geared toward was figuring out
- 00:51:26ways to develop the spiritual and moral
- 00:51:28attitudes and views of people especially
- 00:51:31children
- 00:51:33so social emotional learning grew up
- 00:51:34within a new age religious cult
- 00:51:36environment
- 00:51:38that's where Castle came anyway social
- 00:51:40emotional learning didn't actually start
- 00:51:42there but it got co-opted into that
- 00:51:43castle by the way we'll talk more about
- 00:51:45that in a minute Castle is the by far
- 00:51:47the leading Organization for social
- 00:51:50emotional learning and no matter how
- 00:51:52often I look at their website and poke
- 00:51:54around on their website I feel like I
- 00:51:55just opened another rabbit hole and
- 00:51:57another Rabbit Hole in another Rabbit
- 00:51:58Hole I came here the other night and we
- 00:52:00were going to get a drink the night
- 00:52:01before the conference we're going to go
- 00:52:03down and relax a day finally and I ended
- 00:52:06up in my room I didn't even see the text
- 00:52:07messages because I wanted the castle
- 00:52:09website to see if I need to flush any of
- 00:52:11this out and end up in a rabbit hole of
- 00:52:12an 82-page document another 12-page
- 00:52:14document and all this document after
- 00:52:16document after document the Communists
- 00:52:18never sleep they just publish publish
- 00:52:19and publish documents and guidance Etc
- 00:52:22et cetera it's unbelievable if you go
- 00:52:24spend time on their site it is huge but
- 00:52:27it turns out it started as basically a
- 00:52:29new age cult for how you change values
- 00:52:32into kind of a new hippie spiritualism
- 00:52:34and it collected up what had already
- 00:52:37kind of started in a broader social
- 00:52:40emotional learning experiment that was
- 00:52:42happening in education here and there
- 00:52:44for reasons that aren't entirely bad as
- 00:52:46it turns out
- 00:52:47and that's where we have to turn to the
- 00:52:49fact that the reason you're struggling
- 00:52:51besides if you hadn't heard of it to
- 00:52:53combat SEL and you go and you talk to
- 00:52:55your lawmakers or you go and talk to I
- 00:52:57don't know the Governor of Oklahoma and
- 00:52:59find out that his wife is implementing a
- 00:53:01SEL program in the state of Oklahoma and
- 00:53:03they say no this one's good
- 00:53:05the thing is there's a lot of things
- 00:53:06passing under the name of SEL and there
- 00:53:08literally are a lot of things they are
- 00:53:11actually different
- 00:53:12they're actually different the one in
- 00:53:14Oklahoma it turns out
- 00:53:15pushed by Governor stitt's wife is based
- 00:53:18in Christian principles and it targets
- 00:53:20things in a particular way there are
- 00:53:22many things they're not all the Marxist
- 00:53:24transformative social emotional learning
- 00:53:25being described in these white papers
- 00:53:27and with these projects and the psycho
- 00:53:28data and all of this they don't have to
- 00:53:30be that way they didn't start that way
- 00:53:32so there's a huge bait and switch going
- 00:53:34on with social emotional learning
- 00:53:35there's a lot of things in fact they
- 00:53:38claim that there's all this data that it
- 00:53:39has like an 11 to 1 return on investment
- 00:53:41for every dollar spent on social
- 00:53:43emotional learning you get 11 in
- 00:53:45economic success and output out of the
- 00:53:48students that graduate with a social
- 00:53:49emotional learning program now they
- 00:53:51don't tell you what the ratio is for
- 00:53:53people who didn't go through
- 00:53:54indoctrination or they just tell you
- 00:53:55it's 11-1 investment maybe there's a
- 00:53:57different program that's a 21 to 1
- 00:53:59investment I don't know I'm not saying
- 00:54:00that there is but they don't tell you
- 00:54:02that they just say there's an 11 to 1.
- 00:54:03sounds great let's go and that is one of
- 00:54:06the things that they base it on they say
- 00:54:07look at this meta-analysis we did in
- 00:54:082011 well it's great stuff these
- 00:54:11outcomes all these different good things
- 00:54:13happen so hey social emotional learning
- 00:54:15is Gen generally pretty good they don't
- 00:54:18bother to tell you for example that
- 00:54:20transformative social emotional learning
- 00:54:21really came on the scene in 2016 and 17.
- 00:54:24so they're basing it on studies done
- 00:54:25before 2011 to tell you the thing
- 00:54:27they're selling you that was developed
- 00:54:28in 2017 is good which they have no
- 00:54:31studies on zero studies on whether or
- 00:54:33not that works
- 00:54:35has the same name must be the same who
- 00:54:37would do that well a deceiver with a
- 00:54:38capital D
- 00:54:41so if you read any of these studies you
- 00:54:44know babies are racist you've seen this
- 00:54:45like at three months old they're racist
- 00:54:47you ever read the study justifying that
- 00:54:48complete crap
- 00:54:50complete crap it's the basis for so much
- 00:54:52stuff anti-racist baby raise your
- 00:54:54children anti-racist whatever it is all
- 00:54:56these books that's because children are
- 00:54:58racist by the time they're three months
- 00:54:59old how do they know that well they did
- 00:55:00one study where they dragged some babies
- 00:55:02and their mothers in I guess they just
- 00:55:04drag the mothers in with their babies
- 00:55:05they brought them in and the mothers
- 00:55:07something like 10 or 12 or 18 I think
- 00:55:09it's 18 of them holding the all white
- 00:55:12mothers all with white babies holding
- 00:55:14their babies holding their babies close
- 00:55:15to their chest and up on the big screens
- 00:55:17there are four faces one's white one's
- 00:55:19East Asian one's Middle Eastern and
- 00:55:21one's black and then babies being three
- 00:55:23months old do this kind of thing
- 00:55:26and they track how long their eyes
- 00:55:28lingered on the different images on the
- 00:55:30screen
- 00:55:31and however long it is that's what the
- 00:55:34babies prefer and it turned out that as
- 00:55:36the data showed remember they're all
- 00:55:37white babies with all white mothers
- 00:55:39their eyes lingered longest her shortest
- 00:55:42I should say we'll do it that way
- 00:55:43shortest on the Black Faces next
- 00:55:45shortest on the
- 00:55:47um Middle Eastern faces and
- 00:55:49statistically equally on the East Asian
- 00:55:52and white faces so this means that
- 00:55:54babies prefer white face white babies
- 00:55:56prefer white faces as couldn't possibly
- 00:55:59have anything to do with looks more like
- 00:56:00Mom at three months old
- 00:56:03because they didn't use anybody else
- 00:56:05couldn't possibly be that this is the
- 00:56:07study upon which that entire claim is
- 00:56:09based that babies are racist so we need
- 00:56:11an entire Pre-K intervention SEL for
- 00:56:13infants Etc to overcome your racist
- 00:56:16babies
- 00:56:17who would do that you just completely
- 00:56:19crap in bogus studies in order to
- 00:56:20justify gigantic policy implementation
- 00:56:22at the tune of billions and billions of
- 00:56:24dollars let me give you a hint
- 00:56:25communists
- 00:56:28that's who would do that that's who
- 00:56:29would lie about the evidence so that
- 00:56:31they could justify whatever it is they
- 00:56:32want to do
- 00:56:33and in every paper I've ever read
- 00:56:35invoking that study every single one
- 00:56:37they misrepresent the findings and never
- 00:56:39mention the fact that even in the paper
- 00:56:40like this is severely limited we can't
- 00:56:42really draw any significant conclusions
- 00:56:43they never even mentioned the fact that
- 00:56:45the babies gazed at the East Asian and
- 00:56:47white faces for the same amount of time
- 00:56:48they never mention it they prefer
- 00:56:50light-skinned faces to dark skin faces
- 00:56:52the end racist baby
- 00:56:54[Music]
- 00:56:55probably can't even focus its eyes at
- 00:56:59three months it probably can't seem more
- 00:57:01than like shadowy blobs
- 00:57:04racist baby
- 00:57:06that's the science folks that is the
- 00:57:09science
- 00:57:11so there are a lot of things called
- 00:57:13social emotional learning and the
- 00:57:14studies actually don't justify the thing
- 00:57:16they're selling there's a bait and
- 00:57:18switch happening they're telling you
- 00:57:19this is all this evidence saying this is
- 00:57:21so important and there's not even that
- 00:57:22much of it but there's a couple of like
- 00:57:24kind of groundbreaking meta-analyzes so
- 00:57:26therefore it's great here's how much you
- 00:57:28know how great it is quick remake all of
- 00:57:31education at every level everywhere to
- 00:57:34the tune of billions and billions of
- 00:57:36dollars based on a very small number of
- 00:57:38poorly done studies that are
- 00:57:41misinterpreted who would do that
- 00:57:43Communists would do that
- 00:57:46and the thing is is what they're selling
- 00:57:48now is transformative social emotional
- 00:57:50learning primarily Castle only sells
- 00:57:52transformative social emotional learning
- 00:57:53look it up what is it about focus on
- 00:57:55Equity raising critical Consciousness
- 00:57:57they tell you explicitly what it's about
- 00:57:58that's what it's for that's explicitly
- 00:58:01what it's for it's for consientization
- 00:58:04it's not the older programs that they
- 00:58:06were looking back to that we'll talk
- 00:58:07about here in a little bit
- 00:58:10there's another bait and switch that's
- 00:58:12actually happening here though this is
- 00:58:14another one I just learned about this
- 00:58:15the other day this is shocking I think
- 00:58:18things are going to start coming out
- 00:58:19about this soon I don't want to say it's
- 00:58:20embargoed but we're in a room by the
- 00:58:22time the videos come out it will not be
- 00:58:23embargoed but you know don't go running
- 00:58:26with the story somebody's trying to work
- 00:58:27on it but I'll tell you now
- 00:58:30everywhere you keep hearing College and
- 00:58:32Career Readiness I keep bringing that up
- 00:58:33College and Career Readiness imagine
- 00:58:35what would a Marxist do with a term like
- 00:58:36College and Career Readiness well they
- 00:58:38just freaking redefine it wouldn't they
- 00:58:39to their purposes so what makes a person
- 00:58:41College and Career ready for being SEL
- 00:58:43competency compliant they list a bunch
- 00:58:46of competencies the world economic Forum
- 00:58:48gives like 18 Castle list five core
- 00:58:50competencies with sub-competencies
- 00:58:51within them if you are not those you're
- 00:58:55not College and Career ready according
- 00:58:56to the new definition of what makes you
- 00:58:58College and Career ready so you're at
- 00:59:00risk of graduating not College and
- 00:59:02Career ready so now you have every
- 00:59:04student because every student because
- 00:59:05they're just changing this right now is
- 00:59:07at risk of not being College and Career
- 00:59:09ready by the time they're at graduation
- 00:59:10they're at risk so you've redefined at
- 00:59:12risk to mean something like I don't know
- 00:59:14you're in a terrible neighborhood you
- 00:59:15have a bad home you're getting abused
- 00:59:17blah blah what we think of as an at-risk
- 00:59:19child that we justify you know taking
- 00:59:22steps to help them under things like
- 00:59:24Title One and so on
- 00:59:26to all the kids
- 00:59:28and these at-risk kids qualify the
- 00:59:30school every at-risk child qualifies the
- 00:59:32school to claim various federal dollars
- 00:59:35in education under Esser funding for
- 00:59:37example within say the cares act that's
- 00:59:39like covert relief money or within Title
- 00:59:43One monies that are distributed to
- 00:59:45schools every at-risk kid is worth so
- 00:59:46much money and so now you can just
- 00:59:48redefine at risk to mean not SEL
- 00:59:50compliant or not SEL competent and every
- 00:59:53kid is at risk and because every kid is
- 00:59:55at risk the school gets a boatload of
- 00:59:56money and the point of it is to
- 00:59:58implement SEL there's a bait and switch
- 01:00:00happening there too they're actually
- 01:00:02stealing education it's no longer about
- 01:00:04educating your kids to be academically
- 01:00:06competent it's about making them SEL
- 01:00:07compliant or ESG compliant as it were
- 01:00:10SEL competent they have their
- 01:00:12competencies
- 01:00:14at the very bottom though what is social
- 01:00:16emotional learning it is psychological
- 01:00:18and sociological programming of children
- 01:00:21through what looks like education it's
- 01:00:24performed primarily by teachers who've
- 01:00:27gone through a few weeks of training
- 01:00:28because they're forced to a few of them
- 01:00:30are all into it a lot of them think it
- 01:00:31sounds good many of them don't really
- 01:00:33know about all this but they are
- 01:00:35unqualified
- 01:00:37unlicensed not professionals performing
- 01:00:41psychological and sociological like
- 01:00:43Social Work psychological like therapy
- 01:00:45sessions in no license no professional
- 01:00:49qualifications in uncontrolled
- 01:00:51non-therapeutic spaces in front of
- 01:00:52groups of children
- 01:00:55the people that are making them
- 01:00:57implement this the people who think it's
- 01:00:58a good idea belong in prison that is
- 01:01:00psychological child abuse
- 01:01:02they have no right they have no
- 01:01:04qualification they are not in a space to
- 01:01:07be engaging with that if you actually do
- 01:01:09have at risk or damaged children you
- 01:01:11don't know what you're unearthing and
- 01:01:12you're not in an environment to deal
- 01:01:13with it when it comes up
- 01:01:15social emotional learning has literally
- 01:01:17no place
- 01:01:18the question that we have to keep
- 01:01:20thinking about is should the schools be
- 01:01:21doing this
- 01:01:22and the answer is no it's not the
- 01:01:24school's job it is not the school's job
- 01:01:26to do this well how do they justify
- 01:01:28doing it well because a few kids will
- 01:01:30follow through cracks if the school
- 01:01:31doesn't and then they leap from there
- 01:01:33and another yet another bait and switch
- 01:01:35well a few kids are going to fall
- 01:01:36through the cracks there's your Mott if
- 01:01:38you will with the Mott and Bailey and
- 01:01:39what's the Bailey well we actually need
- 01:01:41to do this for the better man of every
- 01:01:43child it's not actually about catching a
- 01:01:45few kids are going to fall through the
- 01:01:46cracks we don't know who might fall
- 01:01:47through the crack so we're going to do
- 01:01:48it to everybody and what that turns into
- 01:01:50is we know how to raise your child
- 01:01:52better than you do
- 01:01:53in fact it's better to think of these
- 01:01:55children as our children as words of the
- 01:01:58state and that the parents are the
- 01:02:01obstacle the parents are the threat the
- 01:02:03parents are the problem and you see that
- 01:02:05communist attempt to sever one
- 01:02:07generation from the previous to break
- 01:02:09apart the the institution of the family
- 01:02:11again the people implementing this on
- 01:02:14purpose who know what they're doing
- 01:02:15belong in prison I make no apologies for
- 01:02:18saying that I do not think other than
- 01:02:20that I have no compassion for this if
- 01:02:22they know what they're doing and
- 01:02:23implementing this they belong in prison
- 01:02:25is not their role
- 01:02:27it is absolutely not their role
- 01:02:30but this is how they get you as they say
- 01:02:34so in practice what is social emotional
- 01:02:36learning involve it involves data mining
- 01:02:39they're on their little apps they're
- 01:02:41talking to their their AI guy they're
- 01:02:42wearing a heart monitor or whatever it
- 01:02:44happens to be that's the high-tech
- 01:02:45version they're engaging in these
- 01:02:47dialogues endless dialogues filling out
- 01:02:50endless surveys so many surveys the
- 01:02:53surveys are required by the way you want
- 01:02:55to as I said just the other just a few
- 01:02:57minutes ago also the other day it turns
- 01:02:59out that there is a huge fragility to
- 01:03:02the whole SEL program it is called the
- 01:03:04every student succeeds act Essa
- 01:03:07why are they having to collect so much
- 01:03:09damn data through all these surveys
- 01:03:10because Essa requires them to report on
- 01:03:13non-academic competencies at least in
- 01:03:15one domain and here's Castle to fill the
- 01:03:17need immediately here's Panorama to come
- 01:03:19in and fill the need immediately so that
- 01:03:21they can very easily in a very
- 01:03:23streamlined fashion use SEL as the tool
- 01:03:25that require that that required
- 01:03:27reporting can come back to that's what
- 01:03:29it is you repeal Essa or even reform
- 01:03:32Essa you get your legislators in
- 01:03:34Congress to think about that and do that
- 01:03:36and care about that you get rid of Essa
- 01:03:38you break so much of this
- 01:03:41that's why this is happening there was
- 01:03:43an act in 2015 who was president in
- 01:03:452015. thanks Obama
- 01:03:50Data Mining and what do they do with the
- 01:03:51data besides apparently
- 01:03:53creating generative themes for the
- 01:03:55Friday and education method that we're
- 01:03:57focusing on in this Workshop we already
- 01:03:59read from Ben Williamson that they're
- 01:04:00using it to gather data to make economic
- 01:04:03forecasts and new protocols for
- 01:04:06governance of individuals
- 01:04:09in other words to build social credit
- 01:04:10and marketing profiles for your children
- 01:04:12the goal that it's going to be hard to
- 01:04:14get you to have a social credit profile
- 01:04:16tricky they need to get like a magic
- 01:04:19juice pass or something that said that
- 01:04:21you're up to date on your your medicine
- 01:04:22or your maybe you know different things
- 01:04:24hard to get an adult just build it from
- 01:04:25the ground up with the kids
- 01:04:27the profile's already there all you have
- 01:04:29to do is snap your fingers and fire off
- 01:04:31the uh
- 01:04:33digital ID program connected to whatever
- 01:04:35their outcomes and their portrait of a
- 01:04:37graduate or whatever it happens to be is
- 01:04:39by the time they graduate and they have
- 01:04:40a ready-made social credit profile that
- 01:04:42all you have to do is turn it on and
- 01:04:43turn it off whenever you're ready
- 01:04:45that's what that's about what is a
- 01:04:48social credit score work out to Absolute
- 01:04:50tyrannical control of the most
- 01:04:52sophisticated type that Humanity has so
- 01:04:54far devised it's not impossible to break
- 01:04:56out of but it's very difficult to break
- 01:04:58out of especially when you start using
- 01:05:00algorithmic advertising and
- 01:05:01propagandizing so that people don't even
- 01:05:03realize that they're trapped in this now
- 01:05:05we see cracks in that system where it's
- 01:05:06being tested in China and people are
- 01:05:08starting to rise up in a little bit and
- 01:05:10it's not quite containing them as well
- 01:05:12as they'd hoped it would the human
- 01:05:13Spirit turns out to be pretty awesome
- 01:05:15but it is the most sophisticated
- 01:05:18mechanism of social control possible and
- 01:05:20we know that that in addition to finding
- 01:05:22Freudian generative themes that they can
- 01:05:24use to radicalize your children or
- 01:05:26manipulate your children for economic
- 01:05:27and government ends that that's one of
- 01:05:29the things that they're interested in
- 01:05:31doing
- 01:05:33they want to use that to bring the so we
- 01:05:36have the Gathering of generative themes
- 01:05:38through data mining surveying whatever
- 01:05:40and then they want to bring those things
- 01:05:42back as the core competencies and lesson
- 01:05:44plans in other words they want to
- 01:05:46educate your children on social and
- 01:05:48emotional engagement issues
- 01:05:51from within those themes which should
- 01:05:52sound an awful lot like Ferrari's
- 01:05:54codification decodification program so
- 01:05:56we got data mine for generative themes
- 01:05:58use those to model the necessary social
- 01:06:00emotional learning objectives to correct
- 01:06:02the social emotional learning problems
- 01:06:04that they discover in the children to
- 01:06:06present those through codification
- 01:06:07decodification in other words to guide
- 01:06:09them to the correct the so-called
- 01:06:11correct answers about social and
- 01:06:14emotional questions that they're being
- 01:06:15presented with often in age-appropriate
- 01:06:17age inappropriate fashions
- 01:06:21and then you do this in order to have
- 01:06:24psychologically and so Social Work style
- 01:06:26sociologically infused instruction that
- 01:06:28explores those themes
- 01:06:30that's the actual process of social
- 01:06:32emotional learning we've already seen
- 01:06:33that that basically boils down to
- 01:06:35thought reform
- 01:06:38so I come back again to the lingering
- 01:06:40question the looming question behind all
- 01:06:42of this is it a school's role to do this
- 01:06:46and the answer should be unambiguously
- 01:06:49no parental rights legislation that says
- 01:06:52that it is not the school's role to do
- 01:06:53any of this is needed the idea of such
- 01:06:56expertise that our teachers and school
- 01:06:58administrators and wonderful Department
- 01:07:00of Education employees know better than
- 01:07:03parents
- 01:07:04has to go
- 01:07:06they don't
- 01:07:07the primary stakeholder in any child's
- 01:07:09life is their parent
- 01:07:11period
- 01:07:12not a school administrator even when the
- 01:07:15kids are falling through the cracks and
- 01:07:17what you could do as an alternative just
- 01:07:19like there's an alternative to this
- 01:07:20whole environmental crisis that there's
- 01:07:21nothing to do about so we all have to
- 01:07:22starve and have and have electric cars
- 01:07:24that we can't afford just like there's
- 01:07:25this thing called nuclear power we're
- 01:07:27not allowed to talk about
- 01:07:28you know there's like black identities
- 01:07:30and green identities well they're sorry
- 01:07:32blackadines and redis well there's green
- 01:07:34energy and black energy right and
- 01:07:36nuclear is oddly considered a black well
- 01:07:37just like the solution there's a
- 01:07:38solution here
- 01:07:40you can it turns out Target individual
- 01:07:42kids who are falling through the cracks
- 01:07:43and deal with them in separate
- 01:07:44situations programs or whatever it
- 01:07:46happens to be whether it's a run by the
- 01:07:47state that's an open question about how
- 01:07:49we want to debate these things and how
- 01:07:50we're going to solve those problems but
- 01:07:51you don't have to Blink it you don't
- 01:07:52have to carpet bomb all the kids with it
- 01:07:53there's some other agenda at play it
- 01:07:55makes no sense to do that makes
- 01:07:57absolutely no sense to do that
- 01:08:00so should we be doing this for any kids
- 01:08:01the at-risk kids maybe but the question
- 01:08:04is how should we be doing it for all
- 01:08:06kids definitely not it's not their job
- 01:08:09it's not their role they're not
- 01:08:10qualified they shouldn't be doing it it
- 01:08:11should be illegal as a matter of fact I
- 01:08:13keep saying prison
- 01:08:14but the way they got there is by
- 01:08:15changing the definition of at risk
- 01:08:17they're at risk because of covid they're
- 01:08:19at risk because the learning loss are at
- 01:08:20risk because they're not going to be
- 01:08:21socially and emotionally competent by
- 01:08:23the time they graduate they're at risk
- 01:08:25of not being College and Career ready
- 01:08:26therefore and then that ties into the
- 01:08:29rivers of federal money so another huge
- 01:08:31vulnerability here is that you cut off
- 01:08:33the access to Federal money that has any
- 01:08:36string tied to it not just any federal
- 01:08:38money I mean if you listen to say Betsy
- 01:08:40Doss for example she has this whole
- 01:08:41concept former department or former
- 01:08:44former Secretary of Education under
- 01:08:45Trump she has this whole idea that maybe
- 01:08:47maybe the federal doe would be best
- 01:08:50suited to just deliver block grants
- 01:08:53right we figure out an apportioning
- 01:08:56scheme by population or something the
- 01:08:58federal government gives State
- 01:08:59Departments of Education money and has
- 01:09:01no say whatsoever and what the states do
- 01:09:03with it that's a possibility you cut
- 01:09:04that Federal money string tying right
- 01:09:06off you cut the ties to the United
- 01:09:09Nations unless a state wants to go
- 01:09:11straight up with the United Nations from
- 01:09:13the federal level that's very powerful
- 01:09:15tool there are things that can be done
- 01:09:17here
- 01:09:18that's a definite option that people
- 01:09:20should be looking at cutting all of
- 01:09:22those strings at that level is a
- 01:09:24definite thing that we should be looking
- 01:09:25at those strings are the problem those
- 01:09:27strings are the threat looking at the
- 01:09:29teachers unions that's a huge thing
- 01:09:31those are gigantic National
- 01:09:32organizations but it turns out they are
- 01:09:33also not National organizations they're
- 01:09:36tied into something virtually no
- 01:09:37American has heard of called education
- 01:09:39International which is a International
- 01:09:42IST
- 01:09:44teachers union
- 01:09:45that's tied into all the United Nations
- 01:09:47crap and they're the ones creating the
- 01:09:50pipelines down in the teachers union so
- 01:09:51make sure the teachers unions funnel it
- 01:09:52all into the schools severing those ties
- 01:09:55weakens this entire program and we could
- 01:09:57actually rescue the public schools I
- 01:10:00think that the public schools will
- 01:10:01actually be everybody wants to go into
- 01:10:03the market logic I think the public
- 01:10:04schools are easier to rescue than the
- 01:10:06private schools
- 01:10:07private schools can tell you to
- 01:10:08basically go f yourself and get out of
- 01:10:10the school and give you no service
- 01:10:11whatsoever you show up at a public
- 01:10:13school and start complaining somebody at
- 01:10:15least has to pretend to listen
- 01:10:17foreign
- 01:10:18just happened I was talking with my
- 01:10:20congressman in their other Congressman
- 01:10:21present and I was saying something and
- 01:10:23he kind of got distracted for a minute
- 01:10:24and they pointed at him they said Hey
- 01:10:26listen he's your constituent you have to
- 01:10:28listen to everything he says that's the
- 01:10:30idea at least maybe it doesn't always go
- 01:10:32in practice but there's leverage there
- 01:10:33we should be thinking about that
- 01:10:36so let's talk about the weird history of
- 01:10:37SEL because it is weird I mean I've
- 01:10:39obviously mentioned this weird uh
- 01:10:41spiritual New Age Fetzer Institute thing
- 01:10:44but it actually started before that
- 01:10:45guess what year social emotional
- 01:10:48learning started any guesses 1968.
- 01:10:53a lot of things happened in 1968 it's so
- 01:10:56weird you just keep running into this
- 01:10:57the first experiment in Social and
- 01:11:00emotional learning was done by a man
- 01:11:01named Dr James Comer who was at Yale
- 01:11:05he was dealing with I think it was New
- 01:11:07Haven Connecticut schools there were two
- 01:11:09particular let me give you the context
- 01:11:11before I continue you have to appreciate
- 01:11:14the 1968 was a year where we're having
- 01:11:17roiling racial tensions in the country
- 01:11:191968 is the year Martin Luther King Jr
- 01:11:22was shot
- 01:11:24assassinated this is not like
- 01:11:271995 in terms of race relations this is
- 01:11:30not like 2020 2019 in terms of race
- 01:11:34relations in this country this was a
- 01:11:36very racially uh tumultuous year the
- 01:11:40Civil Rights Acts were still brand new
- 01:11:41there were still massive disparities in
- 01:11:43terms of schools in terms of things that
- 01:11:46correlated overwhelmingly tightly
- 01:11:48probably for causal reasons with race
- 01:11:50and he's looking at two schools that
- 01:11:52were literally 99 percent black in New
- 01:11:54Haven Connecticut that were in abysmal
- 01:11:56situations and he implemented this new
- 01:12:00program to see if he could help those
- 01:12:02schools that were in tremendous risk
- 01:12:04tremendous needed tremendous help and
- 01:12:07it's described as I read an article an
- 01:12:09interview I can't find much written by
- 01:12:10James Comer actually but I found some
- 01:12:13some you know profiles written about him
- 01:12:15and is described this way in one Dr
- 01:12:17Comer has been studying the impact of
- 01:12:19social emotional development on students
- 01:12:21in school since the 1960s as the Maurice
- 01:12:24Falk professor of child psychiatry at
- 01:12:26the Yale School School of Medicine his
- 01:12:28work focuses on child development in
- 01:12:30inner city schools and the idea of
- 01:12:32educating the whole child
- 01:12:34the Comer school development program was
- 01:12:36founded in 1968 and continues to support
- 01:12:38schools promoting collaboration amongst
- 01:12:41Community stakeholders and clearing
- 01:12:43Pathways to higher education so in some
- 01:12:46sense this is where SEL started
- 01:12:48these two inner city schools in New
- 01:12:50Haven Connecticut that were in bad shape
- 01:12:51in a very racially tense year in very
- 01:12:54different social and political
- 01:12:56circumstances than we recognize today
- 01:12:59and what happened was he used very
- 01:13:01specific very specific targeted
- 01:13:03engagement and involvement in those two
- 01:13:05schools and within particular you know
- 01:13:08classrooms and individuals within those
- 01:13:09schools kind of a very Stand By Me
- 01:13:11looking kind of thing
- 01:13:12and he took this whole child approach
- 01:13:14what did that mean for Comer that meant
- 01:13:16well you can't just look at his school
- 01:13:18life the student you have to look at
- 01:13:19well what's going on at home how do we
- 01:13:21help fill in for that is he got you know
- 01:13:24is what's going on with how he's
- 01:13:25reacting to what's happening in the
- 01:13:27country around him with his huge race
- 01:13:28tension 99 black school huge racial year
- 01:13:31Martin Luther King being assassinated
- 01:13:33this is not a good year
- 01:13:34there's obviously some stress going on
- 01:13:36so let's look at the whole situation the
- 01:13:39kids in this doesn't actually fall out
- 01:13:41of making sense and what he did was he
- 01:13:43implemented this looking at the whole
- 01:13:44child mostly school life home life
- 01:13:46approach and so what kind of
- 01:13:48interventions can the school get
- 01:13:49involved in to kind of patch up the
- 01:13:50holes here I don't actually suspect that
- 01:13:52James Comer was a bad guy
- 01:13:54I think he was in his heart and head
- 01:13:56were probably in the right place I don't
- 01:13:58know maybe he's a communist I couldn't
- 01:13:59find any any proof I looked I couldn't
- 01:14:01find any proof
- 01:14:04he said I this is Comer himself in one
- 01:14:07of the interviews they did with him in a
- 01:14:08profile I began to speculate that the
- 01:14:10contrast between a child's experiences
- 01:14:12at home and those in school deeply
- 01:14:14affects the child's psychosocial
- 01:14:15development and that this in turn shapes
- 01:14:17academic achievement the contrast would
- 01:14:19be particularly sharp for poor minority
- 01:14:21children from families outside of the
- 01:14:23mainstream so you have a little bit of
- 01:14:24this kind of identity politics thinking
- 01:14:27but again we're in 1968 there's plenty
- 01:14:30of reasons to accept that that's
- 01:14:31relevant very relevant might be slightly
- 01:14:34relevant now very relevant in 1968.
- 01:14:37plenty of reason to believe that and it
- 01:14:39turns out it was fairly successful these
- 01:14:41schools in like five years had a
- 01:14:43complete turnaround went from barely
- 01:14:44graduating anybody to graduating almost
- 01:14:46everybody most of the kids I ended up
- 01:14:48going off to college
- 01:14:49completely successful it's literally
- 01:14:51like The Stand By Me story all over
- 01:14:53again in fact I don't know if that
- 01:14:54movie's based on the story or something
- 01:14:55similar to it
- 01:14:57and so
- 01:14:58this becomes very interesting
- 01:15:01maybe there is something to this maybe
- 01:15:03it matters but what you see though is
- 01:15:06that he was looking at a very specific
- 01:15:07circumstance and intervening where a
- 01:15:09specific circumstance was identifiable
- 01:15:11and using Target interventions on
- 01:15:13individual students and in individual
- 01:15:15classrooms in individual circumstances
- 01:15:17where it's necessary it wasn't carpet
- 01:15:19bombing the education system of
- 01:15:21Connecticut
- 01:15:22he was saying so there's a problem
- 01:15:24specifically here let's intervene and
- 01:15:26see what we can do about it and it had
- 01:15:28positive effects and what the research
- 01:15:30if you look at the so-called 200 or
- 01:15:31whatever it is studies that were in the
- 01:15:332011 metadata or meta-analysis if you
- 01:15:36look at what those studies show in
- 01:15:38general is that it is wildly dependent
- 01:15:40on context of the classroom context of
- 01:15:43the individual excitement and engagement
- 01:15:45of the students and the teachers as to
- 01:15:49whether or not social emotional learning
- 01:15:50produces Improvement outcomes and in
- 01:15:52particular it only seems to really work
- 01:15:54in at-risk situations which is why
- 01:15:57redefining at risk to be everybody is a
- 01:16:00big mistake if I was doing a statistics
- 01:16:02class I would talk to you about type 1
- 01:16:03and type 2 errors
- 01:16:05I do this a lot
- 01:16:07false positives and false negatives and
- 01:16:09if you try to if you focus only on the
- 01:16:11harms of one type of error and work and
- 01:16:13spend all your resources to eliminate
- 01:16:14one type of error a lot of times what
- 01:16:16happens is you generate a whole lot of
- 01:16:17the other type of error why don't we do
- 01:16:19Universal cancer screening to cure
- 01:16:21cancer turns out your body don't mean to
- 01:16:23alarm anybody is generating cancers all
- 01:16:25the time but your immune system is
- 01:16:27killing them all the time you would go
- 01:16:28for your twice yearly screening you'd
- 01:16:30find all kinds of cancers that you don't
- 01:16:32actually need to worry about that would
- 01:16:34never become a problem and you're going
- 01:16:35to get put on chemo for them which is
- 01:16:36going to make you lots of people sick
- 01:16:39it's not appropriate this is a basic
- 01:16:40thing that we actually cover when we
- 01:16:41teach statistics which I've taught so I
- 01:16:43can say it's a thing we actually cover
- 01:16:45turns out why don't we do Universal
- 01:16:47screening for diseases like AIDS or
- 01:16:49something like that or whatever
- 01:16:52or covid
- 01:16:54oh wait we did
- 01:16:56why don't you do that because it turns
- 01:16:58out the false positive rate on those
- 01:17:00tests isn't zero
- 01:17:02so what you end up doing is telling if
- 01:17:04you do Universal screening 330 million
- 01:17:06Americans if you have a five percent
- 01:17:08false positive rate you can do the
- 01:17:10multiplication
- 01:17:11just divide 330 Million by 20 in your
- 01:17:13head you're there whatever that number
- 01:17:15is that in math math speak we're there
- 01:17:17330 330 million divided by 20 done okay
- 01:17:20that's a number it's a rational number
- 01:17:22you're going to tell that many people
- 01:17:24they have AIDS when they don't
- 01:17:27imagine what that's going to do to them
- 01:17:29so by focusing on one type of problem to
- 01:17:31the complete to to complete elimination
- 01:17:34of that problem
- 01:17:36you create a massive amount of
- 01:17:38externalities of the other types of
- 01:17:40problems and so it's generally
- 01:17:42recommended that it's a terrible idea
- 01:17:45same thing here carpet bombing the
- 01:17:47schools with social emotional learning
- 01:17:49when it has some positive benefit in
- 01:17:51particular at-risk situations is a
- 01:17:53terrible idea but it also turns out to
- 01:17:55be a very lucrative grift Consultants
- 01:17:59Industries many billions of dollars will
- 01:18:03pour into this space that 2016 white
- 01:18:06paper from the world economic forum is
- 01:18:07advising tech companies
- 01:18:09PS guys there's a river of gold and
- 01:18:11building the applications that you're
- 01:18:12going to be able to sell to schools
- 01:18:14which they will be mandated by law to
- 01:18:16buy
- 01:18:17huge taxpayer grift you want money money
- 01:18:20there it is
- 01:18:22there's a huge perverse incentive to
- 01:18:25getting this wrong in certain cases and
- 01:18:27this is one of them
- 01:18:29and we come back again to the key
- 01:18:31question even if this is a good idea
- 01:18:34is it the school's job we have to keep
- 01:18:36asking that question is it the state's
- 01:18:38job when is it the state's job and when
- 01:18:40isn't it the state's job to intervene in
- 01:18:43these actually tragic cases or Beyond
- 01:18:48it turns out though this pilot study by
- 01:18:52James Comer inspired the people that
- 01:18:54went on to form Castle
- 01:18:56I guess at the Fetzer Institute
- 01:18:59Castle actually forms though quite a lot
- 01:19:02later not in 1970 or something like that
- 01:19:04but in 1994 also at Yale actually in the
- 01:19:09comer Department
- 01:19:12it actually gets its mainstreaming a
- 01:19:15year later and after a 1995 book that
- 01:19:17has now been widely debunked Daniel
- 01:19:19Goldman's book emotional intelligence oh
- 01:19:22my gosh there's so many different kinds
- 01:19:23of intelligence they're like 11 was it
- 01:19:25Howard Gardner or somebody had the 11
- 01:19:26multiple intelligences there's emotional
- 01:19:28intelligence oh my gosh well we need to
- 01:19:30Foster emotional intelligence so we'll
- 01:19:32have a more inclusive and and fair and
- 01:19:34just world and wow we have a social
- 01:19:37emotional learning program we've been
- 01:19:38experimenting with and the castle is now
- 01:19:40kind of codified uh and started to play
- 01:19:43with in 1994 just the year before and
- 01:19:45the money wheel starts turning massive
- 01:19:47best-selling book drives a fad fad blows
- 01:19:50up now that's the answer to all the
- 01:19:53problems
- 01:19:55this leads us into a person who I've
- 01:19:57been told we're not allowed to talk
- 01:19:58about also starting big in 1994.
- 01:20:01her name is Linda darling Hammond with a
- 01:20:04hyphen write her name down if you want
- 01:20:06we're not supposed to talk about her
- 01:20:08I've Been Told
- 01:20:11all right because she's an AEI fellow or
- 01:20:13something like that I don't know
- 01:20:15turns out corruption's even on your side
- 01:20:18Linda darling Hammond got in bed with
- 01:20:21Castle pretty early on actually
- 01:20:23but what she's always been focused on is
- 01:20:26social emotional learning and Equity
- 01:20:27focuses in education all the way through
- 01:20:30her entire professional career now she
- 01:20:33was tapped in 2008 by Obama's education
- 01:20:37policy transition team and facilitated
- 01:20:39that but was not put into positions of
- 01:20:42Power by Obama in the Obama
- 01:20:44administration because they brought in
- 01:20:46Arne Duncan with common core instead and
- 01:20:48according to what I read about this
- 01:20:50um they're still mad imagine how much
- 01:20:52better the world could have been if in
- 01:20:542008 we had the equity focused SEL lady
- 01:20:56put in place instead of the Common Core
- 01:20:58guy
- 01:21:00um
- 01:21:00she's also been tapped as part of
- 01:21:03Biden's education transition team in
- 01:21:052020. so she's a Democratic party
- 01:21:08darling of Education like I said her
- 01:21:10focus is equity and SEL and it always
- 01:21:13has been
- 01:21:16she was recommended to the Obama
- 01:21:17Administration by one Bill Ayers of the
- 01:21:20weatherman underground a literal
- 01:21:22freaking terrorist
- 01:21:24who one of those 60 radical 60s radicals
- 01:21:27we talked about last night
- 01:21:29where did they go after they left the
- 01:21:32streets not to Yuppie them not to the
- 01:21:34religious cults to the classroom bill of
- 01:21:36heirs weatherman underground became an
- 01:21:40education activist in the 1970s and has
- 01:21:43been ever since and it was on his
- 01:21:44recommendation that the Obama
- 01:21:46Administration said this lady is great
- 01:21:47let's put it on the transition team a
- 01:21:49literal terrorist left-wing Marxist
- 01:21:52terrorist at that
- 01:21:54in 2006 Linda darling Hammond was named
- 01:21:56one of the 10 most influential people in
- 01:21:58education which is funny that you've
- 01:22:00probably never heard her name
- 01:22:03in the administration's where she did
- 01:22:05get to work including within the castle
- 01:22:07program she pushed hard for Department
- 01:22:11of Education School accountability plans
- 01:22:14that's where we come back to Essa and
- 01:22:16the every student succeeds act which is
- 01:22:18a gigantic School accountability plan
- 01:22:20the goal was how can we gather lots more
- 01:22:23data on the schools to make sure they're
- 01:22:24doing what we want from the federal
- 01:22:26government level and we have this woman
- 01:22:29Linda darling Hammond who's an SEL
- 01:22:30Equity Advocate pushing it from the
- 01:22:33start
- 01:22:34her main agendas were to work SEL in as
- 01:22:37a means for this accountability plan and
- 01:22:40that's what SEL has become it has become
- 01:22:42one of the main ways that they can do
- 01:22:44non-academic accountability assessments
- 01:22:46and even wonderfully free states like
- 01:22:48Florida require
- 01:22:50non-academic
- 01:22:52accountability assessments usually in
- 01:22:54terms of Social and emotional outcomes
- 01:22:55of students she's also a big proponent
- 01:22:58of this other nightmare in the schools
- 01:23:00called restorative justice
- 01:23:03restorative justice means your classroom
- 01:23:06is a nightmare restorative justice means
- 01:23:08nobody gets suspended nobody gets in
- 01:23:10trouble and when somebody does get in
- 01:23:11trouble you don't document it so there's
- 01:23:13no paper trail I strongly recommend if
- 01:23:15you can find time to pick up Max Eden's
- 01:23:17book on restorative justice called how
- 01:23:20Meadow died it's about the Parkland
- 01:23:22shooting in Florida
- 01:23:24social or no sorry I don't want to blame
- 01:23:26social emotional learning I want to
- 01:23:27blame restorative justice in the
- 01:23:28inclusive classroom
- 01:23:29the kid involved I'm not going to have
- 01:23:31do a hatchet job on Max's work but the
- 01:23:33kid involved was an obvious mental
- 01:23:37illness case they kept getting put back
- 01:23:38in the class because that's inclusive
- 01:23:42you can't exclude disabled students and
- 01:23:45mental illness including literally psych
- 01:23:48literally psychopathy and saying you
- 01:23:49want to drown like into your Co your
- 01:23:53fellow students blood
- 01:23:55that you want to murder them
- 01:23:57doesn't matter you've got to put them
- 01:23:59back mainstream in the classroom to be a
- 01:24:01title one inclusive classroom that's the
- 01:24:03inclusive classroom remember we're
- 01:24:05having a sustainable and inclusive world
- 01:24:08secondly restorative justice a couple of
- 01:24:11years before the shooting they stopped
- 01:24:12recording any of his incidents of
- 01:24:15violence or threats or any of the other
- 01:24:17crazy stuff he was doing
- 01:24:19and at the moment when the shooting was
- 01:24:21taking place in that school
- 01:24:23virtually every kid according to Max's
- 01:24:26reporting virtually every kid in the
- 01:24:28school knew exactly who was doing it and
- 01:24:30knew that they had seen something they
- 01:24:32had said something and the
- 01:24:33administrators had done nothing and the
- 01:24:35primary reasons that they did nothing
- 01:24:37were restorative justice
- 01:24:39and inclusive classroom restorative
- 01:24:42justice what it actually means is that
- 01:24:43you're not going to use
- 01:24:45um retributive I don't know how to say
- 01:24:47that word justice you're not going to
- 01:24:48punish kids you're going to put them in
- 01:24:50like social worker happy circles and
- 01:24:52talk it out the kid that The Salted that
- 01:24:55you punch a kid and instead of like
- 01:24:57suspending the kid that punched him or
- 01:24:59filing an assault charge against him
- 01:25:01nope you put the kid they punched him
- 01:25:02and the kid that he punched set them
- 01:25:04down from each other and have them talk
- 01:25:05about their feelings together with a
- 01:25:06social worker mediating
- 01:25:08because you got to cut off the
- 01:25:09school-to-prison pipeline which maybe
- 01:25:11doesn't even exist whether or not it
- 01:25:13exists is a question we could analyze we
- 01:25:15could look into
- 01:25:16but you have to cut that off because
- 01:25:18there's huge racial Equity disparities
- 01:25:21in the so-called school to prison
- 01:25:23pipeline which may or may not even exist
- 01:25:24so she's a huge proponent of restorative
- 01:25:26justice basically everything that's
- 01:25:28breaking our schools SEL restorative
- 01:25:30justice inclusive classroom Equity Focus
- 01:25:31Linda darling Hammond is behind it
- 01:25:34she was a huge fan with that
- 01:25:36accountability plan School
- 01:25:37accountability plan not just for SEL and
- 01:25:39restorative justice of student surveys
- 01:25:41she is kind of the queen of make the
- 01:25:43students take surveys while your kids
- 01:25:45taking surveys all the time primarily
- 01:25:47Linda darling Hammond that's why
- 01:25:50named one of the 10 most influential
- 01:25:52people in education in 2006 recommended
- 01:25:55by a literal Marxist terrorist and
- 01:25:57installed by the Obama Administration
- 01:25:58what a fun story
- 01:26:01her goal is actually to make SEL
- 01:26:02systemic that's not just the theft of
- 01:26:05Education which it is and we'll talk
- 01:26:07about that in a minute it is actually
- 01:26:08like I said all the way down to teaching
- 01:26:10mothers to do SEL at Birth teaching
- 01:26:13communities to to reflect SEL back at
- 01:26:16the students as Linda darling Hammond
- 01:26:19said it's about creating a framework for
- 01:26:21teachers pedagogy so they're using their
- 01:26:24regular class time to implement sel's
- 01:26:26values
- 01:26:28that's what her vision is remember I
- 01:26:30said theft of Education it's about
- 01:26:32creating this is Linda darlingham and
- 01:26:34herself it's about creating a framework
- 01:26:36for teachers pedagogy so they are using
- 01:26:39their regular class time to implement
- 01:26:41SEL values
- 01:26:44theft of Education you're not going to
- 01:26:46teach your kids math reading Etc we're
- 01:26:48going to teach them social and emotional
- 01:26:49values for a sustainable and inclusive
- 01:26:51world and Linda darling Hammond for
- 01:26:53those of you who like names is a name
- 01:26:57after 2015-16 the SEL starts taking a
- 01:27:01very deliberate trajectory what a
- 01:27:02coincidence right after Essa passes
- 01:27:05so it's taking a very direct deliberate
- 01:27:07trajectory now they have Federal
- 01:27:09legislation making it so that this
- 01:27:11accountability plan is in place schools
- 01:27:13have to survey schools have to send this
- 01:27:15data in and all of a sudden SEL is out
- 01:27:17trans SEL is in
- 01:27:19transformative SEL with a deliberate
- 01:27:21attempt to consientize into critical
- 01:27:23Consciousness is in
- 01:27:25that's a bait and switch
- 01:27:27you've been tricked
- 01:27:29you've been lied to so they could bring
- 01:27:31in Marxist consientization under the
- 01:27:33banner of something that looks great
- 01:27:35with Spotty data to support it like com
- 01:27:37James Comer's cases are special they're
- 01:27:39specific maybe they work in certain
- 01:27:41cases maybe they don't we don't have the
- 01:27:42data to know what kinds of cases they
- 01:27:44work in in which kind of cases they
- 01:27:46don't we know that teacher engagement
- 01:27:47teacher interest and specific need are
- 01:27:49relevant we also know that targeting
- 01:27:51individuals as opposed to targeting
- 01:27:53classrooms or as opposed to targeting a
- 01:27:55system the entire educational curriculum
- 01:27:57across the board is uh or as a matter of
- 01:28:00difference that can make a difference in
- 01:28:02what might be the outcomes
- 01:28:05the data support older models of SEL not
- 01:28:09the current implementation of
- 01:28:10transformative SEL
- 01:28:12but Castle rules the roost now and they
- 01:28:15push transformative SEL and only
- 01:28:17transformative SEL let me remind you
- 01:28:19transformative means Marxist it means
- 01:28:23transforming the world to its humanist
- 01:28:24goal as Marx viewed humanism what does
- 01:28:27Castle say about this
- 01:28:29casel collaborative for academic social
- 01:28:32and emotional learning social and
- 01:28:34emotional learning they say SEL is an
- 01:28:36integral part of Education in human
- 01:28:37development is it the school's job to do
- 01:28:40human development SEL is the process
- 01:28:42through which all young people and
- 01:28:44adults acquire and apply the knowledge
- 01:28:46skills and attitudes to develop healthy
- 01:28:48identities manage emotions and Achieve
- 01:28:50Personal and Collective goals
- 01:28:53feel and show empathy for others
- 01:28:54establish and maintain supportive
- 01:28:56relationships and make responsible and
- 01:28:58caring decisions what a good sales pitch
- 01:29:01is the school's job to do that
- 01:29:03SEL advances educational equity
- 01:29:07and Excellence through authentic School
- 01:29:10family Community Partnerships to
- 01:29:12establish learning environments and
- 01:29:14experiences that feature trusting and
- 01:29:17collaborative relationships rigorous and
- 01:29:19meaningful curriculum and instruction
- 01:29:21and ongoing evaluation
- 01:29:25they're spying on your kids
- 01:29:28SEL can help address various forms of
- 01:29:30inequity and Empower young people and
- 01:29:32adults to co-create thriving schools and
- 01:29:35contribute to safe healthy and just
- 01:29:37communities what's a just Community
- 01:29:40let's pause on that remember when I said
- 01:29:41the socialism is an administered economy
- 01:29:44where they redistribute shares and they
- 01:29:46redistribute shares so that citizens or
- 01:29:49shareholders are made more equal
- 01:29:52and I said that socialism is that and
- 01:29:54that's the same thing as equity and if
- 01:29:56you run in Marxist theory if you run
- 01:29:57socialism long enough it becomes
- 01:29:59something that people need and can't
- 01:30:00live without and it becomes communism or
- 01:30:01you don't need to state to administer it
- 01:30:03anymore because it becomes automatic
- 01:30:05well imagine if you took equity and ran
- 01:30:07it for a long time until it just becomes
- 01:30:09automatic aha that's Justice that's
- 01:30:11social justice
- 01:30:12social justice equals neo-communism
- 01:30:16it doesn't have to equal that but that's
- 01:30:18what it equals in the common parlance
- 01:30:20where you're extending social justice
- 01:30:21theory out of social Equity Theory which
- 01:30:23is just a rebranding of socialism
- 01:30:25according to Marxist Vision that
- 01:30:26socialism will become spontaneous and
- 01:30:29become communism Equity will become
- 01:30:31spontaneous and finally become justice
- 01:30:33so we're going to have just communities
- 01:30:35when Equity is their automatic state
- 01:30:38as a matter of fact
- 01:30:40Castle says that social emotional
- 01:30:42learning must be leveraged to promote
- 01:30:44equity and Excellence it must be
- 01:30:46leveraged to promote Equity before
- 01:30:48Excellence as a matter of fact they say
- 01:30:50social emotional learning can be a
- 01:30:52powerful lever for creating caring just
- 01:30:55inclusive and healthy communities that
- 01:30:57support all individuals in reaching
- 01:30:59their fullest potential
- 01:31:02systemic implementation of SEL both
- 01:31:05Fosters and depends upon an equitable
- 01:31:07learning environment
- 01:31:08Fosters and depends upon is circular
- 01:31:12where all students and adults feel
- 01:31:14respected valued and affirmed in their
- 01:31:16individual interests talents social
- 01:31:18identities cultural values and
- 01:31:20backgrounds while SEL alone will not
- 01:31:22solve long-standing and deep-seated
- 01:31:24inequities in the education system it
- 01:31:26can help schools promote understanding
- 01:31:28examine biases reflect on and address
- 01:31:30the impact of racism build
- 01:31:33cross-cultural relationships and
- 01:31:35cultivate adult and student practices
- 01:31:36that close opportunity gaps and create a
- 01:31:39more inclusive School community in doing
- 01:31:41so schools can promote high quality
- 01:31:43educational opportunities and outcomes
- 01:31:45for all students irrespective of race
- 01:31:48socioeconomic status gender sexual
- 01:31:50orientation and other differences
- 01:31:52this requires that SEL is implemented
- 01:31:54with an explicit goal of promoting
- 01:31:57educational equity
- 01:32:00the point of social emotional learning
- 01:32:02is the consentai students while
- 01:32:04implementing or promoting socialism
- 01:32:07on all levels of stratification not just
- 01:32:10economic class but also race what do
- 01:32:13they raise socioeconomic status gender
- 01:32:14sexual orientation and other differences
- 01:32:18Castle organizes this according to their
- 01:32:20five competencies the so-called Castle
- 01:32:22five
- 01:32:23these are the soft skills the emotional
- 01:32:25intelligence skills that they want
- 01:32:26education to raise self-awareness
- 01:32:29self-management responsible decision
- 01:32:31making social awareness and relationship
- 01:32:33skills all things that sound great Until
- 01:32:35you realize that self-awareness might
- 01:32:36include self-awareness of what your
- 01:32:38gender is changing to be every day
- 01:32:39self-management might be teaching you
- 01:32:42the skill of resilience as it's been
- 01:32:44redefined which means when they cram the
- 01:32:46Dei lesson on you you don't throw a fit
- 01:32:48that would be white fragility you don't
- 01:32:50reject a lesson you have to be resilient
- 01:32:51in face of your brainwashing
- 01:32:53self-management sit still and take your
- 01:32:56brainwashing
- 01:32:58responsible decision making according to
- 01:33:00whose definition of responsible
- 01:33:04social awareness well you just know
- 01:33:06that's
- 01:33:07critical social justice Marxist nonsense
- 01:33:10you have to be aware of the power
- 01:33:12structures in society that's the whole
- 01:33:13freaking point of all of the
- 01:33:14consientization process and then
- 01:33:16relationship skills like Robin D'Angelo
- 01:33:19teaches shut up and listen that's a
- 01:33:21relationship skill you can't have an
- 01:33:23authentic cross-racial relationship by
- 01:33:24knowing one another as individuals you
- 01:33:26have to engage the racial difference or
- 01:33:28it's not authentic
- 01:33:29that's what she says in her books
- 01:33:31so what's this all about thought reform
- 01:33:34cultural revolution with a bottom-up
- 01:33:36demand Vanguard for ESG and sustainable
- 01:33:38development goals are a sustainable and
- 01:33:40inclusive future
- 01:33:42it works through data mining not just
- 01:33:45for Thought reform but also for social
- 01:33:46credit profiling like I said that's for
- 01:33:48managing profit and government control
- 01:33:50as we saw Ben Williamson explain
- 01:33:52explicitly
- 01:33:54the point of it is to build a new world
- 01:33:56and to staff the new world or a new
- 01:33:58culture to live in the new world
- 01:34:00simultaneously so the people who are
- 01:34:02doing this have to be stopped and put in
- 01:34:03prison
- 01:34:04they don't get to steal our society they
- 01:34:06don't get to steal our children from us
- 01:34:07without facing what's their other
- 01:34:09favorite word accountability
- 01:34:14I want to make a point before I go on
- 01:34:16with the bait and switch somehow I
- 01:34:18missed it in my notes so I have to go
- 01:34:19back I apologize I'm usually so much
- 01:34:21more organized I lost this you got to
- 01:34:22draw a grid I maybe accidentally deleted
- 01:34:24it watch out
- 01:34:26when I said there's a lot of forms of
- 01:34:28social emotional learning this is what
- 01:34:29you got to understand I want you if you
- 01:34:30have your notes in front of you you're
- 01:34:31not doing notes just bear with me and
- 01:34:32use your use your imagination skills I
- 01:34:34want you to make a three by three grid
- 01:34:36and on one axis I want you to to list
- 01:34:39that there are three different types of
- 01:34:41social emotional learning this should
- 01:34:42have gone way earlier I was wondering
- 01:34:43where did I put that okay sorry there
- 01:34:45are three forms of social emotional
- 01:34:48learning in terms of how you target it
- 01:34:50you can Target it at targeted individual
- 01:34:52or targeted interventions you find a kid
- 01:34:54that's literally got at-risk problems
- 01:34:56and you set him aside and say with a
- 01:35:00counselor or whatever and you do
- 01:35:02social emotional learning with them to
- 01:35:04get them up to speed it's a personal
- 01:35:05targeted at-risk kids that's
- 01:35:08individualist in some sense
- 01:35:11then you have where you're bringing it
- 01:35:13into the curriculum
- 01:35:15okay so you can make this your
- 01:35:17horizontal Grid or whatever I don't care
- 01:35:20what you have is bringing it into the
- 01:35:22curriculum you have an entire class
- 01:35:23dedicated to social emotional learning
- 01:35:25and every day you have to have social
- 01:35:26emotional learning class like you have
- 01:35:27reading class every day you have social
- 01:35:28emotional learning class like it's art
- 01:35:30class but now you're having a class on
- 01:35:32your emotions that's a second level and
- 01:35:34then there's what Linda darling Hammond
- 01:35:35promotes which is systemic
- 01:35:37every class every subject football
- 01:35:40coaching everything
- 01:35:42has social emotional learning principles
- 01:35:45woven into it in fact they replace the
- 01:35:47regular academic instruction mathematics
- 01:35:49lesson becomes a mediator for social
- 01:35:51emotional Learning lesson that's what
- 01:35:52Freddie would tell us
- 01:35:54so individual or targeted to curricular
- 01:35:57to systemic the entire school is
- 01:36:00organized around it in every subject at
- 01:36:02all times three levels of implementation
- 01:36:04okay now that's your horizontal if you
- 01:36:06did it horizontal your vertical axis on
- 01:36:09your three by three grid is three
- 01:36:11different models of social emotional
- 01:36:13learning that have been developed so
- 01:36:14there are nine products passing a social
- 01:36:16emotional learning the first one is a
- 01:36:19personal responsibility model everything
- 01:36:21before at least the mid-2000s was like
- 01:36:252000 odds or whatever
- 01:36:27was personal responsibility you
- 01:36:30intervene with the at-risk kid or class
- 01:36:32you sit them down so James cummer would
- 01:36:34have had both curricular and he would
- 01:36:36have had uh individual and you sit down
- 01:36:38and with the kid or the class
- 01:36:40whichever one of those two things that
- 01:36:42happens to be that's two levels and you
- 01:36:44say look
- 01:36:45the point is you have to take
- 01:36:47responsibility for your emotional state
- 01:36:48you got to take personal responsibility
- 01:36:50for how you feel this is how they're
- 01:36:51going to sell your social emotional
- 01:36:52learning you got to take responsibility
- 01:36:55for yourself your emotions and learn how
- 01:36:56to manage them Etc it's going to make
- 01:36:57your life better this is something in
- 01:36:59fact I don't know if the schools it's
- 01:37:00the school's job to do but isn't bad at
- 01:37:03all this is actually good where it takes
- 01:37:06place is a different question but that's
- 01:37:08actually good teaching people to take
- 01:37:09responsibility for their emotional state
- 01:37:10and not to blame it on everybody else is
- 01:37:12great that's the personal responsibility
- 01:37:14model that's level one
- 01:37:15level two which they transition to
- 01:37:18around about 15 years ago is called a
- 01:37:21Civic participatory model
- 01:37:23the participatory model so this what it
- 01:37:26starts to include is that you have
- 01:37:27classes that are dedicated to something
- 01:37:29like social and emotional learning but
- 01:37:31they also go out and get engaged
- 01:37:32civically they go do activist projects
- 01:37:37this is a higher level now they're
- 01:37:38getting involved in Civic stuff it's not
- 01:37:40about Manning managing your emotions
- 01:37:42anymore it's not about dealing with your
- 01:37:44problems it's about let's go clean up
- 01:37:46your community
- 01:37:47let's go to a community project from the
- 01:37:49school
- 01:37:51and then the third level
- 01:37:52is transformative SEL which is
- 01:37:54explicitly to raise critical
- 01:37:56Consciousness so now you have a 9x9 Grid
- 01:37:58or sorry three by three grid for a nine
- 01:38:00square grid and up in the far corner of
- 01:38:03Doom
- 01:38:04you have systemically implemented
- 01:38:07transformative SEL which is what Castle
- 01:38:09is pushing into all your schools this is
- 01:38:12the nightmare
- 01:38:13down here on the other Corner way down
- 01:38:15in the safe corner you have targeted
- 01:38:18interventions with at-risk kids that are
- 01:38:20being done by teaching them personal
- 01:38:21responsibility skills and emotional
- 01:38:23management skills ideally by a qualified
- 01:38:25professional in a therapeutic space
- 01:38:29which could be super good so there's
- 01:38:31your sales pitch there's your problem
- 01:38:34sell the dream service the nightmare
- 01:38:37that's what's happening that's the bait
- 01:38:39and switch that's happening they're
- 01:38:41pointing to personal responsibility
- 01:38:44models implemented either at the
- 01:38:45individual or curricular levels
- 01:38:47and saying look how good and valuable
- 01:38:49this is how could you be against this
- 01:38:51and what they're selling you is raise
- 01:38:54critical Consciousness by hijacking
- 01:38:56every single subject to do social
- 01:38:57emotional learning instead of doing
- 01:39:00educational content and that's the theft
- 01:39:02of education and we saw why they're
- 01:39:04doing it
- 01:39:05the gigantic globalist machine that
- 01:39:07we're all kind of afraid of has a plan
- 01:39:10for your children and the world they're
- 01:39:12going to live in they're transforming
- 01:39:13the world for them to live in a
- 01:39:15different world but they need them to be
- 01:39:16ready to live in that different world
- 01:39:18right out from under you so they're
- 01:39:20using social emotional learning to
- 01:39:21gather the data to build that world
- 01:39:23they're get they're gather the data to
- 01:39:25control and Market to the consumers and
- 01:39:29citizens of the future Global Citizens
- 01:39:31of the future as a matter of fact
- 01:39:34so that they can Implement an entirely
- 01:39:36New World Order that's what social
- 01:39:38emotional learning is really about and
- 01:39:39there are I don't know how the whole
- 01:39:41grid fills out I tried to fill it out in
- 01:39:42my notes in which I apparently lost
- 01:39:44somehow sorry
- 01:39:47old people problems
- 01:39:49I tried to figure out what all nine of
- 01:39:51the things would be and I don't know
- 01:39:52that there are nine specific different
- 01:39:54types of programs maybe we could
- 01:39:55identify them happening maybe you can
- 01:39:57imagine what they look like but
- 01:39:58definitely you have this Clear Vision
- 01:40:00that they're selling off of personal
- 01:40:02responsibility based programs where
- 01:40:05they're intervening with individuals and
- 01:40:06targeted ways or with curriculum and
- 01:40:08targeted schools like James Comer may
- 01:40:10have been doing you can even imagine
- 01:40:12that occasionally with that whole model
- 01:40:13that whole issue model that your whole
- 01:40:16school whole Community so-called model
- 01:40:18you might even imagine that what's going
- 01:40:20on
- 01:40:21is that they're um intervening with some
- 01:40:24Civic engagement let's go work at the
- 01:40:25neighborhood let's go make Community
- 01:40:26connections let's get you kids to know
- 01:40:28the police let's get you you know on
- 01:40:29friendly relations these kinds of things
- 01:40:31fine whatever but transformative SEL
- 01:40:33implemented in a systemic way is the
- 01:40:35theft of education for marxist's goals
- 01:40:38I wonder if I have my list down here at
- 01:40:39the bottom so what do we do about this
- 01:40:44mess
- 01:40:45what do we do about this mess I'll kind
- 01:40:48of wrap up quickly I've kind of touched
- 01:40:50on it as we go
- 01:40:52the only way we can fight this problem
- 01:40:54in education the marxification of
- 01:40:56Education the theft of Education which
- 01:40:58everything we want to call it is to know
- 01:41:00what it looks like and how it's done we
- 01:41:01have to know the magic trick of how
- 01:41:02they're stealing education so we can
- 01:41:04call it out specifically and make them
- 01:41:06stop doing that so we can make good
- 01:41:07legislation so we can make good law so
- 01:41:09we can do that through good lawsuits
- 01:41:11smart lawsuits strategic lawsuits
- 01:41:13instead of random lawsuits thrown at the
- 01:41:15state many of which will be decided by
- 01:41:17judges that will build precedent against
- 01:41:19ending this problem we have to know what
- 01:41:21it looks like and how it works we have
- 01:41:23to learn to spot the generative themes
- 01:41:25approach so that they can use the
- 01:41:27generative themes to hijack education to
- 01:41:29do something like social emotional
- 01:41:30learning and start to draw lines around
- 01:41:32what they're actually doing to find ways
- 01:41:34to start to prohibit what they're
- 01:41:35actually doing as opposed to something
- 01:41:37we're vague about and can't Define
- 01:41:40we need to learn to spot and that was
- 01:41:42the gold primary goal of this Workshop
- 01:41:44was to learn to spot critical pedagogy
- 01:41:46Concepts themes and practices in
- 01:41:48particular the hijacking of Education to
- 01:41:50turn it into consientization are they
- 01:41:51thought performing your kids well what
- 01:41:53does thought reform look like maybe you
- 01:41:54should know what thought thought reform
- 01:41:55looks like and then you can realize if
- 01:41:57they're doing that to your kids or even
- 01:41:58if they're doing it to you at work
- 01:41:59through Dei training
- 01:42:04when we understand what this looks like
- 01:42:05we can draw lines around them and
- 01:42:07challenge them legally and through
- 01:42:08policy but in particular as I keep
- 01:42:10bringing up we actually have the
- 01:42:11opportunity to throw down an
- 01:42:12Establishment Clause violation that
- 01:42:14they're implementing a specific concept
- 01:42:16of man in the world that is a system of
- 01:42:18belief and practice that gives rise to
- 01:42:19identifiable duties of conscience which
- 01:42:21is a direct violation of the existing
- 01:42:24jurisprudence for Establishment Clause
- 01:42:26First Amendment law as to whether or not
- 01:42:29something constitutes a state endorsed
- 01:42:31religion
- 01:42:32the most important thing that you need
- 01:42:34we need to do to take care of this
- 01:42:36problem and I should have said it first
- 01:42:37honestly is you have to protect your
- 01:42:38kids
- 01:42:39you have to protect your kids
- 01:42:42how you're going to protect your kids is
- 01:42:43up to you but you have to figure that
- 01:42:45out you have to do it and you have to
- 01:42:47know that it needs to be done the
- 01:42:48question I wanted you to sit with is if
- 01:42:50you knew you were sending your children
- 01:42:52to a thought reform
- 01:42:54re
- 01:42:56re-education or indoctrination Camp a
- 01:42:58brainwashing camp for 30 to 35 hours a
- 01:43:00week a communist re-education Camp what
- 01:43:03would you do differently you need to sit
- 01:43:05with that question think about it and
- 01:43:07start taking the action to protect your
- 01:43:09kids from what they want to do to them
- 01:43:11what they are doing to them
- 01:43:13we're not part way it's not like oh
- 01:43:15here's the stages of the consientization
- 01:43:16that they're going to run us through
- 01:43:17we're somewhere depending on the
- 01:43:19locality and the kid somewhere between
- 01:43:21stage three and eight for virtually all
- 01:43:23of them
- 01:43:24the kids screaming at the sky when the
- 01:43:25wrong person gets elected is at stage
- 01:43:28eight
- 01:43:29they're at utopian Consciousness to
- 01:43:30scream at the world until it changes and
- 01:43:32becomes perfect
- 01:43:34now I'm going to get controversial
- 01:43:35everybody wants this to be about school
- 01:43:36choice they want the market to solve the
- 01:43:38problem I sympathize
- 01:43:40care is needed I'm not saying that's the
- 01:43:42wrong answer I'm saying proceed with
- 01:43:43caution not red light yellow light think
- 01:43:46it through
- 01:43:47order of operations so to speak matters
- 01:43:50as a math teacher you have to do things
- 01:43:51in the right order
- 01:43:54we have to be aware of how government
- 01:43:55strings are going to tie to voucher
- 01:43:58money
- 01:43:59um student savings accounts or
- 01:44:01educational savings accounts money we've
- 01:44:03got to pay attention to how they're
- 01:44:04going to try to government strings we've
- 01:44:06got to cut the strings especially from
- 01:44:07the federal government state governments
- 01:44:09too but especially the federal
- 01:44:10government we've got to watch how the
- 01:44:13accountability pipeline that Linda
- 01:44:15darling Hammond installed actually works
- 01:44:17we need to think about the accreditation
- 01:44:20and licensure Pipelines
- 01:44:22if all you're pumping out is Marxist as
- 01:44:25teachers who's going to fill the school
- 01:44:27that's in your choice school marxists if
- 01:44:31all of the educational technology is sel
- 01:44:33compliant Google wear what are you going
- 01:44:36to give them to learn with if the only
- 01:44:38way they can get textbooks is through
- 01:44:39something like Pearson that's been
- 01:44:41captured what are you going to teach
- 01:44:42them from the accountability the
- 01:44:44accreditation etc those pipelines have
- 01:44:47to be cleaned up as well but at the same
- 01:44:49time it's easy to look at government and
- 01:44:51say these things and say government's
- 01:44:53all the problem but you have to realize
- 01:44:54that there are two major threats to
- 01:44:56Freedom at least
- 01:44:58in addition to government Authority
- 01:45:01there is Corporate Monopoly
- 01:45:06these are major threats to freedom and
- 01:45:09what we don't want to end up with is
- 01:45:11basically the amazon.com of schools by
- 01:45:14the way they're buying Hospitals now
- 01:45:15Amazon's getting into Health Care
- 01:45:17why wouldn't they get into education
- 01:45:20so you pay your taxes your the state
- 01:45:22takes 10 or 15 percent gives you your
- 01:45:24money back so you can spend on whatever
- 01:45:26school you want and the only School
- 01:45:27available is the one Amazon's giving you
- 01:45:29so that Amazon can educate your kids the
- 01:45:31way that Amazon wants them educated I'm
- 01:45:32not naming Amazon I don't know that I'm
- 01:45:34using as an example a potential example
- 01:45:36hypothetical example you get the idea
- 01:45:40you don't want that you don't want some
- 01:45:42corporate franchise model that basically
- 01:45:43all the schools are owned by one or two
- 01:45:45Mega Corps that are completely
- 01:45:47unaccountable to you that are pushing
- 01:45:48guess what agenda they're going to push
- 01:45:50right now it's going to be ESG and if
- 01:45:52the goon's in charge figure out a new
- 01:45:54scam it's going to be that scam
- 01:45:56you're not going to get around this
- 01:45:57problem by automatically creating choice
- 01:46:00if they're ready to deploy a corporate
- 01:46:01Monopoly that's going to seize all of
- 01:46:03Education data mine your kids and sell
- 01:46:05that data right out from under you as
- 01:46:07part of their cost savings model or
- 01:46:09their profit model so that they can
- 01:46:10undercut every school including the
- 01:46:12public school so you pay your taxes the
- 01:46:14government gives you 90 of your taxes
- 01:46:15back you can spend it on schools but
- 01:46:17because they're selling your kids data
- 01:46:18it actually only costs half as much as
- 01:46:21the public school so you get to pocket
- 01:46:22forty percent of what you paid in taxes
- 01:46:24your kids get a school that's super
- 01:46:26cheap it's outside of the norm they can
- 01:46:28they can bill it as being anti-woke or
- 01:46:31whatever the political wins of the day
- 01:46:33say it is but there sure is heck going
- 01:46:35to be sustainable development goals ESG
- 01:46:37compliant on some level and they surely
- 01:46:39are going to be data mining your
- 01:46:40children and you're not getting around
- 01:46:42this problem that way you're just maybe
- 01:46:43delaying it a little bit while walking
- 01:46:45into a trap you can't get out of because
- 01:46:47what they can't do through the
- 01:46:48government front door they will do
- 01:46:50through the corporate back door that is
- 01:46:51the mean the means of our times that is
- 01:46:54the problem that we have not figured out
- 01:46:55how to solve in the the 21st century yet
- 01:46:59these are all captured or capturable
- 01:47:01markets at present so school choice
- 01:47:03depends on there being a free market
- 01:47:06so we have to figure out how to make
- 01:47:07free make sure the markets are going to
- 01:47:09be free and protected to be free within
- 01:47:11education before we start making a
- 01:47:13gigantic slush fund that's mandated by
- 01:47:15law that you pay your money into that
- 01:47:17corporations walk away with 750 billion
- 01:47:20dollars a year of your taxpayer money
- 01:47:21while you think that you're getting a
- 01:47:23good deal
- 01:47:25you don't get the benefits of choice
- 01:47:26when there's no real choice so you have
- 01:47:29to make sure there's Choice then we push
- 01:47:31for school choice then we use the market
- 01:47:33to leverage all of these things to make
- 01:47:35a good and fair and awesome education
- 01:47:37but that means protections from
- 01:47:38government accountability and it means
- 01:47:40protections from corporate Monopoly and
- 01:47:42if you're not thinking in terms of both
- 01:47:43of those you're not ready to talk about
- 01:47:44school choice
- 01:47:46you got to think for a minute let's just
- 01:47:47be real controversial
- 01:47:49how much money is the school choice
- 01:47:51Lobby spending and how much money have
- 01:47:53they been spending for how long and do
- 01:47:54you not think they expect a payoff
- 01:47:57in terms of these 750 billion dollars of
- 01:48:02federally mandated tax money that gets
- 01:48:04spent in education every year in this
- 01:48:07country
- 01:48:08it's a big slice of pie
- 01:48:13what we have to do more practically like
- 01:48:14I said we have to go after ESG this is
- 01:48:16an education Workshop we have to go
- 01:48:18after SEL with everything we've got
- 01:48:20SEL has to be ended the data mining of
- 01:48:22children has to be ended
- 01:48:23we have to Lobby to have it understood
- 01:48:25our lawmakers need to understand what it
- 01:48:27is our Executives our attorneys need to
- 01:48:30know what it is
- 01:48:32it has to be understood it has to be
- 01:48:34limited prohibited banned removed
- 01:48:37restricted this is a nightmare
- 01:48:41we have to end data mining operations on
- 01:48:43children
- 01:48:44in schools with their education apps
- 01:48:46that pulls the big plug out of their
- 01:48:48plans it's key we have to put a firm
- 01:48:52line not in sand but in concrete that
- 01:48:54you will not practice psychology without
- 01:48:55a license on my child in school in an
- 01:48:58un-therapeutic unlicensed unsecure
- 01:49:01environment you're not going to do it
- 01:49:03and you have to go after the funding
- 01:49:05schemes or get people with power to
- 01:49:06start cutting the funding schemes and
- 01:49:08the strings from them to do that you
- 01:49:10have to research how they're funded or
- 01:49:12follow people who reach their child are
- 01:49:13funded there are many people around the
- 01:49:14country that are already Gathering these
- 01:49:16kinds of resources and and writing about
- 01:49:18them and making databases of them so
- 01:49:21that you can Lobby and fight against how
- 01:49:23this money is being used to corrupt and
- 01:49:25steal education you need to tell your
- 01:49:28lawmakers to go after Essa they don't
- 01:49:30know they don't even know that it exists
- 01:49:31in a lot of cases they need they don't
- 01:49:33know
- 01:49:34do not expect your lawmakers have the
- 01:49:36slightest idea what they're dealing with
- 01:49:38tell them about Essa find out how it
- 01:49:41works first so you have a nice 10 minute
- 01:49:43or five minute presentation you can give
- 01:49:44them a sense of what this is get them on
- 01:49:47board things like this have to be done
- 01:49:49I'm not a policy guy so I have to do
- 01:49:51more homework on this you guys need to
- 01:49:52do homework on this too hopefully I can
- 01:49:54go back to reading my stupid books and
- 01:49:56you guys can do a lot of the policy leg
- 01:49:58work that I don't know how to do
- 01:50:00but in general we need to be pushing for
- 01:50:01education to be more and more local with
- 01:50:03the control at the local level however
- 01:50:05the management of money is that to just
- 01:50:07cut the strings the bigger it is the
- 01:50:08less strings can be tied to it now at
- 01:50:10least at least need to be cutting our
- 01:50:12education out from International
- 01:50:14organizations and corporations that have
- 01:50:16no accountability under our Republic
- 01:50:18system
- 01:50:19and so these are the things we have to
- 01:50:21do with regard to education I would tell
- 01:50:23you another watchword it was somewhere
- 01:50:24in my notes and it got lost so the last
- 01:50:26thing I'll mention right now the castle
- 01:50:28is vigorously pushing this thing called
- 01:50:30communities of practice
- 01:50:32this is to match in with what they're
- 01:50:33calling the Whisk model wscc that's
- 01:50:36pronounced whisk for some reason it
- 01:50:38means whole school whole child whole
- 01:50:40Community every bit of it's to be a
- 01:50:42community of practice which sounds an
- 01:50:44awful lot like a church that reflects
- 01:50:45SEL values all around the student all
- 01:50:48around the child all the time James
- 01:50:50Comer's whole school has turned into
- 01:50:52whole everything for a 360 degree fully
- 01:50:56immersive brainwashing operation so look
- 01:50:59into the whole school model look for
- 01:51:00Community schooling look at how they're
- 01:51:03trying to build communities of practice
- 01:51:04and when you see them crop up in your
- 01:51:05local environment you need to fight them
- 01:51:07vigorously they are not the way of the
- 01:51:09future and most people have no idea
- 01:51:11what's coming and once they're informed
- 01:51:12about it they're going to say hell no
- 01:51:14and they're going to stop it so I'm
- 01:51:15optimistic we know what the targets are
- 01:51:17now
- 01:51:18a year ago we're sitting here screaming
- 01:51:20about critical race Theory and saying
- 01:51:22they're the real racists and nothing's
- 01:51:24going anywhere
- 01:51:25here we are I guess 18 months or so down
- 01:51:27the road and we're literally shooting
- 01:51:29our arrows directly at the foundation of
- 01:51:32their entire program ESG sdgs and SEL
- 01:51:36since it's the education Workshop the
- 01:51:38ferrarian method is coming in the theft
- 01:51:41of education is coming in through SEL
- 01:51:42trans SEL in particular Castle is the
- 01:51:45name of an organization that you can
- 01:51:46start going after and the world economic
- 01:51:48Forum World Bank and all these huge
- 01:51:49scary people are backing it up all their
- 01:51:51plans can be destroyed it's just up to
- 01:51:53us to get informed and do it thank you
- 01:51:55for coming to my workshop we'll have q a
- 01:51:56in a little while
- 01:51:58foreign
- social emotional learning
- thought reform
- data mining
- global education
- World Economic Forum
- United Nations
- Paulo Freire
- ideological agenda
- sustainability
- inclusive education